Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most blended family situations are unhappy

586 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 17/04/2023 08:30

From my experience of many decades as a secondary school tutor, I would say most of the time when children talk about step parents, there is tension and misery ( from the children's point of view, not necessarily the parents)

I am going to say 75% of situations are unhappy, by which I mean most of the children are somewhat unhappy, or one or more child is very unhappy, or the situation breaks down because of parent or child unhappiness. Breakdown could mean the relationship between parents breaks down, or the relationship between a child and step parent breaks down to the extent a teen becomes homeless, or moves out

So to answer this, you probably need to know at least 4 blended family situations reasonably well, yours as a child, parent, or other people's.

I am expecting that some parents will vote that it is happy, when that isn't accurate, as I am aware this is quite common, and the child has a very different feeling than the parent.

However, I will be pleased if I cam completely wrong about this, and lots mare happy! I just dont see it in teaching.

YABU - less than 75% are unhappy
YANBU - 75% or more are unhappy

OP posts:
deepspace9 · 17/04/2023 10:44

mumof2many1943 · 17/04/2023 10:42

Another Cinderella here, mother dumped me under the clock on Paddington Station when I was 6. Father picked me up later, probably only 5 minutes. He remarried when I was 11 to the woman from hell! She was coercive and controlling towards my lovely father who was weak. I was treated like a scullery maid and was dressed in her mother’s cast off clothes. My life started when I was 18 when I left home to start nursing, what joy! Fantastic marriage followed by 3 children then we adopted 6 children 😲 can’t bear to see children rejected.
Phew this has been cathartic!

😂😂 brilliant!

AllInOnePiece · 17/04/2023 10:44

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 10:36

@AllInOnePiece Yeah I get that. It's easier than having no children, but only in the same way that not having a second child is easier than not having a child at all. But with the added factor that the child you do have is being raised elsewhere by somebody else.

Yes of course. I won't down play the hurt at being unable to have the number of children you'd like or the experience of parenting you'd like. But of course once you do already have children ensuring they are considered when making that decision is more important than your feelings.

It could be for a number of reasons, can't financially afford it without reducing existing child's quality of life, don't have the space and so on.. one of which to also consider is the fact the two partners already have X many children between them who are already splitting their time between 2 homes and whether a new child would negatively impact them even more so. I do think it's different if the step parent is childless to begin with compared to if they already have their own children. You've the added complications of step siblings AND half siblings etc.. just seems a bit chaotic. But again I accept I'm probably being unfairly judgemental.

mumof2many1943 · 17/04/2023 10:42

Another Cinderella here, mother dumped me under the clock on Paddington Station when I was 6. Father picked me up later, probably only 5 minutes. He remarried when I was 11 to the woman from hell! She was coercive and controlling towards my lovely father who was weak. I was treated like a scullery maid and was dressed in her mother’s cast off clothes. My life started when I was 18 when I left home to start nursing, what joy! Fantastic marriage followed by 3 children then we adopted 6 children 😲 can’t bear to see children rejected.
Phew this has been cathartic!

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 10:41

Since 86% of single parents are women, what you're really is saying women should live separately to their partner.

The sexism, even inadvertent, is unfair when men are allowed to just live without any judgement because they don't have kids in the house.

If you mean resident parents, it's actually over 90%. And no, it is not sexism. 🙄 I don't think either parent should move in with another adult while the children are under 18 if they are still having contact with that parent. In fact in some ways it's even more damaging if the parent they see less of (usually the father) moves a new partner into their home and has more children because the existing children then feel even more pushed out of the relationship with that parent because the new children get to see them all the time. With the mother, there is obviously a greater risk of violence or sexual abuse from a new male partner, although many step mothers are also abusive but often in a more emotional rather than physical way, on average.

Either way, while there of course will be exceptions, it's mostly terrible for the children and an extremely selfish thing to do. People can start new relationships without cohabiting and having more children.

PelvicFlora · 17/04/2023 10:41

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 10:28

As long as the step parent isn't abusive then there's nothing they or the child can really do to mitigate a situation of the original parents' making.

Well, they could live separately to their new partner so the children's home life isn't disrupted. And not have more children with their parent.

But if the original parent didn't want to live separately from their partner and wants to have more children, then they would go and find someone else wouldn't they?

This is exactly what I mean - the expectation that the stepparent should somehow 'police' or modify the behaviour of the original parent, when it's actually the responsibility of the original parent not to make shitty decisions.

rewilded · 17/04/2023 10:39

Far better to enable them to stay in their own home, with their own things, and let the adults do the shifting.

That is a fabulous concept. I am surprised it has never caught on.

Zebedee55 · 17/04/2023 10:38

rewilded · 17/04/2023 10:23

All of them live with us full time because the SDS mother is frankly a waste of oxygen and DDs dad only sees her for a couple of hours a week.

How did you both manage to have children with such losers?

Well, that could be applied to the single mothers on here really - not just those in blended families.

Most women, presumably, end up as single parents because the man that fathered they children was a loser...🙄

Grumpi · 17/04/2023 10:37

I wouldn’t be surprised OP, that’s sad to read / hear though.

My own blended situation is fine but I definitely would agree there is some unhappiness around it from all parties.

Being “fine” does not equal “happy”. Although I guess it does not necessarily equal unhappy either.

Blended families are hard work and I would really doubt that many people can say that all the family members are happy at all times, but that doesn’t mean it’s disastrous.

Also, children are by their very nature emotionally underdeveloped - blended families become a lot easier to manage and be happy as you get older surely? When you can view relationships with the value of hindsight and life experience? (For instance my relationship with my step mum was very fraught at the start - 20 years later there’s no beef and I don’t ever even think about the “blended” aspect)

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 10:36

@AllInOnePiece Yeah I get that. It's easier than having no children, but only in the same way that not having a second child is easier than not having a child at all. But with the added factor that the child you do have is being raised elsewhere by somebody else.

MMM2022 · 17/04/2023 10:36

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/04/2023 10:13

Yes l found a new baby united everyone. Ours were obsessed with their little sister. She can’t ridiculous amounts of attention.

Same :)

MMM2022 · 17/04/2023 10:36

Bluebells1970 · 17/04/2023 09:59

I would love to know the percentage of children who say that their parent going on to have more children with a new partner enhanced their lives.

Very few, I'd imagine.

I think there will be a lot of different factors to consider in this situation. I am lucky in that we all get along great etc and I have a lovely relationship with my step kids. After breaking the news of the pregnancy they went out and bought me a gift with their own savings and also thanked me. Apparently they had wanted a baby sibling for so long and were thrilled to have blood bond between us.
I let them be as involved as they want and take their suggestions on board etc. They have so much fun together and baby squeals with excitement when they come round. I think it seems nice for them to have another being who adores them no matter what. It’s just as important to me for baby to have good relationship with their siblings.
it helps that their mother has been so accepting of us & baby etc and even babysits if needed.
people do often ask us if it’s weird we all get along so well so I get the impression it is not expected. I do understand this is not so typical though & it is different for everyone. This is just our personal situation.
Most blended families I know have some degree of conflict unfortunately.

AllInOnePiece · 17/04/2023 10:35

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 10:29

I wasn't addressing whether it's good for them. I was addressing the several people saying they cannot comprehend why a parent would WANT another child after separation. To me, it's very obvious why they would want it.

I do think sometimes people (incorrectly imo) think it's not a proper relationship until they've had a child together. I genuinely don't think you need to have a child with every new partner, especially so if you already have them.

mainsfed · 17/04/2023 10:33

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 10:28

As long as the step parent isn't abusive then there's nothing they or the child can really do to mitigate a situation of the original parents' making.

Well, they could live separately to their new partner so the children's home life isn't disrupted. And not have more children with their parent.

Since 86% of single parents are women, what you're really is saying women should live separately to their partner.

The sexism, even inadvertent, is unfair when men are allowed to just live without any judgement because they don't have kids in the house.

Survey99 · 17/04/2023 10:32

I know 6 adults that were the step children in "blended" families. Obviously shit happens and adult relationships fail and adults move on.

3 of them are in the same friendship group and we have discussed this before (under the influence of alcohol!). For most of them their parents co-parented fairly amicably. The common theme for them was a feeling they were the outsiders that had to be a secondary consideration rather than actually an integrated part of their parents second families. They say their was a permanent sense of not "belonging" or being an inconvenience, or being aware their parents were having to try to make them feel included rather than it being real and their relationship with their parents suffered as a result and now as adults they are not close as they would like to be.

The parents that they are close to are the ones where the parents didn't go on to have second families, so while they they were still children they felt it was a more normal child/parent relationship.

I come from an "unbroken", but large family (5 kids) which had it own problems associated with it, but listening to them all talk about the same subtle things that built for them a picture of not belonging and how it made them feel on a daily basis throughout their childhood and impacted their relationships with their parents that I never even considered was eye opening for me.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 10:31

@aSofaNearYou ah I see. Well, yes. What is less understandable is how people are comfortable with putting their wants above their children's wellbeing and needs.

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 10:29

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 10:25

And you really can't see why a parent that only gets to see their child EOW - and during that time that child is almost entirely shaped by somebody else who you don't like and whose teachings you don't agree with - wouldn't feel like an entirely satisfying experience as a parent and compel you to want a child you could actually live with and raise?

And you don't see how it could negatively impact the existing child who is now not "shaped" in their perfect image and considered inferior for that and negatively compared to their half sibling? Written off as an occasional visitor and not part of the "core" family, when they have been through trauma already and feel insecure and then will be pushed out and have even less 1:1 time with that parent.

This is exactly what people mean by selfish adults putting their wants over their children's needs.

I wasn't addressing whether it's good for them. I was addressing the several people saying they cannot comprehend why a parent would WANT another child after separation. To me, it's very obvious why they would want it.

AllInOnePiece · 17/04/2023 10:29

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 10:20

Loads of people on here that aren't even in blended families and live with their children full time are often upset by not having more than one child. And you really can't see why a parent that only gets to see their child EOW - and during that time that child is almost entirely shaped by somebody else who you don't like and whose teachings you don't agree with - wouldn't feel like an entirely satisfying experience as a parent and compel you to want a child you could actually live with and raise?

Oh I can totally understand that yes. I just think it's less, I don't know what the word is, necessary doesn't seem to fit right but hopefully you know what I mean, than if you were completely childless.

For example, I'd have liked to have more children, but I chose a man who already has them. I wouldn't have given up having children at all but I have accepted that despite me wishing to have more, I likely won't if I wish to continue being with DH as he already has children to consider. Its not easy to accept but it's easier to accept than never having had them at all.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 10:28

As long as the step parent isn't abusive then there's nothing they or the child can really do to mitigate a situation of the original parents' making.

Well, they could live separately to their new partner so the children's home life isn't disrupted. And not have more children with their parent.

Weddingpuzzle · 17/04/2023 10:28

My three DC (two boys and a girl) seem much better off watching their soon to be stepfather treat me like a human being. They have had the chance to observe a man who actually likes and respects women and develop a gauge of healthy relationships for the last 5 years. Watching their father break my bones, control me to the nth degree and treat family money as only his to spend made them sad and upset.

We lived alone before I met DP for 5 years and I was skint and stressed and overwhelmed (I enjoyed that 'team' feeling we had don't get me wrong but it was HARD). I studied post grad and got the heralded 'good job' but it still didn't give us the standard of living we have now. Those days were like walking through treacle.

I didn't have any other children because I felt that my DC had had enough to deal with and DP didn't want his own DC. Thinking that other people judge and think that my parenting capacity is compromised is upsetting but I do think it is necessary as a parent to think fiercely about introducing a new adult. I often sit and reflect whether I did it for my own selfish reasons. But then I think that they have had so much more resource made available to them in a two income family. It's not black and white to me as I haven't witnessed any ill effects on my children SO FAR but I am not naive enough to think that there hasn't been any negative impact. Living with anyone is hard - lots of competing personalities and needs.

mainsfed · 17/04/2023 10:28

rewilded · 17/04/2023 10:23

All of them live with us full time because the SDS mother is frankly a waste of oxygen and DDs dad only sees her for a couple of hours a week.

