Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think most blended family situations are unhappy

586 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 17/04/2023 08:30

From my experience of many decades as a secondary school tutor, I would say most of the time when children talk about step parents, there is tension and misery ( from the children's point of view, not necessarily the parents)

I am going to say 75% of situations are unhappy, by which I mean most of the children are somewhat unhappy, or one or more child is very unhappy, or the situation breaks down because of parent or child unhappiness. Breakdown could mean the relationship between parents breaks down, or the relationship between a child and step parent breaks down to the extent a teen becomes homeless, or moves out

So to answer this, you probably need to know at least 4 blended family situations reasonably well, yours as a child, parent, or other people's.

I am expecting that some parents will vote that it is happy, when that isn't accurate, as I am aware this is quite common, and the child has a very different feeling than the parent.

However, I will be pleased if I cam completely wrong about this, and lots mare happy! I just dont see it in teaching.

YABU - less than 75% are unhappy
YANBU - 75% or more are unhappy

OP posts:
Nothingisblackandwhite · 17/04/2023 19:04

3BSHKATS · 17/04/2023 18:51

@Nothingisblackandwhite an unfit parent agreed, however the violence came from an outside influence who traumatised an already traumatised victim of divorce, domestic violence and removal from extended family before the age of 10. Without him, wouldn't have happened.
As the social worker above describes, it's too much, too big a risk even when there isn't physical abuse and the emotional abuse ex h's new wife has inflicted on my children is despicable, moving them off the sofa when she wants to sit next to their dad, turning their "bedrooms" into something for hobby, rinsing their grandmother financially so there's no inheritance for them. The woman doesn't give a fuck about her husbands children and I truly doubt step parents do little more than tolerate them in most cases.

That’s why I said blending works when both people were good parents . No good parent would allow that to happen . I know it happens but once more shouldn’t parents like your ex be protecting them from their new partners ? If my partner as much as had any threatening behaviour towards my children or me he would be out on the streets that same minute . I would never tolerate that and I certainly would never inflict any of that on my step children . Please don’t think all step parents behave that way . My partner is a loving step parent and all my children adore him and my step children love staying with us and we all get along . I honestly do not understand the concept I often see on MN where people just believe their step children are nothing to do with them , my step children are the most important thing in my partners life therefore they are as important to me . They are with us every holiday we book , I spend the same on gifts I spend on my children and although I admit I do not love them as much as my own ( they have a loving my and stepmom too ) I sure as hell would never treat them in any way differently and I do feel they as my responsibility to keep happy too and I do love them to bits .

Nimbostratus100 · 17/04/2023 19:03

Mangogogogo · 17/04/2023 15:37

Wow.. a thread intended to try to make a massive amount of women feel bad.

god I’m so glad mn is a world away from real life

Gross

or maybe a thread that might make some people think again and save a number of children from years of misery......

OP posts:
Yerroblemom1923 · 17/04/2023 18:58

It's not easy to love someone else's children and it's a big ask to expect children to get along with their new "siblings". It's no surprise the poll says it all.

3BSHKATS · 17/04/2023 18:51

@Nothingisblackandwhite an unfit parent agreed, however the violence came from an outside influence who traumatised an already traumatised victim of divorce, domestic violence and removal from extended family before the age of 10. Without him, wouldn't have happened.
As the social worker above describes, it's too much, too big a risk even when there isn't physical abuse and the emotional abuse ex h's new wife has inflicted on my children is despicable, moving them off the sofa when she wants to sit next to their dad, turning their "bedrooms" into something for hobby, rinsing their grandmother financially so there's no inheritance for them. The woman doesn't give a fuck about her husbands children and I truly doubt step parents do little more than tolerate them in most cases.

Nothingisblackandwhite · 17/04/2023 18:39

3BSHKATS · 17/04/2023 16:52

My experience is clouded by the fact that my mother brought a man she knew to be violent into our lives - he got into a fight on their 2nd date and still she married him, had two further children with him. He lifted me off the floor by the throat, which was not the catalyst for them splitting up, him giving her two black eyes was the final straw.
Needless to say i have no relationship with any of them and the younger siblings have no idea about the man their father was because he'd stopped drinking by the time they were old enough to know him.
That man could have easily killed me on that occasion. I've dated men who slowly try to come between you and your children, send him to his dads for that night when they want sex that isn't in the scheduele because you havent got childcare that kinda thing, I can see how a weak woman would become conditioned to start valuing the man's attention over more and more demanding children to their detriment and look at the consequences for wee Arthur and Star of blended families.
Not for me.

That must have been awful . I think your situation was more to do with having an unfit parent that did not put you first . I think some people are just not meant to be parents unfortunately.
I think one of the main differences with making blended families work is both people being good parents from the onset and strong independent people. My partner was and is a great dad to his son and his step son ( he married his ex when his step son was 3 years old , he is now 21 and calls him dad and openly says my partner is his dad and nobody else despite having contact with his bio dad ) , I could never date anyone who had no contact with their children as a example , the other think is we both can stand in our own 2 feet even if we where apart , I’m completely financially independent and have been single for over 13 years until we decided to become a family unit , if things went wrong I will be heartbroken but I can pretty much carry on living my life without taking away anything from my children .
Nobody would ever come between me and my kids , ever . They are will always be my priority .
thankfully 3 years on we seem to be doing well and every kid seems happy and so are we

Eggpie · 17/04/2023 18:37

Nc for this. I am a social worker so this is both my personal and professional experience.

On one hand it’s brilliant that relationships can be relatively easy to walk away from these days. There’s benefits to support single parents now and women can work professional jobs and there is little stigma about breaking up or divorcing. People can now leave toxic relationships much more freely and are not shackled to an idiot they married at 20 when they’re 50. All great stuff so far.

However the flip side of this is when children come into play. There is a massive breakdown of both the family unit, extended family and general community which is wrecking havoc on our children. The fact that the pursuit of our own individual happiness above all else has been rammed down our throats in recent decades has not benefited society, children or ourselves. This is reflected across all classes and the impact has resulted chaos, lack of stability and mental illness in our community.

typical modern day example:

Becky, 20, has a baby called Bella with Harry 22. After several years the relationship breaks down due to infidelity, Becky now 24, leaves with now 4 year old Bella and sets up on her own and Bella stays at dad Harry at weekends. Becky and Harry love their daughter and coparent amicably.

Becky always wanted 3 dc and of course marriage and companionship like everyone else. Of course Becky has a right to happiness and should not write off her right to love, marriage and family at 24 years old.

Harry also desires a partner and is only 26 years old. He too should not be destined for life without a life partner at 26.

So Becky and Harry both start dating again. Harry is able to date quite a lot due to not being the resident parent so quickly manages to have 3/4 relationships over a 2 year period. As hes able to spend a lot of time with each new woman he dates it progresses quit quickly each time meaning that Bella has met at least two girlfriends over the 2 year period. Neither relationship has lasted which happens but Bella has now gone instability from her mum and dad splitting up to meeting 2 of dads ‘friends’ and never seeing them again and she’s still only 6 years old.

Becky hasn’t been able to dad as freely as Harry due to childcare commitments and work. She dates when she doesn’t have Bella but it’s harder to keep the momentum of a new relationship going when you have little free time. Eventually she meets Dan after 18 months of being single. Dan is really sweet and a great match for Becky. Becky introduces Dan to Bella and they get on great. Becky moves Dan in after a year. Bella is now 6.5 years old.

Everything blends well. Bella gets on well with Dan and her dad Harry has now also found someone called Rachel who she regularly sees at her contact time at her dads. Rachel regularly brings her own 2 kids over to play with Bella who are a similar age.

A further year down the line and Becky and Dan are married and start TTC and Becky is pregnant. Harry has also moved in with Rachel and her two children. Becky and Dan have their baby and Bella dotes on the baby.

At this point Bella is now 7.5. She has two ‘step’ siblings at her dads house and a ‘step mum’. She has a ‘step’ dad at her mums house and a new half sibling.

A further year on and Harry and Rachel have now broken up as moving in together hasn’t quite worked out. It ended amicably however Bella will likely not ever see Rachel and her two kids again.
Becky and Dan have also welcomed another baby.

Wind forward to 5.5 years. Bella is 14, Becky 34 and Harry 36.

Dan has changed since the two dc came along. Generally lazy, not pulling his weight and being crap all around. Becky has tried and tried to make it work with Dan but he doesn’t change. Becky decided it was easier to go it along and leaves with her 3 dc.

Harry in the last 5.5 years has also met someone. Over the 5.5 years they have moved in together and him and the new partner have a baby on the way.

…..

So if we look at the above. Bella has gone through so much by the age of 14 years old. She has made connections with people (Rachel, Rachel’s kids, Dan) that have been broken, she’s witnessed break ups, adults moving in and adults moving out. She’s dealt with new siblings etc all by the time she’s 14 years old. Infact realistically she experienced a lot by 7 years old.

Now do I think it’s wrong for Becky or Harry to have desired relationships/companionship after Bella? No. Not at all.

But where do you draw the line? Becky now has a 5, 7 and 14 year old. Harry a 14 year old and baby.

Now look at the general impact of this to society:

Chances are Becky will probably at some point want companionship again as a woman in her mid thirties which will repeat the blending cycle to her younger dc if the new partner has kids of his own.

Dan will likely go on to meet another another woman. She may have kids of her own inflicting blending to her own dc and Dan and Becky’s dc.

Rachel probably met someone else after her break up with Harry thus inflicting blending with another man onto her kids. Rachel’s kids dad may have also done the same.

If Harry and his new partner don’t work out then his new partner will probably also go on to date again especially if she wants more dc, thus also repeating said cycle.

….

So where does that leave the children in our society? Unstable home environments from almost every direction. There is a mental health crisis with our young people and I strongly believe the current breakdown of family/security/stability/community is a massive factor amongst others.

I purposefully left abuse out of this typical example. However when you also factor in abuse and the fact that it’s statically higher for children to be abused by stepparents/boyfriends/girlfriends within the family home. Then it’s actually chilling. At least of those children in the example (Bella, her half siblings, her parents partners children) will be abused at some point on top amongst the various blending.

But abuse aside, where do you draw the line?!

Zippedydoo123 · 17/04/2023 17:40

Busybody2022 · 17/04/2023 16:24

I'm another who is very happily a single woman and single parent. I don't want a relationship in my life at this stage. It isnt putting it on hold, just not what I want.

I am like you. Men rarely enhance my life. A few as platonic friends is fine though.

HRTQueen · 17/04/2023 17:26

Yes I do think too many parents put what they want before their children

do blended families work some of them but I think the majority children are often felt pushed out

I would have loved another child and to be in a relationship where I had a happy little family but was that for me or ds? It was for me he has always been happy I felt well why change this it works

SemperIdem · 17/04/2023 17:15

3BSHKATS · 17/04/2023 16:52

My experience is clouded by the fact that my mother brought a man she knew to be violent into our lives - he got into a fight on their 2nd date and still she married him, had two further children with him. He lifted me off the floor by the throat, which was not the catalyst for them splitting up, him giving her two black eyes was the final straw.
Needless to say i have no relationship with any of them and the younger siblings have no idea about the man their father was because he'd stopped drinking by the time they were old enough to know him.
That man could have easily killed me on that occasion. I've dated men who slowly try to come between you and your children, send him to his dads for that night when they want sex that isn't in the scheduele because you havent got childcare that kinda thing, I can see how a weak woman would become conditioned to start valuing the man's attention over more and more demanding children to their detriment and look at the consequences for wee Arthur and Star of blended families.
Not for me.

I’m sorry that happened to you.

I agree with you that parents who are not naturally inclined to putting their children first are very likely to make poor decisions in the blended family arena, as they are in all other aspects of their lives.

Absolutely terrible for the children.

Beezknees · 17/04/2023 17:06

VWHoliday · 17/04/2023 16:12

That is your choice though.

Women can be alone. I'm sure I'd be fine. Some people like a relationship though, it doesn't make them pathetic because they can't be alone.

I've read your posts and you seem to think you have done better for your child than those who have gone on to meet someone else.

Not all stepparents are wicked step mothers or abusive step fathers.

Nah, I don't think that. I just don't want to risk making any more bad decisions.

3BSHKATS · 17/04/2023 16:52

My experience is clouded by the fact that my mother brought a man she knew to be violent into our lives - he got into a fight on their 2nd date and still she married him, had two further children with him. He lifted me off the floor by the throat, which was not the catalyst for them splitting up, him giving her two black eyes was the final straw.
Needless to say i have no relationship with any of them and the younger siblings have no idea about the man their father was because he'd stopped drinking by the time they were old enough to know him.
That man could have easily killed me on that occasion. I've dated men who slowly try to come between you and your children, send him to his dads for that night when they want sex that isn't in the scheduele because you havent got childcare that kinda thing, I can see how a weak woman would become conditioned to start valuing the man's attention over more and more demanding children to their detriment and look at the consequences for wee Arthur and Star of blended families.
Not for me.

Harrypewter · 17/04/2023 16:47

Qualitative and quantitative research shows that blended families present more problems and are inherently more unstable than the original pairing.

I've just split with my girlfriend, I will never ever without serious vetting and a long dating period let another woman into my children's lives.
Some people are incapable of being a step-parent, they overreach natural boundaries.

Busybody2022 · 17/04/2023 16:24

I'm another who is very happily a single woman and single parent. I don't want a relationship in my life at this stage. It isnt putting it on hold, just not what I want.

Busybody2022 · 17/04/2023 16:23

I think the dynamics of a blended family make it exceedingly difficult. There are so many nuances and dynamics and scenarios to figure out. I'm not surprised so many struggle to get the balance right.

There's plenty of non blended families that are miserable too.

VWHoliday · 17/04/2023 16:12

Beezknees · 17/04/2023 15:56

I find it weird that people think not having a relationship equals "putting your life on hold." It insinuates that women can't possibly be happy alone.

I don't want a relationship, not a serious one anyway. My life is fulfilled enough, a man wouldn't bring anything to it.

That is your choice though.

Women can be alone. I'm sure I'd be fine. Some people like a relationship though, it doesn't make them pathetic because they can't be alone.

I've read your posts and you seem to think you have done better for your child than those who have gone on to meet someone else.

Not all stepparents are wicked step mothers or abusive step fathers.

JudgeRudy · 17/04/2023 16:09

I've got 3 examples that I know very well

Family 1-Mum became a step-parent to son 8, daughter 10 when she married her husband. He had 50/50 custody. Most of the 'challenges' were around SD and she ultimately lived full time with her mum and was very low contact with her dad and SM Daughter went off to uni and is now married, likewise her brother. Dad had 2 more children to wife 2. Last weekend all husbands 4 children were at their (him and W2) house. 2 sets of older children now have familied. Their children call SM Nana. Everyone gets on.

Family 2 -Mum and dad both have part time(weekend, weds overnight) access to 2 pre schoolers. Everyone got on with minor squabbling between the younger 2 boys. Both sets of children called the other 'parent' by their name. They did not refer to each other as siblings. Mum and Dad dated for years before living together. When they did, they lasted a year due in part to different parenting styles. Mum stayed in contact with his boys for a bit as local. They're adults now and both sets of kids and parents reflect fondly on the 'adventures' we all had together but have nothing to do with each other.

Family 3 - Dad has 2 young children living with him from 2nd marriage. Blends with Mum (wife 3) who has 3 kids from 3 men. They have 1 more together - baby. Kids get on but some friction with her eldest 2 towards mum(not step dad). Mun n Dad's relationship deteriorates but they 'stick it out' for a few years His youngest was bullied by SM and has been in counselling for this as an adult. His 2nd wife, mum of 2 has regular 'acces' to her 2 children but often takes next child up and 'baby' if it's a treat day out. Those 2 children call her by her name......fast forward, most the kids are now parents. Dad is in hospital. His 2 bio kids and all of Wife 3s kids are at his bedside. The 3 'girls' are off to London this weekend. Baby recently got married and Dad's 2nd wife was invited to wedding (mother to her youngest 2 'step' siblings. So was wife 2s mother who all 4 youngest children (baby, 2 to wife 2 and 1 step to wife 3) call Nana. Wife 2 is particularly fond (protective/nurturing) towards baby and at times has been there for her when she's fallen out with her bio mum or dad. ....all kids vehemently do not use the word step or half. The kids have a great relationship and all love Dad. They don't all get on with Mum from time to time. Baby is the most 'volitile' and mixed up but Dad's only bio son hates SM even as an adult.

And if you think family 3 is complicated, Dad's wife 2 (mother of 2) is also the mum in family 2.

For comparison Family 4 is Mum Dad and 2 daughters. Parents had good long marriage. As children sisters did not get on. Eldest and mum 'fought' throughout teen. Eldest left home at 17. Youngest went to uni. Sisters had minimal contact for 15/20 years. Eldest and mum have had periods of LC. Everyone gets on now and grandchildren too

Lwrenagain · 17/04/2023 16:08

My DS loves his father and stepmum very much, (I think she's fantastic and whilst we aren't friends who see each other, we send nice messages over holidays etc) however should I pop my cloggs he has made it clear he'd want to remain living with my DP (we had our wedding cancelled over covid, but we've been together 10 years) and his siblings here.
Not because her loves my DP more, he's just more fatherly that his dad is. His dad supports this and would, (not that I'm planning on dying, it's just almost happened a few times!) Be happy to let DS remain with my DP and wouldn't feel pushed out, he just knows he's settled with education, friends and likes that DP is quite routine based, this is is home and safe place.
I think that blended families can be amazing, but the focus needs to be on the kids. We don't use phrases like half brothers or sisters, etc and listen always, I think adults have this fear their children "dictate" to them.
They should always feel comfortable enough to tell you how they feel.
If my DS had ever given me a reason he didn't want my DP involved, I'd have respected that. You only get one childhood.
I think some families are just fucking chaos and they are massively unable to parent effectively with their birth children, let alone bringing stepkids into the mix.

Beezknees · 17/04/2023 15:56

mainsfed · 17/04/2023 10:51

Of course it's sexism. How many of the fathers of children of those 90% single women do you think have meaningful contact with their children?

The idea that women should put their lives on hold may have benefits but it's also inherently sexist because in practise (not in your la la la idealism) it's not expected of men.

I find it weird that people think not having a relationship equals "putting your life on hold." It insinuates that women can't possibly be happy alone.

I don't want a relationship, not a serious one anyway. My life is fulfilled enough, a man wouldn't bring anything to it.

Nothingisblackandwhite · 17/04/2023 15:50

MNisMyGuiltyPleasure · 17/04/2023 15:24

I divorced by exH 8 years ago and I still see my stepkids (they are all adults now) regularly. I don't have kids myself so that probably makes a difference but I think it's telling that even once their dad and I broke up, our relationships continued.

That’s lovely of you and them . My partner divorced his ex 8 years ago , his older son is actually a step son now 21 and altough he has biological son and now a biological daughter ( together ) he is still as much his son and my step son as his bio son . It just comes to show not all step parents are bad and not all step families do it wrong .

Beezknees · 17/04/2023 15:46

Minfilia · 17/04/2023 15:02

Well, she trapped DH by lying about being on contraception. She fell pregnant about 3 months into the relationship and he wanted to stay to “do the right thing”. It was only after they had children that he realised how ineffectual she actually was. According to everyone that knows her, she actually presented as a reasonable human being until having second DC… then it all fell apart.

As for my DDs dad… he would love to see her more, but she has separation anxiety caused by the trauma of a close death and isn’t comfortable being away from home, so has refused overnight stays since she was 10. He contributes financially, and stays in regular contact, but DD just doesn’t want to spend that much time with him. It actually isn’t his fault, and he is a reasonable dad who has tried pretty hard over the years.

As you can see, things aren’t always that black and white. And happily we’ve both moved on to a much happier and more functional relationship since…

You can't "trap" someone into having a baby. Your DH should have used a condom if he didn't want a baby rather than rely on a woman he'd only been with for 3 months to do it all.

MrsH1983 · 17/04/2023 15:43

@katyperryseyelid That was lovely to read and you have highlighted an important factor at play. From what you describe, the different families appear affected by the parents attitudes towards the children as opposed to the actual blended family dynamic.

katyperryseyelid · 17/04/2023 15:39

I’m not delusional but my ds is now a very happy 21 year old, still living at home with me and my dh (his step father) and we talk about these things.

We moved in together and married when ds was 8.

Ds and dh have always had a wonderful relationship and still do now that ds is an adult.

It’s my dh that he turns to ahead of myself and his father at times.

We have 2 children together, born when ds was 11 and 18. He adores his younger siblings, they are so close despite the age gap. We went to great lengths to make sure he wasn’t pushed out when his sister was born when he was 11.

He still says that when I told him I was pregnant with her it was the best day of his life, he was so happy.

He gets on well with his father, but his relationship with his step mother is strained. I think this was a) because his father moved far away to be with her and b) she had two children and didn’t like ds coming to stay often as it disrupted their routine, so he only went to stay a few weeks a year.

Dh had no children when we met, so I think that made his relationship with ds easier as there were no other children’s feelings to think of.

Mangogogogo · 17/04/2023 15:37

Wow.. a thread intended to try to make a massive amount of women feel bad.

god I’m so glad mn is a world away from real life

Gross

Laurama91 · 17/04/2023 15:35

I think it depends on the step parent. My mum passed when I was 6. My dads partner used to compare me and my brother to her sons. Always they wouldn't get or do this. As I got older she hid food/towels/all sorts from me. Sometimes she even left the room when me and my brother walked in. She would cook for her sons while I had ready meal. She would lie about us.

I dont have many memories from being a child but I remember asking my dad for a game and a shirt and she told my dad not to get me them as her sons wouldn't get them both. I only have one parent. They have 2 so would just ask for one each.

Since I've moved out I have only seen my dad twice in a year because I dont want to be around her now I have a choice.

Iwasafool · 17/04/2023 15:28

Holly60 · 17/04/2023 12:21

I do actually think that if you already have children then you need to put the needs of the existing children before your own desire to have another child.

Often having a new sibling can be disruptive, and will inevitably split resources further. If that new sibling is going to be significantly younger than their half siblings that also needs to be considered as a factor.

What may seem a relatively straight forward situation now, may not be in 5, 10, 20 years time.

What children of divorce/blended families need is MORE attention, not less.

I often read that people with existing children decide to have another one with their new partner in order to 'have one of our own'. I'm always a bit Confused- children aren't a commodity or a sticking plaster. Do you really want to bring more children into an already complicated situation?

So do you think my son was joking when he suggested I should get a move on if I wanted another baby with his step father? There was also a considerable age gap but it didn't seem to be an issue, in fact teenage DS told me it made him very popular with girls at school who liked coming round to play with the baby. He seemed to think it was all positive.

We actually waited a few years so as not to rush my children, apparently they got fed up waiting.