Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you’d consider me a failure? Be honest.

453 replies

Ladybirdshere · 17/04/2023 01:34

I met with friends on Saturday I’ve been friends with for around 10 years. We are very close, meeting up twice a month on average and share things about our life.

Well Saturday turned out to be a sort of intervention for me by my two friends. They said that they wanted to speak to me as they’d been talking and they felt that life was passing me by and that they felt I wasn’t doing much with my life.

l I think this was mainly focused around around boyfriends and living situation as we are all 29, I am single but my friends are both engaged and both have children.

Anyway, would you consider me a failure?

  1. I work in advertising for 32k a year
  2. I’m well travelled, last year I went travelling around America on my own
  3. I can drive and have my own car
  4. I have a degree and a masters
  5. Ive lived in 4 different cities in the past ten years

but I don’t have

  1. a partner, I’ve been single around a three years. I had a really bad breakup and simply haven’t found a new person
  2. i recently moved back in with my mum as my finances changed and it meant I couldn’t afford living alone.
  3. I don’t have any children

Am I a failure? We sort of agreed to disagree and they said they wanted to just make sure I stayed on the right track :(

OP posts:
riotlady · 17/04/2023 09:57

I’m 30 and I was talking with one of my friends the other day about how it seems to be nearly impossible to time the whole “settling down” thing perfectly. If you’re one of the first ones in your friendship group to buy a house, have babies etc then you’ll be left out of travelling, nights out etc while you’re tied down with responsibilities that most of your friends aren’t. If you’re one of the later ones, you start running out of easily available friends to do things with and you start worrying about being “left behind”. The absolute ideal is to time it so that you’re exactly middle of the pack but how impossible is that given that so much is up to circumstance?

Anyway, you sound like you have a great life and are not at all a failure. My friends range from living at home and travelling to married with two kids and a mortgage, it’s all normal and just part of the big tapestry of life. Your friends sound like dicks.

dimorphism · 17/04/2023 09:56

Wow OP you need new friends. These sound nothing like friends. They sound jealous. I'm bloody jealous - I used to travel the world and I can't now I have kids. Love my kids but they do restrict what you can do and are very, very expensive!

And why the hell do people think moving back in with parents is a failure? You've lived independently, it sounds like a success that your relationship is so great with your Mum that you'd rather live with her (and save money for travelling, buying a house or whatever) than pay through the nose (destroying your saving options for the future) for some no doubt much more crappy room in a shared house with strangers?

If you want to buy a house or do more extensive travelling, living with your Mum is a no brainer and I bet she loves having you around.

I have severe PCOS and I had a baby at 43, naturally (also had one in my late 30s naturally after spending my late 20s and early 30s trying unsuccessfully via IVF at great cost).

29 isn't a huge age for having children (I can't believe I'm writing this) but if having children is something that is one of the most important things for you, you could consider egg freezing, particularly if you don't want to have to compromise on who you have children with. Or you can choose to go it alone, but that is a big decision and commitment.

The only thing that I think has some merit in what these "friends" have said is that it's worth considering how big of a deal children is for you and there are things you can do (egg freezing) to give you options if you don't meet the right person to raise a family with until later.

However, I would say that I have friends who are childless not by choice (through infertility or not meeting the right person until their 40s) and who went through a period of really wanting children in their late 30s but now, in their 40s and 50s, are living exciting lives of travel and being hands on aunties to friends children. All the people I know in this position say they are glad life turned out the way it did for them.

I also have a friend who's always known she hasn't wanted children and all she's ever wanted to do is travel. So she works, saves (and this has included living with parents for various periods) and then goes on the most amazing month long trips around the world. I live vicariously through her facebook photos. She has a very full life.

Twiglets1 · 17/04/2023 09:55

Ladybirdshere · 17/04/2023 08:46

Thank you all for being so kind. I really wanted perspectives from people of all ages to get a better understanding rather than go off what they assumed was the “normal”

I think a part of it is that they don’t think they much in common with me anymore as they talk a lot about babies ofc and wedding planning. The sad thing is I’m always happy to talk about this stuff and I love their children. It feels like they want me to “catch up” so we are all on the same page.

I think that I’m going to branch out a bit and meet some new friends. I was honestly left mortified and embarrassed by their “intervention” but I’m starting to see that their opinions of where I’m at isn’t going to change things. I actually found a lovely quote which I’m going to send them which says

“There are hundreds of paths up the mountain, all lead to the same place, so it doesn’t matter which path you take. The only one that is wasting time is the one running around the mountain telling everyone that his or her path is wrong”

I think it's an excellent idea to branch out and make some new friends. Just gently distance yourself somewhat from those two. They don't deserve you.

AgrathaChristie · 17/04/2023 09:53

To ask if you’d consider me a failure? Be honest.

No.
Your friends have the old Bridget Jones smug marrieds syndrome. In their minds their lives are the only lives.

Lcb123 · 17/04/2023 09:51

They are not friends in my opinion.
your life sounds great, and I wonder if they are envious! I’d tell them honestly how judgemental they’re being and cut them from your life

Pineapples87 · 17/04/2023 09:49

You are not a failure, far from it.

GeriKellmansUpdo · 17/04/2023 09:46

Getting a boyfriend or being married is not an achievement. I don't know why so many think it is.

Poppyblush · 17/04/2023 09:45

If you are my daughter, I’d be proud of you and wouldn’t consider you a failure in the slightest. maybe in your choice of friends!

They are either bitches or very jealous of what you’ve achieved.

Pushmepullu · 17/04/2023 09:44

My son is 28 and has only just managed to afford to move out. He doesn’t have a girlfriend, but then neither do 3 of his close male friends. His best friend is my friends daughter who is also 28. She is currently living at home (saving for a deposit), has done lots of travelling, has moved into a new job earning £120k. She doesn’t have a boyfriend and only goes on a couple of dates after meeting men online. Is she a failure? Hell no! If she and my son were only being defined by a single aspect of their lives then failures let them be. You and they are not failures. Live your life as you wish to not as others wish you to.

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 17/04/2023 09:43

I also think you sound amazing. There are different ways to live one's life. You're better off single and free than with the wrong person, as you well know. But that's life. Failure would be if you'd stuck with him!
As to the living with mum being wrong in some way, no it isn't. Families have done it for generations. My ds (29) still lives with me for now and helps me out here even though he has bought a flat and is paying the mortgage, because it suits us both. With the ridiculous renting situation there's going to be a trend towards more multi-generational living.

TomeTome · 17/04/2023 09:42

What popped out at me was the comment about your fertility. It’s so incorrect it’s embarrassing for them. I have PCOS and while getting pregnant might take a little longer your menopause and peak fertility are later than non PCOS women. I’m older now but I had my first baby at 30 which was the average age for a first time mum, so what on Earth are they on about?
Nobody sensible would jump into a relationship and reproduce in haste unless they had to. I think they’re being weird and you’re worrying unnecessarily.
As for living with your Mum, tons of people do that to boost their deposit and help with finances. It sounds more like they’d like you to have a flat they can meet at. Find more fun people and accept they can’t see beyon£ their own experience.

PearPartridge · 17/04/2023 09:42

Share the Bridget Jones Smug Married clip on your social media op.

Ladderback · 17/04/2023 09:41

Your friends have a very narrow view of what 'track' people should be on. It makes sense for you to move in with your mother and save for a deposit. Or even if it just suits you both to share, that's fine too. Most of my friends only married and had children in their thirties. But your path might be to continue travelling without being tied down.

Underwaterlife · 17/04/2023 09:41

You found anything but a failure. People who judge success based on whether or not you are coupled and have popped out kids can fuck off. You're doing great.

eyerollwiththepunches · 17/04/2023 09:40

@Ladybirdshere Shagging a random bloke and becoming pregnant was the very last thing I was trying to suggest! And you were right to bin an abuser - no mother would want their daughter to stick with someone who was like that. I was meaning more along the lines of having met someone in the 'natural' way (through work/travel/hobbies). But you're better off with nobody than with the wrong somebody.

Your friends should have got married before having children if they are going down the SAHM route, but I don't suppose you were rude enough to say that to them in response.

I do regard having children as my one success in life, so I can see how people think this. But I wouldn't suggest to my child-free friends that they should have done the same (we are now all too old for any of my child-free friends to change their minds).

MattDillonsEyebrows · 17/04/2023 09:39

😂 All the Gen X’er’s on this thread showing their ages with talk of Bridgette Jones and ‘smug marrieds’
OP, your friends are the reason the book was written! I’d highly recommend you reading it, it will make you feel better.

But to answer your question, not only are you not a failure, I’d consider you an outstanding success!
Stay on the path you’re on, concentrating on yourself and your career. If someone comes along and you want to share it then great. If not, it’s a lot easier to make yourself happy by yourself than in a relationship that isn’t right.

LakieLady · 17/04/2023 09:39

Ladybirdshere · 17/04/2023 08:46

Thank you all for being so kind. I really wanted perspectives from people of all ages to get a better understanding rather than go off what they assumed was the “normal”

I think a part of it is that they don’t think they much in common with me anymore as they talk a lot about babies ofc and wedding planning. The sad thing is I’m always happy to talk about this stuff and I love their children. It feels like they want me to “catch up” so we are all on the same page.

I think that I’m going to branch out a bit and meet some new friends. I was honestly left mortified and embarrassed by their “intervention” but I’m starting to see that their opinions of where I’m at isn’t going to change things. I actually found a lovely quote which I’m going to send them which says

“There are hundreds of paths up the mountain, all lead to the same place, so it doesn’t matter which path you take. The only one that is wasting time is the one running around the mountain telling everyone that his or her path is wrong”

There's no such thing as "normal", OP, and what's more important is what's right for you. I'm not surprised that you feel embarrassed. I would actually have been hurt and angry, so you're reacting much better than I would have!

I was about your age when I realised that having children wasn't right for me. Luckily, I found out before I had any. However, I gave into pressure to marry a BF, and he turned out to be an abusive shit. It was the biggest mistake of my life.

Figgygal · 17/04/2023 09:39

They sound like arseholes and the fact they've ganged up to come to you together means I'd be keeping my distance and not trust them again

Katherine1985 · 17/04/2023 09:35

Please don’t feel you need to justify living at your mum’s. It makes total sense to atm, you have a full life, and seem to love and respect each other. Some very smart life developments can grow out of this period of housing stability and mutual support. If she was stifling you I would think differently

Zanatdy · 17/04/2023 09:34

Of course you’re not. Why do people think you can’t be happy if you’re single? It’s ridiculous when 4/5 people I know in relationships are unhappy. Get some new friends, you’re doing just fine. Settling down and having kids is clearly what they call a success, it’s them that has the problem

ChampagneBlossom44 · 17/04/2023 09:34

feckin cheeky pricks! There’s no one size all ‘right track’. You sound like you’ve had a fulfilling & frankly fab life with the travelling & different cities.
i wouldn’t be surprised if a touch of envy has crept in & they’ve rephrased it as ‘support’.
can you IMAGINE If 2 of you were single & childless & staged an intervention on the mother of the group, ‘oh we’re a bit concerned you’ve missed out on fun in your 20s & reduced you career to bring up your kids, we’re really concerned you didn’t have enough one night stands, we’re just saying don’t have more kids & get back on the right track’

GeriKellmansUpdo · 17/04/2023 09:34

I married at 24 and had two DC. My best friend-didn't want children anyway- married at 49 and had no DC. I didn't try to intervene in her life, and she didn't try to intervene in mine. That's what friends do.

I would be so happy if my DD turned out like you.

NoTouch · 17/04/2023 09:33

SorePaw · 17/04/2023 02:05

@Avarua2 why do you think she needs to move out of her parents house soon?

IF she's happy there & they're happy to have her there, then it's a great arrangement. Wasting money on rent, just to say you don't live 'at home' is stupid. If everyone's happy with the arrangement it's better to save for a deposit, or to travel.

Agree! I thought @Avarua2 must be one of OPs "non" friends.

Sassypants82 · 17/04/2023 09:30

Honestly, they sound jealous and have agreed among themselves that it's your lifestyle is the problem because they are in the same boat together.

Their 20s or part of, have been given over to having children and sounds like you've enjoyed many life experiences they haven't, so, to make themselves feel better, they try to convince you (and themselves) that your lifestyle is inadequate.

Not so. Please don't let this ridiculous attack get in on you.

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 17/04/2023 09:29

Of the 3 (your mum and your 2 "friends"), your mum is right.

The friends have taken a different path and had kids and now have weddings to plan (and fund) which I still think is arse about tit.

You really need to find different (nicer) friends.