Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most blended family situations are unhappy

586 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 17/04/2023 08:30

From my experience of many decades as a secondary school tutor, I would say most of the time when children talk about step parents, there is tension and misery ( from the children's point of view, not necessarily the parents)

I am going to say 75% of situations are unhappy, by which I mean most of the children are somewhat unhappy, or one or more child is very unhappy, or the situation breaks down because of parent or child unhappiness. Breakdown could mean the relationship between parents breaks down, or the relationship between a child and step parent breaks down to the extent a teen becomes homeless, or moves out

So to answer this, you probably need to know at least 4 blended family situations reasonably well, yours as a child, parent, or other people's.

I am expecting that some parents will vote that it is happy, when that isn't accurate, as I am aware this is quite common, and the child has a very different feeling than the parent.

However, I will be pleased if I cam completely wrong about this, and lots mare happy! I just dont see it in teaching.

YABU - less than 75% are unhappy
YANBU - 75% or more are unhappy

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 17/04/2023 08:59

@jenandberrys

Of course they are still broken. The abuser is the one that broke it but they are still broken. It isn’t saying the person is broken, but that the family is. Which it is.

I kicked my abusive, alcoholic husband out when my DD had just turned four (young enough that she didn't really notice his departure). I don't want to minimise the impact of separation on families. I realise it's trite and convenient to say it was all roses and sunshine after he left because it wasn't, but I can promise you she and I were a hell of a lot less "broken" without him in the house.

Suzannargh · 17/04/2023 08:59

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 08:56

@jenandberrys if it harmed them or if they had been unhappy with meeting DH, they would have come first. They were the ones begging for him to move in. I think they craved a father figure and role model.

I’m guessing they were very young?

Anecdotally children who gain a stable stepparent when young seem happier with it.

About 75% of the older children and teens I know are generally unhappy about something, usually their family, regardless of the specific set up.

Brezel · 17/04/2023 08:58

I rightly or wrongly always feel sorry for the original child. The child that parents split and up and then both go on to have children with new partners. The original child is ferried back and forth between these families. I wonder how they feel.

Tarantullah · 17/04/2023 08:57

Itd be interesting how this varies across demographics and whether said children would be growing up in toxic households anyway. I'm not saying its right and that would be better, but there's so many variables it's quite a statement to say that the majority of blended families are miserable and damaging. There absolutely are people who are very reckless and put themselves first by rushing in or moving in a completely inappropriate, abusive adult to their children's safe space; there are also others who after years of dating slowly introduce a new partner that by that point they know very well and manage to strike an appropriate balance to ensure the children come first but they can also move on with their life.

Personally I met someone knew when DS was 3, he moved in when he was 6 and we have a child together now. Me and my ex now get on well and he has 2 further children, there isn't any drama, we are both fortunate I guess that both of our 'new' families are fairly equal in terms of finances so there isn't a competitiveness, we both give DS time alone as well as with his half siblings. If he grows up resentful then that's regrettable but I won't regret moving on.

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 08:57

Kids tend to be unhappier when their parents have split, I doubt the stepparents change that percentage much.

This. But it is what it is, sometimes parents need to separate and we can't have what would make the kids happiest, as there are other things to consider.

Children around the world have suffered much worse fates than this, sometimes things can't be perfect.

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 08:56

@jenandberrys if it harmed them or if they had been unhappy with meeting DH, they would have come first. They were the ones begging for him to move in. I think they craved a father figure and role model.

jenandberrys · 17/04/2023 08:55

ZeroFuchsGiven · 17/04/2023 08:53

No no no, op wants attention, she loves to post controversial threads, its her thing.

The OP does love to do that, but the poll suggest that many agree with her.

jenandberrys · 17/04/2023 08:54

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 08:52

@jenandberrys I disagree completely. My children have benefited from having a step dad as they unfortunately don't have a great relationship with their biological dad. Step dad has taught them how a man should treat a woman and he is always there to protect them.

To misquote Mandy Rice Davies ‘ well you would say that, wouldn’t you’

JaceLancs · 17/04/2023 08:53

I knew when my marriage ended I could never be a step parent so only dated child free men and kept them separate from my children
However I couldn’t stop ExDH remarrying more than once to women who already had children - as he had regular access my DC had no choice
They haven’t come away unscathed from their experiences

ZeroFuchsGiven · 17/04/2023 08:53

FrancescaContini · 17/04/2023 08:48

Why so defensive? The OP has made a very valid point based on the contact she has with school children. She’s speaking about what she’s witnessed.

No no no, op wants attention, she loves to post controversial threads, its her thing.

jenandberrys · 17/04/2023 08:52

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/04/2023 08:51

What about single parent families where a woman has removed herself and her children from a violent or abusive situations. Are they also "broken"?

You do realise, also, that having two biological parents remain together isn't a gold-plated guarantee of family harmony?

I totally acknowledge what the OP is talking about: blending families can be very problematic and difficult. But writing everyone who doesn't remain with their original spouse as "broken" is blinkered and quite offensive.

Of course they are still broken. The abuser is the one that broke it but they are still broken. It isn’t saying the person is broken, but that the family is. Which it is.

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 08:52

@jenandberrys I disagree completely. My children have benefited from having a step dad as they unfortunately don't have a great relationship with their biological dad. Step dad has taught them how a man should treat a woman and he is always there to protect them.

