Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I’m being used as a free day out

116 replies

user1494192508 · 16/04/2023 21:25

We moved into a house in the countryside 4 years ago. Lots of outdoor space and play equipment for the kids.
Friend of mine lives in a not so nice area and loves to bring her 2 kids over for a play date. All lovely, we have lunch, I provide activities for the kids, buy them sweets etc
The problem is she never contributes to the lunch or activities or brings treats for the kids. I’m expected to provide all the time. I am the one that invites them over but AIBU to think that either a contribution OR a return invitation would be nice? We always have such a nice day but I’m starting to feel like a mug and a free day out for them in every half term and school holiday.
Money is not an issue for either of us but I’m starting to feel bitter about it. Should I suck it up and get on with it?

OP posts:
Doingmybest12 · 17/04/2023 07:07

You can't have it both ways really. You can't invite her over often then be annoyed she takes you up on it. It sounds like you are happy to have her company and your children are occupied. Perhaps this is what she brings to the mix for you. Either don't invite so often , avoid meal times, suggest meeting elsewhere. I am sure you ll sort it.

LeatherShacket · 17/04/2023 07:02

This sort of dynamic will soon get tired. The family hosting is providing food and spending time preparing, tidying etc. and the friend is consuming this generous offering.

I've been on both sides of this. When dh and I lived in a 1 bed in London we visited our amazing friends in their big house in Surrey. They hosted generously but after some time I started suggesting meeting at a restaurants, just the grown ups as we couldn't really host our friends and their kids in our scruffy flat. This worked well for everyone for a while and when we moved we did have them over more.

Fast forward to now and another friend is not happy with the state of her house, it's beautiful but very neglected, and she and her family descend on us and won't leave for absolutely hours. They stay for lunch and push out to tea so their kids get 2 meals here plus pudding and snacks. My friend used to bring biscuits etc. but in recent times she hasn't so it's like they are enjoying our hospitality but not ever contributing. It's unbalanced and affects the friendship for me. I now don't really want to see her at our place and suggest cafes and restaurants but while she is well off, she doesn't want to spend the money.

Our kids used to get on well but now they're in their teens they have no interest in each other so it feels like I am forcing her kids on mine for a whole day, which my kids (and I believe hers too) hate as they prefer seeing their own friends or having downtime, not having people they don't have anything in common with spend the whole day in their home. I don't arrange anything anymore.

OkImListening · 17/04/2023 06:57

You sound mean to me and not a very nice friend. I regularly host my best friend and her two DC and wouldn't dream of asking her to bring anything (I never go to hers as she doesn't like cooking). Can you imagine how mortified your friend would be if she knew you'd asked this question on MN, ugh!

Glassfullofdreams · 17/04/2023 06:21

Next time she comes ask her if she can bring some snacks for the kids because you haven't had a chance to go to the supermarket.

mainsfed · 17/04/2023 06:10

@Inthetropics fair enough, I do agree that you shouldn’t feel obliged to host her as often as she hosts you. You sound like a good friend.

Inthetropics · 17/04/2023 05:53

mainsfed · 17/04/2023 05:18

@Inthetropics do you not feel it’s really cheeky to keep going to her lunches, dinners and barbecues but never reciprocating?

And you say you invite others for lunch/coffee so why can’t you invite her? Or take them out for a meal if you don’t want to host at home?

Has your friend started to invite you less?

I do reciprocate but not as often as she desires. She invites us maybe once or twice a month for something at hers and I'll invite her once or twice a year for lunch. I frequently ask her to meet at a restaurant or to have some coffee somewhere nice but she doesn't usually accept. We have been friends for 14 years and she still invites me to hers frequently.

I am the friend who visits her when she is sick and I've helped her when her mum was ill. I will bring her nice biscuits whenever I bake. I've told her if she were fo ever need my help she can call me any time, and she has and I've been there for her. I'll help her clean up when I have lunch at hers. I give her rides whenever she needs. But I don't like to host.

mainsfed · 17/04/2023 05:18

@Inthetropics do you not feel it’s really cheeky to keep going to her lunches, dinners and barbecues but never reciprocating?

And you say you invite others for lunch/coffee so why can’t you invite her? Or take them out for a meal if you don’t want to host at home?

Has your friend started to invite you less?

Inthetropics · 17/04/2023 05:07

I don't like hosting. I have a friend who loves hosting. Me and my partner get invited frequently to her home for lunch, dinner, barbecues, etc. She once asked me why I rarely invite her to my home and I told her the truth: I hate hosting and only invite1 people once in a blue moon. She believed we should reciprocate each and every invitation with a similar invite, which I told her i don't feel comfortable doing. It was very awkward. I find it very transactional to have to show my friendship and care in the same exact way and I don't find it generous when people invite me over with such expectations. When I ask people to come have some coffee or have lunch in my home I do it because I feel like having them here and that's all! We do bring a bottle of wine, a dessert and a little gift when we are invited, though.

My advice would be for you to either stop inviting them or to do it without expecting anything in return just when you feel like it. If you want to have them over but resent the fact they don't buy sweets or contribute to the meal you can either not buy the sweets/ask them to come after lunch or ask for them to bring the sweets or a plate for your meal.

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 17/04/2023 04:53

It's good to be generous and be a joyful giver.
Comes back to you tenfold.

Um, except it’s not coming back her tenfold……?

MrsMorrisey · 17/04/2023 04:34

Tiedup
It's good to be generous and be a joyful giver. Comes back to you tenfold.

I'm saying if she doesn't want to provide then stop asking her!!!

PolkadotsAndCandyfloss · 17/04/2023 04:28

If she lives in a less nice area, maybe money is really tight with the current cost of living crisis which could be why she hasn’t brought anything along.

It would be a shame to stop having her over, if you & the kids have a nice time and you aren’t even worried about the money side. Maybe ask her over less frequently or ask if she could bring something if it really bothers you, or just leave it and enjoy being a kind friend.

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 17/04/2023 04:22

MrsMorrisey · 17/04/2023 04:18

YABU stop inviting her then.
Why are you so stingy, if you don't want to do then don't.

Someone invites another person to their house 100% of the time - and feeds and waters them - and they don’t get anything in return, and you’re calling them the stingy one………..?

Serious LOL.

MrsMorrisey · 17/04/2023 04:18

YABU stop inviting her then.
Why are you so stingy, if you don't want to do then don't.

Purplecatshopaholic · 17/04/2023 03:00

But you are the one inviting her?! Yes, I think she should bring something when she visits, but if you are unhappy with how things are it’s easily fixed, just don’t invite her anymore!

DarkDayforMN · 17/04/2023 01:58

Nntk · 17/04/2023 01:38

AITA?

I have been with my partner just under 2 years and we have a almost 1 year old. I feel we have a good ish relationship and he’s a great father, however he’s not from the UK he’s from an Arabic Muslim country. He wants us to travel together as a family to visit his mother he says is I’ll (it wouldn’t be the first time he’s lied about something) for a week or two. I usually wouldn’t have a problem with this but how? We are not married I’m not Muslim I know nothing about his country how safe it is it’s laws etc, I’ve been in a DV relationship and I have ptsd and anxiety from other events, it’s hard for me to trust and I just can’t bare the thought of putting myself and our babies lives completely in his hands.. he hasnt really given me any reason as to why not, I’ve spoken to his family and his sisters wants to come here to meet us. I really just can’t comprehend it but it’s breaking my heart, he doesn’t really have anyone here and i know how much it means for his mum to meet our child and I can’t stop thinking about if the shoe was on the other foot, if she was to pass soon and they haven’t met would that then be on me forever?😭

You should make a thread of your own! This sounds like a very serious situation, so I didn't want to ignore your post. Please make your own thread where you will get good advice. And DON'T GO.

PinkStarAtNight · 17/04/2023 01:46

I think if you invite someone over then you sign up for hosting and providing snacks. The person isn't obligated to bring something. An invite to hers would be nice, but you've said she lives in a 'not so nice area' so maybe she feels you and your children wouldn't enjoy being there very much, and if you have a bigger garden and play equipment it seems to make sense that the best option for the kids is your house.

In terms of lunch, what exactly are you making? If its just a few sandwiches and some crisps then surely her share of the cost would be such a ridiculously small amount that it really wouldn't be worth bothering. If you're not short of money then why is this such a big deal? Unless when you say 'lunch' you mean a full spread of quiches, sandwiches, potato salad, crackers, cheese, scones, cakes etc etc - in which case just stop putting on such a spread and keep things simple!

Nntk · 17/04/2023 01:38

AITA?

I have been with my partner just under 2 years and we have a almost 1 year old. I feel we have a good ish relationship and he’s a great father, however he’s not from the UK he’s from an Arabic Muslim country. He wants us to travel together as a family to visit his mother he says is I’ll (it wouldn’t be the first time he’s lied about something) for a week or two. I usually wouldn’t have a problem with this but how? We are not married I’m not Muslim I know nothing about his country how safe it is it’s laws etc, I’ve been in a DV relationship and I have ptsd and anxiety from other events, it’s hard for me to trust and I just can’t bare the thought of putting myself and our babies lives completely in his hands.. he hasnt really given me any reason as to why not, I’ve spoken to his family and his sisters wants to come here to meet us. I really just can’t comprehend it but it’s breaking my heart, he doesn’t really have anyone here and i know how much it means for his mum to meet our child and I can’t stop thinking about if the shoe was on the other foot, if she was to pass soon and they haven’t met would that then be on me forever?😭

user1477391263 · 17/04/2023 01:22

Sierra26 · 16/04/2023 21:37

I’d just say “do you and X want to come round on Sat for a day in the garden? Would you mind sorting lunch and snacks this time, and I’ll bake something?”

then just start taking it turn about “fancy coming round? ill do lunch and you bake this time?” Etc etc

especially if there’s no imbalance of power in terms of finances

break the cycle but don’t break the nice thing you have going on

This is exactly what you should do.

If the friend starts avoiding you once you make it clear that there needs to be some contribution from both sides, she is a CF.

Okthenhun · 17/04/2023 01:14

Jesus christ, I must remember to bring gifts every time I visit my mates' houses.

Shit this is going to get expensive.

Tooyoungtofeelthisold · 17/04/2023 01:12

Tbh if I were extending the invitation, I'd expect to host without expectation of any contribution, but as a guest, I'd very much want to contribute or bring a nice gift for the people we were visiting, flowers, chocolate, cake, sweets, wine, a bottle of spirit, and activities for the kids.

TiedUpWithABlackVelvetBand · 17/04/2023 00:35

I can’t imagine turning up to someone’s house, to be hosted, empty-handed.

I don’t know a soul who’d behave like this in real life, either.

Some of you on this thread are either being deliberately obtuse (AIBU is the home of the obtuse, and the disingenuous, to be fair), or you’re completely socially clueless.

OP - YANBU. Really weird behaviour on the part of your friend.

I also think easing up on the invitations is the way forward.

Badbudgeter · 17/04/2023 00:32

Just ask her to bring stuff or meet in a park and bring a picnic. If someone invited us for a play/ lunch I'd assume they were happy to host. I'd probably bake a cake/ muffins or stop by bakery for some sweet treats on the way though.

JMSA · 17/04/2023 00:29

DevonPink · 16/04/2023 22:04

If she’s your friend does it matter?

Yes, it does, because good friendships are a two-way street.

JMSA · 17/04/2023 00:27

I never turn up empty-handed. That would be bad form. Clearly she has no intention of reciprocating, so she should be making up for that in other ways cheeky cow.

Mind you, I have no problem with being honest about how I feel. It's healthier than letting the situation fester and have resentment kick in.

"I've hosted the past few times and it would be nice to have a break. The kids and I would love a change of scene, if you wouldn't mind obliging on this occasion? Let me know and I'll bring some treats!"

Kisskiss · 17/04/2023 00:20

surreygirl1987 · 16/04/2023 23:25

I think YABU. She might be embarrassed about her place if yours is much nicer. And you do keep inviting her. She might think you prefer to meet at hers - I certainly prefer this rather than go to someone else's house!

This is very likely the case, but still weird to never bring anything.. flowers, cake, chocolates or wine?

Swipe left for the next trending thread