Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a surrogate mother...

682 replies

BackDownSouth · 18/04/2023 03:31

Is the biological mother of a surrogate baby that she delivers, even in cases where another egg was used? One thing I hate hearing in the surrogacy debate by pro-surrogacy folks (who like to minimise the connection between mother and child and the effect that separation at birth can have on both) is “the surrogate has no biological relation to the baby” in cases where an egg other than the surrogate’s own were used. Of course she has a biological connection to the baby. She doesn’t have a GENETIC link to the baby - no. But biological? She has about as much of a biological connection with it as she would her own genetic child. The baby is quite literally made of her. The genetic material of the egg may predetermine baby’s genetic make-up to match that of the intended mother’s egg but that is such a shallow link compared to the nurturing happening during the pregnancy. It's the surrogate mother’s body building and nurturing that child. The mother’s body will likely forever retain snippets of the child’s DNA - particularly traces of Y chromosome if she carries a boy. Everything the mother does or eats or feels will influence that child. The baby knows her smell and voice and as soon as they are born they seek her, and they will feel stress at being placed into a stranger’s arms rather than mum’s immediately after birth. It’s completely ridiculous to say there is no biological connection between surrogate and baby. What’s more of a connection, really, to a newborn baby who has no concept of themselves other than the birth mother who is all they have ever known? Is the baby bothered about a mother who makes up half of their DNA but who has been on the other side of the world since their conception and is going to lay claim to them through a financial transaction? Or is the baby instead going to crave the presence of the woman who has grown and nurtured them? The surrogate is mum and the baby is going to need her post-birth no matter how much people want to ignore that.

People like to say “DNA is nothing” in the context of the love between step-parents and their stepchildren, adoptive children etc, and that’s rightly so. A genetic link isn’t what makes a family. But in the case of surrogacies, this is all completely thrown out of the window and the idea of a surrogate mother bonding with her baby (because it is her baby…) is inconceivable because she ‘isn’t even related to them’ despite literally creating and birthing the child.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Newnamenewname109870 · 18/04/2023 15:13

Irritateandunreasonable · 18/04/2023 14:18

I had no idea there was so much hate for surrogacy.

People really will kick off about anything won’t they.

Yep. Bloody depressing.

I wonder if they’ve actually spoken to anyone who’s been involved in the process.

cordelia16 · 18/04/2023 15:11

StrawHatOnTheParcelShelf · 18/04/2023 07:01

Those babies are already on the way, or here. Surrogacy is deliberately creating new babies into less than ideal circumstances (with an ugly side serve of exploitation and profiteering).

Not to mention that in all of those cases (solo, poor, disabled, thick, ugly), the babies are still with their birth mothers. Surrogate babies are removed from their birth mothers and given to someone else. As a previous poster said, the baby instinctively only knows the mother who carried it - he/she doesn't know the mother who provided the DNA.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 15:05

Wenfy · 18/04/2023 14:58

The trauma associated with Surrogacy comes from children not understanding it, or society not making it easy for them to understand it, not due to some make belief epigenetic changes.

this article explains it in easy language for the neanderthals like you.

https://www.today.com/health/new-study-tracks-emotional-health-surrogate-kids-6c10366818

Wow. Neanderthals, eh?

And you posted an article that is very clear that the study went to 10 years old and that that researcher and other professionals point out that the results are likely to be different in later years.

RedToothBrush · 18/04/2023 15:04

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 14:03

This is the argument that I really don't understand.

People who oppose surrogacy think no one has the right to a child. This isn't a homophobic position it applies to everyone equally.

Oh I understand the argument alright.

It's a coercive one to try and smear someone who dislikes all surrogacy as being homophobic because that has social consequences.

Being reasonable and say you want a blanket ban on all surrogacy is harder to argue against due to the Hierarchy of Approved Liberal Moral Values.

Wenfy · 18/04/2023 14:58

BoredOfThisMansWorld · 18/04/2023 14:47

I think one of my kids may be gay and I honestly used to think "by the time he's grown up surrogacy will be normal" and feel happy about it.

Yeah selfish desires to be a grandma one day I guess.

But I looked into it and found out so much more about infancy and trauma through having therapy myself.

Lots of things we really desire but choose not to have or do when we find out more information about the effects. Cocaine, wearing fur, eating too much junk, eating meat, fast fashion etc. Yes having kids is another level to those examples but so are the potential implications for human harm.

The trauma associated with Surrogacy comes from children not understanding it, or society not making it easy for them to understand it, not due to some make belief epigenetic changes.

this article explains it in easy language for the neanderthals like you.

https://www.today.com/health/new-study-tracks-emotional-health-surrogate-kids-6c10366818

New study tracks emotional health of 'surrogate kids'  

Over the past decade the number of births involving surrogacy with donor eggs and sperm has surged. What, experts wondered, does this mean for the mental and emotional health of the growing number of kids who may or may not know the truth about their...

https://www.today.com/health/new-study-tracks-emotional-health-surrogate-kids-6c10366818

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 18/04/2023 14:57

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 12:38

With that and surrogacy there is a massive power imbalance between purchaser and birth mother.

That is what needs regulation.

And, with proper regulation, it's unlikely that many surrogacies will take place.

But that is not the same as saying surrogacy should never take place.

Nah. I live in the Netherlands, lots of regulation around prostitution. Still prostitutes everywhere, it's not decreased, just gives people the illusion that these women have protection and independence so they feel better about pretending abuse doesn't exist, or feel better about paying for these women. Still a massive amount of trafficking, coercion, abuse of women.

Making the abuse of women regulated is not what's needed. Stopping the abuse of women is what's needed, and if women won't fight for it and try to rationalize in all the many ways you have on this thread, then these poor women will keep being abused.

But keep sharing your pointless chat about kidneys, survivor siblings, loving adoption with no gaps if it makes you feel better about yourself.

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 14:52

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 13:22

It's really alarming how there is new proposed legislation around surrogacy that seems to protect the commissioning parents and reduce the choices of the surrogate mother at birth to protect the investment from the commissioning parents

Agreed.

But the answer isn't to ban all surrogacy

It is absolutely the answer. There is no other answer that works.

BoredOfThisMansWorld · 18/04/2023 14:47

I think one of my kids may be gay and I honestly used to think "by the time he's grown up surrogacy will be normal" and feel happy about it.

Yeah selfish desires to be a grandma one day I guess.

But I looked into it and found out so much more about infancy and trauma through having therapy myself.

Lots of things we really desire but choose not to have or do when we find out more information about the effects. Cocaine, wearing fur, eating too much junk, eating meat, fast fashion etc. Yes having kids is another level to those examples but so are the potential implications for human harm.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 14:47

SadAsHell · 18/04/2023 14:36

So if I was asked to be surrogate for someone, and I fully agreed, in the full of my health both mentally and physically, how would that be exploration of me, a woman?

Any utilisation of another person’s body to achieve something you want is exploitation. It is using someone to achieve your goal.

And you didn’t answer my questions as to why you would be doing this?

What is in it for you?

Feeling good about yourself? Wanting to have that pregnancy experience? Feeling like you are needed? Why? Why are you doing it?

Why are you putting your self at risk of death over a nine month period for someone in this way?

Blaueblumen · 18/04/2023 14:42

Surrogacy isn't about the needs or best interests of the baby

Clearly not! It's about grown adults who feel they deserve a child.

Wenfy · 18/04/2023 14:41

Highdaysandholidays1 · 18/04/2023 14:21

I'm sure someone else will have mentioned it, but there is a small transfer of DNA that can happen between a gestational mother and in-utero fetus, it's not true there is absolutely no DNA. Furthermore, epigenetics tells us that the womb environment is one of the things that allows gene expression, so if the womb environment of the gestational mother is optimal, then the gene expression will be different (e.g. if there is poverty of the womb environment, this can then affect things like heart disease risk 50 years later). It's called the Parker hypothesis and is reasonably well-supported.

There is also evidence to support that the Parker Hypothesis can be overridden genetically by a good upbringing. People don’t realise that people’s environments, the things they eat, the ways they play, the people they touch - it ALL causes genetic changes. So to highlight one and them ignore the others is rubbish.

BoredOfThisMansWorld · 18/04/2023 14:40

Irritateandunreasonable · 18/04/2023 14:18

I had no idea there was so much hate for surrogacy.

People really will kick off about anything won’t they.

Is this the best response you have for the thoughtful responses and evidence supplied by posters in this thread?

"Hate"

Blaueblumen · 18/04/2023 14:38

It is homophobic if a poster is basically stating any way to have a child that doesn’t involve a biological man and woman is wrong.

It is absolutely not homophobic. NOBODY has a right to have a child, regardless of their sexual preference.

Humans rely on gametes from one male and one female to procreate. That's just a biological fact. And a newborn baby should continue to bond with the mother who's carried it for 9 months.

SadAsHell · 18/04/2023 14:36

Exploitation *

SadAsHell · 18/04/2023 14:36

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 14:32

And again, you are using a polarisation tactic to try to support your argument for exploiting women’s bodies to produce babies to order.

So, no. Just because there is a certain degree of selfishness in having a child without resorting to surrogacy doesn’t support the exploitation of a female human body to be an incubator for a deliberately created human to fulfill someone’s wish for a child.

So if I was asked to be surrogate for someone, and I fully agreed, in the full of my health both mentally and physically, how would that be exploration of me, a woman?

BoredOfThisMansWorld · 18/04/2023 14:34

Highdaysandholidays1 · 18/04/2023 14:21

I'm sure someone else will have mentioned it, but there is a small transfer of DNA that can happen between a gestational mother and in-utero fetus, it's not true there is absolutely no DNA. Furthermore, epigenetics tells us that the womb environment is one of the things that allows gene expression, so if the womb environment of the gestational mother is optimal, then the gene expression will be different (e.g. if there is poverty of the womb environment, this can then affect things like heart disease risk 50 years later). It's called the Parker hypothesis and is reasonably well-supported.

Thanks for mentioning this!

Epigenetics is absolutely fascinating and is another thing I have learnt about from being in therapy. This is another reason I'm concerned about the silence from Bacp and ukcp. Not everyone seemingly supporting surrogacy can be said to be ignorant of trauma and babies' experience in utero. Which raises worrying questions.

mixedrecycling · 18/04/2023 14:33

a Messiah like hero which is how I'd genuinely describe an adoptive parent.

Thanks but... we're not, really we're not! We're people who want to be parents, and this is the avenue to become a parent for whatever reason. Just as heterosexual couples with no fertility issues can choose to become parents for their own reasons.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 14:32

SadAsHell · 18/04/2023 14:24

Again I raise the point this could be said about any pregnancy!

And again, you are using a polarisation tactic to try to support your argument for exploiting women’s bodies to produce babies to order.

So, no. Just because there is a certain degree of selfishness in having a child without resorting to surrogacy doesn’t support the exploitation of a female human body to be an incubator for a deliberately created human to fulfill someone’s wish for a child.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 14:28

Newnamenewname109870 · 18/04/2023 14:14

There are lots of things that aren’t ‘natural’. It doesn’t mean they should be illegal.

Perhaps not this thread but a lot of the discussion in general. It is homophobic if a poster is basically stating any way to have a child that doesn’t involve a biological man and woman is wrong. It particularly disadvantages those who are not in heterosexual relationships.

I don’t believe anyone has stated that a child needs to be born to a heterosexual couple. If they have, please quote it.

However, the human race relies on gametes from one male and one female to procreate. And not one person on this planet has the right to have a child. That is not homophobic.

People on this thread have mentioned ways same sex families have been created without exploiting any woman’s body bar the woman whose egg has created that child and is carrying that child.

Yes. It does disadvantage same sex couples. That is a fact. It also disadvantages single people who don’t want to be in a relationship. Other groups of people are also disadvantaged by the biological necessity of having one male and one female human being to create another.

No person has the right to exploit the productive resources of a woman to create a child. Not egg donor nor surrogate.

And if a male donor is being used, then I certainly believe that the male donor’s identity should be known to the child, it would be preferable that if the child is old enough that the child has to opportunity to get to know that donor. I don’t agree that a child doesn’t need to have that information at the very least.

SadAsHell · 18/04/2023 14:24

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 13:48

As others have said throughout the thread, none of this puts the child first.

Just because you are prepared to do this doesn't mean it is ethical or in the child's best interests.

There are a whole load of things that some people might want to have a choice to do with their bodies which are also, rightly, unlawful because of the implications for society as a whole.

Again I raise the point this could be said about any pregnancy!

Highdaysandholidays1 · 18/04/2023 14:21

I'm sure someone else will have mentioned it, but there is a small transfer of DNA that can happen between a gestational mother and in-utero fetus, it's not true there is absolutely no DNA. Furthermore, epigenetics tells us that the womb environment is one of the things that allows gene expression, so if the womb environment of the gestational mother is optimal, then the gene expression will be different (e.g. if there is poverty of the womb environment, this can then affect things like heart disease risk 50 years later). It's called the Parker hypothesis and is reasonably well-supported.

Irritateandunreasonable · 18/04/2023 14:18

I had no idea there was so much hate for surrogacy.

People really will kick off about anything won’t they.

Helleofabore · 18/04/2023 14:17

herlightmaterials · 18/04/2023 14:08

People wanting to be parents shouldn't adopt unless they're genuinely ready and willing to take on a host of additional needs. Adoptive parents are not the rest of us. What they do for high needs children is astounding. But we can't all be like them as much as we might want to and shouldn't always even try because the children are let down in those circumstances.

You'd be a fool to think people were arranging surrogacy in the same spirit as those adopting troubled children. There's nothing wrong with just wanting to be a parent and love your child, without being willing or able to be a Messiah like hero which is how I'd genuinely describe an adoptive parent. It is of course about the parents and when you had your child it was about you too.

None of that makes it acceptable to describe children in the same terms as rescue puppies.

And none of what you have just stated makes it acceptable to exploit at least one woman’s body to create a human being on order.

Irritateandunreasonable · 18/04/2023 14:17

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 18/04/2023 03:49

Surrogacy isn't about the needs or best interests of the baby, it's about the adults. It's a selfish process driven purely by selfish needs. No surprise that those who engage seek to minimize the link between baby and surogate-mother as it also minimizes their selfishness. I can't imagine how awful it must be for the baby to be ripped away from the only human it knows so early on.

Gosh

lifeturnsonadime · 18/04/2023 14:17

Newnamenewname109870 · 18/04/2023 14:14

There are lots of things that aren’t ‘natural’. It doesn’t mean they should be illegal.

Perhaps not this thread but a lot of the discussion in general. It is homophobic if a poster is basically stating any way to have a child that doesn’t involve a biological man and woman is wrong. It particularly disadvantages those who are not in heterosexual relationships.

No it doesn't, It's anyone who can't or doesn't want to have a baby naturally.

The fact that some of those people are homosexual doesn't make it a homophobic position.