Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people torment themselves over school places

259 replies

Schoolplacechoicemyth · 17/04/2023 19:36

Im in a local toddler/child social media group.

Every single year there are people on the group who apply wildly optimistically for 2 or 3 oversubscribed schools several miles away from their home, are given the unpopular school they live near and desperately ask how to appeal because they "really love oversubcribed school and absolutely want DC to go there".

They seem completely unprepared for how unlikely it was they'd get a place, baffled that their preference doesn't actually get them the place at the oversubscribed chool, spend weeks/months appealing for schools they have next to no chance of a space at, & complain repeatedly on the group about it. Often the school they live near is fine, its just not the fashionable choice this week.

The local council publish all the info. You can see, easily, how close you need to live to stand a decent chance at a place. All the admission criteria are available.

Why do people do this to themselves!? Do they really think their preference is a factor when applying to a routinely oversubscribed school living miles away? Its like there's some sense of entitlement to a place at the trendy/popular school. I just couldn't torture myself like this. One lady has spent weeks telling her DC they are going to popular school X with their nursery friends. She lives over 5 miles from it & it hasn't taken a non sibling from more than a mile away in over a decade and yet she's bewildered her DC didn't get a space.

OP posts:
00100001 · 17/04/2023 23:15

CurlewKate · 17/04/2023 23:12

If there's a lottery and you only put one school down, you get the first available school place when all other children whose parents weren't daft have been given places.

Ok.

So, kinda what happens now then...

CurlewKate · 17/04/2023 23:12

If there's a lottery and you only put one school down, you get the first available school place when all other children whose parents weren't daft have been given places.

CurlewKate · 17/04/2023 23:10

@00100001 considering that less than 50% of families put their local school first, I'm pretty sure that overcrowding won't be a significant issue. And the exactly equidistant thing just isn't going to happen. I accept that there would need to be provision for children with AEN if their needs can only be met at a particular school.

00100001 · 17/04/2023 23:04

SpicedPumpkinLatte · 17/04/2023 23:02

2nd choice etc

I only put one school down...

SpicedPumpkinLatte · 17/04/2023 23:02

2nd choice etc

00100001 · 17/04/2023 22:59

SpicedPumpkinLatte · 17/04/2023 22:58

A lottery

Ok, and what is a "win" and a "loss"?

If I lose this lottery...where are my kids going?

SpicedPumpkinLatte · 17/04/2023 22:58

00100001 · 17/04/2023 19:42

What system would work in your mind?

A lottery

00100001 · 17/04/2023 22:50

CurlewKate · 17/04/2023 22:40

"And what if you're equally distant between two schools?"
What-to the metre? How likely is that?

Not impossible.

Anyway, if it's by closest school and nothing else. Then do you not think that some schools would be over subscribed? And class sizes far too big?

What about where the nearest school isn't able to accommodate the child's needs?

What would you do about looked after children?

CurlewKate · 17/04/2023 22:48

@00100001 "Ok. My house is equally distant from 2 schools."

To the metre?

Cantseethewindows · 17/04/2023 22:48

Tidsleytiddy · 17/04/2023 20:00

Years ago in our London borough there was a parent who was determined her son was going to the most popular and over subscribed secondary school in the area even tho she lived outside the catchment. She bought him the uniform and told him he was going. Can’t recall how the saga ended but I remember thinking what a stunt to pull and fancy doing that to the kid

I'm a secondary teacher. We had someone do this a few years ago. AFAIK the mother hadn't applied to any schools (new to the country I believe). I think we enrolled the pupil. We were not oversubscribed though.

00100001 · 17/04/2023 22:46

CurlewKate · 17/04/2023 22:42

The answer is simply to go by proximity alone. No other criteria.

Ok. My house is equally distant from 2 schools.

Which one do I get?

CurlewKate · 17/04/2023 22:42

The answer is simply to go by proximity alone. No other criteria.

CurlewKate · 17/04/2023 22:40

"And what if you're equally distant between two schools?"
What-to the metre? How likely is that?

Botw1 · 17/04/2023 22:39

Am I the only 1 that thinks that what school you go to doesn't make a huge amount of difference to a child's propects?

I mean if your parents are drug addicts or lawyers, thats going to have amuch bigger impact

LovePoppy · 17/04/2023 22:30

00100001 · 17/04/2023 19:51

Ok.

And what if you're equally distant between two schools?

What if there is a baby book that year and 35 kids that live in catchment want to fill 30 places?

What if the "real reason" for a child out of catchment has taken the last place and your kid now can't go?

Where I am - they change the amount of classes per grade each year depending on enrollment. We are all placed at the school for the catchment we live in - only difference is if you want French immersion and your local elementary doesn't have it.

If you want a place at an out of catchment school for a language your school has, its possible to move. However if a student moves into the school catchment and needs your space, you will be bumped back to your school

ACynicalDad · 17/04/2023 22:25

By all means put your dream schools down, but have a realistic insurance or two.

00100001 · 17/04/2023 22:23

SonicStars · 17/04/2023 21:59

Oh and to those saying "just be allocated your nearest school" I am equidistant between the tiny school which has zero space to expand/have bulge classes and school 4, which is on the other side of a railway line and a pain to get to on foot but impossible to get to by car due to one way system, closed roads and bus only roads (buses that dont actually go to the school though).
The tiny school is right by a lot of tower blocks and so would be the closest school for so many more pupils than it could fit on its site.

My little block of 15 homes sends/has sent kids to 7 different primaries and 5 secondaries. They all had reasons for choosing their secondary schools and were happy (apart from one). I would not have been happy with at least 2 of those schools and I would have been so sad if I had had to move from my home because my kids had to go to the very closest secondary. (Also v hard to get HA swaps so only the privilaged have the capacity to move into catchments - even just to rent for a few months. If its not a choice for everyone it's not a choice).

Oh to live in a perfect world where every school was great. Maybe if all the influential people didn't send their kids private...

Just move to Scotland.its perfect there apparently...

SonicStars · 17/04/2023 22:22

RaraRachael · 17/04/2023 21:10

It seems hard to believe but we don't have dearer housing near "good" schools. Maybe in cities but not elsewhere.
We had to make the GP room into an extra classroom when there was a bulge in particular year but that's gone now.
A PP described it as "angst" over school places which is a great description. It just doesn't happen here and we find it hard to understand.

I dunno, I have friends in linlithgow who would beg to differ.

Historically rural comprehensives were the only ones to work as population density was low enough that a range of social economic groups had no choice but to send their kids to the nearest school. This was national, not specific to scotland. Whenever you get more people, you get "better and worse" schools, with the people who are able either through money or understanding of the system, able to get their children into the "better" schools, thus amplifying/entrenching the situation.

rowanisla · 17/04/2023 22:19

00100001 · 17/04/2023 22:12

How is that any less batshit than the English system, where kids go to secondary based k t ebri primary cluster?

There’s no real angst about the applications - if you are in catchment A you go to school A (you are automatically also in catchment for a denominational (Catholic) school but these schools have a much bigger catchment per school.) You can make a placing request to go to a different school but won’t get a place if the school is already full. You can only apply to one school - catchment (guaranteed) catchment denominational (guaranteed) or placing request (not guaranteed).

00100001 · 17/04/2023 22:12

rowanisla · 17/04/2023 22:03

The other way it works in Scotland is that P1 class limit is supposed to be 25 going up to 30 in P2-3 and 33 in P4-7. Mine was in a bulge year had 28 in each P1 class - they kept the same classrooms but had extra teaching time. Later years that were bigger were split into 3 classes in P1 then back to 2 in P2 onwards (using the music room as an extra classroom)
The catchments can be a bit bizarre esp in high school as they’re based round feeder primary clusters - kids who live next door to our local high school won’t go to it as they are in a different primary cluster, but overall it all works okish.

How is that any less batshit than the English system, where kids go to secondary based k t ebri primary cluster?

rowanisla · 17/04/2023 22:03

The other way it works in Scotland is that P1 class limit is supposed to be 25 going up to 30 in P2-3 and 33 in P4-7. Mine was in a bulge year had 28 in each P1 class - they kept the same classrooms but had extra teaching time. Later years that were bigger were split into 3 classes in P1 then back to 2 in P2 onwards (using the music room as an extra classroom)
The catchments can be a bit bizarre esp in high school as they’re based round feeder primary clusters - kids who live next door to our local high school won’t go to it as they are in a different primary cluster, but overall it all works okish.

JamMakingWannaBe · 17/04/2023 22:02

Tandora · 17/04/2023 20:36

I think everyone might be over idealising the system in Scotland a bit too much. Just the other day there was a row on a mums group I’m on because one mum (in Scotland) said she was going to lie about her address (use her parents) to get her son into a nicer school as the one near her was too rough, and she couldn’t afford to buy property in the nicer school areas. Didn’t sound so diff to me!

She might try, but I'm pretty sure there are some fairly rigorous checks.
We needed to provide a Council Tax letter and two utility bills in our name (PITA when everything is now online), plus the nursery would have provided the Council with a list of kids and addresses for the "meet the teacher / visit your new school" sessions (as obviously based on catchment). I think they even asked for the GP that DCs were registered at.

SonicStars · 17/04/2023 21:59

Oh and to those saying "just be allocated your nearest school" I am equidistant between the tiny school which has zero space to expand/have bulge classes and school 4, which is on the other side of a railway line and a pain to get to on foot but impossible to get to by car due to one way system, closed roads and bus only roads (buses that dont actually go to the school though).
The tiny school is right by a lot of tower blocks and so would be the closest school for so many more pupils than it could fit on its site.

My little block of 15 homes sends/has sent kids to 7 different primaries and 5 secondaries. They all had reasons for choosing their secondary schools and were happy (apart from one). I would not have been happy with at least 2 of those schools and I would have been so sad if I had had to move from my home because my kids had to go to the very closest secondary. (Also v hard to get HA swaps so only the privilaged have the capacity to move into catchments - even just to rent for a few months. If its not a choice for everyone it's not a choice).

Oh to live in a perfect world where every school was great. Maybe if all the influential people didn't send their kids private...

Fluckinghell · 17/04/2023 21:59

OhmygodDont · 17/04/2023 19:49

Should just automatically get a place at the closest school unless there are reasons real reasons to go else where.

Exactly how it works in Scotland

itsserendipity · 17/04/2023 21:59

Is the answer that we are evolutionarily primed to turn into absolutely insane resource hoarders when we produce offspring? This is the modern day equivalent over snarling over the juiciest carcass.

It's natural to want the best for your child, some of us are able to control the crazy better than others... I say that having felt truly neurotic about primary places.

The system delivers some unfair results and perpetuates inequality, although I don't know what a better alternative is either. It feels like "rich" areas will always get more resources (parent/community donations, engagement, etc). How do we do this better?