Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Son excluded from nieces party

111 replies

Briar250 · 18/04/2023 02:50

My brothers daughter was 6 last week and we come from a large family, there are lots of cousins - who were invited to the party. My daughter, who is 9 months old was Uninvited though as she was deemed too small to engage or interact and my brother felt that there were too many children attending the party anyway which she said costs a lot.

I can see where he’s coming from, but at no point did he even consider my baby. There were others slightly older than my girl and we could have helped out tbh.

aibu for being upset and disappointed

felt like he was trying to impress his and partners mates and put is last

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kets27 · 19/04/2023 13:55

This post really resonated with me. When my baby was 10 months old, my best friend also excluded me and my daughter from her 3 year olds bouncy castle type play party. I remember crying as felt left out and thought i cud have helped and my baby would have still liked to see all the kids.
I had an honest chat with her after the party and she was really upset to know how I felt. Luckily being my bestie she apologised.. even though she really did not have to. Which meant I apologised too for being silly n needy about it. But really wanted to be part of the celebrations.. so I understand completely how you feel. Though its probably not justified.. just natural

Pertinentowl · 19/04/2023 13:10

I don’t think there’s any point in trying to guess motives, I always find it best to assume good intent from people and never assume anything hurtful.

  1. because if they did mean something hurtful it will become apparent in time as a pattern emerges
  2. it is exhausting trying to second guess peoples motivations. I don’t want to live like that and I don’t like people pulling me into that thinking. I’m not going there. wether I’m right or wrong my life is less stressful than my friends who do this. Or they phone you up after a get together wondering if they said something wrong or if things didn’t come out the right way. Don’t feed that part of the brain. If you don’t feed it you don’t have to live in that always wondering state of mind.
JusthereforXmas · 19/04/2023 11:07

Goldbar · 19/04/2023 10:08

Kids parties are different from family gatherings. It would be unreasonable to exclude you and your baby from a family party, but kids parties are normally about the kids' friends not family.

Babies under 1/non-mobile babies really only come to parties as add-ons/accessories to the parents, rather than as party guests in their own right. The convention at the childrens' parties I've attended so far with my older DC (aged 5) seems to be that breastfeeding and non-mobile babies are welcome when attending with an older sibling (so long as free and not counting towards the numbers) but when they're mobile and can be left for longer periods, most people seem to leave them with the other parent or family/a babysitter unless "siblings" are expressly welcome.

I think you might be confusing your niece's party with a family event, when it's actually for her friends? I've never known a 6yo to specifically invite a baby to their party tbh (as opposed to baby coming with another party guest) especially if it's an activity party.

Exactly OP seems confused about who the party is for.

At 1 year old (like her child apparently nearly is) you tend to only invite family as the party is actually all about mam not baby.

However by 6 year old (like niece apparently is) the party is entirely for 6 years olds friends. Adults only attend as begrudging chaperones and its no longer about grandparents and aunts and parents friends.

My siblings and DH siblings do not have kids, I have 3 kids... our siblings have never really been invited to (apart from first birthdays which they did not attend) or wanted to attend a kiddies birthday. If they had a kid this would still apply unless the kids where actually friends of my kid.

My own kids don't tend get invited to their own siblings birthdays. The younger 2 wouldn't be safe to do what oldest wants and oldest would find the younger kids parties embarrassing and dull (what 15 year old wants to sit for 2 hours in a soft play area or do the gangnam style at a disco with 5 year olds).

Plus when hosting, keeping a secondary eye on 30 kids, fielding questions from parents and sorting food etc... I don't have eyes in the back of my head and time to be running round after my toddler.

Goldbar · 19/04/2023 10:08

Kids parties are different from family gatherings. It would be unreasonable to exclude you and your baby from a family party, but kids parties are normally about the kids' friends not family.

Babies under 1/non-mobile babies really only come to parties as add-ons/accessories to the parents, rather than as party guests in their own right. The convention at the childrens' parties I've attended so far with my older DC (aged 5) seems to be that breastfeeding and non-mobile babies are welcome when attending with an older sibling (so long as free and not counting towards the numbers) but when they're mobile and can be left for longer periods, most people seem to leave them with the other parent or family/a babysitter unless "siblings" are expressly welcome.

I think you might be confusing your niece's party with a family event, when it's actually for her friends? I've never known a 6yo to specifically invite a baby to their party tbh (as opposed to baby coming with another party guest) especially if it's an activity party.

