Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a surrogate mother...

682 replies

BackDownSouth · 18/04/2023 03:31

Is the biological mother of a surrogate baby that she delivers, even in cases where another egg was used? One thing I hate hearing in the surrogacy debate by pro-surrogacy folks (who like to minimise the connection between mother and child and the effect that separation at birth can have on both) is “the surrogate has no biological relation to the baby” in cases where an egg other than the surrogate’s own were used. Of course she has a biological connection to the baby. She doesn’t have a GENETIC link to the baby - no. But biological? She has about as much of a biological connection with it as she would her own genetic child. The baby is quite literally made of her. The genetic material of the egg may predetermine baby’s genetic make-up to match that of the intended mother’s egg but that is such a shallow link compared to the nurturing happening during the pregnancy. It's the surrogate mother’s body building and nurturing that child. The mother’s body will likely forever retain snippets of the child’s DNA - particularly traces of Y chromosome if she carries a boy. Everything the mother does or eats or feels will influence that child. The baby knows her smell and voice and as soon as they are born they seek her, and they will feel stress at being placed into a stranger’s arms rather than mum’s immediately after birth. It’s completely ridiculous to say there is no biological connection between surrogate and baby. What’s more of a connection, really, to a newborn baby who has no concept of themselves other than the birth mother who is all they have ever known? Is the baby bothered about a mother who makes up half of their DNA but who has been on the other side of the world since their conception and is going to lay claim to them through a financial transaction? Or is the baby instead going to crave the presence of the woman who has grown and nurtured them? The surrogate is mum and the baby is going to need her post-birth no matter how much people want to ignore that.

People like to say “DNA is nothing” in the context of the love between step-parents and their stepchildren, adoptive children etc, and that’s rightly so. A genetic link isn’t what makes a family. But in the case of surrogacies, this is all completely thrown out of the window and the idea of a surrogate mother bonding with her baby (because it is her baby…) is inconceivable because she ‘isn’t even related to them’ despite literally creating and birthing the child.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Blaueblumen · 18/04/2023 18:32

I think there is a reason that women have evolved to become pregnant with their own babies!

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 18:31

Newnamenewname109870 · 18/04/2023 18:15

What’s your point? Do you also disagree with people who donate kidneys? Is no one allowed to do anything that doesn’t benefit someone else but might harm them?

My point is, how would you react in these scenarios?

You are focused on the outcome. I am looking at the process and the potential issues over 9 months.

The whole ‘kidney’ thing is a poor comparator. I have repeatedly said this on this thread.

A kidney transplant is a life saving treatment for an existing human being.

What part of having a child by surrogacy is life saving? Or would you also just give a kidney to someone who didn’t need a life saving kidney transplant?

And again. No kidney is a sentient being. A human who is deliberately created for the purpose of pleasing an adult where a woman’s body is
exploited as a resource makes that human a transaction. Just another resource to be achieved using another person’s body.

CountZacular · 18/04/2023 18:25

I’ve noticed some pro surrogacy supporters say they agree - in all circumstances or a ‘regulated’ version of it? And what does ‘regulated’ look like? I can’t think how you’d ever mitigate some risks that are fair to all parties. Here’s some examples - what are your takes on these?

Baby is born disabled. Intended parents didn’t want a disabled baby. Surrogate mother didn’t want a child at all. Who is responsible for the baby?

Due to any reason whatsoever the surrogate wants an abortion. Can she have one? Can she have one if she’s already been paid and no longer has the money to pay back to the intended parents?

Intended parents split up and no longer want to continue. Can they force an abortion? If the surrogate won’t have an abortion, has this baby been commissioned to be adopted?

Surrogate is in a war zone and left with the baby for months/ years. Should the intended parents still have ‘rights’ over the baby at some point in the future? Surrogate also can’t afford to feed their existing child let alone a new one. What should happen?

All of these aren’t ‘gotchas’. They are perfectly reasonable things that could/have happened. In all of those scenarios mothers would be responsible to make the right decisions for their family but you have extras throwing money around and being able to pick up and drop other human beings at their whim.

I’d be interested particularly in the friend who didn’t want children but wanted to ‘experience’ pregnancy.

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 18:21

BiscuitLover3678 · 18/04/2023 18:20

Wrong in your eyes. It’s not a fact, it’s opinion which of course you’re entitled to.
I’m assuming you judge me for going through ivf?

Weird assumption.

No, unless you bought eggs from another woman. Then yes.

BiscuitLover3678 · 18/04/2023 18:20

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 17:40

Did yuo forget half your first sentence? Surrogacy IS illegal in many countries, and that will hopefully spread.

I don't care what led people down the path of buying womens eggs and bodies,it doesn't matter. It's wrong whatever their reasons are.

Wrong in your eyes. It’s not a fact, it’s opinion which of course you’re entitled to.
I’m assuming you judge me for going through ivf?

Newnamenewname109870 · 18/04/2023 18:19

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 18:14

That logic does imply the ol’ Monty Python “Every Sperm Is Sacred”. We should be continually pregnant and giving birth, because each egg released during our period is a potential person who could exist and potentially be happy.

There’s something called a middle ground.

FourTeaFallOut · 18/04/2023 18:18

Always the kidney, never an eyeball or a bit of liver. It's like a script.

Newnamenewname109870 · 18/04/2023 18:15

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 16:00

Why?

To make them happy? To fulfill your need to be needed by them?

Because you have a ‘need’ to be pregnant and have chosen to commoditise a human being to fulfill that need?

What’s your point? Do you also disagree with people who donate kidneys? Is no one allowed to do anything that doesn’t benefit someone else but might harm them?

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 18:14

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 18:05

That is a bit of a head fuck that.

That logic does imply the ol’ Monty Python “Every Sperm Is Sacred”. We should be continually pregnant and giving birth, because each egg released during our period is a potential person who could exist and potentially be happy.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 18:05

KimberleyClark · 18/04/2023 17:58

I think there are situations where it is hugely exploitative and situations where it makes a lot of people very happy and allows someone life who would otherwise never had the chance to exist.

Are you saying that if anyone does not have a child for whatever reason, then someone has not been given a chance to exist?

That is a bit of a head fuck that.

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 17:59

It’s really important that we form strong ethics as a society about this kind of thing. Such a Pandora’s box of horrors once you lose sight of the bigger ethical picture confining the scientific advances in human reproduction.

Desperate people who are willing to try anything to become parents are not who we should look to, to set ethical standards.

KimberleyClark · 18/04/2023 17:58

I think there are situations where it is hugely exploitative and situations where it makes a lot of people very happy and allows someone life who would otherwise never had the chance to exist.

Are you saying that if anyone does not have a child for whatever reason, then someone has not been given a chance to exist?

Blaueblumen · 18/04/2023 17:58

Even the women that did it as “a favour” for a friend or relative found it incredibly painful to hand the baby over

What about the baby? It must be harmful to remove it from its birth mother with whom it's been bonding for 9 months, whose voice and smell it recognises...?!

Blaueblumen · 18/04/2023 17:54

Surrogacy is not illegal. Fact. It brings hope to many infertile couples.

This is again about the parents' wishes! Parents seem to think they have a 'right' to have a child.

HistoryFanatic · 18/04/2023 17:54

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 18/04/2023 08:27

Oh, not this again. MN is so vehemently anti surrogacy and the emotive language used about the poor baby being 'ripped' from the 'only human it has ever known' is OTT and nauseating. You can bet that if half of the mothers on here found themselves faced with infertility they would try anything, so step down from your ivory towers

If the IVF hadn't worked we wouldn't have gone down the surrogacy path or indeed that of adoption.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:54

I am still waiting for the procedures on how any regulating body will assess that there is no exploitation in the arrangement at all.

What does that look like in reality? How will this be assessed, over what timeframe and how are the power imbalances to be described?

I am very concerned about the future of surrogacy in the UK and the rest of the world and the impact on the child and the women who are being used as resources to be exploited.

Whiskeypowers · 18/04/2023 17:51

KimberleyClark · 18/04/2023 17:48

Plenty of infertile people on this thread have expressed their opposition to surrogacy. It seems most of the pro surrogacy posters prefer to ignore those people.

Yes they have I agree with you: it’s been overlooked and it’s been posted a number of times

In response to the poster you quoted I also cannot stick this not having an opinion on a practice because you don’t know what’s led some people to do it. That analogy is dangerous.

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 17:51

I condemn it.

Blaueblumen · 18/04/2023 17:50

and it is dangerous to blanket condemn it.

@ibis17 why should we not as a society condemn the concept of surrogacy?

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 17:49

Some people are able to thrive whatever. Take Louis Armstrong - son of a prostitute, in and out of a ‘waifs home’ throughout his childhood, but something about his disposition and humour got him through, some resilience, so he had a really successful life.

There are no guarantees that a baby born is going to be one of these unflappable, optimistic types. So pointing to one person who is cheerful despite being separated from their mother at birth is not a testimony that the separation does no harm.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:49

https://thecritic.co.uk/end-womb-trafficking/

Here is an interesting article by Julie Bindel. I am not sure it has been posted yet. But Julie has been working with this issue for many years.

"What about so-called altruistic surrogacy? Who could be against such a “not for profit” arrangement, based on the generosity of a woman, bearing a child for someone who can’t carry her own? There will, of course, be the odd example of a woman who truly did go through pregnancy and birth for no reason other than her desire to help. But like the “happy hooker”, this woman is a rare exception rather than the norm."

"Many of the altruistic surrogates I interviewed have told me that the process has had a terrible effect on them. Even the women that did it as “a favour” for a friend or relative found it incredibly painful to hand the baby over, and every single one I spoke to told me that it either fractured or destroyed the relationship with the recipient. None of them found it possible to maintain a positive and ongoing relationship with the growing child either, no matter what claims pro surrogacy campaigners might make about what is possible."

End womb trafficking | Julie Bindel | The Critic Magazine

“End womb trafficking” is the fifteenth article in Julie Bindel’s online column for The Critic, “The feminist fix”, which explores feminism’s answer to today’s challenges. The fourteenth article…

https://thecritic.co.uk/end-womb-trafficking/

KimberleyClark · 18/04/2023 17:48

Mojoj · 18/04/2023 17:38

Surrogacy is not illegal. Fact. It brings hope to many infertile couples. Love all these posts about how "sad" it is that some women can't have kids and how being a parent is not a "right". I bet they were written by parents. I mind my own business and try hard not to judge other people's decisions as I have no idea what led them down that path.

Plenty of infertile people on this thread have expressed their opposition to surrogacy. It seems most of the pro surrogacy posters prefer to ignore those people.

Whiskeypowers · 18/04/2023 17:45

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 17:36

I disagree.

I think there are situations where it is hugely exploitative and situations where it makes a lot of people very happy and allows someone life who would otherwise never had the chance to exist.

It would be so much easier if life were black and white, but it seldom is and antagonising increased polarisation just causes difficulty.

Allow someone a life? Did you mean to write that?

what you should when written is “allow someone to commission and procure their own child when they could not have children via any other route, were adamant it was going to happen come hell or high water and balls to the actually human being being born into their show”

I will just keep repeating my point.
As it seems do you.

Let’s hope those people and that child you know are always so “happy” about it……..

Humanbiology · 18/04/2023 17:44

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 17:34

They aren't all exploited. Some of them are the exploitors. They should feel shitty about that. The child is going to have issues regarding their creation, at some level.

What issues should she have according to you?

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 17:44

Do bad