Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most blended family situations are unhappy

586 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 17/04/2023 08:30

From my experience of many decades as a secondary school tutor, I would say most of the time when children talk about step parents, there is tension and misery ( from the children's point of view, not necessarily the parents)

I am going to say 75% of situations are unhappy, by which I mean most of the children are somewhat unhappy, or one or more child is very unhappy, or the situation breaks down because of parent or child unhappiness. Breakdown could mean the relationship between parents breaks down, or the relationship between a child and step parent breaks down to the extent a teen becomes homeless, or moves out

So to answer this, you probably need to know at least 4 blended family situations reasonably well, yours as a child, parent, or other people's.

I am expecting that some parents will vote that it is happy, when that isn't accurate, as I am aware this is quite common, and the child has a very different feeling than the parent.

However, I will be pleased if I cam completely wrong about this, and lots mare happy! I just dont see it in teaching.

YABU - less than 75% are unhappy
YANBU - 75% or more are unhappy

OP posts:
Opalie · 17/04/2023 09:39

I also have 2 half siblings but never thought of then as "half", they are just my brother and sister...

ModestMoon · 17/04/2023 09:39

I disagree with the term broken family. A family isn't "whole" just because the parents live together. And a family isn't "broken" just because the parents have split up.

But having said that I essentially agree with you OP. Parents put their own desires to live with someone they love and perhaps have more children above what is best for their kids. It's difficult figuring out what it is that we owe our children. We don't owe them the best possible life, of course, it's fine to keep working for example. But moving another adult into their home and then creating children that live there full time is almost never in their interest in my opinion.

Suzannargh · 17/04/2023 09:39

Theelephantinthecastle · 17/04/2023 09:13

I agree with you.

There are exceptions - the model that seems to have the best outcomes anecdotally is where the stepdad has no children of his own and takes on his stepchildren completely. When both people have children, it seems very hard to make it work well.

I don't understand why people can't just date and live separately

In a lot of cases this will be due to money. The main residence (generally the mother’s house) is where the children spend the most time so are most comfortable, and it’s the household that receives hundreds of pounds of benefits as well as child maintenance every month.

The NRP may not be able to afford a house with bedrooms for every child (certainly not through social housing) without partnering up.

Beezknees · 17/04/2023 09:38

deepspace9 · 17/04/2023 09:37

Crikey what good work by the OP here. As if life isn't tough enough for us all already! Along comes someone deliberately trying to stir up conflict and everyone falls over themselves to do just that.

Kids can be unhappy in a 'normal' family set up, in a blended family and in a single parent family. They could also be happy in each one. There is no magic set up where everyone is happy all of the time. What happened to 'live and let live eh?!'. Such a shame.

OP ~ great work for a Monday morning 👏👏👏

Unfortunately these conversations have been exacerbated lately by a large number of young children being abused and even killed by step parents, often the step father.

tillylula · 17/04/2023 09:38

My step dad is an arsehole. He caused alot of problems with me because he simply didn't want me there. 12 years later I still don't like him.

daughtersanathlete · 17/04/2023 09:37

@Holly60 I did exactly as you suggest.

and yet my kids are in an unhappy blended family situation and were from a young age.

that’s out of my control. What can I do about it?

FurElise · 17/04/2023 09:37

My DD refers to her SD as her dad in school/outside the home but calls him "Bill" at home. How would you guage her level of happiness OP? Considering you wouldn't actually know she was from a blended family? 🤔

FourTeaFallOut · 17/04/2023 09:37

I think that you are probably right. From my experience, children who have endured the breakdown of their parent's relationship tend to do better when they don't then have to jolly along and share resources and attention with a bunch of other kids from their parent's new partners.

This idea that children are resilient to these kind of changes is largely bullshit. Resignation to their powerlessness in the situation isn't an approximation of resilience but it's a useful myth adults tell themselves to assuage their own discomfort.

Beezknees · 17/04/2023 09:37

I dunno, maybe because I've been on my own for so long I can't see the appeal of living with a man anyway. I like my own space. Also I wouldn't want somebody trying to parent my child when they aren't actually their parent, it would annoy me.

deepspace9 · 17/04/2023 09:37

Crikey what good work by the OP here. As if life isn't tough enough for us all already! Along comes someone deliberately trying to stir up conflict and everyone falls over themselves to do just that.

Kids can be unhappy in a 'normal' family set up, in a blended family and in a single parent family. They could also be happy in each one. There is no magic set up where everyone is happy all of the time. What happened to 'live and let live eh?!'. Such a shame.

