Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think allergy mum is OTT

239 replies

Boogiewoogieanddance · 17/04/2023 21:38

I genuinely don't know if I am or not, this is a genuine question as I thankfully haven't got any experience in having a child with serious allergies. I am, of course, happy to do what I can to prevent a reaction.

There is a child in my DDs class who is allergic to a list of things so we aren't allowed them in pack lunches. That's fine, I have no issue as I know kids can be careless and gross about their food hygiene. My issue is with the nuts, literally anything that says "may contain nuts" or "may contain traces of peanuts" is not allowed... if the occasional time I don't realise and send something (These are not nut flavoured things or anything with nuts in the ingredients, but I assume are just made in the same factory as nuts.) it is sent home unwrapped and she hasn't been allowed to eat it.

But is it really possible that an allergy can be so served that something that may contain nuts could cause a reaction if opened in the same room.

Many thanks!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
TwoFluffyDogsOnMyBed · 17/04/2023 22:56

I’m not sure I believe that a staff member is checking every single packed lunch item….

There is no way I’d have trusted the staff at my DC’s primary school to check and no way I’d send a child to school if their allergy was that severe.

Bringonsummer19 · 17/04/2023 22:56

Child with a nut allergy here. That is insane. Nut free yes, eg a big no to Nutella, M&M peanuts. but the ‘may contain traces’ is not doable, firms like marks and Spencer’s have just updated their ingredients list to say this (lazy fu*kers).

maddening · 17/04/2023 22:56

It is an easy enough accommodation to make to enable a child to attend school safely, yabu

MedievalMadness · 17/04/2023 22:54

I can understand the parents and the schools concerns as it sounds an extreme allergy . I doubt a school could properly control the environment to the extent required though as they’d need to ensure no one in close vicinity to the child had eaten anything containing nuts before school, that all food brought in was manufactured in a nut free kitchen and prepared in a nut free home environment prior to it going into a lunch bag. It’s completely unworkable I think.

Myotherusernamewastakenagain · 17/04/2023 22:54

StressedToTheMaxxx · 17/04/2023 22:51

If it's may contain then it may have nuts in. Which to a severely allergic child, could kill them. I'm not sure why you dont see an issue with that?

As long as they don't share the food it isn't a real risk.

OzziePopPop · 17/04/2023 22:54

Do the parents have a plan for secondary school? Because if you’ve been doing this for six years (as per your previous post) then the kids must be year 5/6….

NeverDropYourMooncup · 17/04/2023 22:53

Myotherusernamewastakenagain · 17/04/2023 22:34

Utterly ridiculous and OTT.

The child with the allergy isn't going to be consuming the food.

The risk of the may contains actually having the product is low, it's not like a game of Russian roulette.

The HT is well meaning but is acting completely ott.

It would be nice if that were true - however, having been glutened by things that had no indication at all that they were manufactured in a dirty place where they clearly weren't as careful about cleaning as they should have been (and I'm not even going to start on the times where gluten free stuff is withdrawn weeks later because they had been dusted with flour), I'd say May Contain is more shorthand for 'if we're having an off day, don't come after us for money to pay for the funeral'.

Thisiscrazyshite · 17/04/2023 22:53

Allergies are very serious and anyone who has ever witnessed a true anaphylaxis would understand. A lot of people haven’t, thankfully, and people do exaggerate their allergies or call intolerance to foods, allergies.
This leads to a lot of confusion.
If the mother says her child has a true allergy to nuts, believe her and do the right thing. Read the labels of all foods going in your child’s lunch box. It’s not difficult. If there’s a warning, it may contain nuts, it’s a no for two reasons:

  1. Peanut spores are air borne and can be inhaled, causing anaphylaxis, which can be fatal.
  2. Children share food, even when requested not to. Or the child with the allergy may touch the food. This can be fatal, keep that in mind at all times.

This family have to live with this fear every hour of every day. They have to check labels of all foods all the time and eating out is a mine field.

So, it’s not a huge ask that parents of kids in the class check the ingredients and warnings on food labels.

YABVU

Myotherusernamewastakenagain · 17/04/2023 22:52

EarringsandLipstick · 17/04/2023 22:46

Excellent, clear post.

Some of the other posts ... 🤦🏻‍♀️

It is AIBU so it's just attracting trolls, surely people can't be that thick.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 17/04/2023 22:51

lokienji · 17/04/2023 21:44

If it’s ‘May contain’ it likely DOES NOT contain and it’s not the child with allergies eating it? Don’t see an issue

Obviously not bringing things in that you know contain nuts but other stuff seems fine. Although it could be the world’s most serious allergy. Better safe than sorry for the sake of one snack which could be an alternative snack.

If it's may contain then it may have nuts in. Which to a severely allergic child, could kill them. I'm not sure why you dont see an issue with that?

Hoppingmad231 · 17/04/2023 22:51

Our school is nut free I know off one child in their with nut allergy needs epipen so very serious allergy, we get told no nuts but never been told no may contain nuts and the dinner ladies don't check lunch bags so even if I sent something In (I wouldnt) with nuts in nobody would know.

Oneandonly22 · 17/04/2023 22:49

It does sound OTT and my DD 4 has a nut and egg allergy. I have other children who do eat items that say may contain nuts. I allow this because these are food they’ve had in past before we found out she had allergies. She also ate things in past that said “may contain nuts” and didn’t have a reaction. She took a severe reaction when her dad gave her a spoonful of his crunchy nut cornflakes. This was first and last time he’s ever done that. She also took a reaction to scrambled egg and then when she handled an whole egg one day at my mums. She can eat cooked eggs in like cakes etc but not a fried egg boiled etc. Her consultant at the hospital explained that the eggs in cakes are mixed with that many ingredients and cooked at such a high temp she is no longer eating an egg. DD carries two epipens everywhere she goes. If she did come into contact with an egg or nut that we couldn’t prevent and she took a reaction then we can deal with it.

Remaker · 17/04/2023 22:48

That’s a complete overreaction. Labelling foods as ‘may contain traces of nuts’ is just a liability covering exercise by corporations. It is no reflection of the actual risk in consuming the product. I know people with severe nut allergies who eat these products because they are not dangerous.

Under these rules, a parent can send in a cheese sandwich made on the same cutting board as the peanut butter toast their child had for breakfast with no issue. But nut-free packaged crackers with a ‘traces’ warning label are banned.

Trying to control the environment is never going to be successful with allergies. You need to educate and empower the child. FWIW I have a severe food allergy myself.

JenniferBarkley · 17/04/2023 22:47

Completely ridiculous.

As others have said, my DC carries epipens due to a peanut allergy but eats may contains with the agreement of her specialist as it's so restrictive to avoid and the risk is very low.

No nuts if it's an airborne allergy is fair enough. No may contains is too restrictive and difficult.

EarringsandLipstick · 17/04/2023 22:46

Simd1 · 17/04/2023 22:02

I'm a mum of a child with a severe peanut allergy. Banning other kids from eating "may contain" foods is totally bonkers. DS doesn't eat these foods himself due to his allergy - many (but not all) allergy sufferers avoid them for themselves scrupulously, but this is not necessary for the others around them. Allergies can be airborne, but "may contain" foods would only have a small trace amount, if anything, that poses no risk to anyone except the person eating it.

"May contain" labelling is not even a legal requirement, although in practice most supermarkets and major manufacturers do so.

Excellent, clear post.

Some of the other posts ... 🤦🏻‍♀️

IForgotMyUsernameAgain · 17/04/2023 22:45

My DH loves peanut butter on toast so whilst we do obviously clean up after ourselves, the sandwiches we send in DC's packed lunches "may contain traces of nuts."

So to me this seems a bit OTT as you would have to effectively exclude all food from kitchens that had peanut butter in them, otherwise how could you be sure?

MrsSkylerWhite · 17/04/2023 22:44

Boogiewoogieanddance · Today 22:05
@Albiboba I'm not brushing it off? It's a genuine question as I didn't know they could be that severe in relation to being in a room with a child eating something that said "may contain traces of nut" could cause a reaction. I asked because I was curious if the mum is a bit over the top or if she is right to be so cautious.”

Well, now you know. Yes, it can be that serious.

Kanaloa · 17/04/2023 22:43

I would wonder how they actually manage that. A ‘may contain nuts’ product is less likely to be contaminated than a sandwich made in my kitchen when we’ve had peanut butter for breakfast! So realistically
it’s not likely to actually work.

Darkchocolatekitkat · 17/04/2023 22:43

Boogiewoogieanddance · 17/04/2023 22:31

Maybe I worded it wrong in relation to using the word severe, I know how bad allergic reactions can be and that they can be life threatening/fatal. What I didn't realise is how sensitive they can be when it comes to other people eating "may contain nuts" food

I never thought about cafes etc, I know the child enjoys a Starbucks so when I think of it that way it is quite frustrating having to be so vigilant about DDs pack lunch.

Starbucks say all their food and drinks may contain traces of nuts and other allergens (as do pretty much all cafes/coffee shops). They have plenty of nut containing products in the place too - almond milk for a start.

So that’s interesting.

AdviceOnLife · 17/04/2023 22:42

As a child, a boy in our class took an allergic reaction to a boy who ate a snickers bar then spoke to him. Clearly a snickers contains nut. No idea what the parents were thinking. It was horrific for the boy and everyone involved.
So I understand the allergy is horrendous.
But this really does sound ott.
Most companies now put may contain nuts even if it is the most minute chance.
There is definitely a middle ground for the school to find hopefully.
You could always take the snack out the wrapper and put it in tupperware as long as you are extremely vigilant about checking for nuts.

Muchtoomuchtodo · 17/04/2023 22:41

As our kitchen isn’t nut free that would mean our dc couldn’t take a packed lunch.

That’s beyond bonkers, and against the advice of allergy specialists as far as I’m aware. I think any school trying to be 100% nut free is setting themselves up to fail, even with the best will in the world from other families without children with allergies and could bring about a false sense of security.

I would read up a bit and politely challenge the policy.

StatisticallyChallenged · 17/04/2023 22:41

I don't think this is reasonable or practical.

As PP have said, anything made in my (and most people's) kitchens would be a "may contain traces" level, and they can't expect other families to maintain allergy safe cleanliness levels for an allergy their child doesn't have. So the whole thing is immediately invalidated as the main component of many of the kids lunches will be nut trace risk anyway.

Then you have to deal with other kids who have allergies themselves which may limit their dietary options. But now the families of kids who are allergic to gluten/dairy/whatever have to try and find snacks which suit their child and also don't have any nut traces warnings. It's just not a realistic ask. My DD has a dairy allergy and a quick look shows that most of her lunchbox snacks would be ruled out due to this.

Pullthecurtains · 17/04/2023 22:41

This is ott. I have a severe nut allergy and eat “may contains” because it’s just manufacturers putting it on to cover themselves. I’ve even seen bottled water with the warning! In this case it’s not even the child with the allergy eating the product which has a minuscule chance of having nuts in it so the risk is basically non existent.

Interestingly there’s also no scientific evidence of airborne allergies causing severe allergic reactions so even in the very unlikely case that something with “may contain” did have nuts in it the child with the allergy is extremely unlikely to react to another child (potentially on the other side of the dining hall) eating it. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33548082/

Peanuts in the air - clinical and experimental studies - PubMed

Allergic reactions to airborne peanut proteins are rare and cannot be predicted by high levels of IgE-antibodies to peanut or Ara h 2. Only small amounts of biologically active peanut proteins were detected in the air and seem unlikely to trigger moder...

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33548082/

Myotherusernamewastakenagain · 17/04/2023 22:34

Utterly ridiculous and OTT.

The child with the allergy isn't going to be consuming the food.

The risk of the may contains actually having the product is low, it's not like a game of Russian roulette.

The HT is well meaning but is acting completely ott.

Darkchocolatekitkat · 17/04/2023 22:31

Nut allergy parent here. It sounds OTT - banning products with actual nut ingredients is potentially reasonable especially if the allergy is airborne or the children are young and the allergic child themselves avoiding “may contain traces of” is reasonable (albeit I exercise some common sense with that one because really the chance of cheddar cheese sticks, orange juice, fish fingers or ketchup containing nuts is zero but I’ve seen it labelled as “may contain”). But expecting a child is never going to be in the same room as a “may contain traces of” product is just not realistic - almost all bakery/non prepacked bread would be off limits for a start but are they checking what bread is used to make the kid’s sandwiches? Auditing their kitchens? What about all the food that doesn’t come in a handy printed wrapper?

I wouldn’t assume it’s necessarily the parent though, often it’s a well meaning and worried about getting it wrong member of staff taking a “better safe than sorry” approach to an extreme. There’s very little training for school staff on this and a lot of responsibility.

Swipe left for the next trending thread