Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a surrogate mother...

682 replies

BackDownSouth · 18/04/2023 03:31

Is the biological mother of a surrogate baby that she delivers, even in cases where another egg was used? One thing I hate hearing in the surrogacy debate by pro-surrogacy folks (who like to minimise the connection between mother and child and the effect that separation at birth can have on both) is “the surrogate has no biological relation to the baby” in cases where an egg other than the surrogate’s own were used. Of course she has a biological connection to the baby. She doesn’t have a GENETIC link to the baby - no. But biological? She has about as much of a biological connection with it as she would her own genetic child. The baby is quite literally made of her. The genetic material of the egg may predetermine baby’s genetic make-up to match that of the intended mother’s egg but that is such a shallow link compared to the nurturing happening during the pregnancy. It's the surrogate mother’s body building and nurturing that child. The mother’s body will likely forever retain snippets of the child’s DNA - particularly traces of Y chromosome if she carries a boy. Everything the mother does or eats or feels will influence that child. The baby knows her smell and voice and as soon as they are born they seek her, and they will feel stress at being placed into a stranger’s arms rather than mum’s immediately after birth. It’s completely ridiculous to say there is no biological connection between surrogate and baby. What’s more of a connection, really, to a newborn baby who has no concept of themselves other than the birth mother who is all they have ever known? Is the baby bothered about a mother who makes up half of their DNA but who has been on the other side of the world since their conception and is going to lay claim to them through a financial transaction? Or is the baby instead going to crave the presence of the woman who has grown and nurtured them? The surrogate is mum and the baby is going to need her post-birth no matter how much people want to ignore that.

People like to say “DNA is nothing” in the context of the love between step-parents and their stepchildren, adoptive children etc, and that’s rightly so. A genetic link isn’t what makes a family. But in the case of surrogacies, this is all completely thrown out of the window and the idea of a surrogate mother bonding with her baby (because it is her baby…) is inconceivable because she ‘isn’t even related to them’ despite literally creating and birthing the child.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 11:58

There are a couple of decisions my (biological) parents made which have had a major, negative, impact on my life. I understand the reasons, but the consequences were pretty bad for a number of years.

But this is not comparable to the yearning that many adopted people have to know their roots.

My friend doesn't know her medical history, doesn't know why she was abandoned (as she sees it), doesn't know if she has any genetic family. She has no other family left apart from distant cousins in the States. She hasn't had children because of the fact that she was worried she would be genetically disposed to child abandonment, I think she's wrong about that but it's how she feels. Her whole life is impacted.

It's very simplistic to say that a child conceived from a commercial arrangement would not have those kind of feelings, or that that might not resent the IPs if they felt the arrangement was born of a power imbalance. Humans are complex but the situations arising from this are nothing like bad decisions made by parents per se.

SadAsHell · 18/04/2023 11:55

If a woman is choosing to do this, willingly and fully knowing the process and / or implications, I have no problem with it. Her body, her choice. Whatever her reasons or gains are, it doesn't bother me, be they monetary, wanting to experience a pregnancy but not wanting a child, or to help a couple, or whatever other reasons they choose.

Obviously anybody being forced into it, or doing it unknowingly (in the wild scenario of being brain dead that I see being discussed) then obviously it is extremely wrong, as it would be if anybody was forced into anything they did not want to do or didn't know they were doing!

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 11:54

The fact that adopted children often have attachment disorders is also no coincidence.

Also, those attachment disorders in adopted children are often because of the reasons - abuse and neglect - that they had to be removed from their birth families! NOT because they were then placed with adoptive parents.

Humanbiology · 18/04/2023 11:53

ShivRoy2nd · 18/04/2023 11:46

I agree @BackDownSouth surrogacy can be summarised as a mother handing her baby over for money to a complete stranger. I feel so sorry for those poor babies taken away from everything they’ve ever known.

There is more to bringing up a child than pushing it out that's only the start and then there is the rest. Don't get me wrong I have enjoyed bringing up my children but it's been fucking hard work emotionally and mentally and children is not easy when they are ready. It takes a mother to bring up a child and that title doesn't belong to all parents who am I to deny another woman that joy?

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 11:52

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 11:47

My point stands you can't possibly KNOW how she will feel at any point in the future.

Even is she doesn't feel the need it doesn't negate the fact that many many people do. Their experience is valid and is pretty well documented.

The fact that adopted children often have attachment disorders is also no coincidence.

Well, none of us can know how our children will feel about any of our decisions in the future. There are a couple of decisions my (biological) parents made which have had a major, negative, impact on my life. I understand the reasons, but the consequences were pretty bad for a number of years.

Funnily enough we have just had a specialist assessment of need through post-adoption, which concluded that she has a secure attachment to me. But she does have complex PTSD from her early life in her birth family.

FourTeaFallOut · 18/04/2023 11:49

A baby is not a kidney. This is where we end up when we dehumanise women and children.

SnapchatJustForTheFilters · 18/04/2023 11:48

Beenhereforever1978 · 18/04/2023 07:39

That article is utterly terrifying. Thankyou for sharing.

Isn't it?? I cannot believe that I have had to tell my DH that if something horrific were to happen and I were declared brain dead that I do NOT want my body used to grow a baby for someone else. Sometimes there must be a line, surely?!

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 11:48

SadAsHell · 18/04/2023 11:44

Surrogacy isn't about the needs or best interests of the baby, it's about the adults. It's a selfish process driven purely by selfish needs.

If you want to go down that road, this could be said about any pregnancy. Couples choosing to conceive ultimately are doing it for themselves!

Exactly! Or adoption.

That's how any adult becomes a parent.

Of course it needs strict regulation to prevent exploitation, as far as possible.

As does living kidney donation. There are serious risks, and there needs to be a process to ensure that the adults making that choice understand those risks and are making a choice as consenting adults.

Very likely that will make surrogacy quite rare. That's fine.

Witchcraftandhokum · 18/04/2023 11:48

I'm assuming you were able to able to have your own children op?

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 11:47

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 11:25

She's 16. In touch with the one half-sister (not half emotionally, just her sister, the fact that they have different fathers is irrelevant). Through her sister occasionally has contact with a cousin, sometimes other (more extended) biological family.

I am 50. Have never felt a gap for my half-sister. I have a brother and half brother. Not close to either, though closer to my full brother as we were brought up together. When mutual father died half-brother was involved in the funeral. Let him know half-sister was welcome if she wanted to come. I didn't feel any sense of loss that she didn't.

I have a very good friend of many years that does feel like a sister. No biological relation.

DD has wonderful godparents, one a previous carer, others the parents of her BFF since she came to live with me over a decade ago. Their relationships are absolutely core to her, and her long-term sense of herself.

My point stands you can't possibly KNOW how she will feel at any point in the future.

Even is she doesn't feel the need it doesn't negate the fact that many many people do. Their experience is valid and is pretty well documented.

The fact that adopted children often have attachment disorders is also no coincidence.

ShivRoy2nd · 18/04/2023 11:46

I agree @BackDownSouth surrogacy can be summarised as a mother handing her baby over for money to a complete stranger. I feel so sorry for those poor babies taken away from everything they’ve ever known.

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 11:45

DD may be a gap in their lives. That isn't her responsibility, and she has no obligation to them.

Especially as they either chose to look away while she was being abused/neglected, or weren't close enough to see what was happening.

SadAsHell · 18/04/2023 11:44

Surrogacy isn't about the needs or best interests of the baby, it's about the adults. It's a selfish process driven purely by selfish needs.

If you want to go down that road, this could be said about any pregnancy. Couples choosing to conceive ultimately are doing it for themselves!

hotpotlover · 18/04/2023 11:44

I completely disagrees with mumsnet's anti - surrogacy stand.

I was lucky to have two children naturally and I am currently pregnant with my third - conceived relatively quickly.

However, I think surrogacy is brilliant for people who can't carry a child.

I disagree that it is super harmful for the child as always portrayed on mumsnet.

Redebs · 18/04/2023 11:42

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 18/04/2023 03:49

Surrogacy isn't about the needs or best interests of the baby, it's about the adults. It's a selfish process driven purely by selfish needs. No surprise that those who engage seek to minimize the link between baby and surogate-mother as it also minimizes their selfishness. I can't imagine how awful it must be for the baby to be ripped away from the only human it knows so early on.

Yes, totally this

KimberleyClark · 18/04/2023 11:41

Jonei · 18/04/2023 11:33

Or maybe your post is goady nonsense.

This.

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 11:40

Jonei · 18/04/2023 11:30

But - DD is my daughter. There's no qualification of 'sort of like' my daughter. She just is my daughter. With a mild interest in biological relations, but I have never stood in the way of contact with them and the biological relatives she does care about are those who have been a constant presence in her life.

So she does still have contact with biological family. She does have an interest in that. Why? Is it the glamour of a biological link? Or something deeper than that?

I have a half-sister I have never met (I'm not adopted) and don't feel any gap in my life.

How about your half sister. Is she with her biological mother? And how would you know if she felt a gap in her life if you've never met her?

DD has three half sisters, the one she was brought up with who matters very much (and is her sister, no half measures), the other two she has never met, and aren't a gap in her life

She may be more interested in them as an adult. But if you tell her you think a biological link is just glamorisation, she may decide not to tell you that. Also, how would you know if your dd is not a gap in their lives?

She has an interest in members of her biological family that have been consistently part of her life. She has a mild interest if she sees a random family member to see if e.g. they have a similar shaped chin. She doesn't feel a gap in her life if she doesn't see them.

She was five when she came to live with me, so it made sense to maintain the positive relationships. There are biological family members she has actively chosen not to see again (despite SW pressure) because they were abusive.

My half-sister grew up with her biological mother. According to my half-brother, when he re-established a connection with our mutual father, their mother had pressured them to break contact after a hostile divorce. Half brother chose to get in contact when he left home, half sister didn't. Half brother occasionally mentioned our mutual father to her, but she never chose to get in touch. She must be in her late 60s/early 70s now.

I have never told DD that an interest in her birth family is a glamorisation. I have encouraged her to keep in contact with those she wants to, and have facilitated that in her younger years. Now she is old enough to be in touch with whoever she wants.

DD may be a gap in their lives. That isn't her responsibility, and she has no obligation to them.

EmotionalSupportHyena · 18/04/2023 11:39

CoffeeBean5 · 18/04/2023 11:06

That’s so exploitative 😕 the practice of offering cheaper IVF in return of asking a desperate woman to ‘donate’ her eggs should be banned. You’re battling the trauma of fertility issues and IVF is not guaranteed to work. However, your biological children could be out there as other women have used your eggs.

I have heard from a Mumsnetter on a previous thread that lesbians are sometimes targeted for this coercion.

Firstly, they are more likely to be attending clinic for social reasons (same sex partners!) rather than reasons relating to physical infertility (so are likely to have healthy eggs) and secondly, they are likely to be younger than women who are there after trying to get pregnant via heterosexual sex for many years first. Younger women are less likely to be financially comfortable than older women so more susceptible to coercive egg donation for monetary reasons.

Of course, lesbians often don’t need IVF at all, at least not without first trying the much less invasive IUI - but that wouldn’t give the clinic an opportunity for extra ‘donor’ egg collection, so bring on the concept of ‘reciprocal IVF’ where one woman has eggs harvested, her egg is fertilised via IVF and the resultant embryo is implanted into her female partner.

Which is much more expensive than IUI and much more invasive, involves medical procedures and expensive drugs for two women rather than one and if embryo transfer is successful, makes for a higher risk pregnancy for the mother than if she’d conceived with her own egg!
And as it’s likely that both women are perfectly healthy and have no medical infertility (because they were only in clinic due to social reasons, ie, needing donor sperm) all that extra financial cost and physical risk is entirely avoidable.

The more you look into this stuff, the more exploitation you find, especially as women who really want babies are likely to be incredibly vulnerable to ‘upselling’ and saying yes to whatever the clinic suggests, because most of us don’t have unlimited funds and want to maximise chances of success.

To think that a surrogate mother...
Humanbiology · 18/04/2023 11:34

BoredOfThisMansWorld · 18/04/2023 11:05

Choosing to abort a foetus and adoption (both scenarios are issues my family has first hand experience of) are different from surrogacy.

Abortions and adoptions also often feature trauma, but that trauma was not commissioned and planned and paid for by wealthy people.

Abortions and adoptions may be for the wellbeing of the mother or child or both but they are a reaction to a set of circumstances. Surrogacy is, mostly, where you get to in a capitalist society which cares more about the desires of wealthy adults than the needs of the humans more vulnerable and routinely exploited.

Altruistic surrogacy may have less concerning implications but, sadly (I know a lovely couple who did this), it is still ignorant of the trauma inflicted on the baby.

I'm am genuinely worried so many people cannot see the difference between humans coping with traumatic events (adoption and abortion) and humans commissioning traumatic events to happen to more vulnerable humans.

I had an abortion at 16 I had 2 options either abortion or packing my bags and leaving with no money or job.

Not all surrogate women are being exploited and for those who do it for other reasons what laws are there to protect them in countries where there is poverty? Do these women know their legal rights because a lot of people don't and that's what makes it easier to exploit people for their own gains?

"Surrogacy is legal in the UK, but if you make a surrogacy agreement it cannot be enforced by the law." Surrogacy: legal rights of parents and surrogates: Overview - GOV.UK (www.gov.uk)

Jonei · 18/04/2023 11:33

SaveMeFromMyBoobs · 18/04/2023 11:25

To be devil's advocate here, everything you said for justifying the birth mother being the 'biological' mother could be said for any parasitic infection. If you get a parasite your body 'nurtures' it, it gets nutrition from you, grows and goes through its life cycle inside you, then can exit and leave behind traces of itself.

Does that mean everyone who has had an infection should feel like its biological parent? Does that mean surrogacy is like having a parasite? Maybe this thread is a whole load of goady nonsense.

Or maybe your post is goady nonsense.

Jonei · 18/04/2023 11:30

But - DD is my daughter. There's no qualification of 'sort of like' my daughter. She just is my daughter. With a mild interest in biological relations, but I have never stood in the way of contact with them and the biological relatives she does care about are those who have been a constant presence in her life.

So she does still have contact with biological family. She does have an interest in that. Why? Is it the glamour of a biological link? Or something deeper than that?

I have a half-sister I have never met (I'm not adopted) and don't feel any gap in my life.

How about your half sister. Is she with her biological mother? And how would you know if she felt a gap in her life if you've never met her?

DD has three half sisters, the one she was brought up with who matters very much (and is her sister, no half measures), the other two she has never met, and aren't a gap in her life

She may be more interested in them as an adult. But if you tell her you think a biological link is just glamorisation, she may decide not to tell you that. Also, how would you know if your dd is not a gap in their lives?

BackDownSouth · 18/04/2023 11:30

SaveMeFromMyBoobs · 18/04/2023 11:25

To be devil's advocate here, everything you said for justifying the birth mother being the 'biological' mother could be said for any parasitic infection. If you get a parasite your body 'nurtures' it, it gets nutrition from you, grows and goes through its life cycle inside you, then can exit and leave behind traces of itself.

Does that mean everyone who has had an infection should feel like its biological parent? Does that mean surrogacy is like having a parasite? Maybe this thread is a whole load of goady nonsense.

A human baby is a bit fucking different to a pinworm though, isn't it? Jesus fucking wept

OP posts:
mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 11:28

Or, of course, the 'saviour siblings'

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 11:27

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 11:25

Sorry, did I miss the answer to how the process would identify if an altruistic surrogate was being emotionally coerced?

Considering how long it has taken me to process and understand the emotional trauma of my childhood, I wonder how any process is going to be robust and productive enough to uncover the coercive issues at play.

Or do you think that a couple of meetings and some ineffective counseling will tick the boxes? Leaving the coercive issues completely untouched.

Again, this is not a kidney donation. This is a child being grown in a woman ’s body, using parts of that woman’s body to do so. This so much more complicated on different layers - physical and emotional, than an organ donation.

Just because you, personally, cannot see the issues doesn’t mean that the issues are not there and are not documented.

Well, there is no absolute way of making sure a kidney donor is not being emotionally coerced.

LadyMuckingabout · 18/04/2023 11:26

I don’t mean just saviour siblings, but genetic matches for the adults for various medical requirements.

Also I dislike the “Celebrity welcomes baby Eureka!” No. Celebrity aged 55 bought baby Eureka.