DelurkingAJ · 17/04/2023 08:51

I think your numbers may be a little skewed because of the ones you never realise are blended. DFIL is actually DH’s stepfather. He then adopted DH when he was Primary age. My DSIL had been dating DBIL for a couple of years before she found out entirely incidentally. I’m not sure my DSs know. It’s not hidden, it’s just utterly irrelevant. DFIL is an absolute brick and DH treats him as his Dad. DH’s biological Dad vanished when he was a baby. DFIL married DMIL when DH was 4.

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/04/2023 08:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What about single parent families where a woman has removed herself and her children from a violent or abusive situations. Are they also "broken"?

You do realise, also, that having two biological parents remain together isn't a gold-plated guarantee of family harmony?

I totally acknowledge what the OP is talking about: blending families can be very problematic and difficult. But writing everyone who doesn't remain with their original spouse as "broken" is blinkered and quite offensive.

FrancescaContini · 17/04/2023 08:51

@Coffeaddict your third paragraph - those poor children. Miserable for them.

jenandberrys · 17/04/2023 08:49

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 08:46

@jenandberrys So parents shouldn't be allowed to move on and have a new life with a new partner?

Not to the extent of ‘blending’ families and having additional children with them. No I don’t think so.

Coffeaddict · 17/04/2023 08:49

I was deeply unhappy as a child/ teen as my parents stayed in a high conflict marriage because divorce in ireland wasn't really a thing. My parents split when I was a young teen, my dad remaried and I really like his wife, I think she's great for him.

I am now a stepmum. I have a good relationship with DSS in fact he often comes to me with the stuff that's bothering him.

On the other hand the thing that is often bothering DSS is his stepdad. He is an abusive prick and its had a really bad impact on him. However DSS stepdad is also an abusive prick to his wife (DSS mum) and his own kids (DSS half siblings). Luckily mum has left said husband but has all but moved in a man she had been dating for 2 weeks 😕
My point is there is no perfect recpie for a happy family and both blended and non blended families can work or not work.

OhmygodDont · 17/04/2023 08:49

Parents can move on of course. But that shouldn’t mean forcing a new “parent” or step siblings onto your children with no thought to them or their home which should be considered a safe space.

You can date and have sex without having to live together. Without making your children suddenly share a house or bedroom with adult and children strangers to them.

FrancescaContini · 17/04/2023 08:48

AdamRyan · 17/04/2023 08:45

What is the purpose of your thread?
Nearly half of marriages end in divorce, that's life. Most people don't end the marriage on a whim or move a step parent in ASAP. Most people do the best they can by their family.

Stop being so judgemental.

Why so defensive? The OP has made a very valid point based on the contact she has with school children. She’s speaking about what she’s witnessed.

Itstoday · 17/04/2023 08:47

I had a step dad after the death of my dad and I can honestly say it was truly traumatic and my mum should never have married him. It was damaging to us all and my mum certainly put her needs above us, her children. If anything happened to my DH I would never bring another man in to my family home.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 17/04/2023 08:47

I think the quality of parents and parenting are what makes a family good or otherwise and being a shite parent is not remotely exclusive to people who are step parents or have a new partner.

ETref · 17/04/2023 08:46

I agree that blending families is not best for the dc in the vast majority of cases. Of course there will be the odd happy blended family where it has worked out perfectly and things are harmonious but I think that this is the exception rather than the rule.

Probably an unpopular opinion but I think that if you are single with young dc (male or female, rp or nrp) then you should accept that you can't have an intense relationship with the view to living with your partner until the dc are much older/nearing adulthood. By all means have relationships, there is no requirement to be lonely or miserable if that is how staying single would make you feel. But it is usually in the best interest of your dc to keep that relationship separate from family life until the dc are nearly adults. I do believe it's pretty selfish to move someone into your dc's home and force them (plus possible step siblings) into your dc's life for the sake of your love life.

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 08:46

@jenandberrys So parents shouldn't be allowed to move on and have a new life with a new partner?

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/04/2023 08:46

I'm sure there are a lot of blended families where it's problematic and kids feel their needs have been pushed aside. That's certainly true. And at the extreme it can be horrendous, I grant you. And I speak as someone whose daughter has a step parent.

That said, I think there's probably more nuance to it than you describe here. There are so many variables at play here that it's impossible to summarise them all but the most critical ones include: what the temperament of the new step parent is like, whether the step parent is committed to actually being part of a "family" or whether they just want the relationship with the parent; whether they resent the children or treat them kindly; whether there are other children involved in the "blending" and what their relationships are like; the ages of the children at the time the step parent came on the scene; the quality of the parents and step parents' relationships, where the family is living; whether the children have to be uprooted and move schools etc; whether there is a downgrade in the quality of life etc.

I do think bringing a step parent and step siblings into the mix automatically raises the stakes for everyone and I do think it needs to be done slowly and with great care and sensitivity. I think some people are not cut out to be step parents and shouldn't move in with children.

I don't think it's automatically a disaster and in some scenarios it can be very positive, but I think parents often are too quick to assume it will all work out in the end and unprepared for what can be a hard road.

AdamRyan · 17/04/2023 08:45

What is the purpose of your thread?
Nearly half of marriages end in divorce, that's life. Most people don't end the marriage on a whim or move a step parent in ASAP. Most people do the best they can by their family.

Stop being so judgemental.

Swipe left for the next trending thread