Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a surrogate mother...

682 replies

BackDownSouth · 18/04/2023 03:31

Is the biological mother of a surrogate baby that she delivers, even in cases where another egg was used? One thing I hate hearing in the surrogacy debate by pro-surrogacy folks (who like to minimise the connection between mother and child and the effect that separation at birth can have on both) is “the surrogate has no biological relation to the baby” in cases where an egg other than the surrogate’s own were used. Of course she has a biological connection to the baby. She doesn’t have a GENETIC link to the baby - no. But biological? She has about as much of a biological connection with it as she would her own genetic child. The baby is quite literally made of her. The genetic material of the egg may predetermine baby’s genetic make-up to match that of the intended mother’s egg but that is such a shallow link compared to the nurturing happening during the pregnancy. It's the surrogate mother’s body building and nurturing that child. The mother’s body will likely forever retain snippets of the child’s DNA - particularly traces of Y chromosome if she carries a boy. Everything the mother does or eats or feels will influence that child. The baby knows her smell and voice and as soon as they are born they seek her, and they will feel stress at being placed into a stranger’s arms rather than mum’s immediately after birth. It’s completely ridiculous to say there is no biological connection between surrogate and baby. What’s more of a connection, really, to a newborn baby who has no concept of themselves other than the birth mother who is all they have ever known? Is the baby bothered about a mother who makes up half of their DNA but who has been on the other side of the world since their conception and is going to lay claim to them through a financial transaction? Or is the baby instead going to crave the presence of the woman who has grown and nurtured them? The surrogate is mum and the baby is going to need her post-birth no matter how much people want to ignore that.

People like to say “DNA is nothing” in the context of the love between step-parents and their stepchildren, adoptive children etc, and that’s rightly so. A genetic link isn’t what makes a family. But in the case of surrogacies, this is all completely thrown out of the window and the idea of a surrogate mother bonding with her baby (because it is her baby…) is inconceivable because she ‘isn’t even related to them’ despite literally creating and birthing the child.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
12
VestaTilley · 03/07/2023 21:12

Just to say for those of you who are interested in opposing surrogacy - a new campaign group has launched - Surrogacy Concern. They’re SurrogConcern on Twitter, or you can read about them on SurrogacyConcern.uk

MavisMcMinty · 22/04/2023 13:25

That’s a great summary, thanks for posting it, @OhHolyJesus . As you say, it makes all the points made on this thread and others before it.

OhHolyJesus · 21/04/2023 20:13

I haven't kept up with this thread so not sure if this has been shared already or not but I'm just stopping by as I noticed that surrogacy was on the front page of the Spectator this week and here is the online article by Louise Perry.

I think it encapsulates a lot of what has been pointed out here and on similar threads in the past.

www.spectator.co.uk/article/womb-service-the-moral-dangers-of-surrogacy/

RedToothBrush · 21/04/2023 16:18

People struggle to discern been fact and opinion

They struggle to understand what is belief and what is evidence based.

They struggle to know the difference between want and need.

These biases show up daily in politics. People with power are better at using language to get what they want for their own benefit - ethics is the moral code designed to try and urge identification of the above to stop this abuse of power.

It always come back to the question of why Hollywood stars benefit from surrogacy rather than act as surrogates for someone living in poverty.

Wherever you see that pattern you can bet that fact/opinion or belief/evidence base or want/need will be twisted in propaganda to support the position of the powerful.

That's why ethics matter.

It's also why we don't see attempts to identify/quantify possible harms from surrogacy. We don't see more discussions on the emotional control used over surrogate mothers or their children. We don't see questions about why the harm to infertile couple is the only valid argument.

It is fascinating to watch, but quite often it's simply about skin in the game.

Helleofabore · 21/04/2023 14:55

I still marvel somewhat that there are people in the world who cannot recognise exploitation and coercion unless it is extreme.

The justifications that have been used on this thread have been astonishing to see.

What is the acceptable collateral of those children harmed by being dseliberately created to fulfill what an adult has deemed as a 'need' which is actually a 'wish'? How many children per 100 have to suffer from significant mental health issues arising from their conception before some people recognise that it is an issue that needs banning completely? 1 in 100? 10 in 100? 50? Whether that is at 10 years old, at 20 years old or at 30-40 when they start having their own children and start processing their own situation?

