Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people torment themselves over school places

259 replies

Schoolplacechoicemyth · 17/04/2023 19:36

Im in a local toddler/child social media group.

Every single year there are people on the group who apply wildly optimistically for 2 or 3 oversubscribed schools several miles away from their home, are given the unpopular school they live near and desperately ask how to appeal because they "really love oversubcribed school and absolutely want DC to go there".

They seem completely unprepared for how unlikely it was they'd get a place, baffled that their preference doesn't actually get them the place at the oversubscribed chool, spend weeks/months appealing for schools they have next to no chance of a space at, & complain repeatedly on the group about it. Often the school they live near is fine, its just not the fashionable choice this week.

The local council publish all the info. You can see, easily, how close you need to live to stand a decent chance at a place. All the admission criteria are available.

Why do people do this to themselves!? Do they really think their preference is a factor when applying to a routinely oversubscribed school living miles away? Its like there's some sense of entitlement to a place at the trendy/popular school. I just couldn't torture myself like this. One lady has spent weeks telling her DC they are going to popular school X with their nursery friends. She lives over 5 miles from it & it hasn't taken a non sibling from more than a mile away in over a decade and yet she's bewildered her DC didn't get a space.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CecilyP · 18/04/2023 22:25

^Interesting. I was going to ask about that - the Scottish system, especially in cities, seems to be very likely to entrench advantage for the rich living in better areas (therefore better catchments and better schools) and, critically, disadvantage for poor families living in poor catchments.

Wouldn't that be much the same as in England where they operate on the shortest waking distance from the school. Then there are other schools with their own esoteric over-subscription criteria and families that fall between two stools. The main advantage of the Scottish system is that there are no ‘black holes’. You may not get the most desirable school but you won’t be allocated an unpopular school miles away from where you live.

CecilyP · 18/04/2023 22:10

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 18/04/2023 08:22

Because they’ve had a shit start in life and so get the first dibs on the best school

That might be how it has worked out though probably the real reason is because looked after children are more likely than others to have moved between allocation and starting school. And the move would be very likely to have been anticipated.

Motheranddaughter · 18/04/2023 20:25

I moved out of Glasgow to the suburbs of East Renfrewshire where the schools are very highly rated and houses are very expensive
My 3 all did very well
They might have done ok anyway,but I was not prepared to risk it
Most of my friends did the same but

Cornishmumofone · 18/04/2023 19:50

I've just learnt that my local area decided to abolish catchment areas in September. Priority for secondary school places now has proximity to the school at the bottom of the list, far below attending a feeder school.

I live on the border between two areas. DD goes to a school in the neighbouring area as my nearest school is terrible and the next nearest ones are so oversubscribed that she wouldn't have got in.

The consequence of this is that DD will not get a secondary school place in the city we live in, unless she travels 3.5 miles to the other side of the city to a rough secondary school.

I can't afford to move house or pay for a private education, so this will be in the back of my mind for the next few years.

SundaeClub · 18/04/2023 18:15

The Scottish system provides more certainty for parents, but this comes at a cost for the schools. It can't be easy to manage a school when you have to rearrange class compositions and school layout each year because of varying numbers of children. It's not as simple as just adding a bulge class to reception year - that class isn't going to be full (unless you have literally double the expected number of children in catchment), and it's not going to do anything for the school budget to have, say, 34 children split into two underfilled classes.

Local authorities in England can adapt to demographic trends because they have a base of schools to spread the load between, so they only need to ensure there are enough overall spaces. Whereas in Scotland they have to ensure that each individual school has sufficient space, and other schools can't relieve the pressure on another local school that has too many pupils - the only available immediate response is to bring in more Portacabins.

Thinkingpod · 18/04/2023 13:30

People want the best for their children and a school in an area a mile or 2 away may have better performance ratings, a full fun and functioning pta which has activities for children to take place in, and better opportunities.

People shouldn't be laughed at for been upset about their child's school placement when it isn't what they wanted.

What should happen is lea and council should look at why certain schools are not popular and work with them to make it an appealing choice for kids and parents.

Coolblur · 18/04/2023 11:35

We live in Scotland and as others have said the system is different, and a lot less stressful here. Kids go to the catchment school, then on to the high school which it feeds into. There are class size limits which increase with age, for example I think Primary 1 is 25, then it's 30, then 33 as they move through the school. If there are lots of kids starting P1 they recruit more teachers. Composite classes combining year groups are common to accommodate overspill. DS' school built an extension with 8 new classrooms due to demand created by new build houses increasing the local population. The house builders funded this as a planning approval condition. If there's no room, or money, to recruit or expand a school the council redraw the catchment area boundaries. This happened close to us so kids living two streets away starting school now go to a school 2 miles away that has capacity. This was awful for people who moved to the affected streets thinking it would be lovely for the kids to walk to school and live near their friends. Some sold and moved up the road closer to the local school.

