Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask who's responsible if a window cleaner falls off his ladder on your property?

113 replies

todayandnottomorrow · 16/04/2023 18:33

We have a new window cleaner starting that many people in the area seem to use. He uses ladders. I suddenly thought, what if he falls on my property and hurts himself? It got me panicked. Would I be accountable?

OP posts:
FarmGirl78 · 17/04/2023 10:11

You've asked a daft question and understandably you're getting flack for it. But I think you're enjoying choosing to get offended by peoples comments.

Maybe you still don't see how ridiculous a question this is. Stop being outraged and stomping off from Mumsnet like a sulky child and consider your original question. I can understand this thought 'crossing your mind' but if the next thought through your head wasn't "of course it wouldn't be my fault" and instead was "I must ask others" then you need to think about employing someone to make decisions for you. 🙄

Ifailed · 17/04/2023 09:43

The 'clean' isn't as great though...and your windows are left wet/dripping with water...which later streaks

They should be using deionised water, that won't leave any marks when it dries.

AuContraire · 17/04/2023 09:32

DRS1970 · 17/04/2023 09:28

I like how the worry about him hurting himself was a PS...

Him hurting himself is not something that is in the OP's control. It goes without saying that it would be tragic if anyone seriously hurt themselves at work.

It's understandable that her question was "how would this unfortunate situation impact me". The "poor guy" doesn't need to be said, as it's so obvious.

DRS1970 · 17/04/2023 09:28

I like how the worry about him hurting himself was a PS...

Ihatepainting · 17/04/2023 09:26

Op. Look you are not responsible unless you cause the accident or something on your property that you should have known about caused the accident.

this sort of anxiety is common on here, you see it when someone says should I let kids play on my swings and folks say what about your insurance or some other crap.

my window cleaner uses a ladder. It’s his job to position it safely and risk assess. If he falls he is responsible. Unless as a pp said I go out and kick it from under him, or I know the ground is unstable or something.

the same question could apply to anything. What if my cleaner falls down my stairs, what if the decorator falls off his ladder, anything, unless you or something in your home caused it there is no chance of you being responsible.

todayandnottomorrow · 17/04/2023 09:19

I no longer understand this forum. I posted a question because it popped into my head and it concerned me - there was a window cleaner who died falling off his ladder around here, and therefore it's something that might occur.

I'm sorry if the question bothered people, or seemed outside of the realm of possible concern for them; but why does it have to indicate anxiety, or a mental health issue, or stupidity?

Why can't we just ask questions without judgment? Isn't that the point of having Mumsnet, a hive of minds etc?

OP posts:
todayandnottomorrow · 17/04/2023 09:16

Robyn847 · 17/04/2023 09:10

If asking yourself this question got you panicking I think you need to address your anxiety issues.

You may not recognise how unreasonable a thing this is to worry about if your anxiety hasn't been diagnosed. I realised my anxiety wasn't normal when I found myself in tears worrying about (amongst other things) the possible issues that might arise when my neighbour put a 12 inch high border between our front gardens.

When you get down the path of dealing with your anxiety you'll be able to look back and realise this wasn't anything that 'normal' people would worry about. (And I use the phrase 'normal' very loosely! 🤣). I think that's people are not understanding why you're asking about something that to them is so obvious and would never raise a question.

To me, having anxiety is like being an alcoholic where people say "I've not drank for 20 years but I'm still an alcoholic. Every day is a battle not to have a drink". I know I would still be panicking about things like foot high garden fences and window cleaners ladders if I didn't have the mental tools to dampen down my anxiety.

I could of course be way off the mark, but until you can see it you won't realise how ridiculous a question this is to get you panicking.

Honestly, you are so off the mark, it's almost offensive

OP posts:
AuContraire · 17/04/2023 09:15

todayandnottomorrow · 17/04/2023 08:52

Well, he's here and he has no insurance. I asked. He said I have considered it but...

Now I'm in a dilemma as to whether to use him again.

What in particular is it you want him to have insurance to cover?

Robyn847 · 17/04/2023 09:10

todayandnottomorrow · 16/04/2023 19:30

I really resent this sort of tone. it's a question because I asked it

If asking yourself this question got you panicking I think you need to address your anxiety issues.

You may not recognise how unreasonable a thing this is to worry about if your anxiety hasn't been diagnosed. I realised my anxiety wasn't normal when I found myself in tears worrying about (amongst other things) the possible issues that might arise when my neighbour put a 12 inch high border between our front gardens.

When you get down the path of dealing with your anxiety you'll be able to look back and realise this wasn't anything that 'normal' people would worry about. (And I use the phrase 'normal' very loosely! 🤣). I think that's people are not understanding why you're asking about something that to them is so obvious and would never raise a question.

To me, having anxiety is like being an alcoholic where people say "I've not drank for 20 years but I'm still an alcoholic. Every day is a battle not to have a drink". I know I would still be panicking about things like foot high garden fences and window cleaners ladders if I didn't have the mental tools to dampen down my anxiety.

I could of course be way off the mark, but until you can see it you won't realise how ridiculous a question this is to get you panicking.

ZeroPlastic · 17/04/2023 08:55

You'd only be liable if you were somehow to blame, either because of something you did or because your property was unsafe. But you should have third party liability cover through your home insurance.

todayandnottomorrow · 17/04/2023 08:52

Well, he's here and he has no insurance. I asked. He said I have considered it but...

Now I'm in a dilemma as to whether to use him again.

OP posts:
Robyn847 · 17/04/2023 08:51

If you kicked the ladder from under him you'd be responsible.

If you didn't, you won't be.

🙄

How some people function every day I have no idea.

SpringIntoChaos · 17/04/2023 07:38

I haven't seen a window cleaner with ladders for YEARS!! Most now use those long extendable pole things, attached to a tank in their car/van. The 'clean' isn't as great though...and your windows are left wet/dripping with water...which later streaks 🤷‍♀️ No chamois leather dry down now 😢 And they get through the 'clean' SO fast!

H&S might be the reason for this, which is fair enough...but I do miss a 'proper' window cleaner!

Make the most of your cleaner OP, they are a dying breed (hopefully not literally 🫢)

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/04/2023 06:05

If he has half a brain he would have insurance to cover him in the case of injury and all that might entail, as well as public liability.

When I worked visiting peoples homes to work with their dogs, I had personal injury cover.

It wasn't cheap, but it wasn't prohibitively expensive and it would have been the height of stupidity to be going into peoples homes with potentially aggressive dogs, without it!

AuContraire · 17/04/2023 05:31

SnackSizeRaisin · 16/04/2023 21:08

If he has income protection insurance it will. If he only has public liability it won't

Income protection would cover his revenue (or fixed costs) of running the business for a year or two max, not personal injury compensation if he injured himself.

You can get personal accident cover, but that's a fixed sum per injury, eg loss of a finger: £1000, loss of a limb: £20,000 etc. It doesn't cover the personal injury compensation of the window cleaner(against himself), eg if he falls, has a serious injury and needs ongoing care and so on.

AuContraire · 17/04/2023 05:10

Aquamarine1029 · 17/04/2023 00:46

Always ask for proof of insurance before you hire anyone to do work on your property.

Insurance for what?

Aquamarine1029 · 17/04/2023 00:46

Always ask for proof of insurance before you hire anyone to do work on your property.

TrueScrumptious · 17/04/2023 00:45

pookiedoodlepuppy · 16/04/2023 22:42

Absolutely not , stupid idea , would never buy them . I've got enough to do in my life without adding another chore to the already long list of shit that needs to be done 😆. I love my window cleaner he brings his dog with him .

But the cost of having your windows cleaned! It’s so expensive, I don’t know how anyone affords it. I’ve had my windows cleaned once in 25 years.

TrueScrumptious · 17/04/2023 00:42

Legislation about ladders at work apply to employees so if he works for himself won't apply.

No, it applies to the self-employed too. I wondered about that, and looked it up.

Beesandhoney123 · 16/04/2023 22:46

Blimey, you'd really flap if you saw our tree surgeons. They climb about with chainsaws. I have to watch, its impressive. Also they are all very handsome so when they first came I thought they were a set up and would do a song and dance routine whilst stripping off.

I have considered asking them if they have a calender available.

pookiedoodlepuppy · 16/04/2023 22:42

Havanananana · 16/04/2023 22:09

This thread got me thinking. I now live in a country in Europe and I've never seen domestic window cleaners here - because our windows all open inwards rather than the UK ones which open outwards, so we can easily clean the windows ourselves from the inside.

Absolutely not , stupid idea , would never buy them . I've got enough to do in my life without adding another chore to the already long list of shit that needs to be done 😆. I love my window cleaner he brings his dog with him .

FrostyFifi · 16/04/2023 22:40

@swimlyn I shouldn't have laughed at that.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 16/04/2023 22:40

Youd only be liable if you were negligent. So doing something that a reasonable person wouldn't do (sneaking up behind him and shouting 'boo!') or not doing something that a reasonable person would do (eg not warning him of a massive concealed hole where he would be likely to put his ladder). And this would be picked up on your households public liability insurance anyway.

Legislation about ladders at work apply to employees so if he works for himself won't apply.

He won't automatically have insurance covering an injury to himself. Tradespeople generally have public liability insurance that covers damage to third party property or injury to third parties. The only way he would be covered for an injury to himself is if he had purchased separate accident cover.

mauveiscurious · 16/04/2023 22:38

I worry about this as a business local to us ended up seeing the owner in prison.

The tradesman fell from a height and was killed . The business owner went to prison

lanthanum · 16/04/2023 22:37

The day they came to install our solar panels there was a yellow weather warning for wind. Fortunately the roofer (just one) realised that it was not safe, and rang in to say it would have to be postponed, but I wasn't impressed that they'd left him to make that decision, and did wonder whether their insurance actually covers them when there's a weather warning.

Swipe left for the next trending thread