And how many women suffering harm are considered 'acceptable collateral' so that others can achieve their desire through the exploiting of women's bodies? 1 in 100? 10 in 100? 50? Whether that harm is immediate or in 1 year, 5 years or 10 years.

RedToothBrush · 21/04/2023 11:19

Helleofabore · 20/04/2023 23:39

So I see we have now got to the ‘ban it and watch what happens’ stage.

Was this supposed to mean that if surrogacy is banned, that people would… actually, what? kidnap babies? Hold women in forced baby farms?

So, not only should surrogacy be legal so people don’t commit suicide because they can exploit at least one woman and a child that has been deliberately and specifically created to stop them committing suicide. But, we now should have legalised surrogacy because some people society cannot control themselves and will get babies illegally.

And this is from a poster who declared that ‘ethical surrogacy’ exists…. who then has stated fucked up and unethical reasons to keep surrogacy legal.

It all amounts to people are going to exploit women and babies anyway, may as well let people do it.

Once you see it, you really cannot unsee it.

Which only reinforced the point about selfish adults doing anything for their own benefit without regards to the mother or child and the point about affluence and exploitation of poor/ vulnerable through coercion, abuse or money.

lifeturnsonadime · 21/04/2023 10:30

MagpieSong · 21/04/2023 09:56

Just wanted to also point out the complexities of judging how affected babies, children and adults who grown up as a baby from a surrogate are by it. Most children feel a strong loyalty to their parents, who’ve brought them up and loved them. In lots of cases this can prevent them being honest about how they feel. You may well have a child who’s successful at school, an adult who gets a successful role in their career, who claims they don’t want to know anything about the surrogate parents, but it doesn’t necessarily mean that they are in fact unaffected or that they’ve honestly looked at their feelings about it. It also doesn’t mean they don’t have other issues that aren’t immediately obvious. It’s like self-reporting - it’s not always an accurate or full picture. I’m not saying everyone who was born from surrogacy is negatively affected, but I do think it’s very hard to judge who is or not.

And to expand on this @Newnamenewname109870 used suicide as a justification for surrogacy.

Imagine the pressure that this could potentially bring to a child conceived of surrogacy if this accidentally slipped, which it could, into their consciousness?

Or if the surrogate child looked into matters and felt that the birth mother had been manipulated either emotionally or financially into making the decision, how would that 'child' feel about the parents who raised them then?

The IPs and the surrogate mother might not have much concerns for the ethics of the arrangement but they can't control how the child will feel about it.

MagpieSong · 21/04/2023 09:56

Newnamenewname109870 · 20/04/2023 20:09

I’m not disagreeing with any of the disgusting coercion, slavery and abuse of clearly vulnerable women on here.
I don’t think there should be a blanket ban because:

  1. I don’t think all surrogate women are destroyed by the process. Clearly this needs to be monitored and some serious legal support put in place.
  2. I don’t think all babies born by surrogacy are damaged by the process.
  3. Even if I thought this happened in some cases, it’s clearly not all. Therefore a blanket ban wouldn’t be fair. I don’t like the idea of abortion but again I understand it’s not a black and white issues and would never want a blanket ban, like in parts of the states.
  4. people are going to do it anyway. Make it legal and make it safe.

now I’m actually going to leave as I don’t think my presence is making much difference tbh.

Just wanted to also point out the complexities of judging how affected babies, children and adults who grown up as a baby from a surrogate are by it. Most children feel a strong loyalty to their parents, who’ve brought them up and loved them. In lots of cases this can prevent them being honest about how they feel. You may well have a child who’s successful at school, an adult who gets a successful role in their career, who claims they don’t want to know anything about the surrogate parents, but it doesn’t necessarily mean that they are in fact unaffected or that they’ve honestly looked at their feelings about it. It also doesn’t mean they don’t have other issues that aren’t immediately obvious. It’s like self-reporting - it’s not always an accurate or full picture. I’m not saying everyone who was born from surrogacy is negatively affected, but I do think it’s very hard to judge who is or not.

