Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think allergy mum is OTT

239 replies

Boogiewoogieanddance · 17/04/2023 21:38

I genuinely don't know if I am or not, this is a genuine question as I thankfully haven't got any experience in having a child with serious allergies. I am, of course, happy to do what I can to prevent a reaction.

There is a child in my DDs class who is allergic to a list of things so we aren't allowed them in pack lunches. That's fine, I have no issue as I know kids can be careless and gross about their food hygiene. My issue is with the nuts, literally anything that says "may contain nuts" or "may contain traces of peanuts" is not allowed... if the occasional time I don't realise and send something (These are not nut flavoured things or anything with nuts in the ingredients, but I assume are just made in the same factory as nuts.) it is sent home unwrapped and she hasn't been allowed to eat it.

But is it really possible that an allergy can be so served that something that may contain nuts could cause a reaction if opened in the same room.

Many thanks!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Youdoyoubabe · 17/04/2023 23:40

It is possible for an allergy to be so serious. Almost everything says 'May contain nut traces' or something like that on it though.

We had this at our school for years and years. Eventually the kid did eat a peanut butter cookie by mistake when he was about 16 and did not react. After testing it transpired that he had grown out of the allergy. The mum was always super careful though. I would be too.

Remember that girl on the plane who ate sesame seeds (or something) and died. It was only a few years ago. Had bought it at pret I believe.

LuckyPeonies · 17/04/2023 23:40

If I was the parent of a severely allergic child, I would likely want to home-school them instead of worrying about the possibility of exposure every day. How do children and adults who have these allergies function in society ? One could be exposed on public transportation, stores/businesses, malls, restaurants, cinemas, employers, and on and on.

SweetSakura · 17/04/2023 23:40

I agree with you op. Unless the school has had this advice from the child's doctor direct (in some very rare instances people are that allergic)

My children both have multiple severe allergies and have had anaphylaxis several times.

But their allergies aren't to nuts (well, they do have nut allergies too). No school is doing to ban milk products, for instance, so we send them in every day knowing they will be surrounded by their allergens and by children who have just eaten their allergens..

School still ring me every time a child brings in a peanut butter sandwich by mistake. But they didn't bother to ring me when I a child threw a whole slice of cheese at my son Hmm

Tradescantia252 · 17/04/2023 23:35

DingsBum · 17/04/2023 21:43

Does that mean no home made food at all, unless you have a nut free kitchen?

Unfortunately I think that's unworkable.

And before I get jumped on, I say this as someone who wouldn't dream of sending actual nuts or anything that contained nuts! But "may contain traces" applies to anything that comes out of my nut-using domestic kitchen so I literally can't do that.

This ^

Myotherusernamewastakenagain · 17/04/2023 23:34

maddening · 17/04/2023 23:11

When it is kids involved it is safer to remove the allergen if possible- eg the boy that died at school when classmates threw cheese at him as a joke - kids can be dicks and generally have lower inhibitions and understanding of risk, it is not worth risking this child's life and this allergy can be easily accommodated.

I doubt little Timmy is going to have an anaphylactic reaction to Johnny throwing a biscuit at him that may contain nuts. It's such an overreaction.

triballeader · 17/04/2023 23:30

IgE allergies really can be that bad. Youngest DS at he age of seven weeks ended up in A&E simply because I had sat near someone eating a cream cake. That was not fun. One of his friends through the hospital clinic had such a severe reaction to peanuts being in the same room that the school had a blanket ban on them. [As in the air ambulance had to be called as child would crash and each time it happened aid child ended in PICU]
IF it’s similarly severe then the school are doing what they can to minimise risks.

Myotherusernamewastakenagain · 17/04/2023 23:29

Thisiscrazyshite · 17/04/2023 23:01

Kids share foods all the time regardless of rules in the classroom. That’s one of the problems.

Then the parents of the child with the allergy need to step up their game and not push for this rule. My child knows not to share food for this very reason and it's been drummed into him for years.

Gimmethemoney · 17/04/2023 23:29

there are many brands on the market that I no longer eat because they contain peanut traces. This includes all m and s chocolates and most of their biscuits for example. So I take the “may contain” very seriously until I’ve had a little test bite without issue.

YeahOkWhatever · 17/04/2023 23:28

My kid's school is nut free. Think there is maybe one kid with a severe allergy. No issue making sure things are nut free, dont think we're on 'may contain' as far as Im aware. Allergic reactions can vary/worsen over time, often nut so it makes sense for the school just to be blanket.
My kid is allergic to egg, not as severely now and will hopefully grow out of it (on the 'egg ladder') but all other parents are very contentious on play dates, parties etc, probably more so that us! I suppose if the reaction is severe you'd want to be reassured as parent that all possible steps had been taken to ensure your child's safety....

SD1978 · 17/04/2023 23:28

No to contains nut products, ok, but may contain traces means it's made in a factory within also makes nut products and it's a disclaimer. I think it's utterly OTT including those products. I highly doubt the parents never, ever take them to a restarting or a food court, which may also contain traces of nuts.

Avocadoandcheese · 17/04/2023 23:26

We give our son (who is severely allergic to peanuts) food that says it may contain nuts. His diet would be incredibly limited otherwise. Some foods more specifically state that they may contain peanuts, so we don’t give him those.

I wrestle with my emotions on the matter and do worry that it’s careless. We always have epipens to hand (also in school) but I would never forgive myself if something happened.

Bellavida99 · 17/04/2023 23:25

Unwrap them and put them in a tub - problem solved! It’s unworkable if you’re allowed to take homemade cake and sandwiches made in a kitchen with a jar of peanut butter and a bag of nuts in it at home.

FrazzledMCPremenopausalWoman · 17/04/2023 23:22

I was taught it could take 1/44,000 of a peanut to kill someone with a particularly severe allergy to peanut protein.
To be honest if my child was severely allergic I'd probably want to bring them home to eat lunch, to keep any risks to a minimum.

KnittingNeedles · 17/04/2023 23:21

All the people who say it's not a big ask have clearly never shopped for a party or something for a child who can't have "may contain traces of" items.

Nearly all biscuits, cereal, crisps have the warning. But also random things like pizza, chicken nuggets, frozen chips. It's a nightmare.

SlippySarah · 17/04/2023 23:19

JenniferBarkley · 17/04/2023 23:03

Much more practical, and much safer, to police the allergic child's behaviour in this sense than to check allergen labelling on every product brought into the classroom.

Yes. I'm on a few allergy fb groups (DD is coeliac) and as schools differ vastly in how well they deal with children with allergies or food restrictions the consensus generally is that the child needs to learn how to keep themselves safe as early as possible because schools can not generally be trusted to do it properly. My DD has been reading and checking ingredients on food labels since she was 7. She never shares food, she washes her hands much more than an average child, she alerts adults in school to issues that could lead to her being glutened. In the case of the OP the school have implemented an unworkable policy due to lack of knowledge and understanding.

Alainlechat · 17/04/2023 23:19

My DDs have nut allergies but eat items that are marked as may contain traces of nuts.

Their primary school had a no nut policy in place but did not restrict items to that extent.

MrsAvocet · 17/04/2023 23:19

My DS has potentially life threatening allergies to a number of things including nuts and peanuts and we have never adopted this kind of approach. As others have said it's not what any of the major allergy organisations advocate and I will be absolutely stunned if a health care professional with expertise in the field has suggested it. It's completely unsustainable and potentially adds risk rather than reduces it.
Yes, airborne allergic reactions are a real thing, though I was recently reading an article suggesting they are less common than previously thought and some reactions that are thought to be airborne are probably touch/accidental ingestion. For example, reactions on planes are actually more likely to be due to contamination of the tray table or seat from previous nut eating passengers than somebody opening a packet during the flight. But you cannot avoid this kind of thing completely. If you ever use public transport, eat in a restaurant, stay in a hotel, go in a shop or even go to the park there is a risk, and you have to learn to live with that.
The likelihood of someone being so sensitive that they would react to airborne contaminants from something labelled "may contain" is incredibly small. I'm not saying it's impossible, there maybe some people who are that unfortunate, but if they are, then they will be reacting all over the place - there are a vast number of ways you would be exposed to a bigger dose of allergens in evety day life than someone eating a "may contain" item in the same room as you.
Of course people with allergies need to be careful but this is a totally illogical and at best pointless policy. At worst it could be actively harmful. Children with allergies need to learn to understand and manage their risk afrom as young an age as possible, but they need to understand the real risks.* *

