Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a surrogate mother...

682 replies

BackDownSouth · 18/04/2023 03:31

Is the biological mother of a surrogate baby that she delivers, even in cases where another egg was used? One thing I hate hearing in the surrogacy debate by pro-surrogacy folks (who like to minimise the connection between mother and child and the effect that separation at birth can have on both) is “the surrogate has no biological relation to the baby” in cases where an egg other than the surrogate’s own were used. Of course she has a biological connection to the baby. She doesn’t have a GENETIC link to the baby - no. But biological? She has about as much of a biological connection with it as she would her own genetic child. The baby is quite literally made of her. The genetic material of the egg may predetermine baby’s genetic make-up to match that of the intended mother’s egg but that is such a shallow link compared to the nurturing happening during the pregnancy. It's the surrogate mother’s body building and nurturing that child. The mother’s body will likely forever retain snippets of the child’s DNA - particularly traces of Y chromosome if she carries a boy. Everything the mother does or eats or feels will influence that child. The baby knows her smell and voice and as soon as they are born they seek her, and they will feel stress at being placed into a stranger’s arms rather than mum’s immediately after birth. It’s completely ridiculous to say there is no biological connection between surrogate and baby. What’s more of a connection, really, to a newborn baby who has no concept of themselves other than the birth mother who is all they have ever known? Is the baby bothered about a mother who makes up half of their DNA but who has been on the other side of the world since their conception and is going to lay claim to them through a financial transaction? Or is the baby instead going to crave the presence of the woman who has grown and nurtured them? The surrogate is mum and the baby is going to need her post-birth no matter how much people want to ignore that.

People like to say “DNA is nothing” in the context of the love between step-parents and their stepchildren, adoptive children etc, and that’s rightly so. A genetic link isn’t what makes a family. But in the case of surrogacies, this is all completely thrown out of the window and the idea of a surrogate mother bonding with her baby (because it is her baby…) is inconceivable because she ‘isn’t even related to them’ despite literally creating and birthing the child.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Humanbiology · 20/04/2023 19:55

Blaueblumen · 19/04/2023 16:44

It is though. It is the most wanted loved thing and everyone involved is doing what they can for that baby

It may be the most desired 'thing' in the world that someone is absolutely desperate for.

It is simply not fair on the innocent baby (that has to be removed from its birth mother) and it is not fair on the 'surrogate' being used to make the baby for you!!

Do you judge surrogate women for their choices do you think they are the problem. If there weren't willing women to do it then there would be no surrogate babies.

Newnamenewname109870 · 20/04/2023 19:51

What about donated embryos? there are so many things that I don’t believe should be ‘banned’ even if it’s something that needs careful monitoring.

Newnamenewname109870 · 20/04/2023 19:48

EmmaGrundyForPM · 20/04/2023 09:09

@Newnamenewname109870 you are talking rubbish. You're trying to justify surrogacy through an "the end justifies the means" argument. It doesn't stack up.

Infertility is a horrible situation, but trafficking a baby (which is NOT a 'thing' as you put it) is not the solution.

It’s because I don’t view it as trafficking when it is not, you know, actual trafficking. I’ve seen it from a very different point of view. The same way I don’t see all abortion as child murder. There are positives and negatives for it in different situations. But fine, fully ban surrogacy in all countries in the world and let’s see what starts to happen.

tigger2022 · 20/04/2023 18:51

I don't really agree. I work in clinical research so I think about medical ethics a lot. It's about weighing up the pros and cons, not ignoring all of either. The joy of parenthood IS a valid benefit (who doesn't have children for themselves?!) but you have to weigh that against the risks which in my opinion in the case of surrogacy are too great. It's about saying the risks outweigh the benefits, not that benefits don't exist.

ClumsyCat · 20/04/2023 09:25

I think

ClumsyCat · 20/04/2023 09:24

I think any reader who has made it this far in the thread will now understand that you don’t actually understand ethics. You don’t understand exploitation of other humans.

@Helleofabore I don’t think Newnamenewname109870 is far from alone alone in not understanding ethics. My feeling is that most people don’t give much thought to ethics at all and their morals just cycle around ‘might is right’, ‘the ends justify the means’ and ‘do as you’d be done by’.

Questions about the ethics about creating one human being specifically to solve the pain of another, are just too heady and far out.

If someone thinks we should create a human being to solve someone else’s pain through surrogacy, why not do it for organ harvesting (talking of movies - My Sister’s Keeper is broadly about this)? Or how about deliberate breeding some human beings with low intelligence, high agreeability and high physical strength to do jobs other people don’t want to do?

EmmaGrundyForPM · 20/04/2023 09:09

@Newnamenewname109870 you are talking rubbish. You're trying to justify surrogacy through an "the end justifies the means" argument. It doesn't stack up.

Infertility is a horrible situation, but trafficking a baby (which is NOT a 'thing' as you put it) is not the solution.

ClumsyCat · 20/04/2023 09:08

brownbeauty80 · 20/04/2023 09:01

@BiscuitLover3678
I saw this... thought the exact same...

I just read the plot of it - that’s really deep and seems to cover so many of the ethical questions about surrogacy.

Helleofabore · 20/04/2023 09:04

Newnamenewname109870 · 19/04/2023 14:20

In none of these posts have I said that’s ok. I’m talking about ethical surrogacy. It does exist. And yes it’s worth it to all those involved. Infertility can cause someone to feel suicidal, whereas surrogacy can be a solution to that problem. The debate is good, sure. More needs to be done to protect exploited women. This debate keeps going round and round. Some of us believe that when done ethically, it is perfectly ok and in fact a good option for people on our society.

“I’m talking about ethical surrogacy. It does exist. And yes it’s worth it to all those involved. Infertility can cause someone to feel suicidal, whereas surrogacy can be a solution to that problem.”

Fuck! I wasn’t dreaming it last night when I skimmed through!

You, a poster who asserts there is such thing as ‘ethical surrogacy’, cannot see the completely unethical mastery in this paragraph you wrote!

There is no fucking way to ever dress up surrogacy to be an ethical prescription to prevent an adult human committing suicide!

I think any reader who has made it this far in the thread will now understand that you don’t actually understand ethics. You don’t understand exploitation of other humans.

”This debate keeps going round and round. Some of us believe that when done ethically, it is perfectly ok and in fact a good option for people on our society.”

Of course the debate goes round and round when you have no understanding of ethics.

Then in the next post you wrote this gem:

”And the desire to have children can surpass all else, life itself. Some people clearly don’t have that in them and it’s fine. It’s like how some people are able to be celibate and some would rather die then never be able to masturbate/have sex. It’s a human need just like any other and some of us have stronger urges than others. It really frustrates me how some people minimalise this.”

If you have such a poor understanding of ‘ethics’, you are going to always be unhappy that others can recognize when ethical boundaries are crossed!

You have now brought in the other way human beings are exploited. Sex. So, do you also believe that prostitution is not exploiting another human body for someone’s ‘need’.

Would you also prescribe a prostitution as a suicide prevention treatment?

“It is the most wanted loved thing and everyone involved is doing what they can for that baby. ”

Fuck! The doors on ethics are wide open here.

So, what other exploitative actions are ok to be dismissed as ‘ethical’ because the result is that ‘thing’ will be much wanted and loved?

And exploitation is fine as long as everyone is doing what they can for that ‘thing’!

You know what that ‘thing’ is? A human being that has been created to prevent an adult from committing suicide or to fulfill the need to have a child that is so bad that other human beings are exploited to remove that need for that adult.

Readers, have the red flags been taken notice of yet? Is the alarm bell being heard?

”So much black and white thinking and no discussion on how to make it legal and ethical, so not much more I can add really.”

Thanks though for showing us what you consider the ‘middle ground’ you assured us earlier really did exist.

brownbeauty80 · 20/04/2023 09:01

@BiscuitLover3678
I saw this... thought the exact same...

Milksheikha · 20/04/2023 04:25

Baby factories actually exist .

www.aljazeera.com/features/2018/9/13/ukraines-baby-factories-the-human-cost-of-surrogacy

Helleofabore · 20/04/2023 00:18

And people are complaining that others understand the ethical issues, so are more ‘black and white’ about the exploitation of children and women to produce a designer child on demand to fulfill an adult’s wish.

Blimey. People understand that there is no such thing as ‘ethical’ surrogacy because they don’t believe that transactions that involve the deliberate creation of a child that is to be born through surrogacy can be ethical. Because at the very least the child has been exploited.

What is also astounding to read is that there are people on this thread that seem to believe that this exploitation of another human being is ok. Because they are given love in return.

Alright then. Exploitation is perfectly fine, it seems, if love is being given as payment. I guess love, a fabulous home, lots of luxuries makes exploitation of another human beingacceptable then.

Good to know.

Helleofabore · 19/04/2023 23:50

.Did I really just read that a child should be deliberately created and at least one woman’s body exploited because some one might be suicidal?

Did I really read that as a justification?

BiscuitLover3678 · 19/04/2023 17:54

Has anyone else watched Mimi? It’s a Bollywood film and there are some aspects of it I don’t agree (such as the overall messaging that motherhood trumps any career dreams etc) but it actually looks at what happens when surrogates are used abroad.

nothingcomestonothing · 19/04/2023 16:45

MagpieSong · 19/04/2023 14:47

To clarify, babies are humans with human emotions. They learn voices in the womb, they have emotional memories and it is beyond belief that someone would still believe no damage is done removing a baby from its birth parents. In all situations, if a child can stay in that situation it is seen as less traumatic. If they can stay with family instead that is the second option and always explored. If not, they are adopted. Nowadays that is the reason babies and children who come from severe trauma are up for adoption, because the trauma of removal must be less than them remaining in danger at home. Babies can not be immediately adopted, unless through concurrency or foster to adopt which is a high risk situation for adopters as it may not end in adoption but does provide stability for the child. It takes months to assess suitable matches from family and outside adopters. Sometimes babies may be getting over NAS or having their needs fully understood while in foster care prior to adoption. It is not generally a quick process. As adoptees, we know our birth parents could not care for us and as children we often read that as we were not good enough to be cared for. On top of that, we often feel different and have a need to know more about ourselves by meeting our relatives. Equally, we are often terrified of meeting them because we were rejected (through emotional feelings, though this may not be true as such it feels like this to many even if logically we can see why our parents couldn’t care for us) once before and once feels like too much already. It’s associated with deep shame and sadness for many. There is no question adoption is traumatic, but for many that trauma is necessary to keep them alive and has several positive factors too with loving parents who put huge amounts into their children.

Babies sitting in hospitals is different but awful. It risks bringing severe attachment issues, my sister was one of those babies as her mother disappeared. No one person meets their needs and nurses cannot answer all their cries, so they learn to not really cry and not to trust adults because they believe they cannot or will not fulfil their needs. A lack of primary carer has plenty of research around it too.

Thank you for posting this. I'm an adopter. My children are so loved, have their material wants and needs met, have lovely experiences and a happy life. None of that makes up for the effects of being removed from their birth mother. They are well and thriving, but that doesn't make it okay, and I can see the impact it has had and still has. The best thing for them would have been to be born to their birth mother and been safely able to stay with her. Creating babies to deliberately remove from their birth mother, to meet the wants of the adults involved, is selfish. It is never done in the best interests of the child, or with acknowledgement that the adults are willing to risk harmful, potentially lifelong effects on that child, to get what they want.

Blaueblumen · 19/04/2023 16:44

It is though. It is the most wanted loved thing and everyone involved is doing what they can for that baby

It may be the most desired 'thing' in the world that someone is absolutely desperate for.

It is simply not fair on the innocent baby (that has to be removed from its birth mother) and it is not fair on the 'surrogate' being used to make the baby for you!!

Blaueblumen · 19/04/2023 16:40

So much black and white thinking and no discussion on how to make it legal and ethical

That's because people feel that the whole concept of 'surrogacy' to produce a baby for someone else is WRONG and should never be made legal

Whiskeypowers · 19/04/2023 16:35

Newnamenewname109870 · 19/04/2023 16:14

It is though. It is the most wanted loved thing and everyone involved is doing what they can for that baby. This could go round for ever.

It’s not a thing
It’s a human being

you can talk about how loved and wanted the baby blah blah blah is the fact remains the renting of another woman’s body for the purposes of growing a baby to order for others will never be ethical.
The fact remains the baby is being removed from their birth mother not for their own safety - as in the derisory unfit mother /adoption argument being put forward here - but because one or two complete strangers have one way or another bought the child.

it’s basically a dystopian nightmare that would never come to pass if men were the ones that gave birth.

as a society we are unravelling if we continue to debate that the anguish of infertility somehow overcompensates for or washes away what is ultimately the baby trade in the case of surrogacy.

Laladybird · 19/04/2023 16:35

I think surrogacy is grotesque. There is a tiny number of women who will do it freely, as a gift to a childless couple. But as others have said, that doesn't take the child's attachment needs into account.

I do wonder what goes on in the minds of (the very few) volunteer surrogates. Ain't no way I'd carry a child for nine months to give it away.

Commercial womb renting is just a particularly abusive arm of the prostitution industry. All payments for eggs and womb space should be illegal. Then see how many women choose to do it.

KimberleyClark · 19/04/2023 16:23

Newnamenewname109870 · 19/04/2023 16:16

A wonderful idea!

Hmmm - either receiving the womb of a dead woman or requiring a living woman to undergo major surgery. A womb is not a life saving organ.

lifeturnsonadime · 19/04/2023 16:21

Newnamenewname109870 · 19/04/2023 16:18

A lot of big assumptions here 🙄 yep I’m out

It's not assumptions though it is based on research and anecdotal evidence from people who were brought up by adoptive parents.

It is obvious it is going to upset those who think a surrogate mother is no more than a vessel. It doesn't make it untrue.

ClumsyCat · 19/04/2023 16:20

Newnamenewname109870 · 19/04/2023 16:18

A lot of big assumptions here 🙄 yep I’m out

Surely it’s an assumption to suggest that babies aren’t affected by being separated from their mothers? 🤔

lifeturnsonadime · 19/04/2023 16:19

ClumsyCat · 19/04/2023 16:16

It must be human nature to at least wonder about the woman who carried you in pregnancy!

I imagine there is something more powerful than just ‘wondering’ - more like feeling an emotional wound from the trauma- non-intellectual and visceral.

I agree, I talked about it earlier.

My friend who was adopted at birth and was brought up in a very loving adoptive family has always felt that something is missing. It has affected her entire life.

Newnamenewname109870 · 19/04/2023 16:18

ClumsyCat · 19/04/2023 16:16

It must be human nature to at least wonder about the woman who carried you in pregnancy!

I imagine there is something more powerful than just ‘wondering’ - more like feeling an emotional wound from the trauma- non-intellectual and visceral.

A lot of big assumptions here 🙄 yep I’m out

Newnamenewname109870 · 19/04/2023 16:17

I’m tempted to leave this thread now. So much black and white thinking and no discussion on how to make it legal and ethical, so not much more I can add really.