ClumsyCat · 21/04/2023 08:51

YY Helleofabore

I agree that it would be extremely tough to get away with illegal surrogacy if it were properly enforced.

Since commercial surrogacy isn’t legal, neither is child trafficking. I don’t understand how people are currently able to traffic babies from abroad like gay male celebrities do. How did they get the British passport for the baby? How come questions aren’t asked at customs and social services aren’t called to remove the trafficked child? They should be asked - where did you get this baby from - you didn’t leave the country with it? Where is its mother? …….. 🫤 Fuck me! that baby would be ‘something to declare’ at customs alright.

If it were properly enforced, and surrogacy was illegal, then the only time I think surrogacy would happen in the UK, would be close relatives.

Births need to be registered, i am pretty sure that I needed to take medical records and ID when I registered my children’s births to make sure I am who I say I am, the baby is mine and I gave birth to her. How could people get around that if surrogacy was illegal?

You aren’t just allowed to give babies/children away. Social services would need to be involved if anyone did it - otherwise there would be problems trying to register the baby at a GP or getting a school place. Since social services would look for someone within the family first to adopt the baby, then ‘altruistic surrogacy’ within the family would be the only you could get away with it.

Helleofabore · 21/04/2023 07:17

The whole “it is going to happen anyway, so may as well regulate it” is borrowed from legalising illicit drugs from what I remember. And prostitution.

That is where this thread has descended. Using activism lines from using harmful drugs and prostitution to support the exploitation of at least one woman for her reproductive capabilities and exploiting a human being created deliberately to fulfill an adults desire.

Considering that it is going to require so many layers of fully qualified and very expensive equipment to run illegal surrogacy businesses. Plus if the rules reflected the human trafficking aspect of exploiting that baby to be trafficked across borders, governments could have procedures for identifying these children, at the border and at other key registration points with significant enough deterrents that parents would not even contemplate it as an option. I suspect that the reality of ‘illegal surrogacy’ will be low and those discovered would be very severely punished.

Just as other forms of illegal ‘sourcing’ of babies today.

If a governing body required the equipment to be highly regulated even to the destruction of old equipment and no resale when equipment is replaced, that would be a start. This would also make sure no illegal IVF clinics or egg harvesting businesses.

The businesses (because illegal surrogacy would be business and not charity) would need many staff, then sourcing illegal equipment. Then another layer to this would be bringing the baby home and trying to register that baby in the home country. A faked document would require significant hacking to make it actually work on the many levels required for access to health services etc. Therefore this becomes another net of capture. Basically, a family who pursues illegal surrogacy will face a life of detection and it will be a very rare person who will do that. And those people would be considering other illegal sources of babies anyway.

So, I am not sure what the ‘watch what will happen’ threat means.

However it was meant, using the ‘watch what will happen’ and ‘ it is going to happen so regulate it’ are threats. They are just as coercive a form of activism as ‘suicide prevention’. They should never be viewed as coherent and evidence based facts and logic to legalise surrogacy.

So, they are unethical reasons to wedge open an unethical act.

And just as emotionally manipulative and not based on science or ethics as any other argument mentioned on this thread so far. If an action requires so much emotional manipulation due to lack of substantive and proven science, it should be raising red flags and sounding alarm bells.

Helleofabore · 20/04/2023 23:39

So I see we have now got to the ‘ban it and watch what happens’ stage.

Was this supposed to mean that if surrogacy is banned, that people would… actually, what? kidnap babies? Hold women in forced baby farms?

So, not only should surrogacy be legal so people don’t commit suicide because they can exploit at least one woman and a child that has been deliberately and specifically created to stop them committing suicide. But, we now should have legalised surrogacy because some people society cannot control themselves and will get babies illegally.

And this is from a poster who declared that ‘ethical surrogacy’ exists…. who then has stated fucked up and unethical reasons to keep surrogacy legal.

It all amounts to people are going to exploit women and babies anyway, may as well let people do it.

Once you see it, you really cannot unsee it.