PickoftheMix · 17/04/2023 23:16

JenniferBarkley · 17/04/2023 23:13

In fairness to the school, if the allergy is so severe that the whole class has to avoid the allergen (and I'm suspicious, but anyway), I wouldn't be trusting everyone to grasp "peanuts are fine but not tree nuts" or "hazelnuts ok in small amounts but cashews very dangerous and pecans lethal" or whatever.

That's true. In a world where some people but eggs in the dairy category I don't suppose they'd realise peanuts are nuts are two different allergens.

Takeachance18 · 17/04/2023 23:16

ooherrmissus14 · 17/04/2023 22:14

Try and see this from a different perspective. Can you imagine how it feels for the parents of this child knowing that, at any time, they could have such a severe allergic reaction that their child might die? They have to live with this all the time and I can't imagine how stressful that might be. So whilst it's an inconvenience to you, it could be a matter of life and death for their child. I know this sounds extreme but it was only through working with a child who had severe allergies that I really understood how serious it is

The problem is any household which has nuts in it is more likely to send in home made sandwiches which may contain nuts than any product from a factory. Reason, if the process is likely to contain nuts it should be labelled as such, because may contain is not sufficient and isn't legally defined - it is company risk assessment.

If the parents think they are protecting their child they are not, because the shop bought cake which says may contain nuts will likely be manufactured in premises, which are cleaned down in between different products to a high standard and products used, likely stored separately so as to not cross contaminate. Compared to a domestic kitchen, with ingredients stored in the same cupboard, likely handle packaging of products containing nuts to get the products out, mixed in bowls and cooked in dishes that have cooked nut products, stored in cupboards with nut products (my mixing spoons are stored in my cupboard with baking ingredients and foods such as nutella/ peanut butter), put in containers that contain or stored next to nut products. Parents also making packed lunches in a morning may have someone pouring crunchy nut cornflakes nearby, children packing lunchbox whilst eating toast covered in nutella.

It is false security. More allergic reactions happen in "nut free schools" than those without bans. If this has gone on for 6 years, what happens in 18 months when they go to secondary- they will not be policing lunch boxes and school dinners may even contain nuts.

CherryCokeFanatic · 17/04/2023 23:15

Remove things from the packaging and send it in that way.

JenniferBarkley · 17/04/2023 23:13

PickoftheMix · 17/04/2023 23:11

Is the allergy nuts or peanuts do you know OP? Or both?

In fairness to the school, if the allergy is so severe that the whole class has to avoid the allergen (and I'm suspicious, but anyway), I wouldn't be trusting everyone to grasp "peanuts are fine but not tree nuts" or "hazelnuts ok in small amounts but cashews very dangerous and pecans lethal" or whatever.

PickoftheMix · 17/04/2023 23:11

Is the allergy nuts or peanuts do you know OP? Or both?

maddening · 17/04/2023 23:11

Myotherusernamewastakenagain · 17/04/2023 22:54

As long as they don't share the food it isn't a real risk.

When it is kids involved it is safer to remove the allergen if possible- eg the boy that died at school when classmates threw cheese at him as a joke - kids can be dicks and generally have lower inhibitions and understanding of risk, it is not worth risking this child's life and this allergy can be easily accommodated.

Fozzleyplum · 17/04/2023 23:11

My child has a severe tree nut allergy and I am of the view that banning "may contain traces" foods is unnecessary, as numerous other posters have explained.

flowagurl · 17/04/2023 23:10

@Lovethetub oh yeah crunchy nut cornflakes are so popular, it just seems like a losing battle go half the class are having peanut butter on toast/ crunchy nut cornflakes etc surely?

I guess at least they’re doing what they can inside the school hours/ environment

Swipe left for the next trending thread