Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I’m being used as a free day out

116 replies

user1494192508 · 16/04/2023 21:25

We moved into a house in the countryside 4 years ago. Lots of outdoor space and play equipment for the kids.
Friend of mine lives in a not so nice area and loves to bring her 2 kids over for a play date. All lovely, we have lunch, I provide activities for the kids, buy them sweets etc
The problem is she never contributes to the lunch or activities or brings treats for the kids. I’m expected to provide all the time. I am the one that invites them over but AIBU to think that either a contribution OR a return invitation would be nice? We always have such a nice day but I’m starting to feel like a mug and a free day out for them in every half term and school holiday.
Money is not an issue for either of us but I’m starting to feel bitter about it. Should I suck it up and get on with it?

OP posts:
Mochinated · 16/04/2023 22:15

Gods sake if you haven't asked her to bring lunch then how could she? It would be incredibly rude to visit someone and bring your own lunch!!

And yes your house is lovely and big, well done you. Do you want to take your kids to her small house and eat her poor lunch? If you don't want to reciprocate by being her guest, then accept it and stop being horrid.

I have a friend like you, lovely big clean house and a cleaning lady. I have a doer upper that we haven't been able to do up yet and don't have a cleaner or spend much time cleaning. She rarely comes over here and perches. Pretends she doesn't mind toddler picking things off floor. Kids happy as anything but she's uncomfortable. No doubt she's also brewing resentment like you. I don't take it personally. Everyone is different and it's easy for me to forgive - I'd love to have the big house and the cleaner, who wouldn't!

Meet in a public place and go cafe or bring packed lunches. Make it an even amount of effort and expense if you must.

Testina · 16/04/2023 22:20

I have a friend who obviously doesn’t like the area I live in - and to be fair, it’s not great and she has a great place in the country, play equipment in a lovely garden… I feel a bit unreasonable being annoyed that I always have the cost of fuel (tbf she gives us lunch though) and the extra time travelling. It’s like it’s always relaxing for her cos she’s just there, whilst I have to think about timing and wrestling the kids out of the door. She’s a bit of an over organiser type - you know, planned “activities” whereas I think the kids are just happy to hang out. Tbh I guess I’m annoyed too that she always has sweets for them all - I prefer that they don’t get used to sweets as part of a trip out. I do really like her, just feels all a bit on her terms, you know? AIBU?

TellHimDirectlyInDetail · 16/04/2023 22:21

Sierra26 · 16/04/2023 21:37

I’d just say “do you and X want to come round on Sat for a day in the garden? Would you mind sorting lunch and snacks this time, and I’ll bake something?”

then just start taking it turn about “fancy coming round? ill do lunch and you bake this time?” Etc etc

especially if there’s no imbalance of power in terms of finances

break the cycle but don’t break the nice thing you have going on

This

Chickychoccyegg · 16/04/2023 22:23

What activities do you provide? You could possibly away with them.
If I was inviting someone to my house,I wouldn't ask them to bring lunch, its a bit rude, couple of pizzas, and cakes wouldn't cost much.
Sweets for the kids, well buy less/dont buy them/suck it up , maybe she sees the sweets as unnecessary?

Truckinghell · 16/04/2023 22:23

DevonPink · 16/04/2023 22:04

If she’s your friend does it matter?

This, really.

It's a nice time and you enjoy it. It's lunch every 6-8 weeks. You invite them so it would be fair of her to assume you're happy with the situation.

But as others have said, just ask her to bring something if that's what you want her to do.

saraclara · 16/04/2023 22:24

I don't get it. You're inviting her. If you invite someone for the day, you feed them, unless you specifically suggest/ask for other arrangements.

If you want that to change, then simply say "I'll do some sandwiches and crisps for a garden picnic, if you can bring something sweet and some drinks?"

But I don't think she's a CF for accepting your invitations.

JoeBlogger · 16/04/2023 22:28

Ask her to bring something specific, like pudding or a roast chicken or something that she can reasonably bring. It's not the cost, but this is a mutual arrangement and it's her lunch too.

Climbles · 16/04/2023 22:28

IMO it’s rude but my guess is it’s never crossed her mind. If money isn’t an issue then she’s probably just a bit unthinking.

Truestorypeeps · 16/04/2023 22:30

FrozenGhost · 16/04/2023 22:07

Sounds fine to me, the main activity is playing outside on equipment that's already there, which costs nothing. So your contribution is a couple of snacks of the kids and a tea bag each? And "money isn't an issue"? And you don't like her place anyway because of the area. I'm not really seeing the problem.

This. I'd say you all would have a much better time at yours anyway, you seem set up for it. If them turning up empty handed is grating then mention this. It would be ashame for your children's sakes if this was the end of the fun at yours over a few quid of snacks. One final thought, paper plates and feck it all in the bin.

Gingergirl70 · 16/04/2023 22:31

Testina · 16/04/2023 22:20

I have a friend who obviously doesn’t like the area I live in - and to be fair, it’s not great and she has a great place in the country, play equipment in a lovely garden… I feel a bit unreasonable being annoyed that I always have the cost of fuel (tbf she gives us lunch though) and the extra time travelling. It’s like it’s always relaxing for her cos she’s just there, whilst I have to think about timing and wrestling the kids out of the door. She’s a bit of an over organiser type - you know, planned “activities” whereas I think the kids are just happy to hang out. Tbh I guess I’m annoyed too that she always has sweets for them all - I prefer that they don’t get used to sweets as part of a trip out. I do really like her, just feels all a bit on her terms, you know? AIBU?

😂

mondaytosunday · 16/04/2023 22:33

As money not an issue really is it such a burden to give one adult and a couple extra kids lunch?
But as you feel put out, then:
Cut down the invites
Suggest you go to hers
Suggest a picnic nearby where you each bring food for.
Ask her to bring something as you 'haven't been to the market' (this obviously will only work once).

Highdaysandholidays1 · 16/04/2023 22:35

I think this constant making it fair is a shame unless it's a real burden on you, you could look on it that you are lucky to have a lovely big house and garden and be able to treat your friend. It's also fine to ask her to bring something to share- crisps, fruit, say you are having a picnic so bring some picnic stuff (or bbq) so it breaks the pattern and she'll do it next time. But you may just prefer to carry on as it's convenient to have them come to you and isn't costing a fortune (I mean you will have to pay petrol and take food if you go to theirs, no?)

Merangutan · 16/04/2023 22:35

Does she think that if she makes the effort to do return travel then you providing lunch is fair? If it’s not an even deal as you’re also providing sweets and activities every single time then ask her to come after lunch or ask her to bring something with her. If I’m invited for lunch I would bring a cake or something with me without needing to be asked; she should at least offer.

Gingergirl70 · 16/04/2023 22:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EyesOnThePies · 16/04/2023 22:37

If you can both afford to provide lunch and sweets without wincing what, please, is the relevance of her living in a less nice area?

Just be specific. “It would be lovely to offer you respite from your hovel for the afternoon, be great if you could pick up some packs of Monster Munch and Nik Naks or whatever is available at your local CashSlasher Korner Shop”

iaapap · 16/04/2023 22:39

Hmmmm
i don’t know op - you are inviting her - she isn’t inviting herself

you’ve said they come half terms/holidays - so 6x per year? 6 lunches in year for a woman and 2 kids doesn’t really sound like a massive financial burden given you’ve said money isn’t an issue. It isn’t usual to offer money if someone feeds you from their fridge (as opposed to takeaway/cafe).

maybe she doesn’t really want her kids having the sweets so isn’t inclined to bring any, and simply tolerates it when you give them sweets

i mean you’ve said she lives in a place you don’t like - do you actually want to go there?

what activities are you providing? Use of your existing equipment? Again not usual to pay for this

you can easily tell her that you are busy in the May half term if that’s what you want to do. But there really doesn’t seem any reason to think she’s a CF

FrumptyMumpty · 16/04/2023 22:41

Oh come on. You don’t have to travel and visit her dodgy neighbourhood and she gets lunch made in return.

When I first read the title I thought you were going to be complaining about paying for your siblings to do an escape room and have a Nandos for your mums birthday because you organised it - that was me the other day…

Surely you can spare a mate a couple of slices of bread, a slice of ham and a brew.

Plus, you can just ask to go to hers instead.

No doubt she’d say yes and then you get to sit there not touching anything, waiting to be waited on, wanting to wipe down the toilet seat and the cutlery before use, etc

saraclara · 16/04/2023 22:43

Testina · 16/04/2023 22:20

I have a friend who obviously doesn’t like the area I live in - and to be fair, it’s not great and she has a great place in the country, play equipment in a lovely garden… I feel a bit unreasonable being annoyed that I always have the cost of fuel (tbf she gives us lunch though) and the extra time travelling. It’s like it’s always relaxing for her cos she’s just there, whilst I have to think about timing and wrestling the kids out of the door. She’s a bit of an over organiser type - you know, planned “activities” whereas I think the kids are just happy to hang out. Tbh I guess I’m annoyed too that she always has sweets for them all - I prefer that they don’t get used to sweets as part of a trip out. I do really like her, just feels all a bit on her terms, you know? AIBU?

Ha! You've just reminded me that I had a friend like this, back in the day. Nice house, everything just so, and (worthy) activities like crafts (which had to be done perfecty) laid on for the kids. One day, when the activity was announced by the friend, my four year old turned to me and said "Mummy, can't we just play?"

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 16/04/2023 22:43

Yabu if you have the bigger space in a nicer area it makes sense to be at your home. I feel a lot of friend and family groups do this and have one specific house they go to due to space, location ect. Yes she could bring something but not everyone thinks like this, if I was going to my mates for the afternoon with the kids I wouldn't take anything the same as I don't expect someone to bring stuff to mine unless it's an actual occasion like a party or bbq then yes bring your own alcohol if you want something specific

Unicorndreams24 · 16/04/2023 22:45

Well as you mentioned your friend lives in a not so nice area and probably feels embarrassed maybe ? To be fair though if it were me I'd bring something so maybe bring it into conversation ie she could bring desserts? Xx

Snaaaaacks · 16/04/2023 22:47

I'm in a similar position well in that the friend has a huge garden vs our normal sized garden (ours has enough room for play equipment, a 12 ft trampoline and room to play, it isn't teeny), but you could times ours by 20 vs theirs. She's hosted a few play dates, not just for us but for other children too. I actually messaged and said can I provide the food this time (we live in the same area and we earn similar amounts really - both comfortable). I felt really bad sending my child round and them laying on food when I'm not hosting. Their outside space and their setup is just so much better than ours, I feel awkward them keep hosting but I'd also feel awkward hosting with my tiny garden (vs theirs) and not having a dedicated "garden room" with giant bi-folds! The friend refused my offer the cater anyway!

I'd feel awkward if I was your friend, but some people are CF and it doesn't bother them. I think it'd be awkward inviting someone over and asking them to cater, she should offer really, I mean unless she's not in a position to, you never know, things might not be how them seem financially for her. If you enjoy the company I'd just carry on hosting, if not stop inviting them.

GloryBees · 16/04/2023 22:52

I find this rather odd. Often when people move away, people find that no one from
their “old” life can be bothered to come visit. If money isn’t an issue then why would it cross her mind you have an issue. She is making the effort bothering to come visit - she spends money on fuel/public transport and time spent travelling. Unless you live in Windsor Castle I can’t believe your garden is that nice!!

nzeire · 16/04/2023 22:55

Who cares.

a cup of tea and a sandwich.

I mean WHO CARES

Swapshopped · 16/04/2023 22:55

It’s a similar situation here, particularly in the summer, with a big garden and pool but everyone always brings something in the way of snacks for the children, wine 🥳 etc.

I enjoy hosting it all and it’s lovely to see the garden being used. I never ask people to bring bits, they just do but I think it would be a little much if it was a regular thing and they didn’t…

Nevermind31 · 16/04/2023 22:58

She is doing the driving, you provide lunch…
of you don’t like it, invite her, but after lunch. Or tell her to bring her own lunch.