Helleofabore · 20/04/2023 23:31

Good point red

RedToothBrush · 20/04/2023 21:36

Helleofabore · 20/04/2023 09:04

“I’m talking about ethical surrogacy. It does exist. And yes it’s worth it to all those involved. Infertility can cause someone to feel suicidal, whereas surrogacy can be a solution to that problem.”

Fuck! I wasn’t dreaming it last night when I skimmed through!

You, a poster who asserts there is such thing as ‘ethical surrogacy’, cannot see the completely unethical mastery in this paragraph you wrote!

There is no fucking way to ever dress up surrogacy to be an ethical prescription to prevent an adult human committing suicide!

I think any reader who has made it this far in the thread will now understand that you don’t actually understand ethics. You don’t understand exploitation of other humans.

”This debate keeps going round and round. Some of us believe that when done ethically, it is perfectly ok and in fact a good option for people on our society.”

Of course the debate goes round and round when you have no understanding of ethics.

Then in the next post you wrote this gem:

”And the desire to have children can surpass all else, life itself. Some people clearly don’t have that in them and it’s fine. It’s like how some people are able to be celibate and some would rather die then never be able to masturbate/have sex. It’s a human need just like any other and some of us have stronger urges than others. It really frustrates me how some people minimalise this.”

If you have such a poor understanding of ‘ethics’, you are going to always be unhappy that others can recognize when ethical boundaries are crossed!

You have now brought in the other way human beings are exploited. Sex. So, do you also believe that prostitution is not exploiting another human body for someone’s ‘need’.

Would you also prescribe a prostitution as a suicide prevention treatment?

“It is the most wanted loved thing and everyone involved is doing what they can for that baby. ”

Fuck! The doors on ethics are wide open here.

So, what other exploitative actions are ok to be dismissed as ‘ethical’ because the result is that ‘thing’ will be much wanted and loved?

And exploitation is fine as long as everyone is doing what they can for that ‘thing’!

You know what that ‘thing’ is? A human being that has been created to prevent an adult from committing suicide or to fulfill the need to have a child that is so bad that other human beings are exploited to remove that need for that adult.

Readers, have the red flags been taken notice of yet? Is the alarm bell being heard?

”So much black and white thinking and no discussion on how to make it legal and ethical, so not much more I can add really.”

Thanks though for showing us what you consider the ‘middle ground’ you assured us earlier really did exist.

Threatening suicide is a known coercive control pattern behaviour.

Humanbiology · 20/04/2023 21:25

SemperIdem · 20/04/2023 21:02

In my early 20’s I talked a friend out of being a surrogate for her older sister. She was being aggressively coerced into the situation at the time. I will forever be glad that my friends first born baby was one she could raise herself.

Her family and no right to do that to her. Coercion is now a crime.

ClumsyCat · 20/04/2023 21:09

SemperIdem · 20/04/2023 21:02

In my early 20’s I talked a friend out of being a surrogate for her older sister. She was being aggressively coerced into the situation at the time. I will forever be glad that my friends first born baby was one she could raise herself.

Well done!

SemperIdem · 20/04/2023 21:02

In my early 20’s I talked a friend out of being a surrogate for her older sister. She was being aggressively coerced into the situation at the time. I will forever be glad that my friends first born baby was one she could raise herself.

Blaueblumen · 20/04/2023 20:48

I do judge surrogate mothers as well as all the others involved. It’s an awful thing to do - grow a baby inside you deliberately, while having no intention to care for it, in fact planning to sell it/give it away. It’s a terrible thing to do.

This

ClumsyCat · 20/04/2023 20:41

Newnamenewname109870 · 20/04/2023 20:34

But you’re only a prostitute if you get paid 😂👍 put any word in there, whatever. Change it to cannabis. You do do.

If that’s the case, that you could swap out the word ‘surrogacy’ for prostitution, cannabis, whatever, in your arguments, then you are right when you say:

“I don’t think my presence is making much difference”

Surrogacy is a different issue, with very different ethical considerations than legalising cannabis, and if you can’t see how it’s different, then you can’t really add anything to the discussion.

nothingcomestonothing · 20/04/2023 20:40
  1. I don’t think all babies born by surrogacy are damaged by the process.
  2. Even if I thought this happened in some cases, it’s clearly not all. Therefore a blanket ban wouldn’t be fair.

