Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the 'trans issue' isn't a big deal

242 replies

angiec89 · 16/04/2023 22:03

It just blows my mind how many people on here are so hung up over trans women. They're such a small percentage of the population. I have never seen an obviously trans woman in a women's toilet (not that it would particularly bother me if I did), in fact I very rarely see trans women out and about ever.
I'd be happy to listen to explanations but I really don't understand the issue. Surely there are thousands of more pressing issues regarding women's rights and safety currently than the 0.27% of the population (a USA statistic but I assume it's accurate enough) that are trans women. And even then it would be a minuscule proportion of those that are ill-intentioned towards women. It just seems like a big fuss about something so obscure when there are huge issues that deserve more attention.

OP posts:
MavisMcMinty · 31/05/2023 13:21

It’s the hair-tossing I always notice.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/05/2023 13:17

being a trans woman has nothing to do with “wanting to wear lipstick and dresses”.

Why do so many of them do so then?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 31/05/2023 13:17

All of this is nothing but ignorance and transphobia. Instead of forming strong opinions about an experience you know nothing about, you would be much better listening and opening your mind to those who are different to you. I know that you don’t want to hear/ won’t absorb this, but the world would be a much better place if you did.

Perhaps you can help by explaining what she is wrong about? You can, right? Should be easy then!

GladAllOver · 31/05/2023 12:40

Well I'm sorry if it makes you weep, Tandora, but there is no room for a penis in a women's space.
It's just as simple as that.

briarhill · 31/05/2023 12:28

bridgetreilly · 31/05/2023 10:57

Well, I care because:

  1. Children are being irreversibly medically harmed;
  2. Children are being deeply emotionally traumatised;
  3. So are adults;
  4. Truth is being abandoned and we are all supposed to go along with the lie;
  5. A mental health problem is being treated with medication and surgery;
  6. Women’s rights are being trampled over by men;
  7. Women’s safety is being counted less important than men’s wishes;
  8. Women are, always, the ones who lose out, whether in sport, at work, in domestic abuse, even in women’s prisons;
  9. Autogynophilia is a kink not a gender identity and society has no obligation to play into these mens fetishes;
  10. It is actual nonsense. However hard you try, a male body can’t become female, nor vice versa. Sex is not determined by outward appearances nor inner feelings. It is a biological reality. Deal with it.
  11. It reinforces gender stereotypes that I thought we’d thrown out 50 years ago.

Yes to all of this!

briarhill · 31/05/2023 12:27

The sex-based rights of women and girls matter big time.

YABVVVU

Tandora · 31/05/2023 12:24

bridgetreilly · 31/05/2023 10:57

Well, I care because:

  1. Children are being irreversibly medically harmed;
  2. Children are being deeply emotionally traumatised;
  3. So are adults;
  4. Truth is being abandoned and we are all supposed to go along with the lie;
  5. A mental health problem is being treated with medication and surgery;
  6. Women’s rights are being trampled over by men;
  7. Women’s safety is being counted less important than men’s wishes;
  8. Women are, always, the ones who lose out, whether in sport, at work, in domestic abuse, even in women’s prisons;
  9. Autogynophilia is a kink not a gender identity and society has no obligation to play into these mens fetishes;
  10. It is actual nonsense. However hard you try, a male body can’t become female, nor vice versa. Sex is not determined by outward appearances nor inner feelings. It is a biological reality. Deal with it.
  11. It reinforces gender stereotypes that I thought we’d thrown out 50 years ago.

All of this is nothing but ignorance and transphobia. Instead of forming strong opinions about an experience you know nothing about, you would be much better listening and opening your mind to those who are different to you. I know that you don’t want to hear/ won’t absorb this, but the world would be a much better place if you did.

Tandora · 31/05/2023 12:22

Ostryga · 16/04/2023 22:05

Yes they are an incredibly small percentage of the population but are taking away from women, and the rights we have lived and died for to gain.

Just because you are ignorant of what women are losing out to accommodate men wanting to wear lipstick and dresses and you don’t understand what we’re up against doesn’t mean it isn’t a big deal.

accommodate men wanting to wear lipstick and dresses

being a trans woman has nothing to do with “wanting to wear lipstick and dresses”. This is so ignorant, it makes me want to weep.

AnneLovesGilbert · 31/05/2023 12:15

Completely agree with @bridgetreilly

You can’t argue with any of that.

BIWI · 31/05/2023 12:13

#TeamBridgetReilly

TheKeatingFive · 31/05/2023 11:03

Well said @bridgetreilly

bridgetreilly · 31/05/2023 10:57

Well, I care because:

  1. Children are being irreversibly medically harmed;
  2. Children are being deeply emotionally traumatised;
  3. So are adults;
  4. Truth is being abandoned and we are all supposed to go along with the lie;
  5. A mental health problem is being treated with medication and surgery;
  6. Women’s rights are being trampled over by men;
  7. Women’s safety is being counted less important than men’s wishes;
  8. Women are, always, the ones who lose out, whether in sport, at work, in domestic abuse, even in women’s prisons;
  9. Autogynophilia is a kink not a gender identity and society has no obligation to play into these mens fetishes;
  10. It is actual nonsense. However hard you try, a male body can’t become female, nor vice versa. Sex is not determined by outward appearances nor inner feelings. It is a biological reality. Deal with it.
  11. It reinforces gender stereotypes that I thought we’d thrown out 50 years ago.
1offnamechange · 30/05/2023 23:05

angiec89 · 16/04/2023 22:25

Is it the actual trans women who experience gender dysphoria and undergo hormones and surgery that bother you? Or is it the pretenders that lie?
Cisgender women have it tough but the mortality rate of trans women is incredibly high, and 5 times the rate of trans men for perspective.

where did you get that statistic from? My understanding is it was based on a survey of trans prostitutes in brazil so not exactly representative of your average trans woman in the uk.

To some extent you're right as in there are probably other things in the uk that have a more direct, wider, and more immediate effect but that doesn't mean it's not worth discussing. For the woman losing sponsorship on the event she's trained for since she was seven due to being pushed off the podium by a man or the woman having to shower or share a cell with a male with penis in prison it's pretty significant.

Also the reverse is true - if the number of trans women in the UK is so so so tiny why are so many changes being made that have the potential to affect so many more people? e.g. if less than 0.2% of the population are trans women what is the justification for changing medical terminology so that it confuses the 10-20% of the population who have english as an additional language/learning disabilities or lower levels of understanding so don't understand what is meant by a 'uterus haver' 'person who bleeds' 'birthing person' 'chest feeder' etc. Why are we making changing rooms less safe for 50% of the population to make it easier for 0.02%? etc. etc.

Florenz · 30/05/2023 22:29

If you accept Trans Women as women, then there are no women anymore. It's one of the most important issues in human history. And that's not exaggeration.

GladAllOver · 30/05/2023 22:24

Yes, REALLY.

SunsetsInVenice · 05/05/2023 22:43

Kirstie Alsopp is that you?

WhyCantYourPartnerDoIt · 05/05/2023 22:41

Ludlow2 · 05/05/2023 22:12

Real women mensturate.

Leave our space.

Nope

DojaPhat · 05/05/2023 22:31

Ludlow2 · 05/05/2023 22:12

Real women mensturate.

Leave our space.

Oh really...

Ludlow2 · 05/05/2023 22:18

Simplestateside · 05/05/2023 21:43

No finger wagging, just a genuinely curious about where you think they should go/ what you think they should do.

Use own toilets 🚻 segregated.

Not to share with biologically born women.
EVER.

Ludlow2 · 05/05/2023 22:16

Even if it doesn't negatively effect.

Leave our space.

YouSetTheTone · 05/05/2023 22:13

I think they should express themselves however they like as long as they observe the material reality of sex In circumstances where it matters - eg sports, hospitals, prisons, rape crisis centres. I don’t give a fuck how anyone dresses, or if they wish to act in a way that contradicts the stereotypes of their sex.
But the moment someone tries to legally and practically act as if they are the opposite sex, in circumstances where it negatively affects people of that sex, that’s the line.

Ludlow2 · 05/05/2023 22:12

Real women mensturate.

Leave our space.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 05/05/2023 22:08

Why do people always try to make out that trans people are being denied their basic rights, whenever people object to them taking away the same rights from other people in order to add them on to their own?

Regular men aren't allowed in women's single-sex facilities, but nobody is trying to make out that people are seeking to banish men from society. Women aren't allowed in men's single-sex facilities, but women aren't claiming hatred or discrimination because of this; the only ones apparently seeking to banish women from society (or at least deny their basic rights) are the aforementioned transwomen who are refusing to respect single-sex female facilities and stay out of them (which is not all transwomen, btw).

It's the same with sports: the false arguments that are made about people wanting to deny trans sportspeople the right to participate - trans people have exactly the same right as everybody else to compete in the appropriate category for their sex.

BIWI · 05/05/2023 21:54

I don't want genuine trans people to be banished or ostracised.

But I don't want trans women to use the same changing rooms or toilet facilities as biological women.

So I suppose I'd like them to be segregated, in the sense that I think they deserve their own places.

TheKeatingFive · 05/05/2023 21:44

No finger wagging, just a genuinely curious about where you think they should go/ what you think they should do.

And an answer has been given. It's not rocket science.

Swipe left for the next trending thread