Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask school why DS was told there are 72 genders?

184 replies

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 16:14

DS - 13 - came home from school & said he had a ‘weird’ Philosophy & Ethics lesson led by a new-ish ( non-binary/trans) teacher where they discussed sexuality and gender and 72 genders were mentioned. They covered some of the ‘main’ ones like pansexual, bisexual, trans etc

I told DS that there’s not 72 bloody genders. But am curious as to what materials were used, where they came from and whether or not this was a genuine discussion as DS said it was stated as fact. So for example
When they discuss Judaism or other religions the teachers don’t state ‘god exists’ they talk about belief systems and how they are similar, how they’re different etc

it sounded like this lesson was more - this is fact.

or so I just leave it, knowing that DS is sensible, and knows that gay, trans, bi etc people exist in the world and that’s fine ask the school what the lesson was exactly?

I’m gay, BTW, so this isn’t some anti LGBTQ thing

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
9
Humanbiology · 18/04/2023 21:06

Vitriolinsanity · 18/04/2023 20:49

@Humanbiology but was he strict because he was gay, or simply because he was a good teacher who happened to be gay?

My ex-boss a gay. Very difficult in 90's City Investment Banking, but he's a phenomenal mind that happens to be a gay man. Thus success followed, and his lifestyle was utterly irrelevant.

My point, no one really gives a monkeys and this never ending attempt at differentiation is just distraction from being a good human that does the best they can.

I have very fond memories about him I was wayward back then. He was the only one who pushed me but he was like that with all his pupils. He was a good teacher and I appreciated that I left with a GCSE.

TakeHimHomeandCallHimClark · 18/04/2023 21:03

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 21:24

I worked with someone recently who said they were a pan/poly asexual bi-romantic.
She's young, like 23/24. And has aspergers.
She described her boyfriend - who's also interested in all genders (pan), having multiple 'partners ( poly) but asexual so no sex, and bi-romantic which means they go on dates, hold hands do stuff together.
So friends, basically. They are friends, and are open to having more friends.

I managed not to say - I think you're a closeted lesbian coming to terms with your sexuality, and as soon as you see the right girl you'll realise that...

Oh god, that sounds very like autistic DS's 'girlfriend', although I think the exact term was demisexual panromantic.

I'm afraid I went for 'sounds like she's not actually interested, sweetheart', but I never was a tactful person.

Vitriolinsanity · 18/04/2023 20:49

@Humanbiology but was he strict because he was gay, or simply because he was a good teacher who happened to be gay?

My ex-boss a gay. Very difficult in 90's City Investment Banking, but he's a phenomenal mind that happens to be a gay man. Thus success followed, and his lifestyle was utterly irrelevant.

My point, no one really gives a monkeys and this never ending attempt at differentiation is just distraction from being a good human that does the best they can.

JarByTheDoor · 18/04/2023 19:17

It's an interesting number to have chosen, for this number-of-genders meme that's been going around for quite a while with the number 72, specifically, attached to it. If you look at the number 72 on Wikipedia, it's a number with a lot of religious meanings and connotations, especially in the Abrahamic religions. 74, for example, has no religious meanings listed. I don't know if it's anything more than a vague attraction towards numbers that already feel familiar or important, or something about the number 72 that just feels nice, but it's kind of interesting to me, anyway.

Dracuuule · 18/04/2023 19:02

Sexuality is simple. You re attracted to opposite sex, same sex, both or neither.

Gender seems to be based on how you feel as a person. So this could actually be infinite. It could be the 100 genders but then it may be permutations of them or ratios of combinations and maybe your interpretation of what it feels like to be a cake isn't the same as mine.
I might a coffee cake in the morning because I feel perky, energetic and robust but become a small fairy cake that someone forgot to put baking agents in by the end of the day Sad

heathspeedwell · 18/04/2023 18:43

If they were being taught about star signs then there might just be a tiny bit of reason behind it. I don't believe in horoscopes, but for example, a child born in July is likely to be one of the youngest in their year at school which may have a very slight influence on their life.

But this 72 genders idea (in fact there are over 100 genders according to the BBC) is so daft I can't think of any reasonable rationale behind it. Can anyone please explain why they believe there are so many genders and why children need to be taught about it?

JudgeRudy · 18/04/2023 17:31

Posters have correctly pointed out that some of the descriptors mentioned aren't even genders, they describe sexuality.

The way I'm looking at it is comparing sexuality to say hair colour. Most people would be a blonde or a brunette but to different degrees, then there's also a few 'bit different' gingers. However if you were to describe your own hair you might say I'm mostly a mid brown with red undertones...So Chestnut? Well kinda, but in the summer or when it's just been washed it's very red, almost ginger. Oh, but it looks pretty mid brown today. Yeah, I think I've got a grey coming through too.
I'm a natural brunette, pretty dark (9/10) but I'm grey in patches so have coloured it dark blonde. If I wear a pony tail it's pretty light, darker roots show if it's down

So everyone could give a very specific way about how they identify. I'm sure you could easily find 100 hair types.

MushMonster · 18/04/2023 17:01

I am made of more than 50% cake. That is a factual fact, it can easily be proven lol! 100% cake gendered! It has taken me years to find my niche amonst humans!

It has gone crazy and if it is, or is fastly evolving, into being a personal interpretation, how you feel, then there is no point on gender. I find that sad because I thought it was nice to make people who do not want to be referred to as he or she feel included and recognised. But since the appearance of this cis term that they throw around I think it has gone downhill, quickly!

Dracuuule · 18/04/2023 15:59

That Cakegender reminded me of Shrek and ogres being like an onion with all those layers.
Is this all it is? Trying to describe what it feels like to be a human being?
Why does it need to labelled as something specific? We all feel like this. No one is especially special.

Verv · 18/04/2023 15:11

BenCoopersSupportWren · 18/04/2023 15:00

LGB = sexual orientations
T = identity based on gendered stereotypes
Q = historically a slur thrown at gay and lesbian people; now a label claimed by mostly straight people who think being 'heteronormative' is the worst insult imaginable

This.

I miss goths, as an aside. They were at least based in material reality.

BenCoopersSupportWren · 18/04/2023 15:00

LGB = sexual orientations
T = identity based on gendered stereotypes
Q = historically a slur thrown at gay and lesbian people; now a label claimed by mostly straight people who think being 'heteronormative' is the worst insult imaginable

EmpressaurusOfCats · 18/04/2023 14:42

There’s a big difference between being LGB & being TQ+.

Being gay is all about same sex attraction, being T is all about prioritising gender.

I came out during section 28 too & I’d say that the gender ideology movement, led over here by Stonewall and Mermaids, is trying very hard to stop the ‘promotion of homosexuality’ once more - even Thatcher at her worst didn’t push for gender non-conforming, probably LGB kids to be given dangerous drugs to stop their growth and eventually have surgery to make their bodies resemble the opposite sex.

See also cotton ceiling.

Ersorrywhatnow · 18/04/2023 10:39

Loads of teachers are gay. I know so many. Same as the NHS,
loads of LGBTQ people,Always has been.

OP posts:
Humanbiology · 18/04/2023 09:12

I had a gay teacher at school and he was very strict with us. I thanked him on my last day of school because he was the only teacher who pushed me.

Ersorrywhatnow · 18/04/2023 08:17

I also support the age appropriate teaching of LGBTQ + relationships etc in the PHSE curriculum - I’m not one of those people who think gay teachers shouldn’t be seen as role models and should hide their personal life completely from pupils.
Section 28 made my life growing up gay very, very difficult

OP posts:
Ersorrywhatnow · 18/04/2023 08:03

I have no idea why anyone would think this didn’t happen. I’m gay, part of the LGBTQ +’community and generally supportive of trans rights.
What would be the point of making this up??

OP posts:
Merangutan · 17/04/2023 22:45

Sex, gender and sexuality are entirely different things which need defining clearly and accurately, not jumbled up so that ‘bisexual’ is defined as a type of gender and god knows what other confusing nonsense the pupils have been told. YANBU.

Itwasnaeme · 17/04/2023 22:20

LumpyPumpkin · 17/04/2023 19:56

This didn't happen.

I don't know if what happened in the OP is true, but I've no reason to disbelieve it since I've seen it in a classroom myself

SpringCherryTrees · 17/04/2023 22:07

Yes I guess a lot of kids have their own stable framework which they judge with.

My DS is very vulnerable, he hasn’t got many ‘frameworks’ in his own head and would likely take 72 genders very factually and literally. Which is why I am more concerned than most I think about ideologies (any of them, religion, trans or otherwise) being presented as facts.

Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 21:52

I asked DS what he thought. He said he didn't think there's 72 genders. I said I agreed. And that was that really.

OP posts:
Ersorrywhatnow · 17/04/2023 21:51

'If a teacher of say Maths are using that to squeeze in their beliefs about gender then that is a serious breach of trust in their responsibility as a teacher.'

This was in the Philosophy & Ethics class - it covers all sorts and is compulsory until they leave school. It wasn't PHSE - that's done separately.
And this isn't the usual Phil teachers which is why I think Ash was given this lesson to teach because of their personal experience

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 17/04/2023 21:49

LumpyPumpkin · 17/04/2023 19:56

This didn't happen.

What do you mean? My dd had similar in year 7. It was during lockdown in a 2 part video during form. I watched the 2nd half and wrote to the school about it.

Mummyoflittledragon · 17/04/2023 21:46

LangClegsInSpace · 17/04/2023 19:20

Shay Woulahan and Hannah Berrelli did a really good talk at LGB Alliance about the origins of the bajillionty genders

Thank you for posting this. It is incredibly interesting and depressing.

VestaTilley · 17/04/2023 21:41

YANBU. Please tell DS that what he was told was wrong. There are two sexes, and no genders. Gender and sex don’t mean the same thing, and there is no such thing as innate gender ideology.

Please complain to the Head and Governors, ask to see the PSHE materials and report to Ofsted. The DfE are undertaking a review of PSHE education on this very topic- they’re looking for this exact sort of evidence. I’d hit the ceiling if my DS was taught this kind of rubbish.

Newnamenewname109870 · 17/04/2023 21:40

saythebellsofstclements · 17/04/2023 21:37

Someone posted this link further up:
https://72gender.com/72-genders-list/

It's absobloodylutely ridiculous. 90% of them sound like the same thing. It's word salad.

Omg this is horrendous! How come someone seriously be teaching that? It really makes no sense and actually ridicules the reality of what trans people feel. Ffs. No wonder it’s become such a mess of a movement.

Swipe left for the next trending thread