Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be this upset about a school place

238 replies

cdoth · 17/04/2023 01:20

Been in tears since I found out my DS didn't get offered a place at the school I applied for.

For background - he has significant speech delay and is on the pathway for an autism diagnosis. He is currently at the nursery of the school we put as our first choice, he is really settled there and they have been fantastic with regards to his SEN. They are helping us to gather as much evidence as possible for his EHCP. The school is also the closest one to us.

I am distraught with worry for what the future holds for him now having to go to a completely new school. I can't stop crying because this seems so unfair for him. He is not good with new places/people, when he started his current nursery last year it took weeks for him to settle in because he was so upset. And for him to have to go through that again genuinely breaks my heart.

I know we can appeal but I don't feel hopeful. Has anybody else been in the same situation? I just don't know where to go from here now.

OP posts:
GastonHaugh · 17/04/2023 14:51

.

Thats not correct. The LA must name that parental choice so long as the placement is not “incompatible with the effective education of others or an inefficient use of public funds.” Children and Families Act, section 35 I think.

niugboo · 17/04/2023 14:49

Staggeringthrough2023 · 17/04/2023 14:47

When a decision has been made wrongly without all evidence being considered.

Why aren’t you encouraging parents to access the lawful route of appeal?

Staggeringthrough2023 · 17/04/2023 14:47

niugboo · 17/04/2023 14:45

On what basis? That doesn’t sound lawful.

When a decision has been made wrongly without all evidence being considered.

niugboo · 17/04/2023 14:45

Staggeringthrough2023 · 17/04/2023 14:43

I'm a borough cllr. And I absolutely have helped reverse these decisions at appeal in the past.

On what basis? That doesn’t sound lawful.

Staggeringthrough2023 · 17/04/2023 14:43

UWhatNow · 17/04/2023 13:26

Oh dear the amount of misleading information on this thread from people who have no idea how school admissions work …sigh.

Contacting your Councillor or MP won’t change a thing. Admissions are tightly controlled in law and are allocated using ‘fair and objective’ criteria to make sure everyone is treated the same. There are no back door ways to circumvent the system.

Op what you need to do is:

  1. keep checking the waiting list as these do move considerably over the summer.
  2. Chase the EHCP.
  3. Make an appeal but as it’s likely to be an infant class size appeal - don’t get your hopes up.
  4. Don’t do what a pp suggested and limit your grounds for appeal. If your distance is a factor then include it. Panels are limited by what they can consider but you can say whatever you want in your appeal.
  5. Be positive for your child. Children might not like change but it’s inevitable as they’re all leaving nursery anyway. Your child - trust me - will eventually thrive and settle whatever school you get.

I'm a borough cllr. And I absolutely have helped reverse these decisions at appeal in the past.

TheNoodlesIncident · 17/04/2023 14:27

Thanks so much everybody for the advice. First thing I will do is speak to the nursery, I will also mention the EHCP and I'm going to look at applying for it myself so we can get the ball rolling. Everything is so overwhelming, he's my first and only child so I have no experience with this and don't what the "norm" is.

So an ECHP hasn't actually been applied for yet? You need to get cracking with that. The IPSEA letters a PP linked upthread are great, you might also need them if your LA is behind with getting their applications processed (as so many are). There are time limits which apply to the process which they must not exceed by law.

You'll get support from posters who've been through this already, but kindly, this is just the beginning: you really need to start finding out what support and services are available to your child and push for them if necessary. It's a steep learning curve that none of us wanted to be on, but you are the best advocate that your child is going to get, and he needs you to fight his corner as he cannot. It's your job to find out as much as you can so you're armed with relevant information and gird yourself to being assertive (if it's not in your nature to be pushy) for what he needs.

I really hope you do get the school you want, it sounds like you will be near the top of the waiting list so don't give up hope. But don't forget that although you and your ds would prefer to stay somewhere that is familiar with familiar staff, that setting might not be the best one for him ultimately. Change is unsettling and frightening for young children with autism, but sometimes it's necessary if another placement is actually better suited for an individual child. Don't get hung up on this one school just because it's the one you know and like... if the provision isn't as good, it won't be doing him any favours.

Forget about appealing this time, they won't have made a mistake over the distances and your child's SEN won't make any difference to the criteria. You might have to later on (I did for secondary) but not for infants. Hoping you move up the list soon!

usererror99 · 17/04/2023 14:24

Is the school your catchment?? It can be closer geographically but not always catchment - doesn't mean you can't apply but if it's the most oversubscribed school in the country and not your catchment then Your chances of getting in were always going to be difficult?

Willowthecrisp · 17/04/2023 14:24

Might be worth focussing on the school he has been accepted to. What is their SEN provision like? Will he know anyone there? Read their ofsted and school website- it might make you feel more positive about it: You say it took him weeks to settle at nursery- sounds rough but he’ll settle at the new school too. Can you start or join a Facebook group for his year at the new school and try and arrange some meet ups over the summer so there are some familiar faces.

Chocolatesandroses · 17/04/2023 14:11

My situation was different to yours but my ds was in nursery and was starting school in the September but school said because of he’s needs etc he would really need to go in to a unit . He had a EHCP but wasn’t diagnosed with autism so he couldn’t get in to any of the units without a diagnosis . They kept him in to nursery even when he was suppose to start school until they found a school for him and he has a diagnosis . While you’re waiting to appeal I would speak to both school and senco to see what support they could give u .

niugboo · 17/04/2023 14:05

kierenthecommunity · 17/04/2023 13:49

But similarly there are mainstream schools with specialist provision in house, and sone of those are an excellent fit for a child with SEN, over their local school. In which case such a school MAY be named

Admittedly it’s moot though as we have no idea what the child’s needs are, but it doesn’t always follow you get the ECHP = school you favour.

Yes it does - and if they don’t name your preference you can appeal.

the law is very clear on this. Parents have a fundamental right to have their children educated in a mainstream setting. The LA cannot override that right. Ever.

Are you actually familiar with the legislation that covers all of this?

diamondpony80 · 17/04/2023 14:04

I could've written your post myself 4 years ago. DD didn't get into our school of choice either. This was the school where she was attending nursery and where DS had gone for 8 years and been very happy at. She also had a speech delay and was on the pathway to an ASD diagnosis. I'm not normally an emotional person, but I was SO expecting her to get in I ended up crying in front of her nursery teacher when she said she was sorry DD hadn't got in. We were told appealing wouldn't do any good and there just wouldn't be a place for her unless 2 children dropped out. One actually did, but obviously that wasn't enough.

The school she did get into was our last choice on the list, and one we never dreamed she'd end up at. Although I was incredibly upset about it, DD didn't really understand, and we decided to let her go to the school she was offered the place at. She's ended up being very happy there and although I do still wonder how she would've got on in the school we really wanted, she's doing well where she is.

Grimbelina · 17/04/2023 14:04

I would absolutely be meeting all the Sencos and heads of the school you want, the school you were offered and any others that are nearby.

The one thing I am certain of is that for a child with SEN you need to feel confident that a school actually wants your child and isn't going to put barriers in your way to support (e.g. not meeting the EHCP) in the hope that you eventually move them (and this happens more than you might think).

Another good idea is to join local SEN groups and hear the inside info. from parents with children in the schools you are interested in (I was advised to do this by CAMHS and it was excellent advice).

Also, definitely apply for the EHCP needs assessment yourself, and start the ball rolling to defer a year so you have more time to work out what to do.

It is also worth starting to investigate if there are any specialist schools near you as this may be something you want/need to pursue if not now then in the future. These schools are often very oversubscribed and it is harder to get in (if not impossible in some places) to get a place in the later primary years.

Deferring a year at least gives you time to make a better and more informed decision.

kierenthecommunity · 17/04/2023 13:51

Just as a matter of interest, the posters who appealed/made a call with a few minor veiled threats and got a place - has this been in recent years? As where I live I can’t see this having worked in the last 7-8 years, as some schools have been that oversubscribed throughout.

kierenthecommunity · 17/04/2023 13:49

niugboo · 17/04/2023 13:40

Whoops typo. Should say must name parental preference. They also cannot name a specialist provision. The right to mainstream is written in law.

@kierenthecommunity

But similarly there are mainstream schools with specialist provision in house, and sone of those are an excellent fit for a child with SEN, over their local school. In which case such a school MAY be named

Admittedly it’s moot though as we have no idea what the child’s needs are, but it doesn’t always follow you get the ECHP = school you favour.

Kennykenkencat · 17/04/2023 13:42

I had a similar experience when eldest was allocated her first school.

Our local authority covered an area shaped like a Y with the school offered some 6 miles away at the top point and our house at the bottom linked by a dual carriageway, no pavements in between.
The schools I chose were nearest to me

I phoned the LEA who said there was no point in appealing. Having seen that if you are allocated a school not of your choice over 3 miles away then the LEA at the time had to provide you with a taxi for pick ups and drop offs

Within about an hour of asking for a taxi for DD’s commute to school I was called back and offered the nearest school I had chosen

Look at whether you are in the same local council as the school and the distance to your allocated school

niugboo · 17/04/2023 13:40

niugboo · 17/04/2023 13:38

That is not correct. With an EHCP the LA must patently preference save for very few exceptions. If the parents select this school the LA would almost certainly have to name. All explained in section 38 of CAFA.

Whoops typo. Should say must name parental preference. They also cannot name a specialist provision. The right to mainstream is written in law.

@kierenthecommunity

niugboo · 17/04/2023 13:38

kierenthecommunity · 17/04/2023 13:34

Exactly, if you’re in position one for example you still have a very good chance!

Habe you looked at the previous years figures to see if it was similarly oversubscribed and what the distance cut off was? As if it’s been very similar every year you may face the exact same problem next year if you defer.

The EHCP isn’t a golden ticket to get a place either - only if it named this school as being the best fit your son. Bear in mind it may well suggest a different school altogether with specialist facilities.

That is not correct. With an EHCP the LA must patently preference save for very few exceptions. If the parents select this school the LA would almost certainly have to name. All explained in section 38 of CAFA.

kierenthecommunity · 17/04/2023 13:38

niugboo · 17/04/2023 13:30

That’s complete nonsense. She’s got no way of knowing that re most oversubscribed and quite frankly if they did know that why didn’t they tell you?!

I mean I suppose it is possible based on the number of applicants, who put it as first choice etc. But I’ve never heard of sone sort of league table either! And I’m surprised the figures are available so soon.

I’m also surprised the nursery never told you how over subscribed the school is if they’ve been so supportive thus far. I can’t imagine this is a one off phenomenon for them.

Foxymoxy68 · 17/04/2023 13:37

Apologies if someone has asked this already, but has his current school said they can meet his needs?

fruitbrewhaha · 17/04/2023 13:37

Crumpleton · 17/04/2023 12:59

This is the closest school to us so the distance thing makes no sense either. It all seems so unfair

Assuming it's the school in your catchment area I'd fight it on this alone.

But it’s not according to which school you are closest to, it’s a numbers game. If there are 30 children who live closer or have siblings in the school they will get offered a place first.

Hopefully you are not far down on the list and will still be offered a place.

What is the school where you have a place like? I do think you are catastrophising. It may be a good school for him.

niugboo · 17/04/2023 13:36

Staggeringthrough2023 · 17/04/2023 13:03

Also-in my borough, first priority is given to SEN/looked after children so I am baffled that you've missed out, especially if you're in the catchment. This should be very appealable.

For SEN rule to apply you have to apply under that rule and prove that only that school can meet need. For example if child was in wheelchair and it was the only accessible school in the area. What’s been outlined here wouldn’t qualify. And it doesn’t sound like they applied using this rule anyway.

kierenthecommunity · 17/04/2023 13:34

LockInAtTheFeathers · 17/04/2023 13:21

Don't give up. It doesn't matter how long the waiting list is- what matters is your position on it, which is likely to be high if you live close by. I'm also sceptical about the most oversubscribed in the whole country claim- I'm not sure how they'd know that!

Exactly, if you’re in position one for example you still have a very good chance!

Habe you looked at the previous years figures to see if it was similarly oversubscribed and what the distance cut off was? As if it’s been very similar every year you may face the exact same problem next year if you defer.

The EHCP isn’t a golden ticket to get a place either - only if it named this school as being the best fit your son. Bear in mind it may well suggest a different school altogether with specialist facilities.

niugboo · 17/04/2023 13:30

cdoth · 17/04/2023 13:18

Just spoke to school briefly at drop off. Not sounding hopeful, said they are the most oversubscribed in the COUNTRY and the wait list is massive but she will book a meeting in with us asap. Don't stand a chance of getting a place, I really want to give up.

That’s complete nonsense. She’s got no way of knowing that re most oversubscribed and quite frankly if they did know that why didn’t they tell you?!

niugboo · 17/04/2023 13:28

cdoth · 17/04/2023 09:56

Thanks so much everybody for the advice. First thing I will do is speak to the nursery, I will also mention the EHCP and I'm going to look at applying for it myself so we can get the ball rolling. Everything is so overwhelming, he's my first and only child so I have no experience with this and don't what the "norm" is.

The school we put as first choice is closer than the one we were offered (we literally live a few streets away) so I thought this would also help in our favour but obviously not. I'm struggling to make sense of everything at the moment.

If they’ve not even applied yet it’s too late for a September start. The process takes 20 weeks.

UWhatNow · 17/04/2023 13:26

Staggeringthrough2023 · 17/04/2023 13:01

PP have given great advice but it's really worth finding your local councillor, asking to have a phone chat with them and see if they can use back channels to try and get some movement on a place. I really hope you get it sorted for him, such a stressful time 💐

Oh dear the amount of misleading information on this thread from people who have no idea how school admissions work …sigh.

Contacting your Councillor or MP won’t change a thing. Admissions are tightly controlled in law and are allocated using ‘fair and objective’ criteria to make sure everyone is treated the same. There are no back door ways to circumvent the system.

Op what you need to do is:

  1. keep checking the waiting list as these do move considerably over the summer.
  2. Chase the EHCP.
  3. Make an appeal but as it’s likely to be an infant class size appeal - don’t get your hopes up.
  4. Don’t do what a pp suggested and limit your grounds for appeal. If your distance is a factor then include it. Panels are limited by what they can consider but you can say whatever you want in your appeal.
  5. Be positive for your child. Children might not like change but it’s inevitable as they’re all leaving nursery anyway. Your child - trust me - will eventually thrive and settle whatever school you get.