Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a surrogate mother...

682 replies

BackDownSouth · 18/04/2023 03:31

Is the biological mother of a surrogate baby that she delivers, even in cases where another egg was used? One thing I hate hearing in the surrogacy debate by pro-surrogacy folks (who like to minimise the connection between mother and child and the effect that separation at birth can have on both) is “the surrogate has no biological relation to the baby” in cases where an egg other than the surrogate’s own were used. Of course she has a biological connection to the baby. She doesn’t have a GENETIC link to the baby - no. But biological? She has about as much of a biological connection with it as she would her own genetic child. The baby is quite literally made of her. The genetic material of the egg may predetermine baby’s genetic make-up to match that of the intended mother’s egg but that is such a shallow link compared to the nurturing happening during the pregnancy. It's the surrogate mother’s body building and nurturing that child. The mother’s body will likely forever retain snippets of the child’s DNA - particularly traces of Y chromosome if she carries a boy. Everything the mother does or eats or feels will influence that child. The baby knows her smell and voice and as soon as they are born they seek her, and they will feel stress at being placed into a stranger’s arms rather than mum’s immediately after birth. It’s completely ridiculous to say there is no biological connection between surrogate and baby. What’s more of a connection, really, to a newborn baby who has no concept of themselves other than the birth mother who is all they have ever known? Is the baby bothered about a mother who makes up half of their DNA but who has been on the other side of the world since their conception and is going to lay claim to them through a financial transaction? Or is the baby instead going to crave the presence of the woman who has grown and nurtured them? The surrogate is mum and the baby is going to need her post-birth no matter how much people want to ignore that.

People like to say “DNA is nothing” in the context of the love between step-parents and their stepchildren, adoptive children etc, and that’s rightly so. A genetic link isn’t what makes a family. But in the case of surrogacies, this is all completely thrown out of the window and the idea of a surrogate mother bonding with her baby (because it is her baby…) is inconceivable because she ‘isn’t even related to them’ despite literally creating and birthing the child.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 10:14

Aerosarethebest · 18/04/2023 09:50

I actually think live kidney donation is a very reasonable comparison. Perhaps we should be looking at how living donor organ donation is done as a blue print for the ethical management of surrogacy.

The life saving aspect of any organ donation is being minimised or handwaved away here.

As is the rights of the human being being transacted.

Donating a kidney has limited comparative value. Unless you are of the belief that surrogacy is life saving.

This is a 9 month process, where the mother contributes parts of her body to that child at a much higher risk than a child of her egg. This is not ‘donating a kidney’.

It is minimising how pregnancy works as well as the rights of a child being a transaction.

Sure, have a process. But the very high potential for emotional coercion around surrogacy is going to be adequately assessed how?

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 10:12

drspouse · 18/04/2023 10:10

Let's just correct something right there.
Adopters are not "incredible". They are just normal parents who try to be good enough.
And while we're at it, adoptees are not "lucky". And yes (despite what some adopters say) they do miss being with their birth mums. It's not "lucky" to be fed drugs before or after birth nor to have a birth mum who can't care for you. It's incredibly unlucky. Adoption is the best solution to a horrible problem.

Very valid points.

DD is thriving without the biological/DNA connection.

Ideally her biological parents would have cared for her, but it has not been 'tremendously' damaging for that connection to be severed. It wasn't ideal, but there are plenty of other everyday factors that are equally damaging to children.

tigger2022 · 18/04/2023 10:12

@drspouse errrrr don't know where you got the idea I was in favour of drugging newborns?! For the record, I'm against that!! 😬

LotsofVikings · 18/04/2023 10:10

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 10:01

@LotsofVikings

That's awful.

Can you complain about the bias?

I can totally understand where you are coming from. It's human nature to wonder and a sense of regret is completely understandable to me.

It was such a long time ago, I don't feel like I can. Perhaps I should. I find talking about it extremely difficult and still feel guilt and shame about it. If I tell, for example, a friend about what I did, the universal reaction is what a great thing I did, so it feels very difficult to say actually, I don't feel like it was a wonderful thing. And then I assume people will think 'well, you got a baby out of it' and think I'm a dick, so I keep it to myself. I probably should complain but it's something I usually try to avoid thinking about- just thought it was pertinent to this discussion.

