Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be this upset about a school place

238 replies

cdoth · 17/04/2023 01:20

Been in tears since I found out my DS didn't get offered a place at the school I applied for.

For background - he has significant speech delay and is on the pathway for an autism diagnosis. He is currently at the nursery of the school we put as our first choice, he is really settled there and they have been fantastic with regards to his SEN. They are helping us to gather as much evidence as possible for his EHCP. The school is also the closest one to us.

I am distraught with worry for what the future holds for him now having to go to a completely new school. I can't stop crying because this seems so unfair for him. He is not good with new places/people, when he started his current nursery last year it took weeks for him to settle in because he was so upset. And for him to have to go through that again genuinely breaks my heart.

I know we can appeal but I don't feel hopeful. Has anybody else been in the same situation? I just don't know where to go from here now.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Moglet4 · 07/07/2023 18:02

They have very strict criteria which is in a hierarchy and they will stick to it. For example, siblings might be given first priority. Distance often comes after that and it’s as the crow flies. Even if you are within catchment, you might be further out in the circumference than another family. Places will be given to those closest to the school first.

LockInAtTheFeathers · 20/04/2023 11:46

@Kennykenkencat I also don't understand your comment about how you were told you could apply to any school and get in if they had places because of your catchment. That applies to anyone- any school with places has to take anyone who applies no matter where they live Confused

LockInAtTheFeathers · 20/04/2023 11:44

@Kennykenkencat Ok, I'm going back to saying it all sounds incredibly dodgy then. School places HAVE to be offered strictly in accordance with the published admissions criteria- there is no subjectivity over how near you live to other schools, etc, and they can't just bump someone because they could more easily get to another school. It doesn't matter how soon you pull someone else's place away if it's a place that should have been genuinely theirs- the 3 day window only applies to places offered in error.

I'm not commenting on how fair the published admissions criteria are here btw (there are 'black holes' where it is difficult to get into any local school due to being just outside of the admissions distance of them all, and I understand that it is very unfair and harsh on those living there), but they are the ones that need to be followed. There would have been no argument whatsoever if the person with the original place hadn't got it back and had gone to appeal.

All I'm trying to say is that any LA that did this is going very strongly against the Admissions Code, so no one reading this should assume that they can get a nearby place by bringing up paying for transport.

Kennykenkencat · 20/04/2023 10:43

LockInAtTheFeathers

but your original post (maybe unintentionally) makes it sound as though you reminded the LA of their requirement to pay for transport if your DD went to her allocated school and they therefore magically came up with a place at the school you wanted

That is exactly what happened. I think the person I got in the phone was on a power trip. He told me there was little point in me appealing. I didn’t have any reason to appeal. That was the school I had been given and that was the school Dd would go to and there was nothing I could do to change that.

I then agreed she would go there but as it was over 3 miles away (even as the crow flies) I would need for them to get me a taxi for her each day as per their terms and conditions.
He took my address and the address of the school and I think looked at it on a map and saw how ridiculous the journey was. He said he would get back to me.

He never did. The next call I had was later that day from the HT of the school nearest to us saying they would like to offer Dd a place there.

You then mentioned that offered places could only be rescinded within a 3 day timeframe and I was saying that this was all within the timeframe.

Ultimately our road is in a unique position being miles away from the nearest schools in our “catchment area” but closest to schools which are technically outside the catchment area. However the pupil who got bumped and then reinstated later on was also outside the catchment area for the school but very close to schools in their own catchment area. IYSWIM

I did call the LEA over a change of schools a couple of years later (school was very much a primary only school. Junior school was in a different location) and was told because of the anomaly of the catchment area and where we lived we could choose any school we wanted in the county and as long as I could transport dc there and back myself and there were current spaces we would get in.
If I didnt choose a school in our “catchment area” and was then allocated one, because of distances the LEA would have to pay for transport for Dc

It was a case of we would cost too much money.

I don’t think anyone had ever considered that our road (9 houses) would have children living on it. I was the youngest by about 30 years when I moved in and I was late 30s.

LockInAtTheFeathers · 20/04/2023 09:31

@Kennykenkencat Ok, but your original post (maybe unintentionally) makes it sound as though you reminded the LA of their requirement to pay for transport if your DD went to her allocated school and they therefore magically came up with a place at the school you wanted. Your latest post saying that an error was made which was very quickly rectified and you got the place you should have been offered in the first place is a different scenario.

Kennykenkencat · 20/04/2023 08:13

LockInAtTheFeathers · 17/04/2023 20:44

@Kennykenkencat That sounds extremely dodgy. If they did take an offered place away then the original recipient would have had very strong grounds for appeal if they hadn't gained the place back. I believe that the general rule of thumb seems to be that 3 days is a reasonable timeframe for an offered place to be taken away (and even then only for a genuine error), and after that then offered places should stand.

Given all the letters would have gone out on the same day. It was probably within 3 days timeframe.

The person who had their place take away (then given back at a later date) lived in a different local authority as well and much further away than me

AWanderingMinstrel · 19/04/2023 20:45

OP if your EHCP names the school your child will usually go to the top of the awarded places (after looked after/ previously looked after children). Going forward this is the way to guarantee a place at the school you want for primary or secondary.

Lougle · 19/04/2023 20:21

FindingNeverland28 · 19/04/2023 20:04

Oh wow. I guess it depends on the panel. Maybe our LA is more “sympathetic”. We’ve had our PAN size reduced to 60, but there’s a chance that appeals will be successful, which will over subscribe us.

Not if they're following the law. The only grounds for an ICS appeal to succeed are:
~ The admissions process was not followed correctly, and if it had been the child would have been given a place. (E.g. the admissions policy states that siblings are prioritised over distance, but a sibling was refused a place and a child who only qualified for a 'distance' place was admitted)

~The admissions policy was contrary to the Schools Admissions Code and the child would have been given a place if it was not (e.g. the school admissions policy makes no provision for Looked After Children, but the Admissions Code mandates that LAC are given priority)

~The decision not to admit the child was perverse in the light of the admissions arrangements (but the bar is 'Wedensbury unreasonableness' which means that no other admissions authority would have refused a place in the same circumstances).

This means that almost all discretion is removed from the panel. They can't say 'That sounds really hard' and award a place.

PatriciaHolm · 19/04/2023 20:12

FindingNeverland28 · 19/04/2023 20:04

Oh wow. I guess it depends on the panel. Maybe our LA is more “sympathetic”. We’ve had our PAN size reduced to 60, but there’s a chance that appeals will be successful, which will over subscribe us.

Nothing to do with the LA, and I suspect the Head is mistaken, or grumpy at that moment for some reason ;-) Appeals are heard by independent panels and the vast majority lose.

ICS appeals are very hard to win. Overall, around 16/17% of primary appeals are won, but ICS is around or under 1%. Secondary win rate is about 20%.

What was your PAN? If it wasn't a multiple of 30, appeals so far won't have been ICS so they run a higher chance of winning, and if your school/Admissions authority has a weak case (for example you have a good sized school, well staffed etc) you may lose more.

FindingNeverland28 · 19/04/2023 20:04

Lougle · 19/04/2023 19:58

The Infant Class Size appeal success rate is 0.4% in my LA. Most parents do not win ICS appeals.

Oh wow. I guess it depends on the panel. Maybe our LA is more “sympathetic”. We’ve had our PAN size reduced to 60, but there’s a chance that appeals will be successful, which will over subscribe us.

Lougle · 19/04/2023 19:58

FindingNeverland28 · 19/04/2023 19:53

I was in a staff meeting last night (teacher) and the head was talking about our intake for next year and how we’re at risk of being over subscribed. She mentioned that most parents win appeals. So don’t give up hope.

The Infant Class Size appeal success rate is 0.4% in my LA. Most parents do not win ICS appeals.

FindingNeverland28 · 19/04/2023 19:53

I was in a staff meeting last night (teacher) and the head was talking about our intake for next year and how we’re at risk of being over subscribed. She mentioned that most parents win appeals. So don’t give up hope.

niugboo · 19/04/2023 14:03

pollymere · 18/04/2023 22:16

Ok... Getting an ASD diagnosis shouldn't cost money, neither should the EHCP. The EHCP is a document you can file yourself saying what support for your child would look like. It needs to be practical things rather than a list of problems. Such as My child has SPD and needs to avoid velvet or cord fabrics. Or, My child has difficulty managing simple instructions so would need an adult to explain them on a one to one basis etc. On the Speech, you could write they have speech issues and would need support in class to be understood and sessions with a speech therapist twice a week (for example).

On the last part of the EHCP, you can put a named school you believe meets the needs of your child. You can say why they can meet the needs of the child. The school then has to appeal or give you a place rather than you needing to appeal. You still have time for this entire process if you do it now. Look at SENDIASS for EHCP advice

This is so far from accurate it’s untrue.

Please ignore all of it.

CoffeeWithCheese · 19/04/2023 13:32

OP - I'd really urge you to take this out of AIBU and start a thread in Primary Education about the appeals/waiting lists side of thing, and one of the SN forums about the SEN stuff/EHCP etc. AIBU can be a real drop-in place for people who can argue very authoritatively sounding about things that they're not always factually accurate about.

Also - get an appointment to visit the allocated school, talk to the SENCO and ideally whoever will be class teacher for September (although this might not have been decided yet obviously) - at the moment it's a big flashing red question mark of unknown in your mind and it might well not need to be that way.

As an aside - my youngest had minimal intelligible speech when she started school, massive continence issues - and was very close in age to my eldest who was in the year above. She'd started school and, well, it wasn't the greatest but I'd listened to MN about local schools and all that stuff - and after school applications had gone in for the youngest - had a huge wobble, things went very wrong for the eldest and I realised they were really only paying lip service to the idea they'd be able to meet the youngest's needs. Ended up hitting the email trail up for local schools - found one with spaces that I'd never ever considered - and moved both kids - and it was fucking amazing. Best parenting decision I ever made in terms of the attitude to SEN, the support for DD's speech, the whole nurturing vibe of the place... shame about the juniors it fed into which was shite, but we won't talk about that aspect now! Just saying that because sometimes things do happen in a way that feels terrible at the time but pans out for the best.

Vynalbob · 19/04/2023 11:56

Appeal (I've done it twice & won, didn't appeal a 3rd time but it worked out better than expected)

Think out your strategy & Google the present rules for appeal, as you're emotional (reasonably) take a calm logical person as support (take notes with you in case you forget something)....maybe do a practice at home. I helped finding facts for someone with a SEN DD and found a specific (to their condition) charity that helped.....maybe an autism charity will help

Grimbelina · 19/04/2023 08:58

OP, I would make another post in the SEN section asking about deferred entry into reception for a child with possible ASD while you apply for an EHCP, look at schools etc.

I know lots of PP's are saying just stay on wait lists, you will get your first choice etc. etc. but I don't think parents of children without SEN fully understand the implications of what your child's needs might look like in the classroom or a mainstream school (especially one which isn't offering the right support).

Lougle · 19/04/2023 06:31

pollymere · 18/04/2023 22:55

Ah @Lougle This will be why I got my own child's EHCP first time and have never had an EHCP rejected for any I've helped write. You don't need a school's involvement to START the process or request one. You are correct that part of the drafting process will involve supporting evidence from medical professionals but you don't need to obtain private consultations with private individuals for this. The documents provided during the diagnosis process are sufficient and do not cost money. I've done this process plenty of times with 100% first time success without expenditure.

Well then you'll know to give accurate advice and that the parents don't write EHCPs and don't dictate the content of them. No money needs to be spent, but parents do need to know that clause 9:49 of the SEN Code of Practice says that the Local Authority must seek "Advice and information from any person requested by the child’s parent or young person, where the local authority considers it reasonable to do so." which means that if the child has sensory needs, for example, the parents can request advice from an occupational therapist, even if OTs aren't commissioned for sensory assessments in their area (as is the case in Hampshire, for example).

Squishable · 19/04/2023 06:08

Honestly I’d be cautiously optimistic. I kept my son back a year as he’s august born and I thought he needed more time. This meant that I still had to apply (in order to refuse a place) to school last year and he got into an oversubscribed one. I felt terrible as it took them ages to update the system ( getting close to summer holidays)So they didn’t offer out his place till then. I’m sure you’ll have some summer babies that won’t take up their places and first choice should go to kids with EHCPs and siblings. Definitely appeal and good luck x

FloatingBean · 18/04/2023 23:05

OP be careful with SENDIASS, some are good but too many repeat the LA’s unlawful policies. IPSEA and SOSSEN are better.

Section I isn’t the last section of an EHCP either.

Schools don’t appeal anything. Most academy schools can seek the Secretary of State’s determination as to whether they should have been named by the LA, but this isn’t an appeal and the parents can still appeal any decision via SENDIST.

pollymere · 18/04/2023 22:55

Ah @Lougle This will be why I got my own child's EHCP first time and have never had an EHCP rejected for any I've helped write. You don't need a school's involvement to START the process or request one. You are correct that part of the drafting process will involve supporting evidence from medical professionals but you don't need to obtain private consultations with private individuals for this. The documents provided during the diagnosis process are sufficient and do not cost money. I've done this process plenty of times with 100% first time success without expenditure.

Pigriver · 18/04/2023 22:41

Sorry posted too soon.
Speech therapy and EP in already. It takes time to build up enough evidence to apply for an echp then a minimum of 20 weeks to get it done. There are massive backlogs everywhere. It would be rare that they could get it done in time for it to influence school placements. I'm a nursery teacher and sendco.
Your best bet it to either defer the place and he spends another year in nursery then get the echp and choose that school or visit the other school and have a honest conversation about his needs and whether these can be met. With a robust transition and possibly part time to start it could work. I know many people gutted by not getting their first choice but being happy overall once the dust has settled and a plan is in place.

Pigriver · 18/04/2023 22:37

If your child started in the nursery in September then they have done well to get speech ther

minimonkey11 · 18/04/2023 22:28

Sorry I haven’t read the whole thread but the closest school isn’t always your catchment school- in our case we put closest (quarter of a mile) as first choice but didn’t get it as it wasn’t catchment school (a mile away). We knew all this we were just hoping to get in anyway! As pp have said there is a lot of movement between getting places and the actual start dates so i am sure it will work out.

Lougle · 18/04/2023 22:28

pollymere · 18/04/2023 22:16

Ok... Getting an ASD diagnosis shouldn't cost money, neither should the EHCP. The EHCP is a document you can file yourself saying what support for your child would look like. It needs to be practical things rather than a list of problems. Such as My child has SPD and needs to avoid velvet or cord fabrics. Or, My child has difficulty managing simple instructions so would need an adult to explain them on a one to one basis etc. On the Speech, you could write they have speech issues and would need support in class to be understood and sessions with a speech therapist twice a week (for example).

On the last part of the EHCP, you can put a named school you believe meets the needs of your child. You can say why they can meet the needs of the child. The school then has to appeal or give you a place rather than you needing to appeal. You still have time for this entire process if you do it now. Look at SENDIASS for EHCP advice

This is not an accurate description of an EHCP or the process for getting one. EHCPs have a strict legal process. The parents give advice to the local authority about the child, but that is alongside advice from an educational psychologist, the child's current educational setting, etc.

If the child has a speech and language difficulty, a speech and language therapist would need to assess and make recommendations. Parents can't stipulate what support the child needs without some foundational evidence.

With regards to school placements, the school doesn't appeal anything. If they feel that they can't meet the needs set out in the draft EHCP, they inform the LA of the reasons why. The LA decide if the reasons are reasonable, and if so, they inform the parents. The parents have the opportunity to appeal to the SEND tribunal. In practice, it's quite hard for schools to turn down a child unless there are significant reasons why they can't meet need, and that can't be ameliorated by reasonable adjustments.

pollymere · 18/04/2023 22:16

Ok... Getting an ASD diagnosis shouldn't cost money, neither should the EHCP. The EHCP is a document you can file yourself saying what support for your child would look like. It needs to be practical things rather than a list of problems. Such as My child has SPD and needs to avoid velvet or cord fabrics. Or, My child has difficulty managing simple instructions so would need an adult to explain them on a one to one basis etc. On the Speech, you could write they have speech issues and would need support in class to be understood and sessions with a speech therapist twice a week (for example).

On the last part of the EHCP, you can put a named school you believe meets the needs of your child. You can say why they can meet the needs of the child. The school then has to appeal or give you a place rather than you needing to appeal. You still have time for this entire process if you do it now. Look at SENDIASS for EHCP advice