So you realise that some babies will be damaged, but you’ve decided that because it’s not all of them, (not sure I agree but anyway) that’s okay? Really? Some babies suffering harm is okay with you, because a blanket ban would be unfair? How many harmed babies is allowable for you, how many is too many? I think my allowable number of harmed children is none.

Newnamenewname109870 · 20/04/2023 20:34

ClumsyCat · 20/04/2023 20:25

No. I mean it literally.

  1. I don’t think all [prostitutes] are destroyed by the process. Clearly this needs to be monitored and some serious legal support put in place.
  2. I don’t think [all lives touched by prostitution] are damaged by the process.
  3. Even if I thought this happened in some cases, it’s clearly not all. Therefore a blanket ban wouldn’t be fair. I don’t like the idea of abortion but again I understand it’s not a black and white issues and would never want a blanket ban, like in parts of the states.
  4. people are going to do it anyway. Make it legal and make it safe.

But you’re only a prostitute if you get paid 😂👍 put any word in there, whatever. Change it to cannabis. You do do.

ClumsyCat · 20/04/2023 20:25

Newnamenewname109870 · 20/04/2023 20:21

Only because you’re assuming there is payment.

No. I mean it literally.

  1. I don’t think all [prostitutes] are destroyed by the process. Clearly this needs to be monitored and some serious legal support put in place.
  2. I don’t think [all lives touched by prostitution] are damaged by the process.
  3. Even if I thought this happened in some cases, it’s clearly not all. Therefore a blanket ban wouldn’t be fair. I don’t like the idea of abortion but again I understand it’s not a black and white issues and would never want a blanket ban, like in parts of the states.
  4. people are going to do it anyway. Make it legal and make it safe.
Newnamenewname109870 · 20/04/2023 20:21

ClumsyCat · 20/04/2023 20:18

You arguments are very similar to the pro-prostitution arguments.

Only because you’re assuming there is payment.

ClumsyCat · 20/04/2023 20:18

Newnamenewname109870 · 20/04/2023 20:09

I’m not disagreeing with any of the disgusting coercion, slavery and abuse of clearly vulnerable women on here.
I don’t think there should be a blanket ban because:

  1. I don’t think all surrogate women are destroyed by the process. Clearly this needs to be monitored and some serious legal support put in place.
  2. I don’t think all babies born by surrogacy are damaged by the process.
  3. Even if I thought this happened in some cases, it’s clearly not all. Therefore a blanket ban wouldn’t be fair. I don’t like the idea of abortion but again I understand it’s not a black and white issues and would never want a blanket ban, like in parts of the states.
  4. people are going to do it anyway. Make it legal and make it safe.

now I’m actually going to leave as I don’t think my presence is making much difference tbh.

You arguments are very similar to the pro-prostitution arguments.

Newnamenewname109870 · 20/04/2023 20:09

I’m not disagreeing with any of the disgusting coercion, slavery and abuse of clearly vulnerable women on here.
I don’t think there should be a blanket ban because:

  1. I don’t think all surrogate women are destroyed by the process. Clearly this needs to be monitored and some serious legal support put in place.
  2. I don’t think all babies born by surrogacy are damaged by the process.
  3. Even if I thought this happened in some cases, it’s clearly not all. Therefore a blanket ban wouldn’t be fair. I don’t like the idea of abortion but again I understand it’s not a black and white issues and would never want a blanket ban, like in parts of the states.
  4. people are going to do it anyway. Make it legal and make it safe.

now I’m actually going to leave as I don’t think my presence is making much difference tbh.

ClumsyCat · 20/04/2023 20:01

Humanbiology · 20/04/2023 19:55

Do you judge surrogate women for their choices do you think they are the problem. If there weren't willing women to do it then there would be no surrogate babies.

I do judge surrogate mothers as well as all the others involved. It’s an awful thing to do - grow a baby inside you deliberately, while having no intention to care for it, in fact planning to sell it/give it away. It’s a terrible thing to do.