Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that if it was France & French no one would care about a name change but because it’s Welsh…

442 replies

Letshaveablackcelebration2022 · 17/04/2023 13:18

Welsh is trending on Twitter because a lot of people don’t like the fact that the Brecon Beacons will revert to its Welsh name https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/apr/17/brecon-beacons-relaunches-with-welsh-name-bannau-brycheiniog-as-picture-of-hope-for-future

People also kicked off when Snowdon also reverted to its Welsh name Yr Wyddfa

Aibu to really not understand the issue. I am Welsh and a Welsh speaker. It makes sense to me to call place names by their Welsh names and not by their anglicised versions if you want to protect a language and culture. Which we do.

Noone would bat an eyelid if in France their decided to only use French names. We drive in France and get by without English alternatives. So what exactly is the problem with Wales doing the same?

Brecon Beacons national park renamed Bannau Brycheiniog in Welsh language move

National park also ditches fiery logo as it embarks on plan to tackle climate and biodiversity crisis

https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/apr/17/brecon-beacons-relaunches-with-welsh-name-bannau-brycheiniog-as-picture-of-hope-for-future

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Mostar · 17/04/2023 21:22

No problem with this whatsoever. I also like those bilingual roadsigns you get in parts of Scotland. More of this kind of thing.

Stellaroses · 17/04/2023 21:21

EsmeSusanOgg · 17/04/2023 20:49

1998 was 10 years ago... Right? I am not a fan of how old I am now!

And dim problem. I was just clarifying.

🙂

GogLais · 17/04/2023 21:16

@ChristinaXYZ , Sturnip posted that the Welsh Not did not die completely until ...

ChristinaXYZ · 17/04/2023 21:12

Sturnip · 17/04/2023 20:54

But the oppression of the Welsh language is far more modern - for the use of the Welsh Not didn’t die out completely until the early 20th century, for example.

Sorry, confused, Welsh died out completely? When?

I am also unsure, if you think historic oppression is something worth investing in emotionally, where the cut off date is?

And I say this as someone who broadly supports the change. I support the supporting of Welsh and Gaelic too in Scotland and Manx in the lsle of Man. Just not the stupid top down reasoning for this particular change and not if the locals don't actually want it.

"The name change had not been included in the months-long consultation on the park's new management plan, which includes the planting of one million trees.

Jodie Bond, from the National Park authority, said the decision to use the Welsh name had come from “organic” discussions among the management."

I know John Humphries has written pointing out the lack of local choice over this matter. Frankly - this is a kind of present-time colonialism. Pushing the culture of the usual elite onto everyone else. I am also pretty sure the head of the National Park is actually English. Might be wrong, but I think so.

I really don't support the Marxist spread of the oppression Olympics. It is devisive, pointless and often based on poor history because it is promulgated by people who don't have any real history knowledge or because a professional historian is fully signed up to a political view point. ie the English academic running the Brecon Beacons National Park (whilst doing loads of other jobs in England I think) pushes uncanvased name change on Welsh population because it fits various ideological agendas shared in the UK wide cultural sector as imported from the US.

That more recent for you?

Pieceofpurplesky · 17/04/2023 21:12

It's just having the proper names assigned. Like the signposts in N Wales were changed to reflect this Conway/Conwy Mold/Yr Wyddgrug etc.

I am on the border and speak the odd bit of Welsh as my cousin (who lived a mile away) was taught at school.
The language and heritage should be celebrated. It's not woke or difficult to understand.

Sturnip · 17/04/2023 20:54

ChristinaXYZ · 17/04/2023 20:22

Frankly people in power fought other people in power for the right to oppress those without any power. Same all over the country not just in Wales. The Harrying of the North for example.

Medieval Wales was proably as feudal as England. The ordinary Welsh would have known little difference who ever was in charge. If their princes had not been fighting the English then they would have been fighting each other and harrassing the populations that dared to support the loser. That's how the middle ages worked. There were no liberal democracies.

The Anglo-saxons lost their language (languages) over-time* too because the Nromans turned up and insisted on speaking Norman French at court and legislatively. And no doubt the average chap in the street (lane, avenue, road, gate?? no language is more welcoming to new words than English) in Yorkshire of Lincolnshire would have felt colonially oppressed too had he had the benefit of a 21 st century postcolonial education in the victimhood Olympics.

If anyone is interested "After the Norman Conquest of 1066, it took more than three centuries for English to oust French as the language of government. The parliament of 1362 was opened with a speech in English by the chancellor and then, in the early 15th century, Henry V became the first king since Anglo-Saxon times to use English in his written instructions." And of course Middle english (that came after Anglo-Saxon) is not the same as Anglo-Saxon very much a 'new' language. https://www.bl.uk/learning/timeline/item126569.html

But the oppression of the Welsh language is far more modern - for the use of the Welsh Not didn’t die out completely until the early 20th century, for example.

EsmeSusanOgg · 17/04/2023 20:49

Stellaroses · 17/04/2023 20:20

I didn’t say you had, I was simply glad to hear there was demand.
as for Cardiff, the 3rd WM secondary opened around 2013/13, but the 2nd opened in 1998. As I said 4th opening in September (though this is a bilingual school so slightly different- though incidentally I happen to think bilinguals are the way forwards) So a nice gradual increase which I hope will continue.

1998 was 10 years ago... Right? I am not a fan of how old I am now!

And dim problem. I was just clarifying.

GogLais · 17/04/2023 20:48

@KnickerlessParsons , iog makes a yog sound. The way you explain it, the Brycheiniog would be said as Brych-ei-NI-og, and I am Welsh enough to know it isn't.
ei does not sound like eye.
au no english equivalent and eye is probably the nearest approximation.

EsmeSusanOgg · 17/04/2023 20:48

GogLais · 17/04/2023 20:23

Oh. thanks @EsmeSusanOgg , that is really nice of you, and I'm so pleased to find you so supportive of your son.
I remember DC1 as a little child, not fluent in English but speaking to another child who spoke no Welsh, and just kept going making up noises to fill any gaps, so my advice is to just use the English word or something, but keep going. You'll get your confidence and you'll probably have a willing teacher.

Ha! He does like teaching me things. :)

EsmeSusanOgg · 17/04/2023 20:47

GogLais · 17/04/2023 20:27

@EsmeSusanOgg , my name is a play on words. Gog because I am from the north and Lais (llais is voice). Goglais is a word - oh well, it tickles me anyway. Wink

It is a good name :)

KnickerlessParsons · 17/04/2023 20:40

GogLais · 17/04/2023 20:17

@KnickerlessParsons , that isn't how I'd say it. It's not too bad as an approximation, but if you aren't familiar with Welsh intonation, you won't get that the stress in on the 'Ban' and the 'ein'. The einiog is nearer ayn-yog than eye-nee-og, otherwise the stress would fall on the 'nee', which it doesn't.

The au, ei and io are diphthongs.

Ban-eye Bruch-eye-nee-og

The "bruch" is difficult to explain. U as in umbrella. Ch as in loch is the best I can do ( but depends on how you pronounce loch)

Au and eye are pronounced the same way (unless you're Welsh enough to hear the difference).

Whether io is a dipthong or not it's ee-o.

GogLais · 17/04/2023 20:27

@EsmeSusanOgg , my name is a play on words. Gog because I am from the north and Lais (llais is voice). Goglais is a word - oh well, it tickles me anyway. Wink

GogLais · 17/04/2023 20:23

Oh. thanks @EsmeSusanOgg , that is really nice of you, and I'm so pleased to find you so supportive of your son.
I remember DC1 as a little child, not fluent in English but speaking to another child who spoke no Welsh, and just kept going making up noises to fill any gaps, so my advice is to just use the English word or something, but keep going. You'll get your confidence and you'll probably have a willing teacher.

ChristinaXYZ · 17/04/2023 20:22

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 17/04/2023 16:27

Colonist mindset so deeply ingrained. Most English people have no idea about the history of Britain, oppression of the Welsh and Irish etc etc. It's not taught in schools for a reason. Just the world wars where we can be painted in a good light, and the Romans so we can glory in empire.

Frankly people in power fought other people in power for the right to oppress those without any power. Same all over the country not just in Wales. The Harrying of the North for example.

Medieval Wales was proably as feudal as England. The ordinary Welsh would have known little difference who ever was in charge. If their princes had not been fighting the English then they would have been fighting each other and harrassing the populations that dared to support the loser. That's how the middle ages worked. There were no liberal democracies.

The Anglo-saxons lost their language (languages) over-time* too because the Nromans turned up and insisted on speaking Norman French at court and legislatively. And no doubt the average chap in the street (lane, avenue, road, gate?? no language is more welcoming to new words than English) in Yorkshire of Lincolnshire would have felt colonially oppressed too had he had the benefit of a 21 st century postcolonial education in the victimhood Olympics.

If anyone is interested "After the Norman Conquest of 1066, it took more than three centuries for English to oust French as the language of government. The parliament of 1362 was opened with a speech in English by the chancellor and then, in the early 15th century, Henry V became the first king since Anglo-Saxon times to use English in his written instructions." And of course Middle english (that came after Anglo-Saxon) is not the same as Anglo-Saxon very much a 'new' language. https://www.bl.uk/learning/timeline/item126569.html

English: language of government

https://www.bl.uk/learning/timeline/item126569.html

Stellaroses · 17/04/2023 20:20

EsmeSusanOgg · 17/04/2023 20:10

I've not disputed the demand. I've actually said that demand outstrips available schools in many areas.

I've also said that until relatively recently, there were substantially fewer Welsh medium schools. If, until the last decade, there was one one Welsh medium secondary school in the capital city of Wales, I can well believe that other towns and cities have been less well served in terms of access to Welsh medium education.

To another poster, who said the new secondary Welsh medium school was undersubscribed in their areas, that is not unusual for any brand new school. It takes a few years - especially as secondary level - for demand to ramp up. It's better to assess demand for a secondary school once it has been established for over 10 years.

I didn’t say you had, I was simply glad to hear there was demand.
as for Cardiff, the 3rd WM secondary opened around 2013/13, but the 2nd opened in 1998. As I said 4th opening in September (though this is a bilingual school so slightly different- though incidentally I happen to think bilinguals are the way forwards) So a nice gradual increase which I hope will continue.

GogLais · 17/04/2023 20:17

@KnickerlessParsons , that isn't how I'd say it. It's not too bad as an approximation, but if you aren't familiar with Welsh intonation, you won't get that the stress in on the 'Ban' and the 'ein'. The einiog is nearer ayn-yog than eye-nee-og, otherwise the stress would fall on the 'nee', which it doesn't.

The au, ei and io are diphthongs.

EsmeSusanOgg · 17/04/2023 20:17

GogLais · 17/04/2023 20:11

@EsmeSusanOgg , I am not familiar with the courses. When I have looked at any out of curiosity, I find that the colloquial language wouldn't make much sense to me. I'd need to see how it is structured.
I'd teach something like 'I am ...' is Yr ydwyf fi... but you might in conversation say or hear Rwyf i... or Dwi...
and 'I am not...' is 'Nid ydwyf fi ddim yn ... but in conversation Nid ydwi'n.. or Dwi ddim yn ...^
That might just be how my mind works though and I do speak a few languages.

@chaivanilla , Brecon Beacons was a made up name, but I agree that it has a nice ring to it, because of the alliteration. The name is pretty meaningless though.

That makes a lot more sense to me, if I'm honest.

I always feel under-served by my Welsh education (English medium schools though my primary was initially billingual/ duel entry then changed to English medium). I can follow conversations with Welsh speakers, but often feel awkward joining in! That's mostly a confidence issue in fairness. I'm brushing up a lot at the moment to help my little boy, who is reception age. My DH is English, but grew up abroad. So speaks bits of several languages... But not Welsh.

GogLais · 17/04/2023 20:11

@EsmeSusanOgg , I am not familiar with the courses. When I have looked at any out of curiosity, I find that the colloquial language wouldn't make much sense to me. I'd need to see how it is structured.
I'd teach something like 'I am ...' is Yr ydwyf fi... but you might in conversation say or hear Rwyf i... or Dwi...
and 'I am not...' is 'Nid ydwyf fi ddim yn ... but in conversation Nid ydwi'n.. or Dwi ddim yn ...^
That might just be how my mind works though and I do speak a few languages.

@chaivanilla , Brecon Beacons was a made up name, but I agree that it has a nice ring to it, because of the alliteration. The name is pretty meaningless though.

EsmeSusanOgg · 17/04/2023 20:10

Stellaroses · 17/04/2023 19:58

Just proves that demand for Welsh medium ed is growing, doesn’t it? Good job more are being planned and built.
Prior to the opening of the other 2 Welsh secondaries, pupils wanting WM ed travelled by bus to Gartholwg and Llanhari.

I assume @Horrace is referring to Newport. There they are aeveral years behind, with oupils travelling to Gwynllyw for their WM ed.

I've not disputed the demand. I've actually said that demand outstrips available schools in many areas.

I've also said that until relatively recently, there were substantially fewer Welsh medium schools. If, until the last decade, there was one one Welsh medium secondary school in the capital city of Wales, I can well believe that other towns and cities have been less well served in terms of access to Welsh medium education.

To another poster, who said the new secondary Welsh medium school was undersubscribed in their areas, that is not unusual for any brand new school. It takes a few years - especially as secondary level - for demand to ramp up. It's better to assess demand for a secondary school once it has been established for over 10 years.

KnickerlessParsons · 17/04/2023 20:09

I don't have a problem with it.
But I would like to know how the names are pronounced!

Ban-eye Bruch-eye-nee-og

The ch is gutteral, like in loch.

Lanadelfrey · 17/04/2023 20:07

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/04/2023 19:34

Derailment alert

In a word, Westminster.

Since 2014, Scotland has elected a government who's core message is independence and key manifes pledge is to hold another referendum 5 times (3 UK and 2 Scottish elections).

Yet we've never had another referendum cause Westminster say no. Wales could try electing a pro independence government but they'll still need England's say so to hold a vote to leave.

I know unionists really struggle with this cause "will of the people" and all that (but only when it suits you of course).

One of the main reasons the SNP have remained in power (apart from their coalition with the equally loathsome Greens) is that there isn’t another viable party to vote for. Labour capitulated, no one would vote for the tories in great numbers and the Lib Dems are an irrelevance but even then, more people voted for them combined than voted SNP in the last Scottish election. So, why should we have another indy ref when the majority of the electorate voted for unionist parties?

Apologies for derailing.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/04/2023 20:06

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/04/2023 19:42

We had the will of the people. We voted no.

The SNP are corrupt and have done no end of damage. Support for independence has declined rapidly. It's over. For the time being anyway.

In 2014 we did. Haven't been allowed a say since despite electing a pro independence party at every election since. Is that not the "will of the people"?

Whether the SNP are corrupt is neither here nor there when if comes to independence. They happen to be the only party willing to stand for Scotland's right to self-determination so unfortunately we have little option on who to vote for. Oh any damage they have done pails into insignificance when compared to what the tories have done, unless you count paying teachers/nurses/public servants etc more than rUK damage?

But I guess we'll see where we stand come 24. Maybe Wales will join us and we can both escape from the collapsing union before it completely destroys us.

mathanxiety · 17/04/2023 20:01

Tarantullah · 17/04/2023 18:07

Do you mean it's not like England? It is like the UK because the UK encompasses the countries you mention with their own identities.

The reality is I suspect most people aren't bothered at all, they'll continue to refer to it how they please. The ones vocal about it either just wait for a reason to pounce or are doing so on principle.

My DH is Welsh and when we were dating I learnt a bit of welsh- I'm absolutely not fluent but I'm conversational; turns out none of his family speak it anyway. I'm glad I learnt it but still...

Just a point of information here - Ireland isn't a part of the UK.

ChristinaXYZ · 17/04/2023 20:00

Naunet · 17/04/2023 13:39

No one with a brain really cares OP, but I would suggest those same people you see being outraged over this, WOULD also object if it was French. There’s always a few.

Why do people do this - say those that don't agree with them have no brain?

Welsh is an important part of the culture of the British Isles and the Welsh are rightly proud of it. But some Welsh people who do not speak Welsh do talk of layers of prejudice in Welsh society to the Welsh without Welsh. An example I know of being a large cultural organisation (very large) suddenly deciding its annual address should be given in Welsh. Many English people also work for this orgnaisation. The person next due to give the address was actaully born and brought up in Wales yards from the head quarters but is Welsh without Welsh. He was furious - said he was made to feel like he was not really Welsh in his own home town. The Brecon Beacons is not in a strong Welsh language area I believe.

The change is a political act on all kinds of levels so some will react politically.

I don't disagree with the change as a such but it is probably another example of political change being forced from above, of people in an arts or cultural orgnaisation doing the nanny knows best thing - was there any local campaign to change it with any indication of wide spread support for example?

Another factor pointing to this being a political act is this:

"Catherine Mealing-Jones, the chief executive of Brecon Beacons National Park, said: “We’re an environmental organisation. We’re trying to cut carbon and push to net zero. So, having a carbon burning beacon just isn’t a good look."

It is an incredible stupid justification and clearly the worst kind of virtue signalling. As though beacons anywhere in the UK have ever been a serious cause of climate issues or that they are anything other than occasional and historic. It just makes the management of the park look stupid.

As I say I think if (if??) there is local support why not change the name but I certainly don't think those complaining have 'no brain'. On a slightly side note I do think there is a strong argument for Welsh being taught in English schools - that would help people in England come away with the pronunciation at least and provide support for an important language.

Stellaroses · 17/04/2023 19:58

EsmeSusanOgg · 17/04/2023 19:51

It's not that small a city. According to Census 2021 the population was 362,400.

For years there was just Glantaf for secondary education. In terms of primary schools, I know of 6 different sets of parents with children who lived virtually on top of the Welsh medium primary school who did not get places for their reception aged children. Especially an issue in Whitchurch.

Just proves that demand for Welsh medium ed is growing, doesn’t it? Good job more are being planned and built.
Prior to the opening of the other 2 Welsh secondaries, pupils wanting WM ed travelled by bus to Gartholwg and Llanhari.

I assume @Horrace is referring to Newport. There they are aeveral years behind, with oupils travelling to Gwynllyw for their WM ed.