Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think allergy mum is OTT

239 replies

Boogiewoogieanddance · 17/04/2023 21:38

I genuinely don't know if I am or not, this is a genuine question as I thankfully haven't got any experience in having a child with serious allergies. I am, of course, happy to do what I can to prevent a reaction.

There is a child in my DDs class who is allergic to a list of things so we aren't allowed them in pack lunches. That's fine, I have no issue as I know kids can be careless and gross about their food hygiene. My issue is with the nuts, literally anything that says "may contain nuts" or "may contain traces of peanuts" is not allowed... if the occasional time I don't realise and send something (These are not nut flavoured things or anything with nuts in the ingredients, but I assume are just made in the same factory as nuts.) it is sent home unwrapped and she hasn't been allowed to eat it.

But is it really possible that an allergy can be so served that something that may contain nuts could cause a reaction if opened in the same room.

Many thanks!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
bossonext · 18/04/2023 09:03

QueenCamilla · 18/04/2023 09:02

Or in your view - should I stop eating all bakery products?

I'm literally NOT interested in carrying the mental load of stranger's illnesses.I have my own shit to deal with & a nut allergic child.
There are reasonable adaptations and those crossing the line. This crosses the line.

Whereas someone staying in hospital their whole life is totally reasonable, right?

QueenCamilla · 18/04/2023 09:02

bossonext · 18/04/2023 08:28

So people with a serious bread allergy should spend their entire lives in hospital and never be allowed to leave?

Or in your view - should I stop eating all bakery products?

I'm literally NOT interested in carrying the mental load of stranger's illnesses.I have my own shit to deal with & a nut allergic child.
There are reasonable adaptations and those crossing the line. This crosses the line.

SweetSakura · 18/04/2023 08:58

*That said, there are also many kids with sensory issues at school who will only eat a very limited amount of things, what's supposed to happen if those things have 'may contain nuts' on the label.

It's a very tough one to try and balance the needs of everyone.*

I agree. I have two children with multiple severe allergies (all of which, with the exception of nuts, children are freely allowed to bring into school), and two with sensory issues around food as a result of autism meaning their diet is very limited.

I think banning "may contain nuts" products is unfair for so many reasons. It's hypocritical when there will be cheese and egg and soya and wheat (etc) all over the lunch room, yet these can all cause Anaphylaxis too. And it's unfair because it imposes so much restriction on children without thinking what their needs are.

Plus it's meaningless because as everyone has said, do you ban home made food? Do you ban children eating nuts at breakfast? So it creates a false sense of security

PassMeTheRedbull · 18/04/2023 08:52

DanceToTheMusicInMyHead · 17/04/2023 21:53

I have a severe nut allergy (including airborne) and eat stuff that may contain traces of nuts...the risk is really small that the item will contain nuts, it is likely arse covering and it isn't feasible to live in a sterile, nut-free environment. It is a risk I take as an adult - if it was my child I may judge differently.

Personally I think a may contain ban in these circumstances is daft- child is more likely to react to the kid sitting next to them who had peanut butter at home for breakfast. The likelihood of a may contain item containing nuts is low enough, and then the child reacting is even lower. But that is my risk assessment and others will assess it differently

I am exactly the same, have anaphylaxis/airborne etc, when I was younger I never ate anything with may contain, my mum and dad always drilled it into me to read every label, I remember years ago aldis own brand ketchup had may contain nuts!, as I've gotten older it's a risk I now take and eat things with may contain, as you said it's company's covering there arse/laziness on there part most of the time.

toastofthetown · 18/04/2023 08:48

May contain nuts, Not suitable for nut allergy sufferers, May contain traces of nuts, May also contain nuts, Produced in a factory which handles nuts and all other alibi labelling statements aren’t legally defined. In products from the same line, M&S might say ‘not suitable for someone with a nut allergy’ and Tesco might say ‘May contain traces of nuts’ but the risk is the same. It’s just depends on how the brand owner wants to phrase it, rather than each phrase having subtle differences in meaning. I wouldn’t read too much into the phrasing of allergen alibi labelling.

