Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask school why DS was told there are 72 genders?

184 replies

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 16:14

DS - 13 - came home from school & said he had a ‘weird’ Philosophy & Ethics lesson led by a new-ish ( non-binary/trans) teacher where they discussed sexuality and gender and 72 genders were mentioned. They covered some of the ‘main’ ones like pansexual, bisexual, trans etc

I told DS that there’s not 72 bloody genders. But am curious as to what materials were used, where they came from and whether or not this was a genuine discussion as DS said it was stated as fact. So for example
When they discuss Judaism or other religions the teachers don’t state ‘god exists’ they talk about belief systems and how they are similar, how they’re different etc

it sounded like this lesson was more - this is fact.

or so I just leave it, knowing that DS is sensible, and knows that gay, trans, bi etc people exist in the world and that’s fine ask the school what the lesson was exactly?

I’m gay, BTW, so this isn’t some anti LGBTQ thing

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
AmuseBish · 17/04/2023 17:08

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 17:04

Ash is trans I believe. so not transphobic. Or possibly non-binary, I don't actually now nor does DS. Ash has long hair but a beard, wears make up and 'feminine' clothing, and answers just to Ash, no surname, and doesn't answer to the usual Miss or Sir, obvs.
And no, not a Science teacher.

It's perfectly possible to be non-binary and transphobic. I would question why they are pushing the notion that sex and gender can "match".

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 17:08

Not a supply teacher, sounds young so I think a NQT with a permanent role in a humanity subject but many of the teachers at the school have other responsibilities or run club outside their subjects.
An English teacher is an ex- England sports woman so runs that sports club after school for example, Science teacher is a chess geek so runs chess club, Geography teacher is also a fairly successful script writer so teaches creative writing etc
They tend to match interests and expertise of teachers to clubs and subjects which obviously is usually a good thing and we're lucky to have such an engaged teaching staff

OP posts:
BenCoopersSupportWren · 17/04/2023 17:06

If there are only two sexes (which there are) and bisexuality is being attracted to both men and women, how is pansexuality different?

OP, I'd follow the example of a PP and ask the school who produced the materials for the lesson and how it was framed (e.g. as fact or belief?)

Transgender Trend have a schools resource pack which includes advice on creating a culture within schools of acceptance of gender non-conformity without denying biological sex, so they may be a good avenue for advice and guidance on how to approach the issue if you decide to take it further.

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 17:04

Ash is trans I believe. so not transphobic. Or possibly non-binary, I don't actually now nor does DS. Ash has long hair but a beard, wears make up and 'feminine' clothing, and answers just to Ash, no surname, and doesn't answer to the usual Miss or Sir, obvs.
And no, not a Science teacher.

OP posts:
Pixiedust1234 · 17/04/2023 17:02

I would email the Headteacher questioning what your son has been taught and since it was a supply(?) teacher ask them if the regular teacher would have taught the same.

I'm sure I read somewhere its 100 genders and counting but never seen a list of them and what they mean. If you find out please post!

Littlemisscol · 17/04/2023 17:01

Wait sorry it isn't pussy footing.

Would it be "gender neutral feline stepping?"

I'm not even sure. Anyway 😂

HermioneKipper · 17/04/2023 17:00

Utter claptrap.

why are they teaching this at school.

I wouldn’t be happy and would want answers from the school

Littlemisscol · 17/04/2023 17:00

In our secondary school the kids have declared "pronoun fatigue" - basically, they're fed up of it all, remembering all the flags, symbols, acronyms, pussy footing etc

I'm wondering if pronoun fatigue is prevailing. 🤔

ItsCalledAConversation · 17/04/2023 16:55

Since when is pansexuality a gender, it’s a sexual orientation isn’t it?

AmuseBish · 17/04/2023 16:55

Nordicrain · 17/04/2023 16:53

I would ask them to list them for you :)

Yep, and they need to make it clear which ones 'match' each sex. If they refuse it means they are preventing anyone from identifying as trans, because you need to know that your gender is not one of the matching ones for your sex to do so.

KittyAlfred · 17/04/2023 16:53

I would complain to the school. I would say, as you have, that things like religion are taught as being points of view rather than facts. And all this multiple gender malarkey should be taught in the same way.
You might be able to educate your child but other kids might believe this rubbish.
There no way I’d let this lie.

Nordicrain · 17/04/2023 16:53

I would ask them to list them for you :)

AmuseBish · 17/04/2023 16:51

Given the teacher, Ash, told them that anyone who identifies with the gender that matches their biology makes them ‘ privileged’

Sounds like Ash is a bit transphobic if they think a gender is so similar to a sex that it "matches" - the two are entirely separate concepts, so cannot match, unless you think that one determines the other?

I'd complain that they are not being told that sex and gender are different things. How can a physical make-up of a body "match" a feeling?

stickygotstuck · 17/04/2023 16:46

FOJN · 17/04/2023 16:28

Not if it's being taught as fact by an activist teacher. People are free to hold any belief they like but they should not use the education system to indoctrinate children with their personal beliefs. Education about belief systems is fine but the distinction between belief and fact should be made clear.

That is exactly how I think about it - so long as you don't present 'belief' (no matter how, shall we say, misguided) as 'fact' or 'data'.

I recently had a conversation with DC's school about this, on the back of their upcoming RSHE lessons. I asked -

  • whether the material was prepared externally, and by whom (any mention of The Proud Trust, Just Like Us and Diversity Role Models, and DC would have been withdrawn from those lessons forthwith)
  • how much emphasis was put on gender ideology and was it taught as fact
Fortunately, the answer was no to both questions.

I did mention that, to my mind, 'inclusion and diversity' is so much more than just gender, which seems to have taken centre stage for no good reason whatsoever to the detriment of other things such as race, disability, even sexual orientation. The teacher seemed to agree, which was encouraging.

AngelinaFibres · 17/04/2023 16:46

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 16:38

Given the teacher, Ash, told them that anyone who identifies with the gender that matches their biology makes them ‘ privileged’ I feel there’s a bit of an agenda, but the teacher isn’t the Phil/ethics teacher normally. They do another subject usually.

Not science presumably

gawditswindy · 17/04/2023 16:42

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 16:38

Given the teacher, Ash, told them that anyone who identifies with the gender that matches their biology makes them ‘ privileged’ I feel there’s a bit of an agenda, but the teacher isn’t the Phil/ethics teacher normally. They do another subject usually.

It's hard to define where the privilege lies, really. The 'specialness', on the other hand...

TidyDancer · 17/04/2023 16:39

Personally I would be asking the school about this because it's bollocks and shouldn't be taught as fact. There are some very impressionable children who may take this as gospel because it's coming from a teacher. At the very least I would want to know how it was being said and what type of material was being used.

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 16:38

Given the teacher, Ash, told them that anyone who identifies with the gender that matches their biology makes them ‘ privileged’ I feel there’s a bit of an agenda, but the teacher isn’t the Phil/ethics teacher normally. They do another subject usually.

OP posts:
Echobelly · 17/04/2023 16:34

Depends, were they told 'there are 72 genders' like it's a fact, or did it come up as 'some people say there could be up to 72 genders',as a discussion point, which would be more reasonable?

I'm parent of a non binary child and while I'm very open to discussions of what gender can mean, I don't think anyone should be teaching as though there are factually a specific number of genders, because it is a construct and while I think it is more than a binary, it's not also any set number and it's misleading to present it to kids as though it is.

FOJN · 17/04/2023 16:28

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 16:23

Guess it’s just a shoulder shrug, and move on then.

Not if it's being taught as fact by an activist teacher. People are free to hold any belief they like but they should not use the education system to indoctrinate children with their personal beliefs. Education about belief systems is fine but the distinction between belief and fact should be made clear.

SpringCherryTrees · 17/04/2023 16:25

Gender is an ideology like religion - so no I would not want this taught as fact and would want to investigate and shut it down.

Genders are something SOME people like to talk about.

They are not fact and also not helpful to a lot of people, esp teenagers who want to explore and experiment. They should be free to do that without being told that if they like the colour pink there is something going on with their ‘gender’.

Although I very much identify personally with ‘cakegender’….

FOJN · 17/04/2023 16:25

I hope there aren't 72 sets of pronouns to remember too

If only there were so few.

Click on the categories on the right hand side to see how many neo pronouns there are in each category. You'll no doubt find a very special person on Tiktok to explain how to use ux/uxs/uxself pronouns so you don't commit an act of literal violence.

https://neopronounlist.carrd.co/#nonthemed

neopronoun list

a rly rly big list of neo pronouns

https://neopronounlist.carrd.co/#nonthemed

Azerothi · 17/04/2023 16:24

caringcarer · 17/04/2023 16:22

They can have as many genders as they like as long as only 2 biological sexes.

This. Absolutely this.

Many more than 72 genders but only ever 2 sexes.

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 16:23

Guess it’s just a shoulder shrug, and move on then.

OP posts:
Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 16:22

‘The things you have mentioned, Bisexual and Pansexual aren't even genders, ‘

I told him that

OP posts: