Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most blended family situations are unhappy

586 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 17/04/2023 08:30

From my experience of many decades as a secondary school tutor, I would say most of the time when children talk about step parents, there is tension and misery ( from the children's point of view, not necessarily the parents)

I am going to say 75% of situations are unhappy, by which I mean most of the children are somewhat unhappy, or one or more child is very unhappy, or the situation breaks down because of parent or child unhappiness. Breakdown could mean the relationship between parents breaks down, or the relationship between a child and step parent breaks down to the extent a teen becomes homeless, or moves out

So to answer this, you probably need to know at least 4 blended family situations reasonably well, yours as a child, parent, or other people's.

I am expecting that some parents will vote that it is happy, when that isn't accurate, as I am aware this is quite common, and the child has a very different feeling than the parent.

However, I will be pleased if I cam completely wrong about this, and lots mare happy! I just dont see it in teaching.

YABU - less than 75% are unhappy
YANBU - 75% or more are unhappy

OP posts:
HelpIcantfindaname · 17/04/2023 11:28

My now DH moved in with us 18months ago. His DS(16) lives with us as his mum died when he was 5. My DD(14) lives with us & sometimes stays with her DF (although this is getting rarer the older she gets & she says she gets bored at his house.)

So far we are all happy. And we do talk to the kids about it.

The only conflict is chores, whenever my DD is asked to do something she needs to know what DSS has done, as it has to be fair. I have 3 grown up children & that happened with them too.

I was diagnosed with cancer last year with a prognosis of 2 years (I've responded well to treatment so I should be here longer now.) If I die before DD leaves home she has said she doesn't want to live with her DF, she wants to stay here with her SD & SB, so I think she must be pretty happy.

VWHoliday · 17/04/2023 11:27

schnubbins · 17/04/2023 11:23

A stepmother entered the life of my best friend about two years after her very loved mum died . She lost her home and her past in one fell swoop .She is 55 years old and has never gotten over it. It has coloured every aspect of her life since.So very sad .

That is very sad.

However, I know someone who's SD's Mum died and she has stepped up and bought her up with her Dad and her own two children. She very much treats her like her own. She even promised the Mum before she died that she would do her best for the girl (not replace her).

rewilded · 17/04/2023 11:26

*Can't decipher what this means. In response to the PP mentioning having more children with a new partner, you questioned whether that would bring positives to the child "or the adults for that matter".

So, are you saying said child would not bring positives to their parents' life?*

Of course DC are always postive! I am just saying why make things harder for existing DC. I mean they will have suffered grief from when their parents parted(may be for good reason) and now you move them/or move in with someone else and start a new family...surely you can see this will make things worse/complicated for the DC. It is confusing for everyone.

What is so wrong with keeping things simple and separate. Have relationships but keep them away from DC - Nesting also seems like the best option.

Sarvanga38 · 17/04/2023 11:26

Whilst realising that MN isn't life, I think the significant number of inheritance discussions about step-families are also a consideration here.

The kick in the teeth for so many people who grew up feeling that they were considered important to a blended family (parents, grandparents etc.), then discover through the medium of wills that the relationships were considered inferior must be horrendous.

schnubbins · 17/04/2023 11:23

A stepmother entered the life of my best friend about two years after her very loved mum died . She lost her home and her past in one fell swoop .She is 55 years old and has never gotten over it. It has coloured every aspect of her life since.So very sad .

Iwasafool · 17/04/2023 11:21

rewilded · 17/04/2023 11:13

You think moving in with a partner and having a child wouldn't have positives for the adult?

I think if you already have DC from other relationships living there you will cause unhappiness for others without a doubt.

I got divorced with two children. Remarried and kids seemed happy with time with dad and time with us. We wanted to have a baby together but felt it was best to wait, when we had been married for about 3 years one of my kids asked if we wanted children, when I said yes they said, "Well don't you think you'd better get a move on or you might be too old." So a year later my kids had a new sibling, they were thrilled and so was DH (it was his first child) and I was happy. Not sure who we were supposed to have made unhappy.

Iwasafool · 17/04/2023 11:17

springhas · 17/04/2023 09:52

The options aren't stay in an unhappy marriage or blend families. It's perfectly reasonable to live as a single parent and have a serious relationship which doesn't involve your children living with a person who is not their parent. you can go out together, you can stay over, you can all go on holiday together but your children aren't put in a position where they are living with an adult who isn't their parent.

You might have missed where I said my mother was happy when GM moved in with someone with children so mum had a stepfather and step sibling. She also had time with a singe parent but was still happier with step family, her mother was happier, she liked her step sibling and step father, financially things were easier. Sometimes the blending families is the happy solution.

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 11:17

rewilded · 17/04/2023 11:13

You think moving in with a partner and having a child wouldn't have positives for the adult?

I think if you already have DC from other relationships living there you will cause unhappiness for others without a doubt.

Can't decipher what this means. In response to the PP mentioning having more children with a new partner, you questioned whether that would bring positives to the child "or the adults for that matter".