I think one of the biggest differences is that schools aren't Offsted rated in Scotland. High school exam performance is published each year which drives demand to be in the catchment for the ones that perform well, but not in the same way as the ratings system seems to in England.

RedToothBrush · 18/04/2023 11:25

It's weird where I am because the criteria for the local high school has higher priority for those at certain feeder primaries.

Half of these primaries have now formed an academy trust to cement this relationship with the high school. So if you are in one of these primaries you get first priority, then if you are in other feeders you get second priority then it goes to distance. But because there has been a low birth rate and house prices have priced out families, some of the academy primaries are getting a situation where kids from 11miles away are getting spaces and then will almost automatically get a space at the local high, yet kids who maybe move to the area between reception and yr6 and don't get a space at the right primary can be living in the closest house to the high school and not get in. It means the pushy parents from low income areas outside area and the borough get an opportunity there.

It's kinda bonkers in its own right though. There isn't a pressure on the primaries here for spaces in reception as a result, but pressure for the high school is exceeds supply substantially and it gets a really high number of appeals every year. They haven't got to the distance criteria for the last few years for admissions, so you really have to know your way away the system from early on.

It does mean you can't just move to the area for a place though at present. You have to have a commitment to the local school community for a number of years instead. I know parents who took their kids out of school for bullying or cos the primary wasn't matching needs and then found they were up shit creek for high school too.

DS is in a situation where he is almost guaranteed a space with the vast majority of his friends, if we choose the school unlike in a lot of areas as a result.

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 18/04/2023 11:02

If you want to get into an oversubscribed school you need to live very near it. So people either pay to live in good school areas or pay to send to private school. The rest get what they are given....and yes, not everyone is happy about that!

RedToothBrush · 18/04/2023 10:56

cantkeepawayforever · 18/04/2023 08:40

Interesting. I was going to ask about that - the Scottish system, especially in cities, seems to be very likely to entrench advantage for the rich living in better areas (therefore better catchments and better schools) and, critically, disadvantage for poor families living in poor catchments.

I’d be really interested to see, for Glasgow and Edinburgh in particular (though I know the private schools skew the situation there), data for results from each high school compared with measures of the socio-economic profile in its catchment.

One of the things about not having catchment areas and people not getting the school they want is you end up with a bunch of well off pushy parents in a not so good school and you get kids from poor backgrounds but with ambitious parents in better schools.

I think the pushy rich parents make a lot of difference in that respect but there are more opportunities for kids from a poorer area to get out too.

It's not enough to scream about how we have great social mobility in England but I do think it would be enough to entrench further in Scotland and have a marked difference compared to England, just by turning the dial up on competition for places rather than a more almost 'accept your lot in life' approach that the Scottish system unfortunately enforces.

Neither system is remotely fair or even, but the reality is a lottery system wouldnt work either because of the implications to kids to get to schools which were further away - especially for those on lower incomes who couldn't afford this.

I think for me, it's probably the fact that parental influence counts for so much in pushing kids that is depressing, because there is clearly a failing here to make up the shortfall where a kid doesn't have any adult really fighting their corner or managing to give that additional encouragement they need.

Schoolplacechoicemyth · 18/04/2023 09:50

"Genuine question, why do 'looked after' kids get priority for school places?"

A high proportion of looked after kids have additional needs& considerations that don't fit within the traditional entry criteria but need to be prioritised.

Eg they may need to be near a particular school because its not only near their foster home but is also in a location that facilitates family visits. They also have a higher need for stability and continuity so might need to continue at a school where theyve attended nursery, or have a place at a school a sibling attends even though theyve moved to a foster or adoptive home further away. They may need to be in a school where other children of their ethnic or nationality background are well represented.

OP posts:
Botw1 · 18/04/2023 09:38

@AncientToaster

Yes. Social mobility isn't really a thing

So if you're a middle class parent, in a middle class area with middle class schools to choose from.....

Your kid will be fine regardless

AncientToaster · 18/04/2023 09:34

People want the best for their children understandably.

Most people are not confident enough to understand the capability levels of their children. DH and I both work or worked in higher education, I actually studied educational outcomes as part of my studies. Looking at income levels, and ethnic groups mainly.

We sent our child to the local comprehensive with below average results. We also had a racist incident or two as he is mixed race, plus he had the piss taken out of him for being posh. We are Southerners in the North and he just picked up our accent quite strongly though he was born here. We discussed all these issues at length with him.

He achieved all A grades at A level. I also did something frowned on by MN payment for results.

I knew my child well and was extremely confident in his capabilities.

@Botw1 educational outcome is governed mainly by Mothers educational level, ethnic group and income group. If you are interested the ONS has a ton of data available online. There are always outliers before someone says but my Mum was daft as a brush and we lived in the gutter and I went to Oxford.

PuttingDownRoots · 18/04/2023 09:23

Part of the problem is there is no "English" system. Its a myriad of systems happening on the same timescale.

My best friend and I live 4 miles apart. We have fixed priority areas, feeder schools, a lottery school and religious schools.
She has a grammar school and entry per distance.

JassyRadlett · 18/04/2023 09:15

Peenuts · 18/04/2023 09:01

@JassyRadlett
That's really interesting to hear. I've not heard of that before. Which areas don't have one and what do they do instead, is it just distance etc?

London, for a start? At least my part of it.

Distance/siblings/looked after/medical need for maintained schools. Faith places screw up catchments massively.

I know over the border into Surrey there are individual schools with feeder primaries and nominal outer/inner catchments but it's not county-wide and consistent, it's set by the individual school which makes things even worse. Some Surrey schools give staff children priority, others don't. Very few primaries there have catchments, some secondaries for and others don't. It's a mess.

Peenuts · 18/04/2023 09:01

@JassyRadlett
That's really interesting to hear. I've not heard of that before. Which areas don't have one and what do they do instead, is it just distance etc?

Tarantullah · 18/04/2023 08:55

L1ttledrummergirl · 18/04/2023 08:30

Wait until your dc get to university age. That will blow your mind, the number of people who want their dc to go to university but have failed to budget for the parent contribution to their loan, then complain about how unfair the system is.

But the system now is unfair. I did my degree not wildly long ago and could live off of the maintenance loan, bursary and a small weekend job because my parents earnt hardly anything. It's becoming less accessible and that's not okay.

mrsbitaly · 18/04/2023 08:45

But if the local schools have poor oftsed ratings/bullying management ect why would you want your child to attend?

cantkeepawayforever · 18/04/2023 08:40

RedToothBrush · 18/04/2023 08:29

"Scotland has the best entry system due to the catchment areas"

Also Scotland
"Much bigger attainment gap between rich and poor pupils in schools"

Something tells me the two things may not be unconnected.

Interesting. I was going to ask about that - the Scottish system, especially in cities, seems to be very likely to entrench advantage for the rich living in better areas (therefore better catchments and better schools) and, critically, disadvantage for poor families living in poor catchments.

I’d be really interested to see, for Glasgow and Edinburgh in particular (though I know the private schools skew the situation there), data for results from each high school compared with measures of the socio-economic profile in its catchment.

cantkeepawayforever · 18/04/2023 08:34

‘Closest school’ would only work if population and schools were evenly distributed (and either extremely flexible in size or very closely matched in size to population needs) either in a non-mobile population with little housing being built or where schools had very significant excess capacity.

Consider a situation where a 1 form entry school is situated close to a 3 form entry school, where there are enough children in the area to fill 4 forms. 85 children have the 1 form entry as closest school. 45have the 3 firm entry as closest school. Are you really suggesting that the 1 form entry should expand to 3 form entry through temporary buildings and employing new teachers, leaving the existing 3 form entry half empty and having to lay some teachers off (the 1 form entry will need 3 teachers; the 3 form will need 2 - there is a need for 1 more teacher than the status quo).

A combination of catchment - larger for the larger school - and preference means that both schools fill to capacity, which is obviously more sensible.

L1ttledrummergirl · 18/04/2023 08:30

Wait until your dc get to university age. That will blow your mind, the number of people who want their dc to go to university but have failed to budget for the parent contribution to their loan, then complain about how unfair the system is.

RedToothBrush · 18/04/2023 08:29

"Scotland has the best entry system due to the catchment areas"

Also Scotland
"Much bigger attainment gap between rich and poor pupils in schools"

Something tells me the two things may not be unconnected.

Devoutspoken · 18/04/2023 08:25

Jenny been, some working parents can walk/cycle!

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 18/04/2023 08:22

Winterday1991 · 18/04/2023 08:11

Genuine question, why do 'looked after' kids get priority for school places?

Because they’ve had a shit start in life and so get the first dibs on the best school

SpicedPumpkinLatte · 18/04/2023 08:12

00100001 · 17/04/2023 23:04

I only put one school down...

Then you'd be randomly allocated if you're not chosen in the lottery