Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a surrogate mother...

682 replies

BackDownSouth · 18/04/2023 03:31

Is the biological mother of a surrogate baby that she delivers, even in cases where another egg was used? One thing I hate hearing in the surrogacy debate by pro-surrogacy folks (who like to minimise the connection between mother and child and the effect that separation at birth can have on both) is “the surrogate has no biological relation to the baby” in cases where an egg other than the surrogate’s own were used. Of course she has a biological connection to the baby. She doesn’t have a GENETIC link to the baby - no. But biological? She has about as much of a biological connection with it as she would her own genetic child. The baby is quite literally made of her. The genetic material of the egg may predetermine baby’s genetic make-up to match that of the intended mother’s egg but that is such a shallow link compared to the nurturing happening during the pregnancy. It's the surrogate mother’s body building and nurturing that child. The mother’s body will likely forever retain snippets of the child’s DNA - particularly traces of Y chromosome if she carries a boy. Everything the mother does or eats or feels will influence that child. The baby knows her smell and voice and as soon as they are born they seek her, and they will feel stress at being placed into a stranger’s arms rather than mum’s immediately after birth. It’s completely ridiculous to say there is no biological connection between surrogate and baby. What’s more of a connection, really, to a newborn baby who has no concept of themselves other than the birth mother who is all they have ever known? Is the baby bothered about a mother who makes up half of their DNA but who has been on the other side of the world since their conception and is going to lay claim to them through a financial transaction? Or is the baby instead going to crave the presence of the woman who has grown and nurtured them? The surrogate is mum and the baby is going to need her post-birth no matter how much people want to ignore that.

People like to say “DNA is nothing” in the context of the love between step-parents and their stepchildren, adoptive children etc, and that’s rightly so. A genetic link isn’t what makes a family. But in the case of surrogacies, this is all completely thrown out of the window and the idea of a surrogate mother bonding with her baby (because it is her baby…) is inconceivable because she ‘isn’t even related to them’ despite literally creating and birthing the child.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
JudgeRudy · 18/04/2023 08:03

StrawHatOnTheParcelShelf · 18/04/2023 07:01

Those babies are already on the way, or here. Surrogacy is deliberately creating new babies into less than ideal circumstances (with an ugly side serve of exploitation and profiteering).

What do you mean 'already on the way'? They're not though are they. People are this moment chosing/hoping to concieve and brig children into the world under less favourable conditions....and they will continue to

JuneShitfield · 18/04/2023 07:59

Endlesssummer2022 · 18/04/2023 07:57

In a follow up to my last post on my suspicions around this glut of threads on surrogacy, I wouldn’t put it past hard right American Christian funded think tanks to be starting them.

I’ve noticed a common theme whereby the OP starts off attacking surrogacy and then PPs will bring in gay men going down that route and how that’s bad. They may pepper the post with trans stuff to make it extra sensational. This will be followed by attacks on sperm/egg donation, IVF and even adoption in some cases.

The perfect scenario is always that the baby is born to a woman and stays in a conventional family setting. The anger and passion of the posts makes it all sounds very Christian. It’s suspect.

Yes, I’ve noticed this too.

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 07:59

As I understand it, there are various restrictions/procedures in place in the UK to check that someone donating e.g. a kidney to a relative are doing so altruistically and not being exploited. Surely the same could be applied to women who choose to become surrogate mothers?

That would allow women in a position to make an informed, non-exploitative choice to do that if they chose.

Endlesssummer2022 · 18/04/2023 07:57

In a follow up to my last post on my suspicions around this glut of threads on surrogacy, I wouldn’t put it past hard right American Christian funded think tanks to be starting them.

I’ve noticed a common theme whereby the OP starts off attacking surrogacy and then PPs will bring in gay men going down that route and how that’s bad. They may pepper the post with trans stuff to make it extra sensational. This will be followed by attacks on sperm/egg donation, IVF and even adoption in some cases.

The perfect scenario is always that the baby is born to a woman and stays in a conventional family setting. The anger and passion of the posts makes it all sounds very Christian. It’s suspect.

KimberleyClark · 18/04/2023 07:55

EnaSharplesStout · 18/04/2023 07:47

@ChienChatCheval why do you think egg/sperm donation should be banned? I absolutely agree with the point about surrogacy- the babies are treated like bags of rice for sale and traumatised (as are the women often), but I don’t see the same with egg/sperm donation. Those aren’t babies to be damaged, and the resulting babies are raised by the mother they know, the one who gestated them.

You don’t mention egg donors, just donation. Using donated eggs is using a another woman’s body just like surrogacy except to a lesser degree. Egg donation is invasive, painful and risky. There’s a dark, exploitative side to it, especially egg sharing in return for cheaper IVF, and especially in countries where it’s less well regulated than here and impoverished young women are able to be targeted.