OP ~ great work for a Monday morning 👏👏👏

AllInOnePiece · 17/04/2023 09:36

It's very hard to answer.

I come at this from two angles, as a stepchild myself and as a step parent.

I met my step dad when I was about 13 and quite honestly I'm fine with it. My parents separation which happened a couple of years prior affected me much more than my mum remarrying did. I actually really really like my step dad (feels weird to call him that tbh as he's never been a "dad" to me just like a close family member), and he's a fantastic grandad to my DC now. Genuinely, and I'm not just saying this, I do feel my life has benefitted from having him in it. But then he doesn't have children of his own so I never had step siblings or anything like that, maybe that would have been different and harder to deal with. Neither of my parents went on to have more children so I've never had to deal with new half siblings either, again possibly making it easier for me.

Now I'm a step parent myself and I also share DC with DH so my step children's half siblings and I'm inclined to agree that with hindsight it's probably not the ideal scenario for the original children and if me and DH split it would be something I would avoid as best I could from my side, happening to my own children. My step children were much younger than I was when I become a SC and I do think that has a lot to do with it. I was much more independent when I met my mum's husband than my step children were, there was a lot less contact (and therefore conflict) between my parents because I was older than there was between DH and DSCs mum.

I will say that I do genuinely believe my stepchildren love their half siblings and wouldn't want to be without them. If they don't they are fantastic actors because they just dote on them. BUT that's not to say there hasn't also been feelings of concern / worry on their part about their dad having more children, there has been (we have talked about it and I hope they feel reassured). So I don't think it's either or... I think my DSC love their siblings by me and their dad and would agree that they would want them in their life, but also thst it's been hard for them to see their dad have new children too. Not either or.

So basically my experience of blended families as a step child was actually fine but from being a step parent myself I appreciate that I am likely in the minority and it's not something I'd want to risk for my own child if my husband and I ever separated.

Nordicrain · 17/04/2023 09:36

Holly60 · 17/04/2023 09:32

If I'd split with my DH, I never would have made my children grow up in a house with another adult who wasn't their parent or related to them.

When I read some of these threads about step parents barely tolerating their step children (and that is always the implication), it makes me so sad.

One poster the other day said she upset her DH by saying that she wouldn't look after her step children if both their parents died. And yet those poor children have to grow up sharing their home and childhood with this woman who would palm them off the minute their parents died.

It's not so much that she wouldn't have kept them (she feels how she feels) it's the fact that despite this, they still have to spend their childhoods with her. Half of their memories will be made in the presence of a woman who would send them away the minute their dad died. I felt like crying for them, to be honest.

"When I read some of these threads about step parents barely tolerating their step children (and that is always the implication), it makes me so sad."

I agree with this. My step mum was never a mum figure to me. But she 100% always treated me as family and she is just as much a grandmother to my kids as to my step sister's children. I also agree that it's astoounding to me that someone can share a home with a small child for a decade or more and still come out of it with no bond or kindness towards that child at all. It strikes me as so callous. How sad for the children who will no doubt have felt it.

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 09:36

@Holly60 This is what I can't seem to get across, sometimes it is beneficial for the kids to have a blended family. If it works, it can bring them happiness and security.

ittakes2 · 17/04/2023 09:36

I don’t have a blended family and still my children are not happy!! I think you can not compare because you are not balancing that out with stats on children who are unhappy and not from blended families. I think the difference is children from blended families might feel they can tell others if they are unhappy as they do not feel as loyal to a step parent.

daughtersanathlete · 17/04/2023 09:36

Also. I didn’t date til my kids were adults. My ex did. I can’t control that. So what does heaping sadness on me coz my kids are going to be unhappy do? More guilt for the mothers.

my partner and I have been dating for 4 years. And we haven’t “blended” our families. He sees his kids and I see my (adult) kids and sometimes we see them together.

but I have my house and he has his (due to location) and that works for us.

and yet I’ve been vilified on here under a different name for saying I wouldn’t enable him to parent because that’s his job.

women can’t win it seems.

this thread is not going to make parents lives easier. It’s not going to be helpful to anyone, regardless of what they’ve done.

the poll is flawed.

what’s the use of the thread at all?

Opalie · 17/04/2023 09:36

My cousin knew his step-dad (my uncle) from about the age of 2 or 3, his own dad wasn't interested in him. He now is an adult and my uncle married his mother, gave him a sibling close in age, and adopted him. He calls him dad and doesn't think of him as a step-parent, or an adoptive parent, he's dad through and through. Likewise, he is treated and thought of like a grandchild just the same as his brother. The idea of "he is my step-dad" just isn't a thing, he's his dad. I suppose the age at which the blending happens make a big difference - he doesn't really remember a time without my uncle.

My own step-dad is the same. My "real" dad left before I was born and wanted nothing to do with me. So in every way, my step is my dad. He is also a grandad to my child, I haven't even explained be isn't a blood relative yet.

Blood isn't really important in our family though... I also have a step grandparent I consider my real grandparent and always have done, and cousins who aren't blood/marriage related so by all accounts aren't "actually" my cousins.

TBF, the ones that seem to work the best usually involve an absent bio parent.

Holly60 · 17/04/2023 09:35

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 08:46

@jenandberrys So parents shouldn't be allowed to move on and have a new life with a new partner?

Not at the expense of the kids.

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 09:35

@Nordicrain I totally agree not all blended families are bad, I'm in one with my DH and our kids from previous relationships.

Holly60 · 17/04/2023 09:35

AdamRyan · 17/04/2023 08:45

What is the purpose of your thread?
Nearly half of marriages end in divorce, that's life. Most people don't end the marriage on a whim or move a step parent in ASAP. Most people do the best they can by their family.

Stop being so judgemental.

But they don't HAVE to get remarried and bring another adult into the home.

Divorce with kids is crap, I'm not denying it. It's often totally out of the individual's control.

What is IN that persons control is not bringing another adult into their child's home.

it's a shitty choice, but surely the right choice is the one that is the best for the children.

Nordicrain · 17/04/2023 09:33

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 09:29

@Nordicrain I am also a child of divorce and my parents remarried, so I was that child too and I don't agree with OP.

I am sorry you didn't have a good experience. However perhaps you can acknowledge that people have different experiences and not all blended families are bad. And it's not jsut the parents/ step parents that have that view.

Tarantullah · 17/04/2023 09:33

springhas · 17/04/2023 09:24

I just can’t see how blending a family can in anyway be an advantage for the children. I’m a lone parent with a partner of 2.5 years. My kids have a brilliant relationship with him but we don’t live together. He spends a couple of days a week here and that’s lovely. I would love to live with him but my teens have a happy, calm and settle home life. There’s no way I would risk unsettling that for the sake of moving someone in. They like our life as it is and quite frankly that’s my priority. I imagine we will live together when the youngest goes to uni in 5 years but why change now? It’s not going to enhance their lives when they’re perfectly happy and settled now

What if you'd have split when your children were young, would you have been content waiting 16 or so years to move in?

CallieQ · 17/04/2023 09:33

AdamRyan · 17/04/2023 08:45

What is the purpose of your thread?
Nearly half of marriages end in divorce, that's life. Most people don't end the marriage on a whim or move a step parent in ASAP. Most people do the best they can by their family.

Stop being so judgemental.

This

Mumma · 17/04/2023 09:33

We are all very happy. We co parent a 15 year old, both have new partners and get on like good friends. We walk into each others houses and have keys etc. Have a big family group chat. Go out to eat dinner together.

However.... people say its 'weird' or that they could never be thaylt way with ex . I fail to see how putting your childs happiness first is weird but i think their attitude explains why happy blended families isnt usual.

WhoDidIt124 · 17/04/2023 09:33

AdamRyan · 17/04/2023 08:45

What is the purpose of your thread?
Nearly half of marriages end in divorce, that's life. Most people don't end the marriage on a whim or move a step parent in ASAP. Most people do the best they can by their family.

Stop being so judgemental.

This.

MN has always had a plethora of LTB threads. I'm not talking about obvious abuse or unhappiness for all involved where it's judtified, but a knee jerk reaction to virtually any problematic or annoying situation.

Which also comes with the caveat that then you should not enter into a serious relationship again until your children are grown and out of the house.

Which completely screws over any woman who DID have the misfortune to be in a shitty, abusive relationship or even just an unhappy one who is then considered to have to remain single for potentially decades, with all the pressures and shit that comes with lone parenting.

Oh, and should never have more DC. Because ending a shitty relationship even in your 20s should mean you live alone with the DC from that relationship till they leave home and never have more.

The attitude is that it's stupid women who should've been psychic and known they were having kids with the wrong man so made their bed and have to lie in it otherwise they're a selfish, feckless parent who is making their child suffer for not wanting to be alone for the next decade and more.

LegallyFit · 17/04/2023 09:32

daughtersanathlete · 17/04/2023 09:31

Also. My kids weren’t happy when we were together. It wasn’t a good marriage or a healthy environment for kids.

how are you mitigating that in your survey?

The consensus seems to be that single parenthood is the gold standard for parenting and anything different to that then we are being selfish and neglecting our children 🤷🏻‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread