Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a surrogate mother...

682 replies

BackDownSouth · 18/04/2023 03:31

Is the biological mother of a surrogate baby that she delivers, even in cases where another egg was used? One thing I hate hearing in the surrogacy debate by pro-surrogacy folks (who like to minimise the connection between mother and child and the effect that separation at birth can have on both) is “the surrogate has no biological relation to the baby” in cases where an egg other than the surrogate’s own were used. Of course she has a biological connection to the baby. She doesn’t have a GENETIC link to the baby - no. But biological? She has about as much of a biological connection with it as she would her own genetic child. The baby is quite literally made of her. The genetic material of the egg may predetermine baby’s genetic make-up to match that of the intended mother’s egg but that is such a shallow link compared to the nurturing happening during the pregnancy. It's the surrogate mother’s body building and nurturing that child. The mother’s body will likely forever retain snippets of the child’s DNA - particularly traces of Y chromosome if she carries a boy. Everything the mother does or eats or feels will influence that child. The baby knows her smell and voice and as soon as they are born they seek her, and they will feel stress at being placed into a stranger’s arms rather than mum’s immediately after birth. It’s completely ridiculous to say there is no biological connection between surrogate and baby. What’s more of a connection, really, to a newborn baby who has no concept of themselves other than the birth mother who is all they have ever known? Is the baby bothered about a mother who makes up half of their DNA but who has been on the other side of the world since their conception and is going to lay claim to them through a financial transaction? Or is the baby instead going to crave the presence of the woman who has grown and nurtured them? The surrogate is mum and the baby is going to need her post-birth no matter how much people want to ignore that.

People like to say “DNA is nothing” in the context of the love between step-parents and their stepchildren, adoptive children etc, and that’s rightly so. A genetic link isn’t what makes a family. But in the case of surrogacies, this is all completely thrown out of the window and the idea of a surrogate mother bonding with her baby (because it is her baby…) is inconceivable because she ‘isn’t even related to them’ despite literally creating and birthing the child.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 13:22

It's really alarming how there is new proposed legislation around surrogacy that seems to protect the commissioning parents and reduce the choices of the surrogate mother at birth to protect the investment from the commissioning parents

Agreed.

But the answer isn't to ban all surrogacy

MrsJamin · 18/04/2023 13:19

Infertility isn't a good enough reason to buy a baby and cause trauma to him or her. If I had cancer, I couldn't buy a kidney so I could live- why should infertility excuse something much worse, removing a baby from his or her mother?
Also if I was to have an egg donor and be pregnant, I'd be seen as the mother - therefore a woman who is a surrogate is the mother. It's no different.
It's really alarming how there is new proposed legislation around surrogacy that seems to protect the commissioning parents and reduce the choices of the surrogate mother at birth to protect the investment from the commissioning parents - it didn't strike me as only thinking about the wellbeing of the child.

turbonerd · 18/04/2023 13:17

Dibbydoos · 18/04/2023 10:01

Agree 100% they are a vessel. And from the countries uou refer to, the pittance paid to them feels like a fortune.

But as you well know a pregnant woman is simply not just a vessel.

And birth is highly risky in humans. Without medical intervention available it is 1 in 5 that die; you may recall some History that taught about the extraordinary change in maternal deaths following improved hygiene and the advent of other medical interventions such as aenestaethics to perform caesereans.

Surrogate mothers do die.

And children with «defects» are born and rejected by the people who commissioned them, and it seems those children have no rights to belong to anyone whatsoever.

The more I learn the more I think surrogacy should be outlawed.

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 13:15

While the stories of surrogates wanting to give another woman the gift of life, who positively love being pregnant & completely happy with handing over the baby are lovely, are they really the majority?

There needs to be regulation to ensure - as far as possible - that this is the only scenario possible for surrogacy.

bozzabollix · 18/04/2023 13:14

This isn’t just about surrogacy per se. It’s about infant needs from the outset. You’re posting about the ideal scenario.

My daughter had to go into NICU from birth and literally couldn’t be with me as she was hooked to machines, I was physically incapable of going to her due to surgery for many hours. She went on to be dependant on those machines for two weeks, which in NICU terms isn’t long, there will be babies in there for months.

Whats the purpose of this post? My daughter’s birth story is shit, but on the other hand could be counted as an extreme success because she is alive. Sometimes life isn’t ideal and you can’t lament it being so.

I’m reading this feeling sad about my daughter’s emotional needs not being met as a tiny baby. Other people will be reading it feeling sad their children’s births weren’t as they should be. Some will have gone the surrogacy route, have wonderful relationships with their children and will feel lesser because of this.

Why post it?

SayyestotheDog · 18/04/2023 13:12

Genuine question how much are babies being sold for @BackDownSouth?

While the stories of surrogates wanting to give another woman the gift of life, who positively love being pregnant & completely happy with handing over the baby are lovely, are they really the majority?

It’s a financial service & to be able to do it means detaching from the process & literally incubating a baby for financial gain.

It just feels like another form of commodification of a woman’s body & horrible that women find themselves either having to do this other to survive financially or choose to do it as a career choice.

amoobaa · 18/04/2023 13:06

ChienChatCheval · 18/04/2023 04:29

Being a parent isn’t a right. You’re not entitled to it. You shouldn’t be allowed to rent a woman and her womb because you want a baby. You post shows that it’s all about the wants of adults and nothing to do with the resulting baby.

I think using egg and sperm donors in any circumstances is wrong too.

It should all be banned imo.

What about a lesbian couple, where one of the women use their eggs and fertilise their eggs with sperm donated by their gay best friend, with whom they have a life long friendship spanning decades? And then they carry the baby and give birth to the baby themselves.

The lesbian couple and their gay best friend (and his long term partner) all go to specialist counselling, both individually, as couples and as a group) to discuss and reflect on the process, it’s complexities (before, during and after the IVF and pregnancy) and ensure that all adults involved work together to prioritise the needs and best interests of the baby (who will become a child, teenager, young person, adult etc etc)

In this scenario, the child is raised in a two parent family (not co-parenting with the gay best friend and his partner). The child has and lives with/ is raised by two mothers.

However, their biological father is always known and present in their life. They are not considered a traditions ‘Dad’ but their identity is never hidden and the mothers arrange quality time for their family to spend time with their biological father and their extended families.

I’m interested what you would think of this scenario?

The child has access to all the significant adults in their life, nothing is cloak and dagger, and should anything happen to both their Mums, their biological father would be their legal guardian.

In this scenario, the child has additional family- connections with extended family from all three significant adults. They are able to access all their family medical history and they know exactly who they are and where they came from.

Clearly a lot of thought goes into an arrangement like this. So I’m wondering… if this is immoral, does it mean you don’t believe there are any ethical ways for same sex couples to have a family?

or what adjustments would you make to this scenario to make it ethical?

I don’t think having a baby is a ‘right’. I think the interests of the baby trumps the aspirations of the adults. But I’m curious where you draw the line? Would the scenario I’ve described be ethical in your view?

Gondala · 18/04/2023 13:04

SaveMeFromMyBoobs · 18/04/2023 11:25

To be devil's advocate here, everything you said for justifying the birth mother being the 'biological' mother could be said for any parasitic infection. If you get a parasite your body 'nurtures' it, it gets nutrition from you, grows and goes through its life cycle inside you, then can exit and leave behind traces of itself.

Does that mean everyone who has had an infection should feel like its biological parent? Does that mean surrogacy is like having a parasite? Maybe this thread is a whole load of goady nonsense.

Why stop at worrying about the biology. Why not force every fertile woman with children to have a baby for the infertile? Just treat it as a parasite, maybe like a long sickness bug. It's only fair afterall. Why stop at one, why doesn't every fertile woman have a second surrogate child for medical research? Afterall what do newborns care, they don't know any better.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 13:00

mybeautifuloak · 18/04/2023 12:56

Yeah, deprive that woman of her one means of earning enough to feed her children...

You think that banning surrogacy is going to deprive a woman the money to feed her existing children? So you think it is ok to exploit women’s bodies then?

mybeautifuloak · 18/04/2023 12:56

MissAmelia · 18/04/2023 03:56

The surrogacy business, in particular surrogates abroad where poor women are being used by British couples, is repulsive to me. Using another woman in this way, who has limited choices should not be allowed.
There are plenty of testimonies of devastated women, who have become surrogates to feed their existing children.
Any woman who gives birth to a child is a mother.

Yeah, deprive that woman of her one means of earning enough to feed her children...

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 12:54

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 12:42

IMO there is always a power imbalance whether money changes hands or not.

There can be emotional pressure as well as financial.

And the emotional pressure can be deeply buried and unexplored. I keep asking what process and regulation will be robust enough to discover this, no answer has ever been forthcoming across different threads now.

I have begun to realise that it is a sop to some people’s wish to be either ‘kind’ or their perception of agency over decisions such as this. Hence we tend to get the same arguments across the threads.

Just like no one tends to answer the questions around what happens if a surrogate decides or is forced to decide due to health to change their mind. Hence another reason why the ‘organ donation’ argument is so superficial. It would only be revelent if someone was growing a kidney inside them and that kidney was sentient being with its own rights once it left the body.

I doubt any ‘altruistic’ surrogacy would even exist if it was robustly regulated to ensure the surrogate is under absolutely no emotional pressure/manipulation. Under what conditions would any woman risk her life, her own fertility, her family and the future relationship to the ‘purchaser’ parents without some degree of emotional coercion or manipulation (from either direction ). Remembering that even with friends or family surrogacies, there is the future relationship with that child as well!

JackGrealishsLegs · 18/04/2023 12:47

Iwasafool · 18/04/2023 12:41

I think both sides have power don't they. The "buyer" is presumably the more powerful financially. The "seller" has the power to provide something the other person/couple desperately want and the power to change their mind and withhold the baby.

This is like saying that prostitutes have power over their punters because they have something the punters want.

No.

JackGrealishsLegs · 18/04/2023 12:46

SadAsHell · 18/04/2023 11:55

If a woman is choosing to do this, willingly and fully knowing the process and / or implications, I have no problem with it. Her body, her choice. Whatever her reasons or gains are, it doesn't bother me, be they monetary, wanting to experience a pregnancy but not wanting a child, or to help a couple, or whatever other reasons they choose.

Obviously anybody being forced into it, or doing it unknowingly (in the wild scenario of being brain dead that I see being discussed) then obviously it is extremely wrong, as it would be if anybody was forced into anything they did not want to do or didn't know they were doing!

How can you tell the difference? And who should decide? You write as though you’d be able to do it, so here goes.

Woman A is being a surrogate for her friend, she gets paid £14,000 (average U.K. expenses). She’s had a baby before.

Woman B is having a baby for a celebrity who is paying her £100,000. She’s signed an NDA so she can’t tell anyone but she says she’s happy to do it. She’s never had a baby before.

Woman C lives in Ukraine and is having a baby for a rich US couple and is being paid £50,000. She isn’t being physically forced, but her husband told her that they really need the money. She has also had a baby before.

Woman D lives in India with several other pregnant women and has been told she’ll be killed if she doesn’t comply with being impregnated and carrying a baby for a rich Chinese couple. She’s never had a baby before.

Woman E is in the U.K. and is 21, never had a baby before. She agrees to have a baby for her older sister who is infertile. The sister can’t pay her but she wants to do it to make her sister happy.

There are so many factors at play before you even begin to consider the baby. How do we know which of these women are fully and responsibly consenting, and which are being coerced with money or the threat of violence? And what happens if they initially think they consent and then they decide they don’t want to have the baby anymore or want to keep it?

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 12:44

But women should be able to have autonomy over their own bodies

Why? They don't in many other aspects of life. We don't have the autonomy to drive a car without a seatbelt or a motorbike without a helmet. We don't have the autonomy to sell a kidney, or any other body part. We don't have the autonomy to sell our bodies for sex or to have a third trimester abortion without a serious anomoly reason.

There are so many ways we do not have autonomy over our bodies. Society keeps us from doing bad things with our bodies,from making terrible choices, especially when they effect others.

Why would we get autonomy over our bodies to be able to grow and sell human beings?

RedToothBrush · 18/04/2023 12:43

justgettingthroughtheday · 18/04/2023 03:42

Go away with your goady threads.
For some of us it is our only chance of being parents through no fault of our own. Just because you were lucky enough to carry children doesn't make you judge of other people.

If buying a baby is your only way to have a baby, maybe admit you support child trafficking and the exploitation of women for the benefit of wealthy couples.

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 12:42

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 12:38

With that and surrogacy there is a massive power imbalance between purchaser and birth mother.

That is what needs regulation.

And, with proper regulation, it's unlikely that many surrogacies will take place.

But that is not the same as saying surrogacy should never take place.

IMO there is always a power imbalance whether money changes hands or not.

There can be emotional pressure as well as financial.

Iwasafool · 18/04/2023 12:41

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 12:35

Paid adoption is also problematic, not just for the reason you have given.

With that and surrogacy there is a massive power imbalance between purchaser and birth mother.

There are also lots of issues with rejecting the less than perfect baby, such as the one you have described.

There was a thread on here recently about a woman going abroad to pay to have sex selective IVF, she doesn't have any fertility issues, that is something which also raises a multitude of ethical issues.

I think both sides have power don't they. The "buyer" is presumably the more powerful financially. The "seller" has the power to provide something the other person/couple desperately want and the power to change their mind and withhold the baby.

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 12:41

Iwasafool · 18/04/2023 12:37

I have a relative who was adopted as a new born. She had a yearning to meet her birth mother and eventually found her. She regretted it, refused to meet her again and had some harassment for a time until the birth mother accepted they were not going to have a relationship. Sometimes you do have to be careful what you wish for.

I think that this is what has, ultimately, stopped my friend from acting.

I think adoption is different but one of my objections to any kind of surrogacy is the fact that you deliberately and knowingly create babies who are human beings who foreseeably will have these issues.

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 12:38

With that and surrogacy there is a massive power imbalance between purchaser and birth mother.

That is what needs regulation.

And, with proper regulation, it's unlikely that many surrogacies will take place.

But that is not the same as saying surrogacy should never take place.

Iwasafool · 18/04/2023 12:37

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 11:58

There are a couple of decisions my (biological) parents made which have had a major, negative, impact on my life. I understand the reasons, but the consequences were pretty bad for a number of years.

But this is not comparable to the yearning that many adopted people have to know their roots.

My friend doesn't know her medical history, doesn't know why she was abandoned (as she sees it), doesn't know if she has any genetic family. She has no other family left apart from distant cousins in the States. She hasn't had children because of the fact that she was worried she would be genetically disposed to child abandonment, I think she's wrong about that but it's how she feels. Her whole life is impacted.

It's very simplistic to say that a child conceived from a commercial arrangement would not have those kind of feelings, or that that might not resent the IPs if they felt the arrangement was born of a power imbalance. Humans are complex but the situations arising from this are nothing like bad decisions made by parents per se.

I have a relative who was adopted as a new born. She had a yearning to meet her birth mother and eventually found her. She regretted it, refused to meet her again and had some harassment for a time until the birth mother accepted they were not going to have a relationship. Sometimes you do have to be careful what you wish for.

Beenhereforever1978 · 18/04/2023 12:36

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 12:34

The idea is that you gave informed consent before you died. But that's not the reason its not ok, that reason is that its a fucking abhorrent dystopian nightmare.

☝

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 12:36

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 12:35

Paid adoption is also problematic, not just for the reason you have given.

With that and surrogacy there is a massive power imbalance between purchaser and birth mother.

There are also lots of issues with rejecting the less than perfect baby, such as the one you have described.

There was a thread on here recently about a woman going abroad to pay to have sex selective IVF, she doesn't have any fertility issues, that is something which also raises a multitude of ethical issues.

Sorry, my post didn't make it clear how abhorrent I find this.

Expenses are a way of making hidden payments

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 12:35

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 18/04/2023 12:32

You are paying for a service that you want to result in a baby. For your own selfish reasons.

In a baby that you will be gestating yourself, and not removing from their mother at birth... I think you're missing the issue here. It's not the money, it's that you're using it to remove a baby from its mother.

With the mother's informed consent. Which she should be able to refuse at any point.

As I have said over and over again, there needs to be stringent regulation. Probably so stringent that it is rare.

But women should be able to have autonomy over their own bodies.

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 12:35

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 12:30

My experience of adoption is in South Africa.

There, women planning to give up their babies for adoption can be paid for expenses.

The result is adopting a white baby is expensive, a black baby is quite cheap.

Paid adoption is also problematic, not just for the reason you have given.

With that and surrogacy there is a massive power imbalance between purchaser and birth mother.

There are also lots of issues with rejecting the less than perfect baby, such as the one you have described.

There was a thread on here recently about a woman going abroad to pay to have sex selective IVF, she doesn't have any fertility issues, that is something which also raises a multitude of ethical issues.

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 12:34

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 12:33

A clinically dead person cannot give informed consent. So of course shouldn't be allowed.

The idea is that you gave informed consent before you died. But that's not the reason its not ok, that reason is that its a fucking abhorrent dystopian nightmare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread