Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would this put you off a new man that you’re dating?

133 replies

Serval · 16/04/2023 18:24

So I’ve been on one date with a new guy that I’ve met.

And while he initiates contact/texting/meeting up to see each other, he seems to have this attitude of “whatever, I don’t need to impress you or make a good impression”, that’s the best way I can describe it. But I can’t work out if I’m being reasonable or a bit of a princess.

Examples;

  • on our first date made a big effort in my appearance, i had my nails done at the salon earlier that day. I wore a nice dress, did my hair, wore my best perfume and wore new shoes. When we first sat down at the bar we went to, he noticed my shoes and said “wow how do you walk in them?” (They’re Strappy high heels) I said “I’ve no idea haha, I’m still getting use to them they’re new”. He then lifted his feet and showed me his dirty trainers and said “You’re wearing new heels and I’m wearing my scruffy trainers haha. (Shrugs) I should be trying to impress you but hey”
  • He admitted while we were at the bar that he’s tight with money, has put weight on recently and he’s getting ‘big saggy man tits’ 😐and that because he’s short the weight shows a lot more on him. There was a cocktail on the menu called a “Long Sclong” so he made a “joke” (wasn’t really a joke) insinuating that he has a small penis
  • I am very active, I do outdoor running and go to the gym several times a week. He dropped that line on me again “I should be trying to impress you but whatever” then admitted he’s too lazy for the gym. Fair enough the gym isn’t for everyone, but I don’t know why that line again felt a bit off.
  • The following night after the date he FaceTimed me, he was in his kitchen. He lives alone and the sink was full of dirty plates and dishes in the background. He pointed that out and said “Told you I was lazy haha” then he gave me a guided tour of his apartment, it was quite cluttered. Then he showed me his overflowing laundry basket and said “I need to do a few washes tonight” I am house proud and would be mortified in anyone saw my home like that, especially a new date.

I’m not expecting him to kiss my feet and treat me like the queen, but is it too much to ask that he not take pride of putting his worst foot forward all the time?

I want to date someone go inspires me, and I feel impressed by. It’s really hard to fancy a man who actively points out all his flaws and finds it humorous.

He’s just asked me out on another date and I’m trying to think how to say no In the nicest possible way.

AIBU and too uptight?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TedMullins · 20/04/2023 16:21

Just say you didn't feel a spark and don't want to meet again. If he persists, block him! You don't owe him anything, you've had one date.

This is making me laugh though as I (a woman) am definitely more towards his end of the scale. I never wear makeup and would frequently go on dates in everyday slightly scruffy clothes. If it got to the point I was having them round then I wouldn't bother to tidy in advance. My thinking was they had to like me for who I really am, which is something of a graceless slob, but I have a great sense of humour to make up for it. I've had a partner for nearly 2 years now that I met on Hinge (and told him I'd only give him an hour of my time on the first date because I was sick of dating) so obviously I'm doing something right!

potniatheron · 20/04/2023 16:10

I think there's a difference between self-deprecation and what this man is doing, which is actually more a form of arrogance. He is communicating, quite clearly, that he thinks he is such a catch that he can afford to flaunt the fact that he is making negative effort. This has the effect of him also telling you that you are not worth his making an effort. Bin and run. You do not owe it to him to explain why you are binning and running, by the way.

WoofWoofBeachLife · 20/04/2023 14:04

I am so glad I'm happily married, this dating lark is a nightmare! @Serval you are NOT high maintenance because you always make an effort at anytime so don't let your friends make you doubt yourself. I'm assuming you've messaged him by now, he's obviously not ready for dating. It sounds like he's looking for a fuck buddy, although the saggy man tits, small cock and filthy trainers wouldn't get him even the Mad Tits character from Facebook 😆

Takeitonthechin · 20/04/2023 13:52

He's probably nervous and thinking he's punching above. And he's already thought through the going to bed with you and realises he's let himself go a-bit.

Putting weight on in itself can make you not dress as snappy and not bother with yourself.

Why don't you ask him if he wants to join you on a run or walk, why not engage in some physical fitness for dates, as for his cluttered mess, maybe if you explain you can't stand it, he may make the effort to tidy/ clean up if you are invited round to his.

Give him a chance first and see, you may be surprised with a bit of communication, if he continues to be a slob then at least you can walk away knowing you tried.

NemoandDoris · 17/04/2023 17:44

First dates are a bit like a job interview. You are showing your best side to try and see you are a good fit fit each other. He made no effort for the date which sets the tone for any relationship really.

If you are struggling for a nice way to say thanks but no thanks try ‘all the best but you are not quite what I am looking for’. No further details required (unless asked).

Frazzledmummy123 · 17/04/2023 17:21

Yanbu. He sounds lazy and it wouldn't hurt to put a little effort into his appearance.

If it wasn't for the comments along with it and you said in every other way you like him, I'd probably advise trying another few dates, but you sound like you really don't want to pursue this any more so therefore, I'd say end it and move on.

My DH was quite lazy with his appearance when we first met, and it remains a slight bone of contention even today, but to be fair, he made an effort for our first date, and after many conversations about it (as I liked him in every other way, and his appearance was never dirty, more a bit too laid back - turning up to visiting older relatives for a meal wearing a faded tshirt and torn jeans), he now makes more of an effort if we go somewhere.

Serval · 17/04/2023 16:42

GanjaDhin · 17/04/2023 12:16

Hey op don’t pay any attention to people who say they can’t believe you had to ask for an opinion. I know exactly where you are coming from. You say that your friends joke about you being high maintenance and I am guessing that “joking” has made you lose confidence in your values. I have had a similar experience. So what if you go to a lot of trouble to groom yourself for a date?That’s who you are and it’s fantastic and nobody else’s business. Your friends can tell say you are too fussy but pay them no mind and carry on the way you are. You’ll find someone.

@GanjaDhin thank you that’s very kind of you 😊

OP posts:
GanjaDhin · 17/04/2023 12:16

Hey op don’t pay any attention to people who say they can’t believe you had to ask for an opinion. I know exactly where you are coming from. You say that your friends joke about you being high maintenance and I am guessing that “joking” has made you lose confidence in your values. I have had a similar experience. So what if you go to a lot of trouble to groom yourself for a date?That’s who you are and it’s fantastic and nobody else’s business. Your friends can tell say you are too fussy but pay them no mind and carry on the way you are. You’ll find someone.

FOJN · 17/04/2023 04:59

Serval · 16/04/2023 19:19

I’m asking if my reasonings are unreasonable as my friendship group have been known to joke that I’m the “high maintenance” one. However I wouldn’t describe myself as that exactly, sometimes people can lack self awareness

You don't need anyone else to confirm if your reasons for not going on another date are acceptable. You'll be the one going on the date, not your friends who think standards equals high maintenance.

You've been on one date, you don't want to go on a second, this is not a 'break up'. Tell him you don't think you are compatible, he doesn't need to be told the reasons why, wish him well and move on. Block after messaging so you don't have to deal with any fall out.

CuriousMoo · 17/04/2023 04:49

Serval · 16/04/2023 18:34

Sorry ? Did you ready my post? I said I’m trying to put together a text saying thanks but no thanks to a next date. I’m asking if my reasonings for saying no are unreasonable or being uptight. Either way I’m not seeing him again

I have to wonder why you're asking others if your own reasons for not dating someone are wrong. You know you don't want to. That's the ultimate, best reason to not date someone!

It's not like you're presuming anything - he's literally showing you who he is, in person and on camera and you don't like it. So you can't date him. And you're not obliged to date anyone ever.

You've only met him once, just tell him there's no chemistry and get on to the next.

barmycatmum · 17/04/2023 03:53

I get the feeling he thought you’re out of his league. He was giving you a little “test.” An ex did that to me - he said “the REAL “test” will be if you still want to be with me after you see how I live!”
he was ashamed, thought I’d leave, and I stayed with him telling myself I wasn’t that shallow.

let’s just say that wasn’t a good decision.

best to just let this one go

JudgeRudy · 17/04/2023 01:27

I think nails done, new shoes and hair is a lot for a first date. Personally I'd do a Wednesday eve and have a pair of jeans and a 'nice' top. I wouldn't be wearing a dress or heels.
On the flipside I wouldn't home in on dirty washing or make silly jokes about my willy.

You're not too uptight. He's not to laid back... but he's too laid back for you.

I can see you 6 months down the line going to your cousins wedding and asking him if he should consider wearing a suit, where as he thinks his 'best' trousers and the birthday shirt you bought him are fine. If he goes 'yes dear' you'll turn into a nag/mum and won't fancy him anymore. If he says take me as l am you'll be torn because he makes you laugh and you have good sex, but angry that he wouldn't just do this one thing for you. It won't be one thing. He could he a great BF but maybe not partner (but probably s good dad!)
Tell you what...find out if he's a gamer. No, try a 2nd date, yes , move on. If he wears the same top/trousers on date 2 move on.

