Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people torment themselves over school places

259 replies

Schoolplacechoicemyth · 17/04/2023 19:36

Im in a local toddler/child social media group.

Every single year there are people on the group who apply wildly optimistically for 2 or 3 oversubscribed schools several miles away from their home, are given the unpopular school they live near and desperately ask how to appeal because they "really love oversubcribed school and absolutely want DC to go there".

They seem completely unprepared for how unlikely it was they'd get a place, baffled that their preference doesn't actually get them the place at the oversubscribed chool, spend weeks/months appealing for schools they have next to no chance of a space at, & complain repeatedly on the group about it. Often the school they live near is fine, its just not the fashionable choice this week.

The local council publish all the info. You can see, easily, how close you need to live to stand a decent chance at a place. All the admission criteria are available.

Why do people do this to themselves!? Do they really think their preference is a factor when applying to a routinely oversubscribed school living miles away? Its like there's some sense of entitlement to a place at the trendy/popular school. I just couldn't torture myself like this. One lady has spent weeks telling her DC they are going to popular school X with their nursery friends. She lives over 5 miles from it & it hasn't taken a non sibling from more than a mile away in over a decade and yet she's bewildered her DC didn't get a space.

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 17/04/2023 21:58

Our DC are not old enough to be thinking about it yet but our local authority has a shortage of secondary school places almost everywhere, except in one very rough school, in Special Measures, in a very well-known sink estate and one slightly better than that school which is miles from anywhere else and gets really poor exam results.

Our local secondary school is totally over-subscribed and being re-built currently. Our DC will be ok because we live so close and there is nowhere for them to build between us and the school. But it's madness what happens. I have sat in the Appeals procedures before. There are many parents who don't even send the forms back on time and then get upset when they are allocated the really poor schools. They appeal with the most ludicrous justifications - have a right to appeal and often are successful because they are often very vulnerable families who can meet the criteria for admission. Then there are parents who apply to the two Outstanding secondary schools and who don't get places because they don't live near them and end up being allocated to the poor schools because their nearest school is also full.

We had parents who were 'shopped' for putting grandparents' addresses down as theirs because grandparents lived near the Outstanding schools, parents who rented a house near one of the Outstanding schools but didn't actually live in it- just wanted it as an address. We had a march of parents protesting about their children being allocated the two poorer schools and saying they would refuse to send them there.

The local council has allowed massive building of new homes but not built any additional school- there is a real need for one in one particular area but if it was built, the two struggling schools would probably close because so much of their intake comes from children being allocated from that area.

It's a mess.

aintnothinbutagstring · 17/04/2023 21:55

I think the English system is good as there's generally more flexibility and fluidity for movement than the Scottish system. Though you may struggle to get a place in a very oversubscribed school - waiting lists exist so they may eventually get a place. You can also move your child quite easily if there is an issue. My nephew is in an abysmal secondary in Scotland - as my SIL couldn't afford to be near a better school - and he is being bullied/assaulted weekly but the school are useless and the LA won't move him. I wish they could move down here as she'd have more choice.

Okunevo · 17/04/2023 21:54

Iwouldlikesomecake · 17/04/2023 21:41

But where do you put these prefab classrooms? We barely had a playground at my inner city primary, let alone a field, if we did sports day it was on the park over the road. Not really possible to just add classes.

There is often an element of choice but you have to choose wisely to have a chance of getting what you want. Choose only one school and you are likely to be placed wherever, but if you choose all your options you have more chance of one of them coming good.

I think numbers are more likely to go up where there are new housing estates nearby and no extra schools. We had space at DS's school.

There were smaller class sizes in the infant years so composite classes were common even with steady intake numbers. Unless you had an intake of 60 maybe so could have three classes dropping to two at year 3, but numbers dropping only slightly could see you lose a teacher and end up with lots of composites.

IfYouLikePinaCoIadas · 17/04/2023 21:52

JamMakingWannaBe · 17/04/2023 21:46

I'm in Scotland. Our catchment Primary school would have been a 25 minute walk. Luckily we got a placing request to our non-catchment school which is geographically closer.

There has been a major amount of new house building locally over the past 5 years and the new estate was meant to include a new Primary School, which was actually a condition of Planning for all the new houses.

It came as no surprise to local residents who know the way the Council operates this has not been built, and what was a 2-stream P1 when my DCs started was 6-stream this year.

In answer to a PP, there are now portacabin classrooms in the playground and the Support for Learning, music and art rooms are now regular classrooms.

There is no other local school for these new kids to attend but there is also now no Breakfast Club for P1 or P2 and the after-school club was already full.

Ah. Portacabins. Cross-posted with my long-winded "pre-fab corrugated iron constructions" above, but yes, same, that's the kind of thing I meant too.

NumericalBlock · 17/04/2023 21:50

In my first house our catchment junior school was rated the worst in the country, I would have been in denial too had we been applying to the attached infants too tbh.

IfYouLikePinaCoIadas · 17/04/2023 21:49

When I was at primary in the eighties, in my last year, there was a sudden influx of kids in the year below (aged 9-10, really no idea why!). It meant they had to accommodate maybe 40 kids (10 new), in a classroom built for 30. So they split my year, which had something like only 20 of us, and mixed us with the other year. I have no idea how the teachers of each form managed, but they each kept us year 4s on one half of the room and set us work for our age, and the year 3s (as it was in those days, now years 5 and 6) were sat in the other half of the room and had separate work to us older ones. We would mix with the other half of our year group occasionally, or allmbe one massive group for sports or stuff like that.
Everyone seemed happy, as far as I can recall.

It was also nice for my brother (18 months younger, but only one school year below me) and me to be in the same form for my last year of primary.

I can't recall what they did for the last year of that year below me once we older smaller set had left.

-

ExH went to school in Scotland. His younger brother's year was oversubscribed. They built pre-fab corrugated iron classrooms for the excess. They are still being used 30 years later (ex PIL still live directly opposite the school, so I've seen them myself).

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 17/04/2023 21:49

00100001 · 17/04/2023 19:42

What system would work in your mind?

Not the person you asked, but I believe in Scotland you just automatically get your closest, there's no application. That's what it should be like.

Rainbowshit · 17/04/2023 21:48

Tandora
I think everyone might be over idealising the system in Scotland a bit too much. Just the other day there was a row on a mums group I’m on because one mum (in Scotland) said she was going to lie about her address (use her parents) to get her son into a nicer school as the one near her was too rough, and she couldn’t afford to buy property in the nicer school areas. Didn’t sound so diff to me!

@Tandora this is exactly my experience and around where I am, renting a property just to get the address and then stopping renting it once the DC gets their place in the preferred school.

"Popular" schools in Scotland have within their acceptance criteria that if you move out of catchment you have to reapply and if there are children on the waiting list then they will get your place.

Unlikely to actually happen in practice but certainly cuts down this kind of cheating.

simplesimples · 17/04/2023 21:48

I think it tends to be more of an issue where schools are terrible. Also where schools are so full that they keep changing the catchment areas (lived in areas both of these things were happening)

My local primary for example my friend taught at and so many dc didn't speak English or even each others language that year 1 was basically spent teaching basic spoken English between the many languages as most of the parents also couldn't speak English my friend also spent a lot of time splitting up inter racial wars over the years and other dd did get caught up in these fights which could get quite violent despite it only being primary,

Didn't want all the politics of the school spilling over into my dc life. My dc only get one set of school years I genuinely believe the pressure is real!

Motheranddaughter · 17/04/2023 21:48

The system gives the illusion of choice,which often isn’t really there
In Scotland if you are in catchment you get in 99% of the time

But often people pay a lot to move into catchment pushing the house prices up

I have to confess to doing this,can totally sympathise with people wanting their DC to go to the best possible school

JamMakingWannaBe · 17/04/2023 21:46

I'm in Scotland. Our catchment Primary school would have been a 25 minute walk. Luckily we got a placing request to our non-catchment school which is geographically closer.

There has been a major amount of new house building locally over the past 5 years and the new estate was meant to include a new Primary School, which was actually a condition of Planning for all the new houses.

It came as no surprise to local residents who know the way the Council operates this has not been built, and what was a 2-stream P1 when my DCs started was 6-stream this year.

In answer to a PP, there are now portacabin classrooms in the playground and the Support for Learning, music and art rooms are now regular classrooms.

There is no other local school for these new kids to attend but there is also now no Breakfast Club for P1 or P2 and the after-school club was already full.

GaslitlikeaVictorianparlour · 17/04/2023 21:46

I love the Scottish education system and there's a lot of great things about it but it really does benefit from falling population numbers and that population being less dense than England's.

Every school my family have gone to since the mid 1970s have had empty classrooms so if there's a bulge there's always somewhere to put them. In the more rural and remote areas the wee village school might only be one or 2 classrooms and the whole school can get mothballed for a couple of years before opening again when there's an intake.

We do have a more sane system than England but I think if we faced the same population problems we might be the same.

MultipleVeganPies · 17/04/2023 21:46

Lots of people think they can game the system

i know some very (usually) intelligent people who think they can game the system by putting their preferred, but out of catchment school first, then only adding schools even further out of catchment. They believe that this way they MUST be given their no 1 choice

they are wrong

Crayfishforyou · 17/04/2023 21:41

orangedalmatian · 17/04/2023 21:37

Because they remember bullying in their own shit school

Yes to this.

SonicStars · 17/04/2023 21:41

I live in a deprived inner city area with 10 schools within a miles walk of us. I remember primary school applications well as my oldest went to nursery class at a strangely sought after school (I think just because it was small). Many people who were further away (but still within walking distance) had it as first choice. Why shouldn't they? They may be lucky, few siblings that year, or idiots not filling in forms on time (there was ALOT of individual support from the school on it). Prior to it being closest as the crow flies there was a catchment and so there was still a lot of misinformation regarding that. The school was next to a main road and if you lived across that Road from the school you were not in catchment. The catchment area was entirely one estate to the other side of the school. Even without the social engineering aspects of catchments I think the current system works better. Just put your last option as one you're guaranteed a place in. Spending time getting your head round an application is easier then looking at catchments when you move house maybe years before you have kids (during that time schools can change vastly anyway).