Dobby123456 · 19/04/2023 09:10

I wouldn't invite a baby to a six-year-old's birthday party, tbh. I invited cousins etc. when they were really small (because the party isn't really for the baby!). Once they're at school and have their own friends, don't invite family any longer. Only babies invited are little brothers and sisters that can't be left at home.

It sounds like you are feeling a bit down and sensitive at the moment. If you are a large, close family, I'm sure there will be lots of other occasions to meet up. When your kid gets older they will have SO many birthday party invitations from their class mates you'll be sick of kids birthday parties! Enjoy the 'baby phase' while it lasts!

Hope this perspective helps!

DoubleZee · 19/04/2023 00:14

I don’t think your being unreasonable I’d be upset to be excluded from what I know when paying per head you don’t pay for infants so that’s no excuse and if it is a money thing I’d offer to pay for myself as you usually have to pay per adult too. My child has never been excluded from family events my nieces and nephews would expect to see their auntys at their party’s regardless of the age of their cousins I also think it’s good socialisation for the baby but maybe that’s just because both my family and my partners family’s are close so we always just invite everyone even those without children

TwoThingsAndAThimble · 18/04/2023 21:48

I think everyone is being a bit harsh tbh. It's not nice to be excluded, and as a new Mum, you're probably already feeling isolated as it is. Your brother is probably just being practical and thinks a 9month old won't get much out of a 6 year old's party (he'd be right). In his mind it might not be a big family gathering, just a kids' party - he likely hasn't thought that he'd be excluding you, because most adults would honestly rather not attend a kids' birthday party unless they have to. If it was a big family gathering I'd feel differently of course. It's a bit weird that they invited a 12-month-old though!

I don't think you're being totally unreasonable, I understand how you feel. But I don't think they have done anything wildly wrong either.

swuidge · 18/04/2023 20:42

I can see your point and disappointment, i have a big close knit family, when we have parties everyone gets invited regardless of age.

But if it was a party at somewhere for that age group i.e trampolining or something then is it really any point of you/baby attending? Not really much baby can do at a place like that, but i’d feel a bit hurt if it was a family garden party and wasn’t invited.

i’m sure in the future you may view this from his perspective when planning parties for your little one.

Dontworkmondays · 18/04/2023 19:20

Is your brother joking?? I can’t relate at all. You are his sister, that baby isn’t someone random, it’s his direct nephew. He should be treating him like his own son not some one he unfortunately has to pay for. Defo not being unreasonable.

Tigermearns · 18/04/2023 19:01

Iwasafool · 18/04/2023 18:08

I could understand that with an older child but a 9 month old baby? How bad can their behaviour be? They aren't going to be running round smashing things are they.

I mean the OPs behaviour not the child... they've uninvited the child so that they don't have to deal with OP

Itsanotherhreatday · 18/04/2023 18:41

40 kids and 80 parents? All out for a social? Wonder why parties get smaller?

HolidayHun2020 · 18/04/2023 18:36

I honestly cannot get over how nasty some of these comments are. Vile.

OP, I understand where you are coming from a similar thing happened to us when DD was 9 months old. We didn’t get invited to a friends 4 year olds birthday because they had too many already ‘around 40 kids’ BUT all of our friends with kids did get invited and went along. It stung a bit as we had no plans and would have been an excuse for us to get out and see friends rather then something for DD to enjoy. I suspect this is more about you feeling uninvited then feeling annoyed that your baby isn’t invited. Hope you’re ok OP x

Iwasafool · 18/04/2023 18:08

Tigermearns · 18/04/2023 17:58

It did make me wonder whether her child was uninvited due to how she may behaves instead when she put that line... like her brother doesn't want her there embarrassing him in front of the other guests so he decided her 9month old doesn't need to be there anyway

I could understand that with an older child but a 9 month old baby? How bad can their behaviour be? They aren't going to be running round smashing things are they.

StephanieSuperpowers · 18/04/2023 18:02

Eatingsoupwithafork · 18/04/2023 06:08

Hmm this post gives me pause for thought. my little girl has asked for a very specific activity for her birthday that my nephew who is 6 years older would have zero interest in. I haven’t invited him even though i know his mum will be upset. It is very clear he won’t enjoy it (and is too old to be there). I will explain to her but I think the natural go to will be upset, which is understandable.

Yeah, I had the same. I just had a chat with my SIL and explained. She was absolutely fine with it.

Tigermearns · 18/04/2023 17:58

It did make me wonder whether her child was uninvited due to how she may behaves instead when she put that line... like her brother doesn't want her there embarrassing him in front of the other guests so he decided her 9month old doesn't need to be there anyway

sarah419 · 18/04/2023 17:38

YABU i’m afraid! Similarly when your child is of the age when you will be hosting parities with age appropriate entertainment, you will realise that her cousin who is 9 years older won’t enjoy the same activities and likely you might leave her out.

EmilyGilmoresSass · 18/04/2023 16:36

Unless it was a family only party, it would never cross my mind to invite a 9 month old baby to the party of a 6 year old.

Mariposista · 18/04/2023 16:31

At 9 months all your child (regardless of gender) can do is sit on your lap, look cute, draw attention away from the birthday child and probably need taking home early once they get tired/hungry/overwhelmed 🙄

poetryandwine · 18/04/2023 16:17

Again, will people please stop piling on the OP?

Firstly she has PND. Secondly she seems to be trying to disguise the details of her situation. If my DH were doing that he would be making similar mistakes, and he is a fairly esteemed professor. OP, I say you are in good company.

But I agree that if the 12 mo old has a sibling of an appropriate age for the party, then gently YABU. Otherwise, YANBU. Are you getting some help with the PND? Best wishes

Elaina87 · 18/04/2023 16:01

Oh it really does not matter though! Just give some constructive advice instead of pulling her apart.

Elaina87 · 18/04/2023 15:59

It depends on the type of party. If it's a kids party with their friends invited, its likely cost per head and very expensive, adults probably limited to one per child, a 9 month old won't get anything from it so don't take it personally. If it's a family party at a house or something then yes you have reason to feel upset and annoyed xx

EasterBreak · 18/04/2023 15:55

Unless your son is actually 9 years instead of 9 months you are massively unreasonable.

JusthereforXmas · 18/04/2023 15:02

MummBRaaarrrTheEverLeaking · 18/04/2023 10:51

So many nit pickers I doubt the OP will be back! A 9 months old baby wasn't invited to a 6 year olds party. Do the sexes of the children involved matter? Not really.

But oh the sleuths of MN, oooo a typo was it yeah right etc etc.

If you admit you're changing details to not be recognised but ballsed it up, then you've just outed yourself. OP probably tried to style it out by saying it's a typo and hoping people would leave it - but didn't count on the faction of Detective Mumsnet who just won't stop until every little bit is exposed, and the OP gets into real life bother if it's picked up by the daily rag.

OP - it's about the child and their birthday party, parties are a stress to organise as it is, and YABU to think you need to be considered. You are probably thinking about the social aspect for you, and how nice it'll be to catch up with the family, they are thinking about the logistics of a bunch of older kids running around a baby. Just go round with a little cake and have a more baby friendly affair later.

But sex of the child wouldn't give this away the details would and if OP is changing the key details then its a completely fake story and people can't give any advice or even comment on fairness.

I mean if last week you hosted a party for your 6 year old daughter and invited all family even a 1 year old but banned your sisters 9 month old as 'too young' then regardless of if the post uses male or female descriptors its still going to be bloody obvious when the daily fail picks it up. No one is going to say 'that senerio entirely matches exactly what just happened in our family but can't be us because they said daughter and my sister has a son'.

Now if in reality the scenario was their 3 year old son was not invited to an 11 year old girl pamper party for being too young and not wanting to have his nails panted while drinking mocktails and listening to Beyonce. However another 6 year old niece was invited because she does like and appreciate those thing then changing it to whats in this post would 'possibly' disguise it. However its only 'disguised' by COMPLETELY changing all the facts into something wildly different.

redskylight · 18/04/2023 14:24

Peapodburgundybouquet · 18/04/2023 07:50

You see things very black and white, dotn you?

Funnily enough I am looking at a black and white screen.

But also not sure of the point you are making? Perhaps you could make a point rather than a personal comment?

Thinkingpod · 18/04/2023 13:18

Is it a boy is if a girl was it your sister or brother... There's a lot of wonky stuff here.

Was the party at a soft play? Or similar? If so, your little son who turned in to a daughter midway through, would have absolutely no level of excitement for the party or interaction and the group of excited 6 yr olds could possibly cause harm yo him/her.

Same if it was at a venue it their house with a bouncy castle. Kids are rough and 9 months old are small