ItsThePlayBusDingDing · 18/04/2023 08:40

Boogiewoogieanddance · 17/04/2023 21:53

I do take it seriously, unopened snacks have been sent home very few times in the last 6 years and this is because I've just not looked at the ingredients clearly enough and there is no suggestion on the type of snack I've bought that there would be nuts in it. It's difficult to get into the hang of reading the ingredients so carefully when the allergy isn't in your home and to take it into account if your in a rush throwing lunch together.

Also alot of super market own brand has the warning on it so I end up having to buy more expensive snacks to accommodate.

I literally couldn't afford to buy expensive brands of anything.

Our school is so picky with what they allow anyway due to all the healthy eating stuff, I've found a good compromise with supermarket brand things, if they were to then say that I couldn't send that in due to the 'may contain nuts' I don't know what I would do.

If there's an allergy that severe then the school should be providing that class snack imo.

That said, there are also many kids with sensory issues at school who will only eat a very limited amount of things, what's supposed to happen if those things have 'may contain nuts' on the label.

It's a very tough one to try and balance the needs of everyone.

KnittingNeedles · 18/04/2023 08:40

Was going to add this! M&S have changed 'May contain' to 'not suitable for nut allergy sufferers' on almost every item. We take a cautious approach and has been fine so far. We risk 'may contain' but M&S make me feel like a bad parent!

But in this case it's not about the person who actually has the allergy, it's about school asking everyone else to avoid the items with a warning too. But are fine with them having peanut butter for breakfast.

I'm increasingly coming round to the point of view that this is the wrong way to be handling allergies. Rather than just banning stuff, coming up with some sort of way of getting through to kids why they shouldn't share foods, must wash their hands, zero tolerance on throwing food etc etc.

bossonext · 18/04/2023 08:28

QueenCamilla · 18/04/2023 00:21

That's crazy and the school are very unreasonable to impose this. Not to send in nuts and nut products - fair. This, however, is OTT and I'm a parent of a nut allergic child.

If one can't share a space with someone eating bread for example, they should be isolated in the hospital as a life-saving measure.

Not only was I killing grannies during Covid, now I'm killing kids by making a packed lunch for my own. Oat and raisin cookie!! 😱

People suck.

So people with a serious bread allergy should spend their entire lives in hospital and never be allowed to leave?

RausageSoul · 18/04/2023 08:22

Bringonsummer19 · 17/04/2023 22:56

Child with a nut allergy here. That is insane. Nut free yes, eg a big no to Nutella, M&M peanuts. but the ‘may contain traces’ is not doable, firms like marks and Spencer’s have just updated their ingredients list to say this (lazy fu*kers).

Was going to add this! M&S have changed 'May contain' to 'not suitable for nut allergy sufferers' on almost every item. We take a cautious approach and has been fine so far. We risk 'may contain' but M&S make me feel like a bad parent!

JenniferBarkley · 18/04/2023 08:18

SweetSakura · 18/04/2023 08:01

I agree. It gives a false sense of security.

Also, i'm interested why those in favour of banning even may contain nuts won't engage with my posts pointing out that many children are severely allergic to things like milk, yet no school is going to ban products that *actually " contain milk (despite the tragic death of Karanbir Cheema)

Why the hypocrisy?

As the parent of a child with a nut allergy this double standard drives me insane. I'm on a few allergy groups and some parents really do have completely unrealistic expectations. Occasionally I've pointed out that they probably think nothing of giving their kid an ice-cream in a public place but I genuinely don't think they see it.

BogRollBOGOF · 18/04/2023 08:06

Banning products actively containing nuts is fairly managable in a school, although there will be slip-ups, so it can't be guaranteed.

Banning "may contain nuts" is totally disproportionate on risk vs practicality. I could send in a "nut free" product, only for the outer packaging to be contaminated by being stored in the same cupboard as my pistachios. With younger children, they could easily go in contaminated by their breakfasts with traces still present on their hands/ faces/ clothes. School age children often go to clubs with others who won't know of the allergy because there's no food on-site so could be exposed that way.

"May contain" is an arse-covering disclaimer that serves to eliminate the chance of a food producer being sued rather than the actual indication of risk.

DS had multiple food allergies, and the first time he ate a product containing cows milk, his face swelled like Harry Potter and a stinging jinx. It was a couple of days before he could open his eyes again. I remember going to a toddler group where some idiot was letting her toddler roam around shedding great clumps of cake all over the floor and toys and watching DS hawk-like to make sure he didn't pick any up and and tripple-contaminate himself with a full house of allergens. I know the fear of young children and common allergens well (and the fear that it could be worse next time) but you can not restrict the community down to "may contain" level, and often it's unfeasable for people with the allergies to restrict themselves that heavily too because so much food is labelled this way.

SweetSakura · 18/04/2023 08:01

MILLYmo0se · 18/04/2023 07:47

So explain the logic of the schools point 'we will not allow you to bring in items made in a commercial premises labelled' may contain nuts' BUT we arent going to tell you please dont give your child peanut butter or crunchy nut cornflakes for breakfast'??????
Logically the child having consumed nuts that morning IS a risk to a child with an airborne allergy but its not being asked of parents, and this policy goes against usual medical advice, so please explain it to me, I am clearly as stupid as the OP

I agree. It gives a false sense of security.

Also, i'm interested why those in favour of banning even may contain nuts won't engage with my posts pointing out that many children are severely allergic to things like milk, yet no school is going to ban products that *actually " contain milk (despite the tragic death of Karanbir Cheema)

Why the hypocrisy?

Baabaa75 · 18/04/2023 07:49

Yes it is, if your child was at risk of dying every time they left the house you'd be OTT too hon

MILLYmo0se · 18/04/2023 07:47

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 18/04/2023 02:46

Are you stupid?

Allergic reactions to nuts etc can kill people. Within minutes.

So explain the logic of the schools point 'we will not allow you to bring in items made in a commercial premises labelled' may contain nuts' BUT we arent going to tell you please dont give your child peanut butter or crunchy nut cornflakes for breakfast'??????
Logically the child having consumed nuts that morning IS a risk to a child with an airborne allergy but its not being asked of parents, and this policy goes against usual medical advice, so please explain it to me, I am clearly as stupid as the OP

weightymatters73 · 18/04/2023 07:42

It's a massive problem "putting it on other parents" as many people have no idea about nut (or other) allergies....

Particularly home made food, where people make "nut free" cakes but have nuts in their kitchen.

dancinfeet · 18/04/2023 07:17

@marseille Just to add about the air borne allergies- my DD can’t get even through the door of the M and M shop in Covent Garden- as soon as she gets a few metres from the door she starts to wheeze, throat feel tight and tongue starts to tingle. Not that she is missing out much by not going in there (!), but when we visited London when she was a younger teenager she really wanted to go inside- which she couldn’t.

dancinfeet · 18/04/2023 07:11

@marseille please don’t minimise air borne allergies (or ‘so called airborne allergies’ as you have called them). My DD had an allergic reaction on a train when someone sat on the other table across the aisle and cracked open a a snickers bar. That was 18 years ago and also how I first found out her allergy could also be air borne. We moved seats into another carriage as soon as I realised, and dealt with it with anti histamine- luckily we managed to stop it going to full blown anaphylaxis that time. We have had some close calls and terrifying moments whilst she was growing up, and now even as an adult she occasionally has a reaction after coming into contact with nuts.
I feel like getting my daughter through to adulthood and able to live with and cope with her allergies has been one of my biggest achievements knowing that she lives with what is essentially a time bomb. She is now in her early 20s and lives at the other end of the country, but I will
spend my life always with the worry that the next phone call could be that she is in hospital after a bad reaction, or worse. Please don’t minimise this. (though I stand by what I said in my previous comment, that the school’s stance in the OP is ridiculous and that May Contain items should be allowed in other children’s lunch boxes).

PickoftheMix · 18/04/2023 07:09

marseille · 18/04/2023 03:23

I wonder with these supposed air-borne allergies how people have made it to school age . Realistically , if they have ever been on a train or walked through a shopping centre , been to a cafe or a restaurant or the cinema then someone around them has been eating peanuts or nuts somewhere nearby. If they've survived until school age then they really can't be killed by air-borne allergens. Surely that makes sense.

I suffer from non-food air born allergies and have to take a precautionary antihistamine each day. I don't always like to as I'm afraid my body will become too used to it and not work if that makes sense. But my allergy can be "just" a swelling of the eye to more serious symptoms, but not always the same. It depends on the threshold dose at the time.

Some allergies can start with needing lots of exposure to overtime the threshold dose being less to trigger a reaction and vice verser.

Badleg85 · 18/04/2023 07:08

My dds school are quite strict on this. It's quite frustrating but I've gotten used to checking the packaging of most things. I do tend to get one phone call a week where something has been taken off DD while they check with me

I do worry though because my dds won't eat the school dinners (and I don't blame them!) And I can't afford to buy everything individually wrapped. I prepare all the fruit and veg on a clean chopping board but we are generally a very "nutty" house.

I wish companies would do some to tackle this and lower the risk.

Albiboba · 18/04/2023 06:36

marseille · 18/04/2023 03:23

I wonder with these supposed air-borne allergies how people have made it to school age . Realistically , if they have ever been on a train or walked through a shopping centre , been to a cafe or a restaurant or the cinema then someone around them has been eating peanuts or nuts somewhere nearby. If they've survived until school age then they really can't be killed by air-borne allergens. Surely that makes sense.

This is the most ridiculous comment yet. There’s every chance the child has come into contact with nuts at least once or they wouldn’t have the diagnosis. Have you ever witnessed anyone, particularly a young child going into anaphylactic shock? It’s truly traumatising.

The school are making a decision which protects the child with the allergy, the teachers and the other pupils. The teachers don’t want to be administering medication and calling an ambulance because someone didn’t think it was really that serious so didn’t care if something ‘may contain nuts’.

Your argument that they can’t have an airborne allergy because they are still alive at 5 years old is literally the height of stupidity.

adomizo · 18/04/2023 06:35

As a teacher and a child with a nut allergy it is not possible to ensure all food in the classroom does not contain nuts. There needs to be better management of this child's condition in the class and of the lunchtime environment.

Bagwyllydiart · 18/04/2023 06:30

LuckyPeonies · 17/04/2023 23:40

If I was the parent of a severely allergic child, I would likely want to home-school them instead of worrying about the possibility of exposure every day. How do children and adults who have these allergies function in society ? One could be exposed on public transportation, stores/businesses, malls, restaurants, cinemas, employers, and on and on.

This is responsible parenting

Srin · 18/04/2023 06:20

I do know parents who give their nut allergy children ‘may contain nuts’ products but the severity of nut allergies vary enormously. I don’t know how people cope with this severity of nut allergy. You wouldn’t be able to use public transport, fly, go to a cafe or go to any public place without feeling anxious about the risk. It must be a total nightmare.

MayThe4th · 18/04/2023 04:46

It’s a cop-out from the school to prevent them having to actually take responsibility for the nut allergic child. Banning of nut products goes against everything that Anaphylaxis UK advises, because it causes complacency. Children never learn to manage their allergies at primary level which means they grow up never feeling they have to. More children suffer anaphylactic reactions at secondary because of this.

Added to which, nuts are an easy food to ban because a lot of people just wouldn’t necessarily think to give them to their child. Yet there are children with such severe allergies to dairy products, and the school would never be able to justify a similar ban on dairy products.

It is pure virtual signalling on the part of the school to make their “may contain traces of nuts” stipulation, because it’s all about the label, and assuming that food is all going to be shop-bought, when actually more kitchens contain traces of nuts than factories.

I would be making a formal complaint to the head and to the governors.

hystericaluterus · 18/04/2023 04:33

My dd has a severe nut allergy (though not airborne) and I think that this is totally bonkers. I very much take the view of @Simd1 and @DanceToTheMusicInMyHead Though I do not feed my children peanuts for breakfast before attending events with a little boy who has a peanut allergy. And in general, I have taught my children to wash their hands and face after eating to minimise risk to others. We never know what people could be allergic to. A colleague of mine is severely allergic to pumpkin.