Extrapolating a bit, if I feel the way I feel about donating an egg, a significant number of surrogates must feel traumatised by handing over an actual baby. We hear lots of stories about happy outcomes from surrogacy and women who were happy to give this gift- if the rhetoric is that surrogacy is beautiful, wonderful, an amazing gift to give to a family, I can imagine that makes it very difficult for women who were surrogates to say 'actually, I don't feel that way' when it seems like society wants them to be these amazing, altruistic gift givers.

Maybe I'm not explaining it very well.

AutumnDaysConkers · 18/04/2023 10:10

Surrogacy should be banned.
It actually makes me feel sick when I see the 'parents' with their new born child looking all smug and happy as if they have just bought a new car.
All I can think about is the feelings and the needs of the baby and the poor mother who has just given birth.
Even worse when it is celebrities who already have children such as Aida Williams, Kim and Khloe kardashian etc.

drspouse · 18/04/2023 10:10

tigger2022 · 18/04/2023 10:02

@drspouse that's amazing I think people who adopt are incredible. I have a biological son and want to start fostering in 10-15 years time. I know that's not the normal way of doing it but I felt like I didn't have enough experience to care for a kid who's been through stuff yet. The child should always come first, but surrogacy is child-last.

Let's just correct something right there.
Adopters are not "incredible". They are just normal parents who try to be good enough.
And while we're at it, adoptees are not "lucky". And yes (despite what some adopters say) they do miss being with their birth mums. It's not "lucky" to be fed drugs before or after birth nor to have a birth mum who can't care for you. It's incredibly unlucky. Adoption is the best solution to a horrible problem.

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 10:09

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 10:03

what about the child?

The one deliberately created to be transacted on the fulfillment of an adults wishes? Where is the child’s rights in all of this?

This is not the same as a child being naturally conceived or even assisted in being conceived with an ongoing parent -child relationship. This really is a transaction where a child is sold, even if money has not changed hands.

Why is it different?

Children are created to fulfil adult needs, let's face it. There is no rational reason to have a child in developed societies (in some societies children are needed for their labour).

Anyone choosing to have a baby does it to meet their emotional needs. Ideally (and in most cases) that results in the baby being well cared for.

But there is no reason for any baby to be conceived and brought to term, except the wants of the adults.

tigger2022 · 18/04/2023 10:06

@LotsofVikings that's awful, I think the egg exchange programme is so exploitative. I actually wanted to donate eggs for genuinely altruistic reasons but couldn't at the time for health reasons and now I still would but I'm too old! I understand that the eggs are less reliable when you're older but they are prioritising coercing younger women who maybe haven't had children of their own yet over older women who still have eggs but are less likely to feel regret.

Jonei · 18/04/2023 10:05

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 09:58

It's not a goady thread and infertility does not give you the right to either exploit other womens bodies or stop the rest of us from talking about that exploitation.

OP was correct in what she said, and you likely know that which is why you are so defensive off the bat.

This.

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 10:04

EmotionalSupportHyena · 18/04/2023 09:56

The difference is that a kidney is not a sentient being who will grow up knowing he or she was given up by his/her birth mother, who may or may not still be around at family
gatherings.

(plus a kidney transplant is life saving rather than life creating. There is even a study into why people make this comparison, when it’s not really a comparable scenario at all)

plus, there are some really weird legal issues around parents by surrogacy in the case of couple separation too - eg a sister could have a baby for her infertile sister using her sister’s partner’s sperm and an anonymous egg donor and the partner could theoretically claim full custody of the baby because the baby is not biologically related to his ex or the ex sister in law, only him.

https://www.lawsociety.ie/gazette/top-stories/2022/may/break-ups-cause-huge-control-issues-for-those-using-surrogacy

An ex can’t do a runner with the kidney his SIL gave to her sister!

Yes, there are currently weird legal aspects that should be clarified.

Y'know, there are adopted children who are happy with their adoptive family and don't have a burning need to connect with their birth family. DD would be devastated to lose contact with her older sister, because they grew up together for 7/8 years as sisters. The rest of her birth family? Well, neither one way or the other, she doesn't miss them though is quite happy to say 'hi' from time to time.

She is very connected to previous carers and friends, and would miss them if she lost contact.

So the genetic connection isn't the be all and end all.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 10:03

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 09:44

No, but I think women should be able to decide what they do with their own body.

There needs to be protection against exploitation. But also if a woman decides to carry a child on behalf on someone else, knowing the risks, they I think they should be able to.

I wouldn't want to, I wouldn't think many would. But just as I wouldn't tell another woman that they should or shouldn't have an abortion, I wouldn't tell them they shouldn't have a baby.

what about the child?

The one deliberately created to be transacted on the fulfillment of an adults wishes? Where is the child’s rights in all of this?

This is not the same as a child being naturally conceived or even assisted in being conceived with an ongoing parent -child relationship. This really is a transaction where a child is sold, even if money has not changed hands.

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 10:03

EmotionalSupportHyena · 18/04/2023 10:01

That sounds like a massive headfuck Flowers
I would imagine your feelings are not unusual and I’m horrified to hear first how one-sided the counselling was (I have read about it in articles but not directly from someone directly affected).

It's exploitation ultimately.

I think it's completely unethical.

Jonei · 18/04/2023 10:02

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 09:54

when the impact upon the birth mother and baby are likely to be tremendously damaging both physically and psychologically.

It isn't 'tremendously' damaging for the baby. I have an adopted child. She has been significantly impacted by the abuse and neglect she experienced in her birth family. Being separated at birth from her first mother? No - it wouldn't have been ideal, but also not 'tremendously' damaging, not compared with her birth mother putting alcohol in her formula milk for example.

The two aren't comparable. It's great that your adopted child has you. And adoption sounds like a good outcome for your child under the circumstances. But it would also be better if your child had not experienced what happened to them in the first place. So the best outcome was found for them under the circumstances that were beyond their control. Surrogacy is not the same by any stretch of the imagination. We do not start off with the premise of causing children harm. We do rescue them from harm however (as in your case). You're making it around the needs of the adult, not the child, by conflating the two situations.

tigger2022 · 18/04/2023 10:02

@drspouse that's amazing I think people who adopt are incredible. I have a biological son and want to start fostering in 10-15 years time. I know that's not the normal way of doing it but I felt like I didn't have enough experience to care for a kid who's been through stuff yet. The child should always come first, but surrogacy is child-last.

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 10:02

Endlesssummer2022 · 18/04/2023 07:57

In a follow up to my last post on my suspicions around this glut of threads on surrogacy, I wouldn’t put it past hard right American Christian funded think tanks to be starting them.

I’ve noticed a common theme whereby the OP starts off attacking surrogacy and then PPs will bring in gay men going down that route and how that’s bad. They may pepper the post with trans stuff to make it extra sensational. This will be followed by attacks on sperm/egg donation, IVF and even adoption in some cases.

The perfect scenario is always that the baby is born to a woman and stays in a conventional family setting. The anger and passion of the posts makes it all sounds very Christian. It’s suspect.

I don't know what posts you are reading. That's not at all accurate., Every thread says this isn't about gay men, we are just as opposed to women in a "conventional family" (whatever that is) re surrogacy.

From anyone with a strong opinion on it its very clear that they mean ALL surrogacy, and not at all the picture you are painting.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 18/04/2023 10:01

LotsofVikings · 18/04/2023 09:50

Just a personal experience, but I shared my eggs in return for cheaper IVF. The counselling they gave me was all very one-sided, explaining to me how it was a wonderful thing to do and I very much shouldn't think any children born from my donation as 'my' baby.

The problem was, that was exactly how I felt about it after I'd done it, which I'm sure the counsellor would have told me was misguided. I didn't choose or want to feel that way, I just couldn't help it. I did it because I was desperate to have a baby but after I'd done it, I was tortured by the idea of having a child that was genetically related to me out there somewhere and not knowing whether they were happy, well cared for, or how they would feel about the whole thing. And there was no support available for me- it felt like I was just told there was a right way to think about it and that was that.

It's still something that troubles me to this day. I was too afraid to call the clinic to ask for a long time but in the end I did and the relief when I was told that no children were born from my donation was immeasurable. But I also felt this tremendous guilt because I did conceive, and benefitted in the form of cheap IVF, and what kind of person does that make me to feel like I feel about it.

That sounds like a massive headfuck Flowers
I would imagine your feelings are not unusual and I’m horrified to hear first how one-sided the counselling was (I have read about it in articles but not directly from someone directly affected).

Dibbydoos · 18/04/2023 10:01

MissAmelia · 18/04/2023 03:56

The surrogacy business, in particular surrogates abroad where poor women are being used by British couples, is repulsive to me. Using another woman in this way, who has limited choices should not be allowed.
There are plenty of testimonies of devastated women, who have become surrogates to feed their existing children.
Any woman who gives birth to a child is a mother.

Agree 100% they are a vessel. And from the countries uou refer to, the pittance paid to them feels like a fortune.

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 10:01

@LotsofVikings

That's awful.

Can you complain about the bias?

I can totally understand where you are coming from. It's human nature to wonder and a sense of regret is completely understandable to me.

Georgeandzippyzoo · 18/04/2023 10:00

I have a birth son but tried IUI to have more with DH which didn't work.
My view previously was that surrogacy was ok as long as it wasn't done for financial gain, going to a lovely family who desperately want them.
12yrs later we started Fostering(older children ,) and the training and research I've done in pre birth effects on children, removal from birth mum and handed over to a 'new' person and the effect this has on their lives really makes me question how surrogacy is done.
When a foster child is going to adoption there are several steps where they meet the adoptive parents over time, with the foster parents stepping back so the child can 'attach' which helps the child.
A baby simply handed over at birth is going to suffer. Their only safety has gone and no matter how much love the new parents hive , that is STILL a loss for that baby.
I understand that biological refers to DNA but i do get where OP talks about the gestational mum being biological - she has given ghat embryo life, she has nutured fed and grown that baby, all of those things are biological in nature.
Anything done financially feels immoral and if it continues maybe the time of birth and early life needs to be developed further only for the benefit if the baby, not for ease or convenience of the parents to be.

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 10:00

tigger2022 · 18/04/2023 09:45

At the time of signing "consent" it is quite literally impossible to know how you will feel towards a hypothetical child you give birth to that doesn't even exist. When that baby is real and a part of you it's no wonder so many mums change their minds.

That's a valid point, and consent should be reversible until the baby is finally placed.

And all parties should know that in advance, and make an informed choice based on that.

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 09:58

justgettingthroughtheday · 18/04/2023 03:42

Go away with your goady threads.
For some of us it is our only chance of being parents through no fault of our own. Just because you were lucky enough to carry children doesn't make you judge of other people.

It's not a goady thread and infertility does not give you the right to either exploit other womens bodies or stop the rest of us from talking about that exploitation.

OP was correct in what she said, and you likely know that which is why you are so defensive off the bat.

drspouse · 18/04/2023 09:57

justgettingthroughtheday · 18/04/2023 03:42

Go away with your goady threads.
For some of us it is our only chance of being parents through no fault of our own. Just because you were lucky enough to carry children doesn't make you judge of other people.

Why do you have the right to be a parent? Why is it goady to ask this?

(I am an adoptive parent by the way. We adopted children who needed a home, we did not buy a woman's body to create them).

EmotionalSupportHyena · 18/04/2023 09:56

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 09:42

The same for donating a kidney

The difference is that a kidney is not a sentient being who will grow up knowing he or she was given up by his/her birth mother, who may or may not still be around at family
gatherings.

(plus a kidney transplant is life saving rather than life creating. There is even a study into why people make this comparison, when it’s not really a comparable scenario at all)

plus, there are some really weird legal issues around parents by surrogacy in the case of couple separation too - eg a sister could have a baby for her infertile sister using her sister’s partner’s sperm and an anonymous egg donor and the partner could theoretically claim full custody of the baby because the baby is not biologically related to his ex or the ex sister in law, only him.

https://www.lawsociety.ie/gazette/top-stories/2022/may/break-ups-cause-huge-control-issues-for-those-using-surrogacy

An ex can’t do a runner with the kidney his SIL gave to her sister!

Break-ups cause ‘huge control issues’ for those using surrogacy

‘Frightening’ imbalance of power can ensue

https://www.lawsociety.ie/gazette/top-stories/2022/may/break-ups-cause-huge-control-issues-for-those-using-surrogacy

StressedToTheMaxxx · 18/04/2023 09:55

"The baby knows her smell and voice and as soon as they are born they seek her, and they will feel stress at being placed into a stranger’s arms rather than mum’s immediately after birth".

So my baby felt stress at being placed in my partners arms immediately after birth while I was being stiched up following my c section? Hopefully she's not traumatised for life...

Useyourfork · 18/04/2023 09:54

A child should never ever be part of a commercial transaction. There will always be someone with dodgy ethics who will want to capitalise. Where does it all end baby farms, buyers wanting a return???