Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the 'trans issue' isn't a big deal

242 replies

angiec89 · 16/04/2023 22:03

It just blows my mind how many people on here are so hung up over trans women. They're such a small percentage of the population. I have never seen an obviously trans woman in a women's toilet (not that it would particularly bother me if I did), in fact I very rarely see trans women out and about ever.
I'd be happy to listen to explanations but I really don't understand the issue. Surely there are thousands of more pressing issues regarding women's rights and safety currently than the 0.27% of the population (a USA statistic but I assume it's accurate enough) that are trans women. And even then it would be a minuscule proportion of those that are ill-intentioned towards women. It just seems like a big fuss about something so obscure when there are huge issues that deserve more attention.

OP posts:
Dontbelieveaword · 16/04/2023 22:46

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

sst1234 · 16/04/2023 22:46

Wait, wait, OP is now pulling the science card in schooling you all on cis being a scientific term. Yet the whole premise of the thread is dismissive of science as she doesn’t think that a dude calling himself a woman is a big deal, nor scientifically inaccurate.

Honestly, this thread is such a poor attempt at winding people up.

daughtersanathlete · 16/04/2023 22:45

Op can you explain to me why my daughter should be precluded from representing Great Britain purely on the grounds of her sex.

Thanks.

Noicant · 16/04/2023 22:44

Cis isn’t a scientific term when used in this context. For it to be so someone would have had to prove there is such a thing as gender identity and it is completely unrelated to biological sex and we all have it . Please point me in the direction of such evidence

DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 22:43

angiec89 · 16/04/2023 22:13

That's understandable. But surely men could do that anyway? There's nobody standing outside checking, any perv could just walk in if he so desired to

Because there is a social convention that men stay out of women's spaces. Any man who invades such a space risks consequences, because no man ever invaded women's spaces uninvited with a good motive. It is important therefore that the social convention isn't undermined, such that some men are now permitted access (because reasons) because once you give an inch, suddenly you've lost a mile.

BIWI · 16/04/2023 22:42

Exactly @WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll

Transwomen are not women.

Women are not ciswomen.

You cannot change your biological sex.

(Do we really have to go through all this again?)

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/04/2023 22:40

Obviously you wouldn't need to differentiate between cis and trans in every sentence about women. But in certain specific examples it's a useful word.

In which case, you simply use 'women' and 'transwomen'.

EmmaEmerald · 16/04/2023 22:40

Pixiedust1234 · 16/04/2023 22:35

but the mortality rate of trans women is incredibly high, and 5 times the rate of trans men for perspective.

Please link to your source. I believe the mortality rate has been debunked.

Also using cis is a slur, so don't use it on me, thanks.

This
OP are you familiar with how self ID is working?

angiec89 · 16/04/2023 22:39

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/04/2023 22:37

I didn't say all women were cis. Only the women born as women. It's a scientific description for women who aren't trans.

It's a description that is rejected as an unnecessary loaded slur by many, many women - and men. Would you be at pains to talk about a 'feline cat' or a 'canine dog'?

'Males' is also a scientific description for transwomen, but that doesn't seem to be quite so warmly received....

Obviously you wouldn't need to differentiate between cis and trans in every sentence about women. But in certain specific examples it's a useful word.

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 16/04/2023 22:39

GladAllOver · 16/04/2023 22:07

Do we really have to explain this all over again?

I doubt it. The OP isn't looking for an answer, they're just being goady.

literalviolence · 16/04/2023 22:38

angiec89 · 16/04/2023 22:34

That statistic was from a study in the US

I didn't say all women were cis. Only the women born as women. It's a scientific description for women who aren't trans.

No. You're wrong. It means that a woman has a gender identity which matches their birth sex. According to stonewall. Most women don't have a gender identity. It's not just 'not trans'.

Where does the US study get it's data from.and how applicable is it here?

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 16/04/2023 22:37

I didn't say all women were cis. Only the women born as women. It's a scientific description for women who aren't trans.

It's a description that is rejected as an unnecessary loaded slur by many, many women - and men. Would you be at pains to talk about a 'feline cat' or a 'canine dog'?

'Males' is also a scientific description for transwomen, but that doesn't seem to be quite so warmly received....

angiec89 · 16/04/2023 22:37

Pixiedust1234 · 16/04/2023 22:35

but the mortality rate of trans women is incredibly high, and 5 times the rate of trans men for perspective.

Please link to your source. I believe the mortality rate has been debunked.

Also using cis is a slur, so don't use it on me, thanks.

Crikey who decided that was a slur?
It's a scientific term.

OP posts:
BIWI · 16/04/2023 22:35

I didn't say all women were cis. Only the women born as women. It's a scientific description for women who aren't trans

And it's totally unnecessary when we already have the word 'women'.

I am a woman. If you're a trans woman, then you use the descriptor 'trans' to differentiate yourself. Because you are different.

I am a woman. I need no other descriptor or differentiator. I was here first.

NamelessNancy · 16/04/2023 22:35

Satsumastocking · 16/04/2023 22:25

The problem is when people use the existence of trans people to pretend gender is more than an oppressive social construct. i.e. to pretend that boys and girls have some imaginary, elusive essence that makes girls worse at maths or boys unable to grasp basic emotional understanding. Very, very damaging misconceptions feminists have fought and fought to disprove, now swept aside.

I have no problems with anyone identifying as whatever they like. I'm not bothered by people of different sexes but identifying as an outdated and offensive "feminine" or "masculine" social construct using the same public loo as me (god knows there are enough real females pandering to offensive"feminine" stereotypes and far too many real men dressed as horrific "masculine" stereotypes). But...big hut...I respect and care that many women have good reason to feel scared and upset by it and they deserve to have their needs listened to.

What I do object to is people enforcing gender essentialism on us.

The view that someone can somehow be an opposite sex while biologically just jot being that sex is based on the ideology that males and females have ingrained, essential, biological character differences, different brains or something ludicrous and made up, and is reactionary, regressive and dangerous.

Thank you for explaining so clearly how I feel about this. It's a rigid reinforcement of gender stereotypes isn't it?

Pixiedust1234 · 16/04/2023 22:35

but the mortality rate of trans women is incredibly high, and 5 times the rate of trans men for perspective.

Please link to your source. I believe the mortality rate has been debunked.

Also using cis is a slur, so don't use it on me, thanks.

angiec89 · 16/04/2023 22:34

literalviolence · 16/04/2023 22:31

Normal women who don't need to label themselves also have it tough. Don't assume all women are cis. It's ascribing an identity to them which many find regressive and insulting. You need to look closer at thr data re TW risk because its skewed by South American sex workers and you're not making a valid comparison. You also need to know that most TW do not undergo surgery and you'd be labelled a TERF for suggesting that they're not actual TW. TW who'd you label as valid still have no place in women's spaces.

That statistic was from a study in the US

I didn't say all women were cis. Only the women born as women. It's a scientific description for women who aren't trans.

OP posts:
literalviolence · 16/04/2023 22:33

ColdHandsHotHead · 16/04/2023 22:32

YANBU. There's a bunch of people on Mumsnet who try to make it a big deal, though.

😂😂

MRA at it's finest!

ColdHandsHotHead · 16/04/2023 22:32

YANBU. There's a bunch of people on Mumsnet who try to make it a big deal, though.

daughtersanathlete · 16/04/2023 22:32

My daughter is an athlete.

She will never represent her country again if they don't ensure that male bodied people can't compete with women.

She is also at physical risk due to the size and weight differential, and she plays a non-contact sport.

She also shouldn't have to see a male body, with male genitalia, in her changing areas.

BIWI · 16/04/2023 22:31

"Sorry solid"

WTAF does that mean?

literalviolence · 16/04/2023 22:31

Normal women who don't need to label themselves also have it tough. Don't assume all women are cis. It's ascribing an identity to them which many find regressive and insulting. You need to look closer at thr data re TW risk because its skewed by South American sex workers and you're not making a valid comparison. You also need to know that most TW do not undergo surgery and you'd be labelled a TERF for suggesting that they're not actual TW. TW who'd you label as valid still have no place in women's spaces.

sst1234 · 16/04/2023 22:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CKL987 · 16/04/2023 22:30

100% agree with you.

Lockheart · 16/04/2023 22:30

DappledOliveGroves · 16/04/2023 22:16

But this is the crux of the matter. At present, a "pervy" guy who was in the women's loos, changing rooms etc, could legitimately be challenged, whether by other women, or security, or the Police. If any man says he's a woman, and we have to accept this, then you lose any right to challenge any pervert in a female-only space. So the risk to women is multiplied significantly.

What happens if the man says he's a trans man and is biologically female?

Swipe left for the next trending thread