So, are you saying said child would not bring positives to their parents' life?

rewilded · 17/04/2023 11:13

You think moving in with a partner and having a child wouldn't have positives for the adult?

I think if you already have DC from other relationships living there you will cause unhappiness for others without a doubt.

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 11:11

People really do think children from second relationships are a blight on society, don't they.

Wouldn't even bring positives for their own parent.

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 11:09

Are any of those points going to be positive for the DC though or the adults for that matter? It always throws out more probems than it solves

You think moving in with a partner and having a child wouldn't have positives for the adult?

rewilded · 17/04/2023 11:07

I think it depends on a few things OP, such as the ages of the children, whether the step parent who moves in has children of their own, whether the couple go on to have children together etc.

Are any of those points going to be positive for the DC though or the adults for that matter? It always throws out more probems than it solves.

I can understand relationship breakdown, that is inevitable sometimes and but throwing DC from chaos into chaos will never work.

FrancescaContini · 17/04/2023 11:07

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 09:00

It was horrific for our family. After our parents' divorce but before they remarried all of us were fine but the step parents changed everything. One step parent viewed us as an inconvenience and openly told us she didn't like children. The other step parent was abusive. All siblings have suffered with mental health problems, one with suicide attempts. One sibling forced to leave home as a young teen. Other parent wouldn't house them because they had "made a deal" with their partner that the children wouldn't ever live with them so left a teenager to live alone. Another sibling moved to the other side of the world and has never returned. The damage done was immense. All have very little, if any, contact with parents now. Our parents would have told you it was all great, though.

I have maybe 20 friends whose parents divorced and remarried that I can think of and only one of them didn't find it utterly miserable and traumatic.

I am now a lone parent and my children will never be subjected to step parents. I don't understand why anybody would involve a new partner in their children's lives or worse still move in with them or have more children with them. It's so selfish knowing that in the vast majority of cases it's dreadful for the children, who have been through the trauma of family breakup already.

This is what I understand from what I have observed, too.

NeatCompactSleeper · 17/04/2023 11:01

I think it depends on a few things OP, such as the ages of the children, whether the step parent who moves in has children of their own, whether the couple go on to have children together etc.

ArabeIIaScott · 17/04/2023 11:00

A break up/separation/divorce is usually a time of transition and often difficult.

All families go through times of unhappiness and relative happiness.

'All happy families resemble one another, but each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.'

123sunshine · 17/04/2023 10:54

You raise a very valid point. However I think most family situations aren't perfect. I grew up as an only child in a home where my parents loved each other but had a very unhealthy relationship. It was volatile and not a very happy place to be in the middle of. My mum finally left my dad when I was 16. I never had to shut doors with my parents new partners, but even as an adult my relationship with my dads partner is strained, but thats her personality and mine, but we rub along ok. My own marriage broke down and I lived alone with my 2 children for 5 years. I did however meet someone new and remarry eventually, we haven;t had children togetehr, for me that would be too messy and my 2 children were enough. I didn't remarry becasue I was deperate and needed a man, but because I fell in love and found someone I wanted to build a life with. Kids were happy and onboard, however the teenage years have been tough....at times my marriage has been hanging by a thread and all of us, kids hubby and me have felt unhappy at different points, however there is lots of love in our home too. However I do think teenage years particuarly are difficult in any family, let alone a step family. I also have a stepson, who is older. I was honest with myself from day one that I didn't have it in me to be a stepmum to young children, I don't l think that makes me a bad person, just an honest one.
I also think step parents should not be called step parents. They are your mum or dads wife/husband/partner. I don't believe they should have a parental role.

I think the most damage is around kids and parents relationship with exes. I get on fine with my ex husband, kids are free to come and go between the 2 homes as they wish. I detest the whole every other weekend thing, its not fair on kids or adults. However ask any kids what they would want and they would say they would want their parents to be back together, but life isn't a fairy tail....we just all try to do our best with the situation we are in. Families in all froms are complicated.

AdamRyan · 17/04/2023 10:53

My children were very worried about their dad when he was "single" (he was shagging around but they didn't know)
They are much happier now he has a long term partner. And call her kids step sisters.

I don't think this idealistic view of being single until your children are adults is great for them either. Not sure it's healthy for children to think they should be prioritised ahead of anything and anyone else in life.

mainsfed · 17/04/2023 10:51

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 10:41

Since 86% of single parents are women, what you're really is saying women should live separately to their partner.

The sexism, even inadvertent, is unfair when men are allowed to just live without any judgement because they don't have kids in the house.

If you mean resident parents, it's actually over 90%. And no, it is not sexism. 🙄 I don't think either parent should move in with another adult while the children are under 18 if they are still having contact with that parent. In fact in some ways it's even more damaging if the parent they see less of (usually the father) moves a new partner into their home and has more children because the existing children then feel even more pushed out of the relationship with that parent because the new children get to see them all the time. With the mother, there is obviously a greater risk of violence or sexual abuse from a new male partner, although many step mothers are also abusive but often in a more emotional rather than physical way, on average.

Either way, while there of course will be exceptions, it's mostly terrible for the children and an extremely selfish thing to do. People can start new relationships without cohabiting and having more children.

Of course it's sexism. How many of the fathers of children of those 90% single women do you think have meaningful contact with their children?

The idea that women should put their lives on hold may have benefits but it's also inherently sexist because in practise (not in your la la la idealism) it's not expected of men.

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 10:49

So what if they do? Doesn't mean you have to choose to be complicit in a situation that you know is likely to be damaging to children who've already been through trauma. And odd to find someone attractive who has so little regard for others, even their own children. Nobody is saying "step parents should police" anything. 🙄 However, shirking responsibility for your decision to be part of creating that situation to the likely detriment of the children is silly.

If they're seeking out a childless partner - they're unlikely to have put as much in depth thought into it and may have very little experience of whether it's good for the kids or not. A childless person with no experience of kids is just going to trust that if the parent thinks it's fine for the kids, it probably is. Hence why it's more logical to expect the parents to have thought it through.

VWHoliday · 17/04/2023 10:49

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 10:41

Since 86% of single parents are women, what you're really is saying women should live separately to their partner.

The sexism, even inadvertent, is unfair when men are allowed to just live without any judgement because they don't have kids in the house.

If you mean resident parents, it's actually over 90%. And no, it is not sexism. 🙄 I don't think either parent should move in with another adult while the children are under 18 if they are still having contact with that parent. In fact in some ways it's even more damaging if the parent they see less of (usually the father) moves a new partner into their home and has more children because the existing children then feel even more pushed out of the relationship with that parent because the new children get to see them all the time. With the mother, there is obviously a greater risk of violence or sexual abuse from a new male partner, although many step mothers are also abusive but often in a more emotional rather than physical way, on average.

Either way, while there of course will be exceptions, it's mostly terrible for the children and an extremely selfish thing to do. People can start new relationships without cohabiting and having more children.

I have read your other posts and I'm sorry you have had such a bad experience.

I actually know my SC are happy that when their parents split up they met new partners. Especially my SD who would have hated her Dad to live alone when her Mum had her a new partner. Now they are adults they like that someone is there with their Dad.

We had a child together and they all have a really relationship.

I do things with my SC when their Dad is busy sometimes like shopping, meals out, walking the dogs. I also babysit their children sometimes.

It can work.

CurlewKate · 17/04/2023 10:49

In my experience, if all the adults involved, including extended family, genuinely put the children first, then it can work brilliantly. Also in my experience, both IRL and on here, this very rarely happens.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 10:48

mumof2many1943 · 17/04/2023 10:42

Another Cinderella here, mother dumped me under the clock on Paddington Station when I was 6. Father picked me up later, probably only 5 minutes. He remarried when I was 11 to the woman from hell! She was coercive and controlling towards my lovely father who was weak. I was treated like a scullery maid and was dressed in her mother’s cast off clothes. My life started when I was 18 when I left home to start nursing, what joy! Fantastic marriage followed by 3 children then we adopted 6 children 😲 can’t bear to see children rejected.
Phew this has been cathartic!

Wow that is amazing!!! 😊

Weddingpuzzle · 17/04/2023 10:46

This wide eyed, hand wringing 'how did you end up having children with such a loser' is such a weird, victim blaming, odd take to me. My ex H didn't become physically abusive until I was pregnant with our DD, the third child. He was and still is a decent Dad but as soon as he heard that one of the twins I was carrying no longer had a heartbeat he HATED me and basically life was hell for years after that.

I realise now that he was emotionally abusive before that but didn't know I was being emotionally abused as my DF was controlling and I was struggling with childhood trauma. I didn't have the capacity to make the right decisions back in my twenties and 'red flags' and misogyny weren't a thing to me back then. I didn't know about that stuff. Being incredulous that people don't always have the same capacity as you to 'choose wisely' smacks of unhelpful black and white thinking to me.

AllInOnePiece · 17/04/2023 10:46

This is exactly what I mean - the expectation that the stepparent should somehow 'police' or modify the behaviour of the original parent, when it's actually the responsibility of the original parent not to make shitty decisions

Yes I definitely think there is a lot of this that goes on. Step parents being treated as the Scape goat for shit parenting.

DryYourEyesWeepingWillow · 17/04/2023 10:45

But if the original parent didn't want to live separately from their partner and wants to have more children, then they would go and find someone else wouldn't they?

This is exactly what I mean - the expectation that the stepparent should somehow 'police' or modify the behaviour of the original parent, when it's actually the responsibility of the original parent not to make shitty decisions.

So what if they do? Doesn't mean you have to choose to be complicit in a situation that you know is likely to be damaging to children who've already been through trauma. And odd to find someone attractive who has so little regard for others, even their own children. Nobody is saying "step parents should police" anything. 🙄 However, shirking responsibility for your decision to be part of creating that situation to the likely detriment of the children is silly.