Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most blended family situations are unhappy

586 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 17/04/2023 08:30

From my experience of many decades as a secondary school tutor, I would say most of the time when children talk about step parents, there is tension and misery ( from the children's point of view, not necessarily the parents)

I am going to say 75% of situations are unhappy, by which I mean most of the children are somewhat unhappy, or one or more child is very unhappy, or the situation breaks down because of parent or child unhappiness. Breakdown could mean the relationship between parents breaks down, or the relationship between a child and step parent breaks down to the extent a teen becomes homeless, or moves out

So to answer this, you probably need to know at least 4 blended family situations reasonably well, yours as a child, parent, or other people's.

I am expecting that some parents will vote that it is happy, when that isn't accurate, as I am aware this is quite common, and the child has a very different feeling than the parent.

However, I will be pleased if I cam completely wrong about this, and lots mare happy! I just dont see it in teaching.

YABU - less than 75% are unhappy
YANBU - 75% or more are unhappy

OP posts:
VWHoliday · 18/04/2023 12:05

daughtersanathlete · 18/04/2023 11:57

Thank you both.

But I want to hear from @Nimbostratus100 what s/he thinks. They’re the one who started this judgemental thread.

I guess they aren't coming back but are probably still reading.

You sound like a fabulous Mum.

aSofaNearYou · 18/04/2023 12:05

@DryYourEyesWeepingWillow The issue I was describing is not unique to parents - it's not really anything to do with parents. It's unaffordable for anybody to live in a house without two incomes, in many cases. Taxes on parents are not the cause of that, housing is just generally too expensive.

The government are not going to suddenly completely change the economy to make it affordable for individuals to comfortably live alone just to stop step parents needing to move in, this would be a complete overhaul of our entire society. It is built around the assumption that couples will pool resources.

I'm glad you say you can see why others will be tempted. But in your previous comment, you didn't. At that point, you blithely said that you couldn't understand the "obsession" with cohabiting.

daughtersanathlete · 18/04/2023 12:00

children are unhappy in blended families. That is the premise of this thread

my kids are unhappy because they’re in a blended family. What can I do about that? What does the op expect me to have done? My kids were unhappy when I was with their dad. Was I supposed to stay in a terrible relationship where the kids were unhappy?

at least as things stand I can control what happens in MY home. I couldn’t do that when I was with my ex as it was his home too and I certainly don’t get to control what my ex did or does in his new life.

VWHoliday · 18/04/2023 11:59

@DryYourEyesWeepingWillow Do you think you'll ever live with someone when the children are older? If not that's fine of course as long as you have friends and family. When the children are older they will be living their own lives and will worry about you as they won't want you be lonely and then feel guilty.

I know when my DH was ill it gave my SC happiness knowing that he had me.

daughtersanathlete · 18/04/2023 11:57

Thank you both.

But I want to hear from @Nimbostratus100 what s/he thinks. They’re the one who started this judgemental thread.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 18/04/2023 11:56

@daughtersanathlete you have no control over what the other parent has done. I don't think anybody has said people should stay in a disfunctional and damaging relationship. Then your DC would be living in an unhappy situation 100% of the time. As it was, they had you and a stable and secure and undisrupted home with you. One good parent and home where they feel safe and secure is sufficient for most people to be ok. As they grow older then they generally choose to spend most time there. I don't see any comments that are blaming parents like you for the choices you ex has made and neither will your children. The worst problems generally occur when both parents do this to a child and introduce new partners/ step siblings/ have more children so the original children feel they have no safe space at all and don't belong anywhere anymore.

funinthesun19 · 18/04/2023 11:56

daughtersanathlete · 18/04/2023 11:29

@funinthesun19 I’ve very carefully not blended with my new partner. I didn’t date until my kids were grown up. I thought I did everything right. And yet here’s a thread on here to judge me for something I have ZERO control over (my ex getting a new partner and blending).

it’s really upset me. I don’t understand why the op isn’t taking into account that my kids would’ve been unhappy if I’d stayed with their dad. And why s/he is not answering the questions I’ve asked about this. It’s goady and judgemental and I can only hope she doesn’t teach in any of the schools my kids attended.

I did my fucking best for my kids. And yet. It’s not good enough. Can’t find a stick to beat you with so let’s try this one.

it’s horrible.

No you absolutely shouldn’t have stayed with him just to avoid any potential stepparents entering your children’s lives. I can’t believe someone would actually think that, given how many children live in toxic households where one or both parents are making the children’s lives miserable. Better for the children to have at least one stable home with one parent than no stable home at all.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 18/04/2023 11:49

I think this is quite a simplistic reply. I'm not saying people should move in together purely because of finances, but it is a natural, socially normalised endgame for couple's that are happy and settled together and would happily cohabit, and part of that will be because pooling resources is the most sensible way of affording to live in our economy. House prices are not compatible with single incomes.

Something being normalised socially is not a rational or good reason to do it, particularly when plenty of robust evidence exists that it is likely to be a bad choice with more negative outcomes for children. There is no reason a relationship has to involve co-habiting. In fact that is a social norm that on the whole disadvantages women more than men in the long run on average, so I see nothing wrong with challenging this assumption. Yes the economics are tricky. But as I said this is largely due to the UK system of tax which is an outlier internationally. Most tax systems in comparable countries do not penalise single people or single parents in the way the UK system does because they recognise that this is counterproductive, increases child poverty and is more expensive for taxpayers in the long run. So the focus should be on fixing that IMO, to bring us in line with international approaches that have been proven to work and then there would be less pressure on people to make relationship choices based on finances which is obviously not going to end well in many cases.

Single parents will be in the position where they are having to forsake that social norm in order to ensure their children don't have to live with a step parent, and as such, quite likely expose themselves and their child to a lot of financial hardship they are aware could be avoided. A decision will be made. For many that will be that cohabiting with a trusted partner or spouse is better than the alternative they are living with.

As above, this is entirely within the gift of us as voters to pressure our political representatives to fix. If our tax system didn't disadvantage single adult - and particularly single parent - households (deliberately in my view, but also no pressure to fix it from other women despite 90% of single parent households being led by women, how depressing) then finances would be less of a factor in decisions, child poverty would be reduced, children being exposed to unsuitable partners reduced and associated abuse/ DV, and the cost to the taxpayer over the long term would be lower. That's why other countries don't design their systems this way, because the outcomes for everyone are worse and as you say it creates peverse incentives. So yes I understand the motivations you are describing caused by financial pressures but the answer IMO is to campaign for changes to the tax system to change that penalisation of single parents, not to encourage them to move partners in with their children for financially motivated reasons.

I get why people wouldn't make that choice, but find it a bit privileged when people go on about how they simply can't fathom why people might be attracted to the idea of living together.

Obviously having double our income and double the hours per day to work/ care for kids would make my life much easier! But given the other factors, it's not a risk/ compromise I'm prepared to make nevertheless. As I've said I can see why others make a different choice. Ideally we'd want people to be able to make choices forcusing on the factors that are about their DC's happiness and safety rather than money, so again the answer to that is to fix the tax system rather than try to justify people ignoring the evidence of impacts on children for financial reasons when that is something that can be fixed, in a fair way, simply by levelling the playing field for single parents with two parent households.

daughtersanathlete · 18/04/2023 11:40

Sometimes, you know, there’s no perfect choice.

I couldn’t engineer a situation that would have made my kids happy.

I went with the least worst option.

I can’t control what my ex does or did.

how was I supposed to square the circle ?

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 18/04/2023 11:33

Conversely, the people I know raised by single mothers who didn't co-habit again are mostly well-adjusted and happy adults. The men who grew up in these families are mostly huge feminists. 😊 I know maybe 8 or 9 people well who were raised for most of their childhood by single mothers, never a new partner moving in. One struggles still with mental health immensely, but that's (IMO) because of being in a house with domestic violence until they were 9 when their mother finally left the father. The others are all now happy, well adjusted. Three have decided to remain child-free but two of those have been married for years, very happy. One decided to remain single and has never pursued relationships at all, but has a very successful career and is minted, travelling all over the place. The rest settled down with family lives like most people do. Only one has divorced so far so less than in my general population of friends, as a percentage, and a lower percentage even when compared only to those with nuclear families throughtout childhood. The one who has divorced has decided to remaim single while their children grow up.

Again, not a statistical sample by any means but a pattern I've seen from my experience: better outcomes. Closer relationships with their parents, happier lives and better mental health as adults. And again, roughly matches what you see in statistical studies in proper academic research on the topic and long-term outcomes.

I found @Eggpie's comments illuminating, seeing it from the perspective of a social worker.

I think everybody is trying to do their best for their children (with a few very distressing exceptions, like we read about in the news). But I do think some of the judgements made would be different if people were fully aware of the risks involved in different approaches and the statistical likelihood of different outcomes for the children involved - not just the risk of abuse which is significant and important but clearly not going to happen in the majority of cases - but the likely mental health impacts and impact on the chances of happy relationships and outcomes in adult life. Childhood experiences affect people's lifes immensely, and I think many parents do underestimate this: saying children are "resilient" (or should be), will "adapt" etc. And they may well seem to. But often, they don't or can't or it makes them very unhappy.

In many cases it sounds like it does work well and even enhance the children's lives. But I do find the refusal of some posters to accept that these are not the majority - despite the research - depressing. Especially the belief that if you're careful and slow about doing it then it's safe and will be fine, or if you listen to your children and commit that if they statw they're unhappy or you witness anything unkind or abusive you'll end it is a robust safeguard. In most cases it may be, but if you do this realistically you have to accept that in some cases it won't be: you would never know what is happening or the damage being done until it's far too late.

We all have to make our own choices and life is imperfect but refusing to accept that you are exposing your children to higher risks by "blending families" - whether those are risks of abuse or mental health damage - is dishonest. You may be lucky and it works out fine, but denying the research showing that mostly the impact is negative, and that the risks of abuse are much, much higher and there's really nothing much you can do to prevent that if you go ahead with it, is denying reality.

I don't think anybody can judge anybody else's life, but we should all be fully informed of the risks and statistically likely outcomes of the risks we take and decisions we make, particularly when it involves DC. Even if that makes some adults feel uncomfortable.

daughtersanathlete · 18/04/2023 11:33

*date

daughtersanathlete · 18/04/2023 11:33

I should add. I was single for 15 years. I had fuck buddies and fwb scenarios but I didn’t dare at all until my youngest was (almost) an adult.

and yet. Oh woe is me. Kids in blended families aren’t happy.

well. Can someone please tell me what the fuck I was and am actually supposed to do about that?

daughtersanathlete · 18/04/2023 11:29

@funinthesun19 I’ve very carefully not blended with my new partner. I didn’t date until my kids were grown up. I thought I did everything right. And yet here’s a thread on here to judge me for something I have ZERO control over (my ex getting a new partner and blending).

it’s really upset me. I don’t understand why the op isn’t taking into account that my kids would’ve been unhappy if I’d stayed with their dad. And why s/he is not answering the questions I’ve asked about this. It’s goady and judgemental and I can only hope she doesn’t teach in any of the schools my kids attended.

I did my fucking best for my kids. And yet. It’s not good enough. Can’t find a stick to beat you with so let’s try this one.

it’s horrible.

funinthesun19 · 18/04/2023 11:24

daughtersanathlete · 18/04/2023 11:14

My kids, with me as a single parent, have had a better life (even with the blended family shit show) than they would have had if I’d stayed with their dad. Where’s that in this poll @Nimbostratus100 ?

Mine too! I’m 3 years single and I still wake up each day thinking thank fuck for that. I honestly dread to think what our lives would be like if I had stayed with their father.

It was a toxic, dysfunctional atmosphere created by him. He has an older child with his ex wife and absolutely not their fault, but the whole experience has put me off ever being a stepmum to young children again. So I shall stay single and concentrate on me and my own.

daughtersanathlete · 18/04/2023 11:14

My kids, with me as a single parent, have had a better life (even with the blended family shit show) than they would have had if I’d stayed with their dad. Where’s that in this poll @Nimbostratus100 ?

aSofaNearYou · 18/04/2023 11:11

Starting a new relationship or moving in with a partner for financial reasons is a terrible idea. Entangling finances is one reason so many people get trapped in miserable and even abusive relationships. The answer to this problem is to campaign for the UK to stop penalising single parents financially, not to move unrelated adults into your children's home.

I think this is quite a simplistic reply. I'm not saying people should move in together purely because of finances, but it is a natural, socially normalised endgame for couple's that are happy and settled together and would happily cohabit, and part of that will be because pooling resources is the most sensible way of affording to live in our economy. House prices are not compatible with single incomes.

Single parents will be in the position where they are having to forsake that social norm in order to ensure their children don't have to live with a step parent, and as such, quite likely expose themselves and their child to a lot of financial hardship they are aware could be avoided. A decision will be made. For many that will be that cohabiting with a trusted partner or spouse is better than the alternative they are living with.

I get why people wouldn't make that choice, but find it a bit privileged when people go on about how they simply can't fathom why people might be attracted to the idea of living together.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 18/04/2023 10:55

aSofaNearYou · 18/04/2023 10:47

I find the obsession with needing to move in together quite odd, personally

Clearly you've never struggled financially, then.

The vast majority of the single people I know live in house shares, and of all the couple's that live somewhere better than that, they need both incomes to afford it.

The pull towards living together is quite obvious if you're not rich enough to afford a home alone.

Starting a new relationship or moving in with a partner for financial reasons is a terrible idea. Entangling finances is one reason so many people get trapped in miserable and even abusive relationships. The answer to this problem is to campaign for the UK to stop penalising single parents financially, not to move unrelated adults into your children's home.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 18/04/2023 10:52

The other thing with statistics is that you can’t measure the other side.

So, how many of those who had unhappy blended family situations due to poor parenting would have been happier with their poor parent solo? Or with their poor parent and other biological parent?

Statistically my children, with a blended family, have apparently had a poorer quality childhood than me who lived with both their parents…

Whereas in reality my children (the step children in the mix are now adults) had a happy childhood where as being burned with an iron and starved was such a regular occurrence in my household I told my teacher about it in the way a normal child would tell their teacher what they had for tea…

I’d say the crucial statistic that gets missed a lot is poor or selfish parents. Shitty parents that have zero regard for their child’s well being don’t suddenly get better if they are, or stay, single.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 18/04/2023 10:52

What a silly reply ! Everyone runs into that danger , but the reality is most men will not pray in your children !! Pedophiles are not the majority of men and certainly not a huge part of step dads like you like to believe !! What utter nonsense .
The reality is they can be anywhere , men , women , a teacher in school , someone at church , a tutor , a friends dad , a grandparent .

My replies have all been respectful and I think to be honest that speaking to a victim of abuse in this way is not appropriate.

Your reply is the "silly" one here. Do not try to twist what I said, read it again.

I did not say "most men pray [sic] on children".

I did not say paedophiles are the majority of men, or a "huge part of step dads [sic]".

Of course they can be anywhere. But unsupervised access increases the chance of occurrence massively. And they will seek out opportunities for access so often target single mothers. This is a fact.

Moving an unrelated man into a child's home is statistically the most dangerous decision you can make as a parent. This is a fact. Not just in terms of paedophilia but also physical abuse. Research has shown this to be the case.

This isn't the only issue with it anyway, as I described in my other posts. But your comments about this are ill-informed I'm afraid. And highlighting a much increased risk and that fact that the parent would not be able to tell, so any false sense of security they may have due to knowing the person for a long time, or them being seemingly very nice to the children and the children liking them, etc, is exactly that: false.

aSofaNearYou · 18/04/2023 10:47

I find the obsession with needing to move in together quite odd, personally

Clearly you've never struggled financially, then.

The vast majority of the single people I know live in house shares, and of all the couple's that live somewhere better than that, they need both incomes to afford it.

The pull towards living together is quite obvious if you're not rich enough to afford a home alone.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 18/04/2023 10:44

VWHoliday · 18/04/2023 10:29

@DryYourEyesWeepingWillow I have just read your first post and I'm sorry you had such a bad time but this is not normal.

I can't believe you have 20 friends who have been through the same unless you met them at some therapy group of people who have been badly treated by step parents.

In my large circle I have no experience of people being treated like this.

Thank you. But no, I didn't mean to imply oir family situation was the normal outcome. Just an example of what can happen. The 20 or so friends whose parents divorced and remarried, sometimes with additional half/ step siblings and sometimes not, mostly did not experience the level of abuse we did, only one of them. The other 19 or so though were all varying degrees of unhappy and mental health impacts from the situation that persist into adulthood. Also impact on their lives in a practical sense as many left home earlier than they should have to escape the situation. Lots of unpleasant behaviour by step parents, making them feel unwanted or an inconveniece, being treated very differently to other unrelated/ half related siblings. Some nasty verbal abuse. So no, not implying of course that all step parents are physically and sexually abusive of course. However, the outcomes for the vast, vast majority of children were negative. Only one speaks positively about the blending and that happened when she was a very small child still (her mother died when she was a baby), her step mother happened to be a lovely woman and loved her, there were no other children before or afterwards.

Obviously this is not a statistical sample! But the studies done on the topic bear out that for the vast majority of children "blending" is a negative experience, particularly if additional children are in the mix/ created afterwards. And also that it massively increases the risk of child abuse and mental health issues.

So for me, it's absolutely not something I'd ever even contemplate. It's for me to live with the consequences of my decisions as an adult and bad judgements I made, even if that might be inconvenient or not what I'd ideally want. Not for my children who've already suffered as a result of me choosing a poor father for them to now potentially suffer more disruption or instability or emotional insecurity or higher risks of abuse etc (or me even to risk that) for my own preferences or gratification.

As I said above, and is clear from the stories here, sometimes it works out fine and is beneficial for the children. But the fact remains that in most cases it does not, and that when embarking on this you have absolutely no way of knowing no matter how careful you are and slowly you take it. So personally I just wouldn't. If I did want a relationship I could have one without involving them in it, so it's not either/ or, the comments about being a "martyr" are disingenuous in my view. It's perfectly possible to strike a balance and protect your children and keep home their stable santuary while having romantic relationships separately, if separated parents wish to do so.

GabriellaMontez · 18/04/2023 10:42

ZeroFuchsGiven · 18/04/2023 09:01

Honestly, the op is only here to goad, he/she/they like to drop bombs and watch people tear each other apart.

Considering on another thread she started she was a foster carer and brought troubled kids (including a burglar, who went on to burgle them)into her home with her kids, she has absolutely no ground to stand on judging others parenting. I wonder how happy her kids were with a single parent bringing different kids into their lives regularly.

I dont believe a word this poster says, on any thread EVER! Far too many similarities with another poster who happens to be banned.

True.

She's goady, biased and disingenuous.

She's claims this is a discussion, and infers that her experience makes her made up statistics scientific. Its anything but.

piratypotato · 18/04/2023 10:39

Nothingisblackandwhite · 18/04/2023 10:32

What a silly reply ! Everyone runs into that danger , but the reality is most men will not pray in your children !! Pedophiles are not the majority of men and certainly not a huge part of step dads like you like to believe !! What utter nonsense .
The reality is they can be anywhere , men , women , a teacher in school , someone at church , a tutor , a friends dad , a grandparent .

Of course its not most men, but you don't know which men it is. They don;t wear badges. Yes, it could be anyone anywhere, but its overwhelmingly likely to be in your own home.
We do know that paedophiles look to make opportunites, we know that they target single mothers with children the right age, we know its literally the most likely scenario of abuse.

Its nice for you if you don;t know much about this, but your naivity is not licence to call other people "silly" for talking sense.

Nothingisblackandwhite · 18/04/2023 10:32

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 18/04/2023 10:12

There comes a point when you have been with someone for 5/6 years, you have married them and they have proved time and again that they are a good and trustworthy person when you trust them implicitly with an older child.

I'm afraid this isn't true.

I'm not talking about your relationship or your particular partner's relationship with your son, as that may well be lovely as you say: this comment is about risk levels. And obviously a slower, more cautious approach is less risky than moving in random people you barely know.

However, many people think the above ^^ and that their children are safe and happy with an unrelated partner but have misjudged. And many such partners hide who they really are successfully for years while abusing children. Many people feel this certainty, that they've done everything "right" and the children are fine, only to be proved wrong. My mother was an example of this. This is why the statistics show that the kost dangerous thing you can do as a parent is move an unrelated man into their home. Of course that is not to say all step fathers are a risk, but like with male abuse and violence in general, you have no way to know which ones are a risk. They don't have a neon sign on their head, in fact they are very, very good at manipulating and pretending to be wonderful people. It's a very dangerous game to play with a child's safety.

What a silly reply ! Everyone runs into that danger , but the reality is most men will not pray in your children !! Pedophiles are not the majority of men and certainly not a huge part of step dads like you like to believe !! What utter nonsense .
The reality is they can be anywhere , men , women , a teacher in school , someone at church , a tutor , a friends dad , a grandparent .

VWHoliday · 18/04/2023 10:29

@DryYourEyesWeepingWillow I have just read your first post and I'm sorry you had such a bad time but this is not normal.

I can't believe you have 20 friends who have been through the same unless you met them at some therapy group of people who have been badly treated by step parents.

In my large circle I have no experience of people being treated like this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread