Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most blended family situations are unhappy

586 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 17/04/2023 08:30

From my experience of many decades as a secondary school tutor, I would say most of the time when children talk about step parents, there is tension and misery ( from the children's point of view, not necessarily the parents)

I am going to say 75% of situations are unhappy, by which I mean most of the children are somewhat unhappy, or one or more child is very unhappy, or the situation breaks down because of parent or child unhappiness. Breakdown could mean the relationship between parents breaks down, or the relationship between a child and step parent breaks down to the extent a teen becomes homeless, or moves out

So to answer this, you probably need to know at least 4 blended family situations reasonably well, yours as a child, parent, or other people's.

I am expecting that some parents will vote that it is happy, when that isn't accurate, as I am aware this is quite common, and the child has a very different feeling than the parent.

However, I will be pleased if I cam completely wrong about this, and lots mare happy! I just dont see it in teaching.

YABU - less than 75% are unhappy
YANBU - 75% or more are unhappy

OP posts:
CheezePleeze · 20/04/2023 09:46

SailorsWife · 20/04/2023 09:31

This is such utter BS. You have no actual data, only your own judgmental bias. This thread is toxic AF

I think the thread is very measured in places with honest posts from those who have blended their families, and those who have been raised in one.

SailorsWife · 20/04/2023 09:31

This is such utter BS. You have no actual data, only your own judgmental bias. This thread is toxic AF

maddening · 20/04/2023 09:26

Suzannargh · 17/04/2023 08:33

Kids tend to be unhappier when their parents have split, I doubt the stepparents change that percentage much. In many cases stepparents will mean they have a better quality of life than if their parents were single.

I agree with this - particularly depending on when the split was and how acrimonious it was which could increase risk of dissociative disorders plus genetic dispositions within the family- you may be more likely to split if one of the parents has, for example, personality disorders and the dc may also be genetically predisposed.

So you will have a mix of increased risk of issues caused but the split not to mention the individuals themselves- and then you blend that with another mix of issues - possible 4 times over. Imo it is too complex to even begin to theorise or generalise as to why you see such issues

VWHoliday · 20/04/2023 09:15

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 20/04/2023 09:07

Not incredibly common at all. Very much in the minority.

I don't why you refuse to believe that many half siblings do like each other but it does happen more than you choose to believe.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 20/04/2023 09:07

aSofaNearYou · 19/04/2023 16:43

A person saying something that is incredibly common for people to say on here.

Not incredibly common at all. Very much in the minority.

Ruth97 · 20/04/2023 08:12

This is a huge generalisation, and it’s unfair to label parents as selfish or putting their needs above their children.

Children grow up miserable in family homes, where parents argue day in, day out. Is it better to leave them in that situation?

My parents divorced when I was 4. I now have a stepfather, stepmother and 2 step siblings and it was the best outcome for our family. My stepdad has been a rock to myself and my sister, and raised us as his own since we were 6 years old, and our stepmother since we were 10. Now all of us “step kids” are well into our late 20’s, and we all get on great (and always have done).

I probably had less arguments with my step siblings and parents than my biological sister! What’s key here is that all parents made clear that no parent was being replaced, we were simply getting bonus parents.

AlmostThere2023 · 20/04/2023 07:18

Having been part of a blended family and have cousins & friends who also have been, I’ve seen both sides of the coin.

Friend & Cousind had amazing step parents, great relationships with them, however, one came to the family as a single person and the other did not move in their children, so maybe this was the difference?

I was part of a step family and it was a disaster. Step sibling did not want to share their mother at any cost, we were forced in to sharing a room and they absolutely hated me. Step mother didn’t have the time nor energy for me, did the minimum required and made no attempt to form a real relationship. Was very hard for me growing up and in to adulthood as my natural born mother was not on the scene.

Based on my own experiences, if myself and DH had ever to part I probably would not form any sort of blended family until my own DC were adults.

LaDamaDeElche · 20/04/2023 07:14

It would be interesting to compare this with teens with both parents still together and see how many of them are "happy", or teen in a single parent family with no step parent.

VWHoliday · 20/04/2023 06:39

@ziggiestardust your post is very thought provoking and sad.

I can't understand how any woman would put a man before their child. I am with my child's biological Dad and I still would put my child first before him.

I will say I appreciate me and my friends have been fortunate in our blended family situations. None of my close circle have had bad steparents as youngsters and seem to have been lucky/sensible in choosing new partners.

I do understand that there are some awful experiences for a lot of people.

@Nimbostratus100 did say 75% originally but then tends to insist that most blended families are unhappy and that we don't know how our children feel. I ask both my DC and DSC how they are feeling about all sorts of things.

I think teachers will mainly hear the bad experiences because I know mine wouldn't be bothered to tell a teacher about his homelife because he didn't need to.

ziggiestardust · 20/04/2023 05:38

The OP's original comment was that she thinks 75% ish of kids in blended families are unhappy. So if you're in a blended family and you're happy; there's no need to get upset by that because obviously you're not one of the unhappy ones she's talking about. It is possible to have a happy blended family dynamic; I think they probably are in the minority based on personal experience and observed experience, but I have seen them exist.

In this thread I do see a lot of adults coming forward and talking about their really unhappy, sad and in a lot of cases; abusive experiences in blended families. That should never be glossed over or invalidated. I won't go into my own experiences here in detail because to be honest, I'm still really affected and upset by it even though a majority of it happened to me as a legal adult. I do think that was probably for the best, because I wasn't a particularly hardy child and without the support network I currently have, I think I can safely say had I gone through that as a child/young teen I probably would have committed suicide. And none of it was even physical; just intense and sustained rejection from blood parent(s) and their new partners. I should say initially, I was excited to be a part of a blended family. Rejection by a parent is one of the most ... intense (I can't think of a better word. It's more than that actually) things I think you can go through. You're biologically wired as a child to try to be close to your parent and be a part of the group. It will affect me for the rest of my life.

As I say, my saving grace was that the majority of it happened to me as an adult. My mother always, always, always put the man/men in her life before me. I think it's probably better that she stayed in her original (still awful, abusive) relationship with my blood father as long as she did, because in her own words 'she shouldn't be trusted to make the right call when it comes to men'. She said that in the gap between my blood father and her next boyfriend. I maintain that it was better the devil we knew; my blood father did not sexually abuse me or beat me to the point of hospital. I think she was absolutely capable of becoming involved in another relationship that could have been like that, and I think she would have stayed/defended her new man over her child. She was not, and never has been, capable of being without a man and just living by herself. I'm not saying that's all single mothers, I can only relate to my experience personally, and the experience of my family (aunts and uncles) and also close family friends. As I say, I have seen it work and work well, but that shouldn't invalidate the experience of what I honestly feel is a hell of a lot of people, living with the choices of their parents forever.

LaDamaDeElche · 19/04/2023 21:26

Elastom I think it's a really normal situation. Most teenager go through a stage where they hate everyone. It's easier to channel that angst at someone who isn't your birth parent, and step parents are human beings, so at times they don't deal with the shit in a calm, measured way and in the eyes of the teen they become the bad guy/girl. We have to remember that teens don't have an adult level of emotional maturity, so they can kind of be excused to a point for their bad behaviour, but also parents and step parents aren't emotional beating boards with no emotion or feelings either. Mostly the teens grow up and get this. Polling them for statistics of happiness at such a difficult age doesn't prove a lot in my opinion. Ask them 10 years later and if they still feel the same maybe the statistics would have some real meaning.

ancientgran · 19/04/2023 20:48

Nimbostratus100 · 19/04/2023 18:48

maybe, but I didn't and many dont - sp children never left together unsupervised even for a few seconds

Great so we agree that when you said that they are never left alone unsupervised you were actually talking about your experience and not all foster care arrangements. Glad we cleared that up.

Elastom · 19/04/2023 20:31

LaDamaDeElche · 19/04/2023 07:48

You could ask children of that similar age whether they have a problem with their teachers and probably the same percentage would say yes. A lot of it really is down to age. I had issues with my step dad and argued a lot with him from around the age of 12-15, and sane with my
mum. Then I grew up and realised that he was a good guy just trying his best and I was the one more often than not causing problems. It’s ever been thus with teenagers.

This really resonates for me. I grew up a step family with two older half brothers from my mum’s first marriage. I remember my brothers clashing with my dad quite a bit when they were teenagers, but as adults they both say he was a great step dad and are closer to him than their bio dad, their kids call him granddad etc.

I do think it’s hard to make step families work but then it’s hard to be a good parent. I had very good parents and they made it work, there was no hierarchy between us all as siblings. I can fully appreciate that isn’t always the case.

Grapewrath · 19/04/2023 19:56

Yanbu
i think single parent families function far better than those in unhealthy or unhappy marriages or partnerships and I HATE the term broken family. However, when a separated parent brings a new partner and kids into the mix it very rarely works well for everyone. I work with families and I honestly can’t think of one family I know professionally or personally where everyone is happy and settled within a blended family dynamic
I certainly believe parents should move in if they wish but I personally would keep the two households as just that.

daughtersanathlete · 19/04/2023 19:50

@ily0xx what’s your point? I stayed single for 15 years

@Nimbostratus100 so you had social workers living in your house? That’s extremely unusual but ok.

ily0xx · 19/04/2023 19:27

daughtersanathlete · 19/04/2023 18:48

You still haven’t answered my questions.

my questions are

where in your pool do you take account of children who would’ve been unhappy if their parents had stayed together?

And I’ll ask. so what? The children are unhappy because of a situation not of my making. What am I supposed to do about that? Your post is judging me equally to my ex, and yet there is nothing I can do about what he does or did on his time.

it’s a horrible thread.

Oh FFS. There are many that studies show it’s much worse for children to be a step family than live with their parents.

This is not a horrible thread, what is horrible is the amount of selfish parents forcing their kids to live in a crappy step family situation because they want to move in the new boyfriend.

https://www.iol.co.za/lifestyle/family/parenting/why-children-with-step-parents-are-more-troubled-12765482

I’m so glad as a kid my mum remained single after my parents divorced and I wasn’t forced to live with a stranger who barely tolerated me.

Nimbostratus100 · 19/04/2023 19:19

daughtersanathlete · 19/04/2023 18:56

You can’t possibly know the order of magnitude. Your poll is unscientific in the extreme.

j don’t believe you had social workers constantly supervising the children in your care. Or the relationship you and your other child/even had with foster children. I have literally never known that happen.

Well of course I know the order of magnitude of my own experiences! AS to the rest of your post, I dont even understand it, so cant comment

OP posts:
Bigcat25 · 19/04/2023 19:04

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 08:46

@jenandberrys So parents shouldn't be allowed to move on and have a new life with a new partner?

There's a way to go about it the right way that doesn't always happen. You have to choose a good partner for your child as well, who isn't a jerk. There needs to be a plan for how to co parent step kids and manage the issues and expectations that arise.

On AITA there's lots of examples of poorly blended families and of course, the kids pay the price.

daughtersanathlete · 19/04/2023 18:56

You can’t possibly know the order of magnitude. Your poll is unscientific in the extreme.

j don’t believe you had social workers constantly supervising the children in your care. Or the relationship you and your other child/even had with foster children. I have literally never known that happen.

Nimbostratus100 · 19/04/2023 18:51

daughtersanathlete · 19/04/2023 18:48

You still haven’t answered my questions.

my questions are

where in your pool do you take account of children who would’ve been unhappy if their parents had stayed together?

And I’ll ask. so what? The children are unhappy because of a situation not of my making. What am I supposed to do about that? Your post is judging me equally to my ex, and yet there is nothing I can do about what he does or did on his time.

it’s a horrible thread.

  1. some children are unhappy with their natural parents for all sorts of reasons - not in the same order of magnitude though
  1. Answered earlier
OP posts:
daughtersanathlete · 19/04/2023 18:48

Nimbostratus100 · 19/04/2023 10:21

I have told you what I think - I think most blended family situation are unhappy as I have defined unhappy. The poll and this thread seem to bear that out

You still haven’t answered my questions.

my questions are

where in your pool do you take account of children who would’ve been unhappy if their parents had stayed together?

And I’ll ask. so what? The children are unhappy because of a situation not of my making. What am I supposed to do about that? Your post is judging me equally to my ex, and yet there is nothing I can do about what he does or did on his time.

it’s a horrible thread.

Nimbostratus100 · 19/04/2023 18:48

ancientgran · 19/04/2023 18:02

So when you said, For a start, foster children and own children are never left unsupervised together even for a moment. And social services monitor the relationship constantly. you knew that wasn't true for every fostered child? My neighbour definitely did not supervise her own and fostered children all the time , no where near in fact and they certainly weren't monitored by social services constantly.

I'm not sure how children could be supervised 24 hrs a day, what about when they are all in bed and parents downstairs? Do they never play in the garden while mother is cooking, how does mum ever go to the bathroom, if the postman rings the doorbell does she gather all the children together to answer the door? Doesn't sound very likely to me and it isn't like any foster family I know and I know some lovely foster parents and I've sat in the kitchen having a coffee and a chat while all the kids play, totally unsupervised.

maybe, but I didn't and many dont - sp children never left together unsupervised even for a few seconds

OP posts:
PeloMom · 19/04/2023 18:21

YANBU. I was the child in the situation and contrary to what many are saying, I wasn’t upset about parents splitting as they split shortly after I was born and an only parent was my normal. We (or at least I) were very happy until step parent and Step sibs were in the picture. Step sibs moved out a year later as we weren’t getting along at all and step parent finally went away eventually after many years. I did end up moving out at 16 as I couldn’t stand them and the relationship with my parent is broken down to this day. As a grown up I’m still to see a well functioning and happy blended family (many of my friends created blended families, some my extended family is in blended fam situation) as there is at least one broken down relationship.

Theelephantinthecastle · 19/04/2023 18:13

An example from my acquaintance:

Her mum remarried and had another child. Her new stepfather then left them. Her dad's family were super welcoming to her half sister even though she was not biologically related to them. Her mum then married for a third time and is blissfully happy with him, she gets on well with his kids and even babysits his grandchildren regularly.

Five years ago, I would have said that they were a shining example of how well blended families can work when families are open to it and treat each other equally. But it turns out that her grandad regularly raped her half sister throughout their childhood and is now facing criminal charges. It's torn their family apart.

So in answer to the OP's question - yes I do know some blended families that are very happy, but I also know this one which has been a total shit show and I also know several more where one or more person is quietly unhappy.

I don't doubt the folk who are coming in to say that they are blissfully happy and genuinely that's great for them but equally I know that on some of those cases other people involved may not be as happy. My acquaintance thought her half sister was super happy.

ancientgran · 19/04/2023 18:02

Nimbostratus100 · 19/04/2023 17:30

well, we were local council, so yes, carefully monitored. I am sure there are rogue agencies out there

So when you said, For a start, foster children and own children are never left unsupervised together even for a moment. And social services monitor the relationship constantly. you knew that wasn't true for every fostered child? My neighbour definitely did not supervise her own and fostered children all the time , no where near in fact and they certainly weren't monitored by social services constantly.

I'm not sure how children could be supervised 24 hrs a day, what about when they are all in bed and parents downstairs? Do they never play in the garden while mother is cooking, how does mum ever go to the bathroom, if the postman rings the doorbell does she gather all the children together to answer the door? Doesn't sound very likely to me and it isn't like any foster family I know and I know some lovely foster parents and I've sat in the kitchen having a coffee and a chat while all the kids play, totally unsupervised.