Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think allergy mum is OTT

239 replies

Boogiewoogieanddance · 17/04/2023 21:38

I genuinely don't know if I am or not, this is a genuine question as I thankfully haven't got any experience in having a child with serious allergies. I am, of course, happy to do what I can to prevent a reaction.

There is a child in my DDs class who is allergic to a list of things so we aren't allowed them in pack lunches. That's fine, I have no issue as I know kids can be careless and gross about their food hygiene. My issue is with the nuts, literally anything that says "may contain nuts" or "may contain traces of peanuts" is not allowed... if the occasional time I don't realise and send something (These are not nut flavoured things or anything with nuts in the ingredients, but I assume are just made in the same factory as nuts.) it is sent home unwrapped and she hasn't been allowed to eat it.

But is it really possible that an allergy can be so served that something that may contain nuts could cause a reaction if opened in the same room.

Many thanks!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
ZZTopGuitarSolo · 30/04/2023 15:28

ZombieMumEB · 30/04/2023 01:36

Is it really the mum that is is OTT here, OP?

Surely it's the school, and the child's specialist who worked towards having this ban in place?

Also - is there no dad in the picture? Let's just blame the mum, like society tends to do.

One of my kids went to school with a few kids in their school level, who were highly anaphylactic to nuts. Both parents worked with their child's specialist and the school to ensure the school environment didn't kill their child.

I saw what the mums went through with the fear of sending their child to school, not knowing if they'd survive the day due to their severe allergies. Just be thankful OP that you don't have to deal with that - you have the easier task.

I doubt very much a specialist who would recommend the sort of plan the OP describes. It's not within any allergy guidelines issued by specialist organisations.

It sounds like the school and the parents have just come up with a somewhat uninformed and panicky plan that doesn't follow any best practices.

I am one of those parents with a child who has had anaphylactic reactions to nuts, and I'm thankful that the schools my daughter went to actually followed best practices rather than imposing uninformed blanket rules that didn't actually help such as in the OP's situation.

But I do agree that it's sad that once again the mum is being vilified, and the dad is not mentioned.

Sennelier1 · 30/04/2023 09:13

Personnally I think that "may contain traces of ...." should be safe enough if the allergic child does not eat nor touches it. But! As a mother ánd a grandmother me too I would try and exclude as many possible risk factors as possible. So yes, I would go with it and try my best to do as asked. It may demand rethinking foodshopping and making packed lunches, but ... oh well.....#mothersformothers

ZombieMumEB · 30/04/2023 01:36

Is it really the mum that is is OTT here, OP?

Surely it's the school, and the child's specialist who worked towards having this ban in place?

Also - is there no dad in the picture? Let's just blame the mum, like society tends to do.

One of my kids went to school with a few kids in their school level, who were highly anaphylactic to nuts. Both parents worked with their child's specialist and the school to ensure the school environment didn't kill their child.

I saw what the mums went through with the fear of sending their child to school, not knowing if they'd survive the day due to their severe allergies. Just be thankful OP that you don't have to deal with that - you have the easier task.

Cakeorchocolate · 30/04/2023 01:15

LysHastighed · 18/04/2023 14:04

If only the people who had fully read and understood the question were allowed to answer the poll might look a bit different, though. People are responding as if the OP is asking about products containing peanuts when she is in fact asking about products that do not contain peanuts (but were made in the same place as products that do).

I did fully read and understand that. Strange of you to assume most responding to the poll didn't.

TeenageAllergyzlife · 20/04/2023 01:25

Scottsy200 · 19/04/2023 22:03

But don’t they cover themselves with a lot of things these days by putting “may contain traces of nuts” on loads of stuff 🤷🏼‍♀️

One hundred percent, the “May Contain” labels are more convenient to the food industries than to the consumers and personally I think that they are used to cover themselves. In America, the Food Allergen labelling and consumer protection Act doesn’t require those statements, because they can be confusing and in fact don’t tell you the actual risk, “May Contain” means it may or it may not, which could make people avoid food for no reason at all. I follow the American Allergy Developments and Organisations because they seemed to be years ahead of the UK ones, I do find great practical advice there.

Scottsy200 · 19/04/2023 22:03

But don’t they cover themselves with a lot of things these days by putting “may contain traces of nuts” on loads of stuff 🤷🏼‍♀️

bossonext · 19/04/2023 13:24

QueenCamilla · 18/04/2023 00:21

That's crazy and the school are very unreasonable to impose this. Not to send in nuts and nut products - fair. This, however, is OTT and I'm a parent of a nut allergic child.

If one can't share a space with someone eating bread for example, they should be isolated in the hospital as a life-saving measure.

Not only was I killing grannies during Covid, now I'm killing kids by making a packed lunch for my own. Oat and raisin cookie!! 😱

People suck.

I doubt that you actually have a child with allergies if you think people with severe allergies should be imprisoned in hospital for life?

Allergies suck. And people like you who belittle and insult people who have them also suck.

TeenageAllergyzlife · 19/04/2023 12:16

Precautionary Allergen Labels (PALs) such as “May Contain” are voluntary, so there are many, many products in the market which are “May Contain” or at risk of cross contamination that don’t have that label. Anything produced in a kitchen that handles an allergen is also “May Contain” because the possibility of cross contamination exist. Therefore assume anything produced in a school kitchen is a “May Contain” product, unless that kitchen is free from that allergen. The policy of banning products cannot be applied to all allergens, my son is allergic to dairy (anaphylaxis) but imagining requesting a ban on all dairy products, it is not possible. Anybody who wants to understand food labelling (essential for families who live with allergies) should take the free and very useful online training in Food allergies and Intolerances from the Food Standards Agency (took me 4 hours spread over days). The only products that can guarantee to be free from an allergen are the ones labelled “Free From” the rest are not.

Socialdistancechampion · 19/04/2023 09:52

It is possible however I do question how the child functions outside of school. Can they walk round a supermarket or go to a restaurant? If they can do either of those then I would say the restrictions are silly.

mummyoffourminimes · 19/04/2023 09:50

Ban on nuts totally should be in place. Ban on 'may contain traces' is crackers, the certified nut free products are so expensive, if every family in the school needs to buy those then maybe the school should be centrally catering instead? As others have said home kitchens aren't certified but free and most children aren't. Should the child not be playing with children who've parents have nuts at home?

It's a minefield. Poor child and mum though, this must be so stressful for them.

EarringsandLipstick · 19/04/2023 07:45

@moomoomoo27

Of course it's not a relevant example! It's utterly unrelated to the OP's point - you didn't read it properly.

You were on a flight and requested not to eat a nut product due to a passenger with a nut allergy. So you didn't eat your Snickers (containing nuts).

The OP is talking about a ban on products that don't contain nuts, but are made in factories where there were nut products. It's not remotely comparable.

You need to read a bit more carefully.

gogohmm · 18/04/2023 21:20

That seems unmanageable - what do they do about families who scratch cook? My children had homemade granola bars or wholemeal veg muffins in their lunches, nut free (ish, our kitchen isn't but free) but no labels. I make my own bread too. My eldest is autistic and nuts are one of the things she always ate!

flowagurl · 18/04/2023 21:14

Is banning nuts not increasing allergies for others though? Like if your nursery banned nuts and then your school did would that increase the likelihood children would be allergic as a lot of the children would have never have really ever had exposure?

nationallampoons · 18/04/2023 21:01

My daughter is allergic to nuts and the school had procedures in place to keep her safe.
Obviously nuts shouldn't be allowed in schools but banning may contain is daft

Myotherusernamewastakenagain · 18/04/2023 20:57

Cakeorchocolate · 18/04/2023 13:55

Yes the allergies really can be that severe.

The poll has a majority for YABU so it doesn't seem like you are backed in this by the majority of posters as your most recent post states.

The posts from people that live with allergies daily, either their own or their families are overwhelming saying that the op is NBU. There's next to none that say the OP is BU. It says more about the general users on this forum than it does about the subject.

Blueroses99 · 18/04/2023 19:00

moomoomoo27 · 18/04/2023 18:46

No because it was very clearly part of the instruction we were given that those were included too.

But if unclear, the safest thing is to operate from a worst outcome scenario. If the worst outcome in a situation is that someone is seriously ill or dies, do everything possible to avoid it being possible even if the chance is minute.

If people were told to avoid anything that ‘may contain’ nuts, then I can see that your example is comparable to the OP.

However it is not failsafe as manufacturers do not need to put a ‘may contains’ warning on a label. Two products could be manufactured in the same factory, one brand decide to put a warning on, the other doesn’t. Both are equally safe or unsafe to the person with the allergy.

Doone21 · 18/04/2023 18:53

Yes, the May contain thing is just annoying but it is sadly true.

moomoomoo27 · 18/04/2023 18:46

Blueroses99 · 18/04/2023 18:03

But what if you’d had a different chocolate bar that didn’t contain nuts but had a ‘may contain’ warning? Would you have still have opened that? Because that’s the actual comparison here, no one is disputing that actual nut products are harmful - should it extend to products that may or may not have come into contact with the allergen?

No because it was very clearly part of the instruction we were given that those were included too.

But if unclear, the safest thing is to operate from a worst outcome scenario. If the worst outcome in a situation is that someone is seriously ill or dies, do everything possible to avoid it being possible even if the chance is minute.

Blueroses99 · 18/04/2023 18:03

moomoomoo27 · 18/04/2023 17:22

Because the question is, are nut allergies really that severe, and the example confirms that. It's not just hysterical parents being dramatic about their beloved DC, or an opinion-based matter, or a school/nursery thing.

Really surprised I had to explain a link so obvious, but mumsnet I guess.

But what if you’d had a different chocolate bar that didn’t contain nuts but had a ‘may contain’ warning? Would you have still have opened that? Because that’s the actual comparison here, no one is disputing that actual nut products are harmful - should it extend to products that may or may not have come into contact with the allergen?

moomoomoo27 · 18/04/2023 17:22

EarringsandLipstick · 17/04/2023 23:05

🙄

This is relevant to the OP how?

Because the question is, are nut allergies really that severe, and the example confirms that. It's not just hysterical parents being dramatic about their beloved DC, or an opinion-based matter, or a school/nursery thing.

Really surprised I had to explain a link so obvious, but mumsnet I guess.

Pestispeeved · 18/04/2023 15:43

Dr Natasha Campbell-McBride is not a registered doctor in the UK she is a nutritionist like Gillian McKeith
Up to 80% of children with allergies grow out of them, please exercise extreme caution with anyone who claims to cure allergies or autism.

Dontsweatit · 18/04/2023 14:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LysHastighed · 18/04/2023 14:04

Cakeorchocolate · 18/04/2023 13:55

Yes the allergies really can be that severe.

The poll has a majority for YABU so it doesn't seem like you are backed in this by the majority of posters as your most recent post states.

If only the people who had fully read and understood the question were allowed to answer the poll might look a bit different, though. People are responding as if the OP is asking about products containing peanuts when she is in fact asking about products that do not contain peanuts (but were made in the same place as products that do).

LysHastighed · 18/04/2023 13:56

northernbeee · 18/04/2023 13:39

But is it really possible that an allergy can be so served that something that may contain nuts could cause a reaction if opened in the same room.

Yes! it is really possible for an allergy to be THAT severe. I don't have any allergies in my family but i'm a grown adult therefore know that some people can have a reaction if a packet is merely opened near them. Your child may eat their biscuit or whatever then go touch the child with the allergy - that could trigger a reaction. In this day and age its not really that hard to check your snacks.

That’s about packet of the actual food to which the person is allergic, though. This post isn’t about that. It’s about products made near other products containing the actual food to which the person is allergic having the potential to cause airborne allergies or not.