Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most blended family situations are unhappy

586 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 17/04/2023 08:30

From my experience of many decades as a secondary school tutor, I would say most of the time when children talk about step parents, there is tension and misery ( from the children's point of view, not necessarily the parents)

I am going to say 75% of situations are unhappy, by which I mean most of the children are somewhat unhappy, or one or more child is very unhappy, or the situation breaks down because of parent or child unhappiness. Breakdown could mean the relationship between parents breaks down, or the relationship between a child and step parent breaks down to the extent a teen becomes homeless, or moves out

So to answer this, you probably need to know at least 4 blended family situations reasonably well, yours as a child, parent, or other people's.

I am expecting that some parents will vote that it is happy, when that isn't accurate, as I am aware this is quite common, and the child has a very different feeling than the parent.

However, I will be pleased if I cam completely wrong about this, and lots mare happy! I just dont see it in teaching.

YABU - less than 75% are unhappy
YANBU - 75% or more are unhappy

OP posts:
joebloggs1 · 20/04/2023 22:49

My mother died when I was five years old, my father met a new woman and married her when I was seven. She was nice at first, but once she moved in she showed her true colours. She despised me and made it very clear.

My childhood was utterly miserable and I remember being about eight or nine years old and fantasising about sticking a kitchen knife in my neck over and over again. Ended up being kicked out the house aged sixteen, any of my possessions I couldn't fit in a couple suitcases etc were thrown out.

She is very good at acting superficially nice, especially when others are present, so to outsiders family situation would look "normal". Also she has poisoned my father's relationship with his parents, and with his siblings.

Of course everything has always been my fault, I've been told plenty growing up how vile and nasty I am. (this has impacted me a lot, low self esteem etc). At least my siblings and I didn't end up in the care system, so I am grateful for that.

I've had friends who had loving step fathers who they considered their "real dads" etc, but I've known more who were miserable step children.

Usually there is some truth to stereotypes (not always ofc).

ziggiestardust · 20/04/2023 21:13

@DryYourEyesWeepingWillow I wonder if the people who have made the comments that are on the harsher end of the spectrum in this thread, were victims of the types of negative situations we’re talking about and are still struggling to process it and are lashing out. Not making excuses for them, that’s still poor form and we are all responsible for our own triggers, but still.

and I absolutely agree with you that the posters insisting their situation is good; absolutely no one is disbelieving you! If you say it’s good, it’s good. So you’re probably not the 75% or whatever percentage it is and you shouldn’t be defending those 75% because they’re not putting their children first.

Your point about how to avoid this; I couldn’t agree with you more (again!!) we need to support single mothers more. Bottom line. Mostly financially. Because severe financial strain puts you in a survival mode type state, and I don’t think that puts you in the mind of choosing a partner properly. There will always be the women (like my mother) who simply can’t live without a man, but that’s a mindset type thing and it’s way more complex to unpick. But yes, proper support, funding and kindness would go a LONG way to prevent these types of negative situations I bet.

SemperIdem · 20/04/2023 20:27

I’m a step parent, I have my own child - there are currently no shared children.

Do I love my step children as much as I love my own child - no, I don’t.

Do I love my step children, want them to be as happy as they possibly could be, achieve as much as they could, as much as I want that for my own child? Yes absolutely, they are my family. I care deeply about their happiness.

All of the most challenging conversations in my relationship are about how we can make sure our children are happy. I don’t mean challenging in a negative way - the end result is positive, I suspect we’re more open than many couples in “standard” families.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 20/04/2023 16:39

I agree @VWHoliday . There have been some horrible posts on this thread, as on so many others on MN these days. It's such a shame and it changes the tone and makes everyone defensive and then of course more harsh in their own replies.

Used to be quite a supportive and often rather hilarious place here! I wish we could get back to that.

VWHoliday · 20/04/2023 16:32

@DryYourEyesWeepingWillow I do understand what you are saying.

I've found your posts and some other posts very interesting and informative.

There are a couple of posters who haven't come across so well.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 20/04/2023 16:13

But just because it's been ok for most people in your circle doesn't mean you can extrapolate that as a general picture of how it usually works out or the risks involved. That's what academic research is for, longitudinal research one outcomes. So it's completely valid to say that in most cases this is bad for children, without that in any way implying that your family's choices or those of other people you happen to know have worked out badly. There is always some risk and luck involved in that so they did take some large risks given the data but it sounds like it's worked well and that's great. What I don't understand is this insistence that because it's worked for some people or those they know that their experience somehow overrides the statistical facts that in most cases, it doesn't.

Obviously there will be mitigating factors. The personalities of the parents, their economic status, the level of animosity between the original parents, whether they decide to have more children, how slowly it is all done, whether the children had a veto on it, their ages, how traumatic the original separation was, and on and on. And luck. Whether their parent happens to marry an abuser or psychopath and they simply could not know this.

But it is a huge risk, no matter how careful you are. This is a fact. Some will have happy endings which is great. But no matter what our personal sample is, we do know from research that most if these situation do not end happily for all of the children involved and often have life-long negative impacts. I don't see what's wrong with acknowledging that. It's not a personal criticism of anybody to acknowledge the truth, especially it they're certain that their own family is an outlier and that's not the case for the children in their family.

VWHoliday · 20/04/2023 16:05

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 20/04/2023 16:00

In my opinion, better questions would be: how do we raise current children with better attitudes to relationships and childrearing so that family breakdown is less common? How do we educate young adults better about how to identify bad partners before they have children with them and understand the risks to children? How do we ensure better mental health support and social services are in place so that children who are suffering can access them? What needs to be done to raise the standard of care homes in the UK to the levels in many comparable countries so that there is a realistic alternative option for children in awful family situations that will give them a decent shot at life? What changes do we need to make to the tax system so that people don't feel compelled to co-habit for mainly financial reasons and reduce the financial penalties imposed on single parent households, to bring us in line with international norms on this, as I described upthread?

These are the things we should all focus on. Not attacking each other because we don't want to believe the reality that while our own children may be happy, many others are not.

I agree with this.

However, I don't think it was just the people who have happy children that were doing the attacking.

VWHoliday · 20/04/2023 16:02

It is not MOST cases in my circle though and I KNOW not believe that our children all get on.

So to be told we are disillusioned is as ignorant as you thinking I'm ignoring the fact that a lot of blended families are bad for the children.

I wouldn't even keep posting if some posters admitted that I'm not kidding myself. We have been a blended family over 2 decades and everyone is still really close.

I'm not even the one who has moved another adult in, I'm actually sticking up for DH's ex in this and how all four adults have made the children's now adult's lives happy.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 20/04/2023 16:00

In my opinion, better questions would be: how do we raise current children with better attitudes to relationships and childrearing so that family breakdown is less common? How do we educate young adults better about how to identify bad partners before they have children with them and understand the risks to children? How do we ensure better mental health support and social services are in place so that children who are suffering can access them? What needs to be done to raise the standard of care homes in the UK to the levels in many comparable countries so that there is a realistic alternative option for children in awful family situations that will give them a decent shot at life? What changes do we need to make to the tax system so that people don't feel compelled to co-habit for mainly financial reasons and reduce the financial penalties imposed on single parent households, to bring us in line with international norms on this, as I described upthread?

These are the things we should all focus on. Not attacking each other because we don't want to believe the reality that while our own children may be happy, many others are not.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 20/04/2023 15:45

Why does this always have to happen?

There have been some horrible and goady comments, as always. But surely a rational discussion should be possible?

It can be horrific for children to go through a family breakup and then have step families imposed on them. Sometimes it works, but we know from the data that in most cases it creates more unhappiness than parents separating from a bad relationships and not cohabiting again.

That doesn't mean it isn't beneficial in some circumstances. Or that some children grow up happy in those situations. It just means it's much less likely. We know that if a relationship is toxic it's better for the children to leave it, on average. We know that if that has to happen the next best option statistically is for them to be raised just by their parents but in two separate households with amicable co-parenting, and that if this happens then their outcomes are indistinguisable from those in nuclear families. We also know that if amicable co-parenting or no contact from one parent is possible, that being raised by a lone parent is the next best option, statistically. We know that moving in with a new partner is likely to create worse outcomes, more family conflict, more risks of mental health issues and more risks of abuse. We know that these issues are compounded in cases where this blending involves step siblings or new babies from the new partnerships. These are statistical facts, all available in the studies online.

Of course there will always be exceptions. Of course it hurts to have been through traumatic things yourself, and then read these things and it's normal to feel attacked I suppose when it feels like a personal criticism because people are stating that in most cases your family situation is bad for children, when you believe yours is not.

I do get that - as I said in an earlier post when I read the vitriol heaped on single mothers I feel the same. That is must be somehow my fault or I must have ignored red flags or made bad judgements or my kids will be screwed up by not having a male role model or I must have tricked a man into having babies or I must be claiming benefits etc etc. It's horrible to feel tarred by the same brush based on one characteristic of your family when you know that picture doesn't apply to you. That hurts and it's horrible to feel judged when it's not applicable in your situation but that doesn't change the data, that actually those of us feeling like that in happy single parent families or blended families are the outliers, because many people in those situations haven't planned properly to ensure the children's needs are met and prioritised above the adults' wants, and haven't provided stability and security and safety and love and financial security and a sense of belonging and that the child matters more than the adults.

So those who have done that, great. I'm trying to do the same. There are different ways to do it and as long as it does work and give the children stability and happiness of course it's fine, whatever it looks like. But why have to have this reaction, that the data should be ignored just because you are an exception and it doesn't apply in your case? Deny the risks, ignore the reality that for most children, it's not good. When we know this for a fact. Shutting the discussion down just means that the children in those situations where the adults are NOT putting their needs first and are taking big risks with their happiness and wellbeing and safety will continue to be ignored, with more tragic and sad stories and ruined lives that could have been different. It isn't a personal attack on specific families to speak the truth about the wider picture that for most children this doesn't work out well.

VWHoliday · 20/04/2023 14:22

Other people are happy.

VWHoliday · 20/04/2023 14:21

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 20/04/2023 13:51

I can both read and properly comprehend, so I see the big discrepancy between the percentage of parents claiming their children are happy and the percentage of children (now old enough to post on MN) saying how unhappy they were. A good number even adding that they hid their unhappiness from their parents.

So your posts don't hold a lot of weight. For multiple reasons.

MN is not the whole population. Most of my friends wouldn't use it so wouldn't be telling their happy stories on here. They are happy and are just living happy blended family life.

I'm not going to make my DC/SDC come on here and swear on the bible that they love each other.

Just because you may have had a bad experience don't be ignorant and bitter that other people aren't happy.

My SC are adults. They have their own children. They still have a very close relationship with their half sibling. They aren't doing it to keep peace. They love him and he is Uncle to their children.

So sorry to prove you wrong but you are.

Loveyou3000 · 20/04/2023 14:18

@LaDamaDeElche my parents were and still are married, I was miserable and depressed, so much so I left home at 17. Had tried to end my own life about three times before that point. I'm 26 now so not really a relic of a bygone time either.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 20/04/2023 13:51

I can both read and properly comprehend, so I see the big discrepancy between the percentage of parents claiming their children are happy and the percentage of children (now old enough to post on MN) saying how unhappy they were. A good number even adding that they hid their unhappiness from their parents.

So your posts don't hold a lot of weight. For multiple reasons.

VWHoliday · 20/04/2023 12:16

@ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave I see you are one of those people who believe that no parents know if their children are unhappy and we are delusional.

You are wrong and I'm sorry if your experiences are different but some people are close to their children.

VWHoliday · 20/04/2023 11:31

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 20/04/2023 11:23

I don't know why you can't read.

I can read thanks.

There are more than the opinions on this thread.

My experience is is that non of my friends or family who have half siblings dislike them.

If that's what you even meant.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 20/04/2023 11:23

VWHoliday · 20/04/2023 09:15

I don't why you refuse to believe that many half siblings do like each other but it does happen more than you choose to believe.

I don't know why you can't read.

aSofaNearYou · 20/04/2023 10:45

Not incredibly common at all. Very much in the minority.

Says who? I have seen people saying they love their half siblings and view them like full siblings countless times. Comparatively, I have rarely seen people say they wish they didn't have half siblings.

maddening · 20/04/2023 10:40

ily0xx · 20/04/2023 10:13

Yes they’re temporarily unhappy with the split, but living with a stranger they have absolutely no attachment to is a different type of trauma. How would you like it if you were forced into living with a stranger right now? It’s horrible for the kids. Even without abuse it’s still likely an uncomfortable situation.

True, obviously not the case for all though, not all would be strangers for example. It is just all about risk factors imo, and increased risk of certain factors being in play, and once you blend your risk factors increase. Obviously these are just risks so there will be many cases where all is amazing, many where no detriment, but obviously the risk is there, and it is heightened based on circumstance and individuals involved, in some cases.

It is so very complex.

ziggiestardust · 20/04/2023 10:27

@ily0xx 👏 👏 👏

FrancescaContini · 20/04/2023 10:24

@ily0xx spot on

ily0xx · 20/04/2023 10:13

maddening · 20/04/2023 09:26

I agree with this - particularly depending on when the split was and how acrimonious it was which could increase risk of dissociative disorders plus genetic dispositions within the family- you may be more likely to split if one of the parents has, for example, personality disorders and the dc may also be genetically predisposed.

So you will have a mix of increased risk of issues caused but the split not to mention the individuals themselves- and then you blend that with another mix of issues - possible 4 times over. Imo it is too complex to even begin to theorise or generalise as to why you see such issues

Yes they’re temporarily unhappy with the split, but living with a stranger they have absolutely no attachment to is a different type of trauma. How would you like it if you were forced into living with a stranger right now? It’s horrible for the kids. Even without abuse it’s still likely an uncomfortable situation.

Divorcedalongtime · 20/04/2023 09:56

I am reassured to read this as I’ve been a single parents since my children were small and they are now fast approaching adulthood.
I tried dating in the early days and quickly realised the compromises would be too harsh for the kids.
Sometimes I feel that I should have modelled a good adult relationship to them with a new partner but I’ve seen so many of my friends do this and often am struck at the compromises their kids have to put up with.

ziggiestardust · 20/04/2023 09:47

@CheezePleeze absolutely, and I applaud all those who have come forward with their personal experiences to share, good and bad. It has made a really interesting thread to read through.

ziggiestardust · 20/04/2023 09:46

@SailorsWife a lot of people on here, if you read through; are talking about their own personal distressing experiences in blended families, as they are as adults now. Those experiences are valid, and shouldn’t be silenced because it doesn’t fit a narrative. If it doesn’t fit your personal experience (and there are plenty of people who had wonderful, positive experiences!) then you don’t need to be upset by this thread, because those negative experiences don’t apply to you. Even as someone coming from a non positive experience; I can see that others had good experiences. And that’s great; I’m truly, truly happy for them because all children should be loved and made to feel wanted. But that isn’t the case for a lot of us.