Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be this upset about a school place

238 replies

cdoth · 17/04/2023 01:20

Been in tears since I found out my DS didn't get offered a place at the school I applied for.

For background - he has significant speech delay and is on the pathway for an autism diagnosis. He is currently at the nursery of the school we put as our first choice, he is really settled there and they have been fantastic with regards to his SEN. They are helping us to gather as much evidence as possible for his EHCP. The school is also the closest one to us.

I am distraught with worry for what the future holds for him now having to go to a completely new school. I can't stop crying because this seems so unfair for him. He is not good with new places/people, when he started his current nursery last year it took weeks for him to settle in because he was so upset. And for him to have to go through that again genuinely breaks my heart.

I know we can appeal but I don't feel hopeful. Has anybody else been in the same situation? I just don't know where to go from here now.

OP posts:
niugboo · 17/04/2023 13:25

Temporaryname158 · 17/04/2023 01:22

  1. you can appeal in the basis of the EHCP being developed
  2. you can immediately put him on the waiting list for the school you want. Not everyone offered a place there will accept it
  1. only if they’ve agreed to issue. And on that basis you don’t need to appeal. You just name the school on the plan.
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 17/04/2023 13:25

cdoth · 17/04/2023 13:18

Just spoke to school briefly at drop off. Not sounding hopeful, said they are the most oversubscribed in the COUNTRY and the wait list is massive but she will book a meeting in with us asap. Don't stand a chance of getting a place, I really want to give up.

She can't possibly know that.

In any case, people will move, go private, get their kids in somewhere else etc. So it's worth doing.

niugboo · 17/04/2023 13:22

Which rule did you apply under? When did application for ehcp go in?

LockInAtTheFeathers · 17/04/2023 13:21

cdoth · 17/04/2023 13:18

Just spoke to school briefly at drop off. Not sounding hopeful, said they are the most oversubscribed in the COUNTRY and the wait list is massive but she will book a meeting in with us asap. Don't stand a chance of getting a place, I really want to give up.

Don't give up. It doesn't matter how long the waiting list is- what matters is your position on it, which is likely to be high if you live close by. I'm also sceptical about the most oversubscribed in the whole country claim- I'm not sure how they'd know that!

cdoth · 17/04/2023 13:18

Just spoke to school briefly at drop off. Not sounding hopeful, said they are the most oversubscribed in the COUNTRY and the wait list is massive but she will book a meeting in with us asap. Don't stand a chance of getting a place, I really want to give up.

OP posts:
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 17/04/2023 13:18

cdoth · 17/04/2023 09:56

Thanks so much everybody for the advice. First thing I will do is speak to the nursery, I will also mention the EHCP and I'm going to look at applying for it myself so we can get the ball rolling. Everything is so overwhelming, he's my first and only child so I have no experience with this and don't what the "norm" is.

The school we put as first choice is closer than the one we were offered (we literally live a few streets away) so I thought this would also help in our favour but obviously not. I'm struggling to make sense of everything at the moment.

It will have helped you in that you'll have had higher priority than an otherwise identical child who lives further away, but as 4 year olds aren't evenly distributed around schools, you can still have situations where ones who are very close miss out on a place.

But the fact that you're so close is likely encouraging in terms of the waiting list. Agree with other posters, get on that. I do have one NT with no EHCP myself so I get the stress.

GinUnicorn · 17/04/2023 13:18

Keep on the continuing interest as there is often a lot of movement. Don’t lose hope.

swimsong · 17/04/2023 13:17

We were coparenting and were refused the school that was halfway between us. Although we were both slightly outside the catchment area, they could have accepted on social grounds. I went to a solicitor who said that sometimes it just takes a letter - he did just that, asking for the minutes of the meeting where applications were decided. The day after they received it we got a call saying that he was now accepted from the waiting list.

moozles · 17/04/2023 13:17

I appealed for my son as I didn't get my first choice school. My view on it was if I didn't at least to try and appeal, I would never know! However I had the support of the school and sounds like you would too, I would definitely try. You may be surprised, we also won our appeal and got the place we wanted. Good Luck!!

NewNovember · 17/04/2023 13:08

I would definitely defer to start reception in 2024

BaconMassive · 17/04/2023 13:07

The SEN thing is like anything else if they haven't formally got the SEN / EHCP designation then they are treated the same as everyone else.

It's like trying to buy a house by saying you have a million pound deposit, but when they come to check, you haven't actually got a million pound deposit but expect to shortly. You won't be allowed to buy the house.

If it was allowed then non-scrupulous folk might try to use it as a way to bend the rules. It's unfortunate that the SEN designation / EHCP hasn't been put in place prior to the admissions process as this would have ensured they were near the top of the priority criteria.

Staggeringthrough2023 · 17/04/2023 13:03

Also-in my borough, first priority is given to SEN/looked after children so I am baffled that you've missed out, especially if you're in the catchment. This should be very appealable.

gogohmm · 17/04/2023 13:02

@Crumpleton

But it may have been even closer for other pupils. You can't appeal on distance unless they miss measured the distance

Staggeringthrough2023 · 17/04/2023 13:01

PP have given great advice but it's really worth finding your local councillor, asking to have a phone chat with them and see if they can use back channels to try and get some movement on a place. I really hope you get it sorted for him, such a stressful time 💐

Crumpleton · 17/04/2023 12:59

This is the closest school to us so the distance thing makes no sense either. It all seems so unfair

Assuming it's the school in your catchment area I'd fight it on this alone.

NothingSurprisesMeAnymore · 17/04/2023 12:57

Contact Sunshine Support – Sunshine Support (sunshine-support.org)* *@cdoth It's run by parents/carers of ND children, providing information and support to other parents/carers. Their wealth of knowledge is incredible.

Sunshine Support – Sunshine Support

https://sunshine-support.org/

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/04/2023 12:56

YouJustDoYou · 17/04/2023 12:24

Just because it is the closest, doesn't mean it's in your catchment - my friend couldn't apply to the school one road over because she was 2 houses out of the catchment line! It's insane.

Being out of catchment doesn't prevent you from applying.

Smineusername · 17/04/2023 12:54

Sorry don't have time to rtft so apologies if this has already been mentioned but your health visitor can also write a letter in support of your application, laying out the reasons why the school is the best fit for your child. I would contact them to ask for this

LockInAtTheFeathers · 17/04/2023 12:52

YouJustDoYou · 17/04/2023 12:24

Just because it is the closest, doesn't mean it's in your catchment - my friend couldn't apply to the school one road over because she was 2 houses out of the catchment line! It's insane.

Only certain areas of the country have catchments, and in England you can always apply for any school you want to, regardless of whether it is your catchment school or not. You may not get a place if you are out of catchment and those in catchment get priority, but there is nothing to stop you applying.

Best of luck with getting a place at your first choice school OP. Today is not the end of the journey by any means- as others have said there is likely to be movement on waiting lists, and there are plenty of very knowledgeable posters on here who can help you. Please accept the school you have been offered for now though so that your son has somewhere to go in September as a back up- that won't make you any less likely to get the school you want.

Serena73 · 17/04/2023 12:44

What number is he on the waiting list? We were refused a place at our junior school, the feeder school from the infants. We weren't expecting this but it was a high birth year. I was distraught and planned an appeal but my child doesn't have SEN or anything. He was number 4 on the waiting list and was offered a place before the appeal. I think at least 6 people on the waiting list got a place this way.

CoffeeWithCheese · 17/04/2023 12:43

LIZS · 17/04/2023 11:17

The school we put as first choice is closer than the one we were offered (we literally live a few streets away) so I thought this would also help in our favour but obviously not. I'm struggling to make sense of everything at the moment.

There is a chance you are near the top of a wl , which will be ordered according to the same admissions criteria.

First thing OP - go onto the Primary Ed board and start this as a thread there - there are a couple of posters who know the admissions code inside out who are incredibly helpful when it comes to technicalities and planning appeals and the like.

Second - it's very likely you were incredibly near the cut off boundary - and it might well be that, when places shake down and people accept or move away as house moves complete or whatever else - a place comes up. We've just been in this situation with DD1 for secondary places - accepted our second choice and then got our first choice offered a couple of weeks later. You need to make sure you're on the waiting list for your first choice school and the process for that varies - so ring the admissions department at the LEA and ask them (make a cuppa - the wait will be awful on the phone today).

Thirdly - you need the back up plan - if that's looking into deferring and spending longer in nursery or accepting the offered place. Would he be able to cope with staying in the nursery if his current cohort of peers had moved up into the main school? I didn't defer DD2 (similar circumstances) because I didn't think she would and felt that for her, extended time with a younger social group would not have been beneficial but kids are all different.

Primary forum will be very helpful OP - people on here are being kind (you're bound to get the twats riding in later) but there are posters in there who really really know their school admissions stuff.

BaconMassive · 17/04/2023 12:33

The admissions team should be able to provide the criteria for all the places awarded and how many got down to distance and then the furthest distance away from the school that was awarded. If they don't provide it then you can request it through a FOI request.

Many authorities provide this as part of the service, maybe they are supposed to.

i.e.

https://www.sheffield.gov.uk/schools-childcare/oversubscribed-schools

Anyway you will see for example which categories of children aren't getting in their 1st choice school. If children with siblings already in the school aren't getting in then you probably have little chance on distance alone, so either you have to hit one of the higher criteria or you have to join the waiting list.

The notion that somebody reviews all the applications and decides based on a review of the child is ridiculous. Firstly, the local authority no way have resources for such an exercise, secondly it will come down to opinion and then that would be challenged - it would never end. The LA systems will just say "you live 1.3 miles away, they live 1.1 miles away" they take priority in the pecking order over you. That's it.

Oversubscribed schools | Sheffield City Council

https://www.sheffield.gov.uk/schools-childcare/oversubscribed-schools

YouJustDoYou · 17/04/2023 12:24

Just because it is the closest, doesn't mean it's in your catchment - my friend couldn't apply to the school one road over because she was 2 houses out of the catchment line! It's insane.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 17/04/2023 12:19

You need to appeal based on the admissions criteria for the school.

You can use SEN as your grounds for appeal but not inconvenience of distance. You need to be confident that you missed out on a place that was yours based on the admissions criteria of the school

Also, there will be lots of movement on the lists yet so get your name down on the waiting list for your preferred choice as you've more chance of getting a place through that than through appeal if you don't meet the admissions criteria?

Get your SEN team on board with regards to the appeal too.

Sugargliderwombat · 17/04/2023 12:18

Reception teacher here - there are always significant changes to our lists. People apply and then decide to go private/ move / defer. Get on that waiting list ASAP 🙂.