Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a surrogate mother...

682 replies

BackDownSouth · 18/04/2023 03:31

Is the biological mother of a surrogate baby that she delivers, even in cases where another egg was used? One thing I hate hearing in the surrogacy debate by pro-surrogacy folks (who like to minimise the connection between mother and child and the effect that separation at birth can have on both) is “the surrogate has no biological relation to the baby” in cases where an egg other than the surrogate’s own were used. Of course she has a biological connection to the baby. She doesn’t have a GENETIC link to the baby - no. But biological? She has about as much of a biological connection with it as she would her own genetic child. The baby is quite literally made of her. The genetic material of the egg may predetermine baby’s genetic make-up to match that of the intended mother’s egg but that is such a shallow link compared to the nurturing happening during the pregnancy. It's the surrogate mother’s body building and nurturing that child. The mother’s body will likely forever retain snippets of the child’s DNA - particularly traces of Y chromosome if she carries a boy. Everything the mother does or eats or feels will influence that child. The baby knows her smell and voice and as soon as they are born they seek her, and they will feel stress at being placed into a stranger’s arms rather than mum’s immediately after birth. It’s completely ridiculous to say there is no biological connection between surrogate and baby. What’s more of a connection, really, to a newborn baby who has no concept of themselves other than the birth mother who is all they have ever known? Is the baby bothered about a mother who makes up half of their DNA but who has been on the other side of the world since their conception and is going to lay claim to them through a financial transaction? Or is the baby instead going to crave the presence of the woman who has grown and nurtured them? The surrogate is mum and the baby is going to need her post-birth no matter how much people want to ignore that.

People like to say “DNA is nothing” in the context of the love between step-parents and their stepchildren, adoptive children etc, and that’s rightly so. A genetic link isn’t what makes a family. But in the case of surrogacies, this is all completely thrown out of the window and the idea of a surrogate mother bonding with her baby (because it is her baby…) is inconceivable because she ‘isn’t even related to them’ despite literally creating and birthing the child.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Blaueblumen · 18/04/2023 19:20

"Sue is a surrogate for a couple. Jane and Jim are the biological parents"

Jane and Jim may have provided their gametes but Jane did not grow the baby inside her womb got 9 months... Sue grew the baby in her body and formed a bond with the baby.

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 19:17

Basically being ‘provider of a gamete’ is the father’s role in reproduction.

Providing the gamete is far lesser in importance in terms of being a mother than gestating and giving birth.

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 19:17

Blaueblumen · 18/04/2023 19:13

But you are essentially saying that the perfectly happy 20 something in my example shouldn’t exist because you disagree with their origin…

Yes, that person should not have been created the way they were created.

Parents do not have a right to a child. As many have pointed out, the potential for harm is too great.

You see, it’s exactly this that I have a problem with. No one should feel it is ok to tell another human they shouldn’t exist. Still less when that human is a happy early 20 year old going about their life who you have never met.

I’m baffled that you feel this is an ok judgement to pass.

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 19:16

DHsPoorBack · 18/04/2023 19:03

Ok, but they haven't changed.

Everyone knows what is meant in surrogacy, when you say biological mother, or biological father. They are basically identifying the person who's DNA it is, and a more basic level, just clarifying they are talking about the person who isn't the surrogate.

"Sue is a surrogate for a couple. Jane and Jim are the biological parents"

Baffling as to what that could possibly mean. Baffling Hmm

I disagree. The surrogate mother is the biological mother - the same meaning as you would have in adoption.

Surrogacy has borrowed the language of adoption.

A woman who donates the gamete is more like a ‘father’ in terms of her reproductive role. It’s would be more accurate and representative to call her the ‘female biological father’ than the biological mother.

Whiskeypowers · 18/04/2023 19:15

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 19:13

I think we need to agree to disagree.

At the end of the day, you have never met these people and I accept you will not be convinced that this is a happy family resulting from surrogacy.

Id repeat again details in my agreement that the wider issue is morally fraught but you seem to overlook this each time.

You don’t get extra points for happiness

at the end of the day they commissioned and procured a human being because they wanted their needs to trump every other aspect of the situation . They are not different from any number of individuals whose circumstances you might find less agreeable or ideal.

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 19:15

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 19:11

So do you or do you not support a blanket ban on surrogacy?

I honestly don’t know. I can see there is a ‘greater good’ argument for it (as I’ve already said several times) but I also see it as complicated given the situations where it brings life and joy. After tonight’s debate I’m very glad that it’s not a decision that’s up to me.

Blaueblumen · 18/04/2023 19:13

But you are essentially saying that the perfectly happy 20 something in my example shouldn’t exist because you disagree with their origin…

Yes, that person should not have been created the way they were created.

Parents do not have a right to a child. As many have pointed out, the potential for harm is too great.

Whiskeypowers · 18/04/2023 19:13

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 18:57

But you are essentially saying that the perfectly happy 20 something in my example shouldn’t exist because you disagree with their origin… that’s a big thing to say about a human being.

stop being obtuse.
you cannot possibly speculate on the issue of happiness to this “child” and what issues might raise themselves in years to come as a result of this arrangement; that being that one woman was “keen to experience pregnancy” without a child at the end which is highly unusual and indeed that there were a childless couple happy to take advantage of that.

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 19:13

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 19:03

You are again using emotional manipulation to try to support your position.

What would your position be if you discover next year that this child is actually struggling with poor mental health because of the decision of three adults to deliberately create that life as if they were a resource to be purchased either via money or other reward?

I think we need to agree to disagree.

At the end of the day, you have never met these people and I accept you will not be convinced that this is a happy family resulting from surrogacy.

Id repeat again details in my agreement that the wider issue is morally fraught but you seem to overlook this each time.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 19:11

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 19:10

I’ve said all along I think it is morally fraught.

you asked for a positive story, I gave you one. You spent a long time trying to argue that it was not a positive story, and I responded that I maintain it was.

In almost every post I included the disclaimer that I was discussing one story and believe the wider issue is more complex.

My point remains that it is possible to campaign for a ban on surrogacy without stigmatising those who exist through surrogate parenting.

So do you or do you not support a blanket ban on surrogacy?

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 19:10

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 19:00

Yes I agree you are saying it is a positive outcome. I am pointing out that you are ignoring the ethics of the situation using the hindsight of what you consider a positive outcome with the intention that there should be no blanket ban on surrogacy.

I understand what you are saying. I disagree that it was free from exploitation and I think that laws should reflect all aspects of exploitation as some countries have recognised.

You seem to have also tried to portray my and other’s views as unusual somehow, yet I can assure you that it is not unusual and it is very well written about by many feminists and feminist groups. It is highly topical because the government review process.

I’ve said all along I think it is morally fraught.

you asked for a positive story, I gave you one. You spent a long time trying to argue that it was not a positive story, and I responded that I maintain it was.

In almost every post I included the disclaimer that I was discussing one story and believe the wider issue is more complex.

My point remains that it is possible to campaign for a ban on surrogacy without stigmatising those who exist through surrogate parenting.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 19:07

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 19:03

No, I am saying you shouldn’t devalue the lives of those who have been born.

You don’t seem to be able to separate the ethics of the conception and birth of this child from a discussion where their life now is devalued.

Their situation has not changed. There were ethical issues that you seem to not be able to answer without resorting to ‘but they are alive and’ supposedly ‘happy’. That is falling back on emotional manipulation to support a decision that is either ethical or it is not.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 19:03

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 18:57

But you are essentially saying that the perfectly happy 20 something in my example shouldn’t exist because you disagree with their origin… that’s a big thing to say about a human being.

You are again using emotional manipulation to try to support your position.

What would your position be if you discover next year that this child is actually struggling with poor mental health because of the decision of three adults to deliberately create that life as if they were a resource to be purchased either via money or other reward?

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 19:03

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 18:05

That is a bit of a head fuck that.

No, I am saying you shouldn’t devalue the lives of those who have been born.

DHsPoorBack · 18/04/2023 19:03

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 18:46

trying to argue the definition, is just being pedantic and gains nothing.

Having clear terms and knowing what they mean are really important during a period of scientific advance with serious ethical implications, (especially when those advances are combined with market forces), which have led to the meanings of clearly understood words changing.

You can’t really get more ethically serious than when interfering with human reproduction.

Ok, but they haven't changed.

Everyone knows what is meant in surrogacy, when you say biological mother, or biological father. They are basically identifying the person who's DNA it is, and a more basic level, just clarifying they are talking about the person who isn't the surrogate.

"Sue is a surrogate for a couple. Jane and Jim are the biological parents"

Baffling as to what that could possibly mean. Baffling Hmm

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 19:00

Blaueblumen · 18/04/2023 17:50

and it is dangerous to blanket condemn it.

@ibis17 why should we not as a society condemn the concept of surrogacy?

Because you are alienating and stigmatising those who have been born through surrogacy and are leading their lives, in some cases happily.

absolutely bring up the question as to whether going forward it is something that for the greater good should be prohibited, however sone of the view and language being used in this argument ignores those who have found joy through surrogacy - including children.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 19:00

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 18:54

I’m saying that in this situation the outcome was positive.

as I’ve said all along, surrogacy as a whole is morally fraught.

Yes I agree you are saying it is a positive outcome. I am pointing out that you are ignoring the ethics of the situation using the hindsight of what you consider a positive outcome with the intention that there should be no blanket ban on surrogacy.

I understand what you are saying. I disagree that it was free from exploitation and I think that laws should reflect all aspects of exploitation as some countries have recognised.

You seem to have also tried to portray my and other’s views as unusual somehow, yet I can assure you that it is not unusual and it is very well written about by many feminists and feminist groups. It is highly topical because the government review process.

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 18:57

Whiskeypowers · 18/04/2023 17:45

Allow someone a life? Did you mean to write that?

what you should when written is “allow someone to commission and procure their own child when they could not have children via any other route, were adamant it was going to happen come hell or high water and balls to the actually human being being born into their show”

I will just keep repeating my point.
As it seems do you.

Let’s hope those people and that child you know are always so “happy” about it……..

But you are essentially saying that the perfectly happy 20 something in my example shouldn’t exist because you disagree with their origin… that’s a big thing to say about a human being.

LotsofVikings · 18/04/2023 18:56

I think it's good that there's a robust debate about this. I can quite believe that there are some arrangements where things work out ok for all involved.

The problem is, the potential for things to go wrong is huge. It could be the scenarios that a PP described, or it could be a case of the woman who acted as the surrogate feeling miserable about it for the rest of her life (because, to me it's common sense that you can't be certain you'll be able to cope with handing over a baby you've grown and birthed until it actually happens), or the child grows up feeling distressed about their origins, or any number of things.

It seems to me that the chances of at least one of these things happening is quite high. I can't see how you can tell which are the cases that will work out one way or the other without a crystal ball, especially as each case involves a person who doesn't exist yet.

Then there's the question of how you regulate to reduce these risks. First, there's how you provide counselling to the surrogate mother to ensure she knows her legal rights and isn't being coerced. Who provides that? It can't be anyone with any skin in the game like a clinic- I think my story upthread demonstrates the pitfalls of entrusting that job to someone who stands to make money from the arrangement.

And then how do you ensure that the woman really is in a position to change her mind if she wants to without any emotional pressure from the person/people she's giving the baby to? To ensure that, you'd have to have someone independently monitoring the situation constantly to ensure that there was no pressure applied- even inadvertently. I can easily imagine a woman changing her mind but feeling obligated to go through with it if the person/people are excited, expressing their joy at the prospect of the birth...

And then who is responsible for the woman's care if she struggles to cope with her decision after the birth, or even years down the line as things sink in? Is she entitled to ongoing support if, for example, she suffers birth injuries and ends up incontinent/infertile?

And that's only the things I can think of. How could you possibly regulate for all these outcomes? To me the risk of harm is just too high.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 18:54

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 18:37

Because it is possible, and happens, that people can donate a kidney and carry on living normal lives, perhaps?

But the potential for exploitation is high, and there are potential health impacts for the donor, and therefore there is a rigorous process in this country for accepting a living donor.

So tell us how the process should work? How long is the process, who should involved, what questions should be covered in depth, and what checks should be done.

ibis17 · 18/04/2023 18:54

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 17:35

You are the one here that is trying to say that a positive outcome means there is no 'exploitation' or ethical dilemma.

I’m saying that in this situation the outcome was positive.

as I’ve said all along, surrogacy as a whole is morally fraught.

ClumsyCat · 18/04/2023 18:46

trying to argue the definition, is just being pedantic and gains nothing.

Having clear terms and knowing what they mean are really important during a period of scientific advance with serious ethical implications, (especially when those advances are combined with market forces), which have led to the meanings of clearly understood words changing.

You can’t really get more ethically serious than when interfering with human reproduction.

DHsPoorBack · 18/04/2023 18:40

Haven't read the full thread, but on the basis of the OP, when talking about surrogacy, the term biological is referring to the genetic mother. Because the biological father isn't carrying the child either. But it's still the term "biological father". Of all the issues regarding surrogacy, nitpicking over a word, that you know full well is a term used to mean the genetic parent, but trying to argue the definition, is just being pedantic and gains nothing.

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 18:37

FourTeaFallOut · 18/04/2023 18:18

Always the kidney, never an eyeball or a bit of liver. It's like a script.

Because it is possible, and happens, that people can donate a kidney and carry on living normal lives, perhaps?

But the potential for exploitation is high, and there are potential health impacts for the donor, and therefore there is a rigorous process in this country for accepting a living donor.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 18:33

Newnamenewname109870 · 18/04/2023 18:19

There’s something called a middle ground.

what is the ‘middle ground’ that you envision?

Swipe left for the next trending thread