JuneShitfield · 18/04/2023 07:55

Personally, I think there’s definitely some tightening-up that needs to happen around the legalities of surrogacy, especially as regards the rights of the child. But some of the gatekeeping around quote-unquote ‘natural’ fertility on threads like this is truly alarming.

PuttingDownRoots · 18/04/2023 07:53

In the olden days it was acceptable for "respectable" couples to basically be able to buy a baby from the "orphanage" i.e. from a mother deemed unfit to raise her child.
Mother and Baby homes like these are now seen as abhorrent.

Commercial surrogacy is just the modern version. Its banned in most if Western Europe, the UK is an outlier.

Truly altruistic surrogacy, with no money involved, a sister for example has less ethical issues.

I've no doubt that a lot of couples involved in surrogacy make great parents. As did a lot of couples involved in the old adoption practices. Doesnt make it right.

Blossomtoes · 18/04/2023 07:51

SoupedUpSue · 18/04/2023 07:49

For many people having someone else’s organ is their only chance of not dying. Should we allow the sale of human organs?

No, of course we shouldn’t. Nor should we disallow altruistic surrogacy.

Aussiegirl123456 · 18/04/2023 07:51

KimberleyClark · 18/04/2023 07:44

But then I look at the little girl who currently lives across the road from me, who is only 3. She’s just had her eggs frozen as she’s undergoing brutal chemotherapy for cancer which will leave her infertile, if she survives. And then I think how fucking cruel is the world to take the opportunity of choice of being a parent away from such a small and innocent child?

Poor little thing. But I thought egg freezing was only possible for girls who have gone through puberty?

I don’t know the full details to be perfectly honest. It may have been her ovaries that have been frozen. Either way, it is truly sad.

SoupedUpSue · 18/04/2023 07:49

justgettingthroughtheday · 18/04/2023 03:42

Go away with your goady threads.
For some of us it is our only chance of being parents through no fault of our own. Just because you were lucky enough to carry children doesn't make you judge of other people.

For many people having someone else’s organ is their only chance of not dying. Should we allow the sale of human organs?

OhHolyJesus · 18/04/2023 07:49

I am probably in the wrong focusing so much on technical terms perhaps, but my wider point still stands that surrogacy is exploitive to both mother and baby for the reasons stated in the OP.

Not at all OP, if you think about the language and labels of how the way the surrogacy industry and media manipulated stories on surrogacy, often erasing the biological mother completely ("born through surrogacy") your focus is entirely appropriate and relevant.

In adoption the biological mother is often called the birth mother - in surrogacy she is the 'surrogate'. It doesn't take much to understand why 'mother' is completely done away with.

Folicacidtablets · 18/04/2023 07:48

If it’s the surrogates egg then yes she is the biological mother. If it’s a donor egg then no, she is not the biological mother. It’s that simple.

If you want to go into a debate about whether surrogacy is right or not you really need to present your argument in other ways as trying to change fact isn’t going to help your argument . Move away from the genetic side of things and try to focus on the ethics if you feel the need to

KimberleyClark · 18/04/2023 07:48

Just because you are infertile does not give you the right to shut down debates about the ethics of ways of overcoming infertility. I say this as an infertile person.

EnaSharplesStout · 18/04/2023 07:47

ChienChatCheval · 18/04/2023 04:29

Being a parent isn’t a right. You’re not entitled to it. You shouldn’t be allowed to rent a woman and her womb because you want a baby. You post shows that it’s all about the wants of adults and nothing to do with the resulting baby.

I think using egg and sperm donors in any circumstances is wrong too.

It should all be banned imo.

@ChienChatCheval why do you think egg/sperm donation should be banned? I absolutely agree with the point about surrogacy- the babies are treated like bags of rice for sale and traumatised (as are the women often), but I don’t see the same with egg/sperm donation. Those aren’t babies to be damaged, and the resulting babies are raised by the mother they know, the one who gestated them.

berksandbeyond · 18/04/2023 07:45

justgettingthroughtheday · 18/04/2023 03:42

Go away with your goady threads.
For some of us it is our only chance of being parents through no fault of our own. Just because you were lucky enough to carry children doesn't make you judge of other people.

What makes you think it’s an automatic right to have a baby? It’s not

Nicecow · 18/04/2023 07:45

DisquietintheRanks · 18/04/2023 07:25

@BoredOfThisMansWorld the idea that newborns are traumatised by removal at birth from their surrgogate (birth) mother and being raised by an adoptive parent is a theory not a fact. Interestingly it's a trauma that doesnt manifest if the birth mother dies or babies are accidentally swapped at birth, or if a wet nurse or nanny is used- those babies simply bond to their new caregiver. Which makes me suspect that those that claim otherwise for surrogacy have an agenda.

Agree. Having a child is ultimately a selfish act (unless perhaps you are adopting an underprivileged child from somewhere that has been abandonded). There are examples all the time that show people are putting themselves before their child, it's a sliding scale and you can't really say everything is ok except for surrogacy.

Endlesssummer2022 · 18/04/2023 07:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I agree. Everyday there seems to be a new thread started in the middle of the night on surrogacy with PPs whipping themselves into escalating levels of frenzy. It almost seems like a coordinated campaign. It’s nasty.

I’m under no illusion some surrogates are exploited and that more safeguards could be considered but in many many cases surrogacy is completely fine for all parties including the child.

People become parents in many different ways and this campaign against a particular set of parents is not in the spirit.

Pottedpalm · 18/04/2023 07:45

justgettingthroughtheday · 18/04/2023 03:42

Go away with your goady threads.
For some of us it is our only chance of being parents through no fault of our own. Just because you were lucky enough to carry children doesn't make you judge of other people.

This

OhHolyJesus · 18/04/2023 07:45

The person who provided the egg is the biological mother.
The person who went through the pregnancy is the birth mother.
And the person who raises the child is the mother.

The woman who provides the egg is the genetic mother, and there is a genetic relationship with any of her other children by whatever means those children come are conceived.

The woman who gives birth is the birth mother and as birth is a biological process she is the biological mother. See fetal microchimerism and DNA methylation.

The parents - of either sex - raise the child are the social and usually also the legal parents (if they have had a parental order in the U.K., though this process is set to change - see nordicmodelnow.org/2023/04/01/ask-your-mp-to-say-no-to-commercial-style-surrogacy-in-the-uk/

KimberleyClark · 18/04/2023 07:44

But then I look at the little girl who currently lives across the road from me, who is only 3. She’s just had her eggs frozen as she’s undergoing brutal chemotherapy for cancer which will leave her infertile, if she survives. And then I think how fucking cruel is the world to take the opportunity of choice of being a parent away from such a small and innocent child?

Poor little thing. But I thought egg freezing was only possible for girls who have gone through puberty?

Aerosarethebest · 18/04/2023 07:42

Arewethereyet22 · 18/04/2023 07:11

Dads don’t carry babies, they still have as close a bond with their babies as the mum who carries them. So why wouldn’t a parent have as close a bond with their child even if they weren’t able to carry them. I don’t like commercial surrogacy for the reasons already mentioned but I don’t buy the argument that the baby will be traumatised from being ‘ripped from the birth mum’ if they’re going straight to the intended parents.

Not at birth they don’t. If they are good, present Dads then they develop that bond over the comings days, weeks, months and years. Which parent gave birth is unlikely to be the deciding factor in which parent an 18year feels they have a stronger bond with. But at 2 minutes old? 2 days old? 2 weeks old? It makes a huge difference. Mothers have a months long head start on that bond from the baby’s point of view. It’s not helpful to lie to Dads (or mums in lesbian couples where their wife is the one giving birth) about this either. It can come as a bit of a shock when you were expecting your newborn to love you both the same, and they don’t.

W0tnow · 18/04/2023 07:41

True. But as adults, the children of sperm doners seek their biological fathers, and when the law was against them, there was much emotional turmoil. This is why anonymous sperm donation is no longer possible.

what we know for sure, is that people want to know who their genetic parents are. I’m going to guess that they will want to know who their birth mothers are, too.

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 18/04/2023 07:41

I guess it’s good we can all individually believe what we want because I don’t agree with you.

Beenhereforever1978 · 18/04/2023 07:39

SnapchatJustForTheFilters · 18/04/2023 06:15

For me, I can see both sides of the surrogacy debate. When talking about a completely ALIVE surrogate who has given permission (all moral debate aside, obvs).

This fresh circle of hell, however: https://www.womenshealthmag.com/uk/health/a42773281/brain-stem-dead-women-surrogates-backlash/

So….is using a brain dead woman for her womb the natural next step for surrogacy???

That article is utterly terrifying. Thankyou for sharing.

Milksheikha · 18/04/2023 07:38

I find the concept of foreign surrogacy akin to foreign sex tourism.
Go to a country where the laws are loose and order baby comparative to going to buy underage sex .
The attitude of paying for something you want and disregarding ethics is incredible..

I hope people are aware that often women are forced into being surrogates and criminal gangs are behind the glossy xlinic webpages in Eastern Europe. Women and babies die in this shady business.