EllandRd · 17/04/2023 01:15

He is not responsible for the way you feel OP. Clearly ain't the one so just move on.

CheekyHobson · 17/04/2023 01:10

“I should be trying to let you down gently, but 🤷🏻‍♀️ I think our relationship has run its course”

LOL, this is actually the best answer.

“I would normally try to put this politely but as you were very direct with me, I’ll also be honest and say I was put off by your shabby shoes, talk of moobs and a small willy and the grim state of your house. Kudos for keeping it real, but I’m looking for someone who is prepared to put in more effort. All the best with finding someone who matches your lifestyle.”

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 17/04/2023 00:35

You don't need to go into why's and wherefores, just say you're not of a mind to go ahead thanks and good luck, bye.

And then book yourself in to a therapist to build your confidence before you date anyone else. Seriously. The fact you'd have to ask is alarming.

tothelefttotheleft · 16/04/2023 21:57

I think it's unkind to leave him hanging about whether you want to see him or not.

Just tell him no thanks.

Ihatepainting · 16/04/2023 21:22

do,you rarely date? I can’t understand why you’re making such a big deal of this. Just say was lovely to meet you, wasn’t feeling a spark, so bowing out.

samqueens · 16/04/2023 21:18

“I should be trying to let you down gently, but 🤷🏻‍♀️ I think our relationship has run its course”

The block and move on.

ModestMoon · 16/04/2023 21:07

Two problems here: the standards themselves you can chalk up to basic incompatibility. Someone being really tidy or really messy would be a no for me, as I know it would cause problems down the line, and I'd rather know that sort of thing early on. Same with someone who only wears tracksuits or someone who likes women who put a lot of time and effort into their appearance. That sort of difference makes you just say thanks, no spark, and move on.

But the real problem is that his attitude sounds terrible, I hate the idea of a man joking about how he hasn't made an effort, as if the woman he's with isn't worth it. I would never dress up in heels or go to the salon for a date, I usually live in a pair of muddy boots - for a date I'd probably go for nicer clean boots. But if my date had shown up in nice shoes and the topic of conversation had moved that way, I would probably say something about how I love boots, I would be very keen to stress that this IS me making an effort! I wouldn't want him to think that I hadn't made an effort, but at the same time, the conversation would rule out men who like their women more dressed up. Job done, with no one feeling bad. It's that he deliberately wants you to know that he doesn't give a shit that's the problem.

iklboo · 16/04/2023 20:21

The only possible way I'd overlook this is him being Chris Hemsworth

Even then I'd make him do the bloody dishes. Just after I'd worn him out elsewhere 😄

GanjaDhin · 16/04/2023 20:17

It is ok to acknowledge that he’s just not in your league. He probably couldn’t believe it when you walked in. There is someone out there for the lazy-arse-Saggy-tits man in the dirty trainers but it ain’t you. Next!

Baabaa75 · 16/04/2023 20:17

Tbh this smacks of a guy who's had relationships end because of his slovenliness and he's trying to head off future arguements 'but you KNEW what we were like when we got together, I was quite open ', just run now 👍

PickoftheMix · 16/04/2023 20:16

Think about it the other way around. If he showed in a nice suit, new shoes and hair done nicely and you showed up in old trainers, jeans and a manky old t-shirt with your hair messy, then made "jokes" about your saggy tits and flappy fanny and told him how messy you are, do ou think he'd be pondering over what to write in a "no thanks" message! Us women do beat ourselves up don't we!

Baabaa75 · 16/04/2023 20:15

AIBU and too uptight?

Who cares? You don't want to see him again, he obviously didn't do it for you so DON'T SEE HIM AGAIN. In 12 months he won't remember your name, why are you overthinking this? 💐

WindyWends · 16/04/2023 20:13

Serval · 16/04/2023 20:03

Yes I can’t believe he let me see that as well. I was so confused and trying to understand his thought process behind it 🤔

The whole lack of effort just screams male entitlement to me. I can’t imagine many women showing off their laundry basket of dirty knickers with great pride and disclosing that they have a fanny like a wizards sleeve

And actually boasting about laziness and lack of basic cleanliness, just what the hell!

Like he doesn't even need to bother trying to look good, thinking you obviously can't wait for a 2nd date, with no effort, at his depressing dirty dive. Ick!

Swipe left for the next trending thread