For me, having been messed up by primary school, I worried and worried and made spreadsheets and read school newsletters and put a wildcard as #1, the school we were very happy with and expected as 2 and the tiny local one as 3. Got into 2, were very happy for several years and then big staff, teaching and ethos changes sent it drastically downhill. My youngest got a place in the wildcard school after a couple of years but to all those people saying "I would move if I didn't get the school I wanted." It wouldn't have helped if we'd moved into the pe shed at that point, as if there are no spaces you remain on the waiting list until a space comes up. Far easier to get into a school at application time than in year. Lots of movement at start of reception though.

Anyway I've rambled. OP, your mums are unreasonable because they claim to care but don't engage with the details. To everyone else, remember the best school for one family isn't necessarily the best school for yours.

JennyBee23 · 17/04/2023 21:41

There definitely is a bit of controversy in Scottish schools.

I used to live in Jordanhill but my house was build after 19something and was explicitly not part of the Jordanhill school catchment. The other local primaries were much of a muchness, the usual Catholic, non-denom and even a Gaelic medium were all on offer.

For secondary though it was a whole other thing. Hyndland secondary was considered wonderful, as was the local Catholic girls school but the Catholic coed was awful meaning Catholic boys would be placing requested to hyndland and end up at St Tams.

I now live in Bearsden and both non-denoms are good but the Catholic kids are bussed to a less good school in Kirkintilloch. Every year a parent on the local face ache page cries that she sent her kid to the Catholic primary here (so undersubscribed it's ludicrous) in the hopes of a place at Bearsden Academy (they're next door to each other) but now she needs to either send her kid to Kirky or go to Drumchapel high (which is basically always on fire).

Iwouldlikesomecake · 17/04/2023 21:41

But where do you put these prefab classrooms? We barely had a playground at my inner city primary, let alone a field, if we did sports day it was on the park over the road. Not really possible to just add classes.

There is often an element of choice but you have to choose wisely to have a chance of getting what you want. Choose only one school and you are likely to be placed wherever, but if you choose all your options you have more chance of one of them coming good.

CecilyP · 17/04/2023 21:40

Where does the physical classroom come from? Do they have spare ones sitting empty?

Not necessarily. One thing that can be done if a school looks to be getting full is to put a cap on placement requests. The other is to not accept out of catchment siblings. So a school that is very full higher up will not necessarily take the full complement of P1s. Composite classes are also pretty normal.

2023forme · 17/04/2023 21:39

Tandora · 17/04/2023 20:36

I think everyone might be over idealising the system in Scotland a bit too much. Just the other day there was a row on a mums group I’m on because one mum (in Scotland) said she was going to lie about her address (use her parents) to get her son into a nicer school as the one near her was too rough, and she couldn’t afford to buy property in the nicer school areas. Didn’t sound so diff to me!

@Tandora this is exactly my experience and around where I am, renting a property just to get the address and then stopping renting it once the DC gets their place in the preferred school.

orangedalmatian · 17/04/2023 21:37

Because they remember bullying in their own shit school

TooManyPlatesInMotion · 17/04/2023 21:34

00100001 · 17/04/2023 19:43

It's because they think the rules.dont apply to them and their darling offspring.

This.

Okunevo · 17/04/2023 21:33

00100001 · 17/04/2023 19:59

Oversubscribed is a thing. If you have 32 eligible children in catchment, and perhaps 3 eligible out of catchment (looked after etc) you have 35 kids asking for 30 places... Then it's over subscribed.

Some people are equal distance from schools. So how would you put them in the nearest school?

Similar in Australia. Pre-fab classrooms are used for an extra class, teacher funding based on student numbers, often mixed age classes are needed.

RaraRachael · 17/04/2023 21:33

We have an RC school in our town. It claims that it has to keep a certain percentage of places free at each stage for RC pupils who may movd into the area.

(Usually trotted out when we have a child with behavioural needs is looking for a different school)

Seaweasel · 17/04/2023 21:29

I think the illusion of choice is confusing for many parents new to the system. Given that this has been a problem for years, instead of criticising parents who just want the best for their kids and may even have their own issues around literacy, learning etc, we could just make the system easier to navigate. Common problems that I see are: 1) people only putting one school, thinking that if they only choose 1, they'll have to be given it. 2) people choosing only out of catchment with no local back-up, and 3) not understanding the correct additional forms needed in the case of church schools. All these scenarios can very easily result in a school place so far away, it's not viable. Parents genuinely think that if they put the three best schools they know down, they'll have to be given one of them. On the face of it, that's not so crazy as they are asked for their three choices.

Chipsahoy · 17/04/2023 21:28

00100001 · 17/04/2023 19:59

Oversubscribed is a thing. If you have 32 eligible children in catchment, and perhaps 3 eligible out of catchment (looked after etc) you have 35 kids asking for 30 places... Then it's over subscribed.

Some people are equal distance from schools. So how would you put them in the nearest school?

Not a thing where I am in Scotland. They have to provide a place in your zoned school. Each postcode is zoned to a school. You re guaranteed a place in that school.