Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this kind of behaviour in the classroom is not acceptable?

37 replies

stabledoor · 16/04/2023 22:21

My DD is in Y7 at the local comprehensive. I have a DS in Y10 at the same school. It's a big and very diverse school, but I'm a strong supporter of comprehensive education, and have been firmly of the belief that a bright child will do well wherever they are. My DS is motivated, has been lucky enough to make friends with a group of like-minded and bright boys, and appears to be doing well - academically and socially.

However, from my DD I'm hearing a lot more than I ever have from my DS about some of the behaviour in the school, and I'm just astounded at some of the things that I'm hearing. I don't know if this is normal for urban secondary schools, and very keen to get some perspective on this from others. I'm worried about the effect this is having on her and her learning (she's a very different character to my DS).

For example, my DD says that in class, during lessons, the other girls will do things like sit there and curl their eyelashes or get out body spray and spray themselves and the teachers do nothing. Children turn up late to lessons, sometimes with ridiculous excuses, and teachers appear to do nothing about it. All of Y7 have to have computers this year and she says often in lessons, if they're meant to be doing something on their laptop the other kids will just be playing games or watching stuff - the teachers seem to be aware of this and do nothing about it. They have a lot of supply teachers and she tells me that some teachers say to the class that they don't have to do the work that's been set, just go on their laptops and as long as they keep quiet that's fine. In Art and Drama, 2 subjects which my DD loves, the teachers apparently spend so much time trying to control the class - one boy in particular - that they hardly get to actually do or learn anything - to the extent that DD said the other day that she's beginning to hate art lessons.

So AIBU to be shocked by some of these things. Are they just what happens in schools these days? Will things be any better if I move my DD to another school (if I can even do that - we'd have to wait for a place to come up as other local schools are all over-subscribed)? Should I be complaining to the school about these things that I'm hearing? (I have already written to them about a couple of teachers/lessons that I haven't been happy about).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CoffeeCantata · 17/04/2023 11:09

I worked in what was considered a middle-class faith school (big comprehensive)and I was shocked at what went on in some lessons (I wasn't a teacher at the time).

I've seen a lot of it over the years and I think students and parents have far too much power. Teachers and SLT are terrified of them, which I just don't understand. There are huge disincentives to excluding children and it means that the majority of children who come to school to try and learn have their opportunities spoiled by a feral minority, to whom sanctions mean nothing.

I've given it so much thought over the years (as a secondary teacher and in other capacities in schools). Class size is key, but also making sure that parents are really on board with expectations when their children join a school too. I remember, while visiting schools with one of my children in Y5/6 the Head's speech really laid it on the line. She said 'If you don't want to work, do your best, hand in homework on time, be polite and helpful etc etc etc, then this is not the school for you!'. She didn't bother with any of the 'soft soap' and mushy PR which the other Heads had all spouted and I really respected her for that.

We escaped this because we live in a grammar school area so the problems were minimal in terms of disrupted lessons - but not zero. But I know from working in big comprehensive schools just what challenges teachers and motivated students face. Schools are just too damn big these days, for one thing, but the problems are very complex.

OfCourseImNameChanging · 17/04/2023 11:06

Please don't blame individual teachers who seem to 'do nothing', OP. The behaviour policy of the school is the issue, and the lack of resources to make anything better. I left an 'outstanding' comp after a long and successful teaching career because I wasn't safe in the classroom and I couldn't keep the students safe either. Pregnant staff members were getting punched by kids who received no consequence; they were expected to keep teaching them the next day. That was pre-covid and it's only got worse since.

Sourfairy · 17/04/2023 11:04

Zipidydodah · 16/04/2023 23:07

This is why teachers are leaving in droves- the alphabet soup of ‘diagnosis’ that mean that children can do whatever the fuck they like because they have “additional needs”

I'd be willing to bet that the girls doing their lashes and using body spray during lessons are NOT the ones with additional needs. Those girls are sitting there quietly masking and following the rules.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 17/04/2023 10:56

Yep, that was my experience at school in the 90s/00s. I've teacher friends who all say similar, but with added assault and violence. It sounds bloody awful.

Plumbear2 · 17/04/2023 09:49

It's certainly not the norm in my child's school. Being late, abusive language, running etc gets you a detention and isolation. Disruption to the class gets them sent out of the lesson so others can work. Many people say this is to strict but it actually works. It's certainly not all state schools and private schools and s certainly not the only option.

twistyizzy · 17/04/2023 09:45

Yep this is standard in our local secondaries and is the reason why we have chosen private for DD.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/04/2023 09:39

Sounds fairly normal from my experience of teaching secondary for 26 years.

A teacher can only do so much. How does your dc know the teachers knows the kids are on computer games? Its what kids do.

My ds no 29 with 2 MA’s and a brilliant job is very proud of the fact that he managed to complete an entire game in 2 years of school IT. It’s one of his biggest achievements apparently.🤷🏼‍♀️They’re kids.

Tidsleytiddy · 17/04/2023 09:28

I was at a comprehensive school in the 70s. We ran riot and sat and did our make up and bunked off. We all now have degrees and successful lives. I know the behaviour sounds bad but it really isn’t an indicator of what can be achieved

stbrandonsboat · 17/04/2023 09:15

If things get to a point where your dd's future is being compromised, look into private online education. It's more affordable than conventional private schooling. We had to do this with ds2 when things got too bad in his school. Some of the kids were downright feral and bullying was rife.

He left online secondary school with eight good International GCSEs and is doing very well at college now.

oakleaffy · 17/04/2023 09:14

Aphrathestorm · 17/04/2023 08:47

This is why I dont believe in comprehensive education.

School should be for learning.

For DC with difficulties there needs to be a more social program to get them to the point of being able to engage in education without that disturbing the majority.

Completely agree with you.
Schools seem to be awful these days [At least at secondary level]..Very disturbed children that disrupt classes..It seems to be far worse in the past few years.

Aphrathestorm · 17/04/2023 08:47

This is why I dont believe in comprehensive education.

School should be for learning.

For DC with difficulties there needs to be a more social program to get them to the point of being able to engage in education without that disturbing the majority.

MrsKeats · 17/04/2023 08:18

Of course it's not acceptable but it is how it is,
This is largely why there is a crisis in teacher retention (as well as ridiculous workload)
Parents would be shocked if they spent any time in a high school. A colleague of mine had his arm broken by a student and ended up retiring early. Why should that be tolerated?

oakleaffy · 17/04/2023 01:43

mathanxiety · 16/04/2023 23:33

YABU to be shocked.

This is why people send their children to private schools. There are other reasons too, but the way children can be left to sink or swim in state schools is high on the list of reasons people go private.

THIS.
Many State schools now appear to be horrendous.

People choose to send their children to Private schools to avoid this.

Murdoch1949 · 17/04/2023 01:29

Retired secondary school teacher here, with friends still working. The examples you have given do happen, but are not happening in the majority of lessons in the majority of schools. I was never told to fuck off, had I been, that student would have been internally suspended. Students refusing to work in a lesson would be removed, then later disciplined for their poor behaviour. Behaviour Management in secondary schools is vital to successful teaching and learning, it is a relentless slog but has to be consistently carried out. For every disturbing incident you hear about, contact the teacher, tutor or head of year. You be as persistent as the school should be.

SpaghettiSquash · 17/04/2023 01:10

It sounds about right to me. Behaviour has got much worse since covid.

unvillage · 17/04/2023 00:58

Teaching early secondary is extremely difficult.

I mean, music lessons in year 7? With the buttons on the generic keyboard all enabled at all times? DJ! DJ! DJ! sexy lady moan! DJ! DJ!

They have no idea what they're interested in. I honestly understand not being bothered until about year 9 when GCSE options start to manifest. I bet the teachers are fed up and permissive. Pick your battles, etc.

Jivens · 17/04/2023 00:38

I’m in Scotland where no one gets punished for anything if they are under 18 and from a rough background. So if a child assaults your child and is charged by police, they can be sat next to your child again the next day in class. There is nothing you can do about it. It’s absolutely horrendous. The poor, poor kids. There’s a reason school refusal is rising rapidly. There is no way as an adult I would want to head into such a violent and lawless situation every day yet we expect it of our kids. It’s crazy. My kids school is meant to be one of the best state schools in Scotland.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 16/04/2023 23:48

A lot of the behaviours you describe don't actually impact your DD's learning.

TheFireflies · 16/04/2023 23:43

Well it certainly sounds like my secondary school in the late 80s (apart from the laptops)

Dibbydoos · 16/04/2023 23:39

Ywudu · 16/04/2023 22:47

Sounds fairly typical.
At my childs school they put the children in sets for the main subjects after Christmas in year 7.

It seems to work fairly well as the ones who want to learn are kept separated from the ones who don't.

Obviously it isn't very beneficial for the children who want to learn but struggle.

Schools and exams only measure performance in one and we've all fallen into the same trap.

Why do we accept theres a group who want to learn and a group who dont?

Teach kids practical stuff not useless facts!

surreygirl1987 · 16/04/2023 23:38

This doesn't surprise me at all. I teach at a private school so we don't have this, but I don't think this is unusual for many state schools. It is wrong, but it doesn't surprise me. From the title of your thread I was expecting far worse!

mathanxiety · 16/04/2023 23:33

YABU to be shocked.

This is why people send their children to private schools. There are other reasons too, but the way children can be left to sink or swim in state schools is high on the list of reasons people go private.

lanthanum · 16/04/2023 23:32

Ywudu · 16/04/2023 22:47

Sounds fairly typical.
At my childs school they put the children in sets for the main subjects after Christmas in year 7.

It seems to work fairly well as the ones who want to learn are kept separated from the ones who don't.

Obviously it isn't very beneficial for the children who want to learn but struggle.

You make it sound like the point of setting is to keep your child away from the oiks.
It isn't; it's to make it easier to ensure children are working at an appropriate level - which hopefully makes it less likely that they will switch off and more likely that they will be motivated to work.

One of the big disadvantages of setting can be that the lower sets end up with a disproportionate number of the disruptive children. Schools do try to mitigate that - the lower sets are often smaller, and may get more TA support. However this doesn't always work, as you have acknowledged. That's partly why some schools prefer to stick with mixed-ability, and spread the trouble-makers as thinly as possible.

Remaker · 16/04/2023 23:27

I think there’s a difference between behaviour that impacts other classmates and behaviour that doesn’t. Other students curling eyelashes or playing games instead of working shouldn’t stop your DD from doing her own work.

Is your DD generally happy? Does she have friends at school? When my DD started secondary her cousin also started at a different school. My niece was determined to find fault with her school because most of her primary friends had gone to private schools and she felt resentful that she hadn’t. So every day there would be a laundry list of every transgression she’d witnessed. My SIL was so stressed about this ‘terrible’ school and all the rough students. Meanwhile DD reported that many of the same things happened at her school but she just ignored them and focused on her own work/friends.

Mamamess · 16/04/2023 23:23

Sounds like my experience of secondary school. Drugs were also the norm at my school as in pupils on drugs at school. Fighting was also a regular occurrence. The anxiety of just getting through the day unscathed was overwhelming at times, my stomach is flipping just thinking about it. I didn’t really confide in my mum as I just presumed it was normal. Feel really sorry for teachers, can’t completely blame it all on parents either, my own research points a lot towards our system.