Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most blended family situations are unhappy

586 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 17/04/2023 08:30

From my experience of many decades as a secondary school tutor, I would say most of the time when children talk about step parents, there is tension and misery ( from the children's point of view, not necessarily the parents)

I am going to say 75% of situations are unhappy, by which I mean most of the children are somewhat unhappy, or one or more child is very unhappy, or the situation breaks down because of parent or child unhappiness. Breakdown could mean the relationship between parents breaks down, or the relationship between a child and step parent breaks down to the extent a teen becomes homeless, or moves out

So to answer this, you probably need to know at least 4 blended family situations reasonably well, yours as a child, parent, or other people's.

I am expecting that some parents will vote that it is happy, when that isn't accurate, as I am aware this is quite common, and the child has a very different feeling than the parent.

However, I will be pleased if I cam completely wrong about this, and lots mare happy! I just dont see it in teaching.

YABU - less than 75% are unhappy
YANBU - 75% or more are unhappy

OP posts:
MrsH1983 · 17/04/2023 15:26

MNisMyGuiltyPleasure · 17/04/2023 15:24

I divorced by exH 8 years ago and I still see my stepkids (they are all adults now) regularly. I don't have kids myself so that probably makes a difference but I think it's telling that even once their dad and I broke up, our relationships continued.

That is very telling and lovely that you are all still in contact. If they were truly unhappy with you as they were growing up, I doubt you would have a relationship now.

In my experience, relationships with stepparents can be closer and more healthy than those with the biological parents.

MNisMyGuiltyPleasure · 17/04/2023 15:24

I divorced by exH 8 years ago and I still see my stepkids (they are all adults now) regularly. I don't have kids myself so that probably makes a difference but I think it's telling that even once their dad and I broke up, our relationships continued.

KnittingNeedles · 17/04/2023 15:17

I think there are probably some scenarios which can work. For example A and B have kids, later split. Kids live with A. A then meets and marries C, who doesn't have kids and doesn't want any more. B meets someone else and doesn't have more kids. A,B and C all get along fine.

However when you have A and B having 2 kids together then splitting, A then meets C, who already has a kid with D and another with E, A and C have two kids together, B then goes on to meet F, who already has a child with G, and they go on to have two more kids together - what a huge MESS with dozens of parents, aunts, uncles, grandparents, people who are fully related, half related, step related.

Minfilia · 17/04/2023 15:02

rewilded · 17/04/2023 10:23

All of them live with us full time because the SDS mother is frankly a waste of oxygen and DDs dad only sees her for a couple of hours a week.

How did you both manage to have children with such losers?

Well, she trapped DH by lying about being on contraception. She fell pregnant about 3 months into the relationship and he wanted to stay to “do the right thing”. It was only after they had children that he realised how ineffectual she actually was. According to everyone that knows her, she actually presented as a reasonable human being until having second DC… then it all fell apart.

As for my DDs dad… he would love to see her more, but she has separation anxiety caused by the trauma of a close death and isn’t comfortable being away from home, so has refused overnight stays since she was 10. He contributes financially, and stays in regular contact, but DD just doesn’t want to spend that much time with him. It actually isn’t his fault, and he is a reasonable dad who has tried pretty hard over the years.

As you can see, things aren’t always that black and white. And happily we’ve both moved on to a much happier and more functional relationship since…

VWHoliday · 17/04/2023 14:56

Parents not parent.

VWHoliday · 17/04/2023 14:55

HeckyPeck · 17/04/2023 14:46

I'm so glad my parents didn't have such a narrow view of life.

My step parents and half siblings have improved my family. My parents are happier and my family is bigger. I wouldn't have wanted to them to alone or for my siblings tommot exist!

I agree. Parent are happier and another sibling to love. It's not all doom and gloom.

VWHoliday · 17/04/2023 14:50

piratypotato · 17/04/2023 14:40

You can totally love a new half sibling but still be quite unhappy with the way things are.

I'm not saying they didn't find the initial separation upsetting but they are very happy with how things have turned out. By the time sibling had come along all was well.

To argue with me though you will say that they are just pretending even as adults that they aren't happy even though I know they are.

HeckyPeck · 17/04/2023 14:46

Sunshineandshowers39 · 17/04/2023 14:43

This.

I'm so glad my parents didn't have such a narrow view of life.

My step parents and half siblings have improved my family. My parents are happier and my family is bigger. I wouldn't have wanted to them to alone or for my siblings tommot exist!

MrsH1983 · 17/04/2023 14:46

@Nothingisblackandwhite Could not agree more, you are spot on.

HeckyPeck · 17/04/2023 14:45

piratypotato · 17/04/2023 14:40

You can totally love a new half sibling but still be quite unhappy with the way things are.

But, in my experience, the unhappiness was with the fact that the parents separated at all.

I love my half siblings and step parents and I'm really glad my parents were both able to find someone who loves them. They're happy and I'm happy with the new family members I gained.

I think most people who's parents split up will be unhappy because of that. It's often easier to then blame the new step family/half siblings on that than place the anger/upset with your own parents though.

Nothingisblackandwhite · 17/04/2023 14:44

This whole post is ridiculous! Not only proves that headteachers clearly have preconceived ideas and are unable to be unbiased , probably causing massive harm to their students by not being able to actually being ambiguous but people here also seem unable to see that lots of blended families actually work and everyone is happy . Yes not all , but lots do so calling them “broken families” , or single parents broken families or claiming children from second families cause no happiness to their parents or siblings is simply utter BS .
Lots of blended families are a lot happier than those with married parents , lots of single parents families are a lot happier than those with married parents .
And yes my children have a lot to gain from having a step dad and step siblings and a new sister and their step siblings had a lot to gain from having a step mum and see their dad in love and happy . They gained new friends , more financial stability more holidays ,more reasons to meet new people .
By all means if you choose to try and find negatives on it you go ahead but you will literally be creating them in your head .

Sunshineandshowers39 · 17/04/2023 14:43

ETref · 17/04/2023 08:46

I agree that blending families is not best for the dc in the vast majority of cases. Of course there will be the odd happy blended family where it has worked out perfectly and things are harmonious but I think that this is the exception rather than the rule.

Probably an unpopular opinion but I think that if you are single with young dc (male or female, rp or nrp) then you should accept that you can't have an intense relationship with the view to living with your partner until the dc are much older/nearing adulthood. By all means have relationships, there is no requirement to be lonely or miserable if that is how staying single would make you feel. But it is usually in the best interest of your dc to keep that relationship separate from family life until the dc are nearly adults. I do believe it's pretty selfish to move someone into your dc's home and force them (plus possible step siblings) into your dc's life for the sake of your love life.

This.

piratypotato · 17/04/2023 14:40

VWHoliday · 17/04/2023 14:36

I didn't force my SD to feed the baby, push the pushchair, take pictures, cuddle the baby, entertain the baby. She asked to do it. She must have been a really good actor to keep this going for so long. Obviously they have only got a relationship now to keep the parents happy - you don't know what you are talking about.

You can totally love a new half sibling but still be quite unhappy with the way things are.

BlueAndGreen89 · 17/04/2023 14:36

As an ex primary school teacher, I witnessed this an awful lot. From what I saw, many children were unhappy because dad had a new partner and a baby together, mum had a new partner and a baby together, and they felt they didn’t belong anywhere. Some of the things they came out with, as mere 7/8/9 year olds, were truly heartbreaking.

VWHoliday · 17/04/2023 14:36

DrManhattan · 17/04/2023 13:30

All this 'they love the new baby' - do they really? Or are they just saying that so they make their parent happy and to fit in? It's really sad.

I didn't force my SD to feed the baby, push the pushchair, take pictures, cuddle the baby, entertain the baby. She asked to do it. She must have been a really good actor to keep this going for so long. Obviously they have only got a relationship now to keep the parents happy - you don't know what you are talking about.

Nothingisblackandwhite · 17/04/2023 14:32

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 14:23

@Nothingisblackandwhite Are you responding to the PP I was quoting? I was saying much the same thing as you.

My apologies yes I was

aSofaNearYou · 17/04/2023 14:23

@Nothingisblackandwhite Are you responding to the PP I was quoting? I was saying much the same thing as you.

Nothingisblackandwhite · 17/04/2023 14:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MrsH1983 · 17/04/2023 14:12

@piratypotato You raise a very good point which could likewise apply to those who have had good experiences. Yet those are being dismissed. Why?

if people are going to state it as fact that blended families harm children then it has to be questioned. A blanket statement cannot apply to all families and all situations.

piratypotato · 17/04/2023 14:09

MrsH1983 · 17/04/2023 14:07

@piratypotato Young children may not understand why they are unhappy. It may be because of their family situation, but there may be other reasons at play that the child doesn't understand.

Children who are now adults will have a greater understanding and their experiences are valid. But there is still the issue of causation. Was it the blended family that caused the unhappiness? Or was it the parents personalities? Could I have been that the parents ignored the children when in a new relationship which led to resentment? There are so many variables but to just say it is solely down to a family merging is short sighted.

It's not for you to deny peoples lived experience and try and prove them wrong or offer another reason for their unhappiness. You know nothing about them and their families.

MrsH1983 · 17/04/2023 14:07

@piratypotato Young children may not understand why they are unhappy. It may be because of their family situation, but there may be other reasons at play that the child doesn't understand.

Children who are now adults will have a greater understanding and their experiences are valid. But there is still the issue of causation. Was it the blended family that caused the unhappiness? Or was it the parents personalities? Could I have been that the parents ignored the children when in a new relationship which led to resentment? There are so many variables but to just say it is solely down to a family merging is short sighted.

piratypotato · 17/04/2023 14:02

MrsH1983 · 17/04/2023 13:59

There is no evidence to substantiate the claim that the blended family is the cause of some children's unhappiness. There could be numerous elements at play if a child is unhappy which may or may not be down to the blended family situation.

To automatically jump to blended families being the sole and only reason why a child may present as unhappy is extremely narrow minded. Correlation does not equal causation.

it does when those children tell you that the blended family situation is making them unhappy. We don't need objective evidence to believe a child.

MrsH1983 · 17/04/2023 13:59

There is no evidence to substantiate the claim that the blended family is the cause of some children's unhappiness. There could be numerous elements at play if a child is unhappy which may or may not be down to the blended family situation.

To automatically jump to blended families being the sole and only reason why a child may present as unhappy is extremely narrow minded. Correlation does not equal causation.

DrManhattan · 17/04/2023 13:52

@deepspace9 lol

SemperIdem · 17/04/2023 13:52

I think anyone in a blended family can be a bit unhappy sometimes. Same as in non-blended families. Some of the difficulties can be different and unique to the fact it’s a blended family, but many will be the same.

I think a key factor in children of separated parents being happy, step parents and step siblings regardless, is a surety in their biological parents roles in their lives and consistency.