How did you both manage to have children with such losers?

I suspect because people can put on a front for extended periods.

Ted Bundy's wife didn't know he was a serial killer.

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 10:26

Bluebells1970 · 17/04/2023 09:59

I would love to know the percentage of children who say that their parent going on to have more children with a new partner enhanced their lives.

Very few, I'd imagine.

If you look at anecdotes on threads like this, it's a pretty even mix. There are always lots of comments from mainly parents saying their kids hate it, and loads of positive comments from former SC saying their half siblings are just siblings, they're offended by the very notion of calling them half etc etc etc.

My DSS loves his half siblings, he has a much better time here for having another child to interact with in his life.

I doubt it's as skewed towards the negative as you think, there will be good and bad just like there is with full siblings.

PelvicFlora · 17/04/2023 10:26

I find step parents are often blamed for the consequences of the poor choices of the original parents.

I do think that the unhappiness begins with the breakdown of the 'first family'. After that it's really about making the best of the situation. As long as the step parent isn't abusive then there's nothing they or the child can really do to mitigate a situation of the original parents' making.

And yes, I absolutely understand that sometimes it's necessary - even life-saving - to leave a relationship.

Life happens, I guess? Sometimes shit things happen to us that aren't our fault and we just have to bear it. Maybe we'd all be able to cope a bit better and be more resilient if we didn't have this expectation that we should all be blissfully happy all the time?

Sarvanga38 · 17/04/2023 10:26

There are obviously a wealth of situations in this - step parent with no children of their own, both with children, then with added complication of shared children in new partnerships.

I imagine a lot of step parents must think that they love step children as their own, until they do have their own child and the difference becomes very clear.

No, I don't know of any situations personally where I think a blended family has been to the benefit of the children, whether that be through tensions in the house, or a 'parent' who has been part of a child's life for many years, often from a very young age, but then is not able to have any further involvement after a split, as they have no legal rights.

I think as well as wanting to live with a new partner, there are obviously huge financial incentives to co-habitation these days too, when everyone is feeling the pinch of rising costs.

I know it's unpopular and can see the issues, but I do feel that the best thing for the children would actually be the 'nesting' concept. Small children can be more portable, but most secondary age children of my experience absolutely hate being shunted between houses as parents claim their right to access. Far better to enable them to stay in their own home, with their own things, and let the adults do the shifting.

HalliwellManor · 17/04/2023 10:25

I was a step child and my stepdad always treated me as an inconvenience,would pick faults all the time etc.My elder sister he never seemed to have any issues with.He and my mom had a child together and they split when I was 11 and their child was 2 and he never bothered with the 2 year old,she's 35 now and never known what it is to have a father.
I have a dd10 and am single and it will stay that way until she's a young adult,I have no desire for a man,we love our little bubble just the two of us and I can't imagine bringing someone else into our lives/home.She has a dad who she sees and loves to bits so she doesn't need another man in her life. I couldn't bear the thought of her feeling the way I used to feel as a stepchild,I know loads of step parents are great but there's also loads who aren't.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 10:25

And you really can't see why a parent that only gets to see their child EOW - and during that time that child is almost entirely shaped by somebody else who you don't like and whose teachings you don't agree with - wouldn't feel like an entirely satisfying experience as a parent and compel you to want a child you could actually live with and raise?

And you don't see how it could negatively impact the existing child who is now not "shaped" in their perfect image and considered inferior for that and negatively compared to their half sibling? Written off as an occasional visitor and not part of the "core" family, when they have been through trauma already and feel insecure and then will be pushed out and have even less 1:1 time with that parent.

This is exactly what people mean by selfish adults putting their wants over their children's needs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread