Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To notice the 10% benefit rise and know I'm on the bones of my ass

241 replies

Letspovertyplayagain · 16/04/2023 14:03

I know it's tiny. But when you are properly skint after everything you notice this tiny rise will mean some strawberries for the kids or some fresh milk instead of uht. This is for the people who complain they are poor or feeling the pinch when they really have no idea. And define their poverty as not going on holidays....

OP posts:
Chattycathydoll · 16/04/2023 19:54

korgy · 16/04/2023 19:38

@Chattycathydoll I'd like to ditch my life for UC but I don't know how to. Do you have to lose your job before you claim or can you give it up. I think I'd be better off on UC than what I currently have after work related costs.

UC is structured so that you should never be better off without a job. Have you done the calculations?

If you earn less than you would be getting on UC, you are most likely eligible for in-work UC top up anyway (a lot of people are including me).

salcombebabe · 16/04/2023 19:48

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 14:05

10% isn’t exactly a ‘tiny’ rise though.

10% of not very much is not very much 🤦‍♀️

Xenia · 16/04/2023 19:46

I am not short of money but I did some work today and the fee has not increased since it started in 2008.

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 19:43

@Howpo *I don't see the connection between Nurses pay and Benefits increases tbh.

They are simply not related.*

The OP said it was fine for nurses to get 5% but the benefits increase of 10% is too low.
I didn’t link them initially, the OP did.

Plus they are related in that both funds come from the public purse. It’s simply unfair that nurses have to strike for 5%.

Once again I don’t have an issue with benefits rising by 10%, I disagree that it should rise more than that at a time when public sector pay isn’t rising anywhere near that.

OnlyTheBravest · 16/04/2023 19:43

@korgy If you quit, without good reason, you will be sanctioned for at least 3 months (could be more). You will also have to follow the new rules re: claimant commitment. Have a look at the info on the government site. A lotof people who seem to be better off may still be on legacy benefits or are exempt from the benefits cap e.g. household includes disabled members

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 19:40

@Flowersun6 Don't assume, you seem to be assuming an awful lot right down to UC childcare costs how an earth would you know exactly what percent parents are getting?

How is it an assumption? It’s public information how much UC pays towards a childcare bill based on how much UC you receive. I don’t understand what exactly you have problem with?

Howpo · 16/04/2023 19:39

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 19:33

And what are you basing that off exactly? I’ve no problem with benefits increasing by 10%. I think it’s a fair and appropriate rise.
I disagree with benefits raising by more than 10%, as the OP suggested they should, at a time when public sector workers are striking and being offered half that or less.

No idea how that makes me 5. It seems like
you’re the ignorant one if you’re struggling with basic comprehension.

I don't see the connection between Nurses pay and Benefits increases tbh.

They are simply not related.

Food inflation is still around 18%, energy has gone up from a price "cap" of £1200 to around £2500, so a 100% increase and fuel is still around 50% more than it was a couple of years ago.

I really don't know where these 10% inflation figures come from, apparently the price of CDs and DVD recorders are included in the "everyday" basket of goods we buy

korgy · 16/04/2023 19:38

@Chattycathydoll I'd like to ditch my life for UC but I don't know how to. Do you have to lose your job before you claim or can you give it up. I think I'd be better off on UC than what I currently have after work related costs.

Flowersun6 · 16/04/2023 19:37

@Albiboba I'm not ignorant. I work in the public sector myself. Don't assume, you seem to be assuming an awful lot right down to UC childcare costs how an earth would you know exactly what percent parents are getting? I'm not struggling to comprehend. I'm well aware of how UC works are you?

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 19:33

Flowersun6 · 16/04/2023 19:21

@Albiboba your posts are ignorant and one sided. If your that jealous of benefits go and sign on them yourself. I honestly don't have the time of day for posts like yours.

Are you 5?

And what are you basing that off exactly? I’ve no problem with benefits increasing by 10%. I think it’s a fair and appropriate rise.
I disagree with benefits raising by more than 10%, as the OP suggested they should, at a time when public sector workers are striking and being offered half that or less.

No idea how that makes me 5. It seems like
you’re the ignorant one if you’re struggling with basic comprehension.

Flowersun6 · 16/04/2023 19:21

@Albiboba your posts are ignorant and one sided. If your that jealous of benefits go and sign on them yourself. I honestly don't have the time of day for posts like yours.

Are you 5?

Densol57 · 16/04/2023 19:21

Its based on the CPI % for the previous Sep. This also applies to Civil Service pensions. One of my pensions went up by £650 a month ( net )

banjaxxed · 16/04/2023 19:19

"Obviously £3.42 per day is not enough to feed a child three nutritious meals. So no, it is nowhere near enough to cover food."

Don't talk garbage

I spent just over £100 in the supermarket yesterday- 2 adults, a teenager and an 11 year old

£3.42 per day is nearly 25% of that and I absolutely can feed all 4 of us well for £100 per week

Babyroobs · 16/04/2023 19:17

OnlyTheBravest · 16/04/2023 19:05

What I do not understand is why do prices have to go up every year. There has to be a point were you can not increase prices anymore, if you do not want to increase the pay/benefits that people receive.
I do wonder if we are approaching the end of capitalism and are closer to a universal basic income for the majority of workers.

I honestly don't see how so much spending on benefits can continue without taxes having to rise hugely. We have an ageing population and I see daily how much some pensioners are getting in benefits, Attendance allowance, pension credit, housing benefit .it is a lot ! Add to that them paying out more for childcare ( I do understand why they need to do that and that they are hoping it will pay off in taxes longer term ) and private rents just rising and rising uncontrollably and more and more young people standing no chance of getting on the housing ladder until their parents die. It's just a ticking time bomb in my opinion. Also the number of people applying for disability benefits has risen hugely recently with more ill health, longer NHS waiting lists etc. And these benefits just go on for years and years on end. No sure how a UBI would work - most people would still need to be topped up hugely.

Letspovertyplayagain · 16/04/2023 19:07

@MayThe4th if you don't have children then no you won't get child benefit, that isn't being unfair 🤷

OP posts:
Botw1 · 16/04/2023 19:07

@Mangolist

No ot wasn't set to rile people up. It was to answer the point that no one on benefits gets what nurses do.

Clearly they do.

I'm glad people who are genuinely disabled get the financial support they need. It should be increased more than 10%.

I'm not really sure what the point of the thread was tbh?

Other than riling people up.

Letspovertyplayagain · 16/04/2023 19:05

Love the poster saying my kids shouldn't have strawberries! Why not? Yes they go quickly but they eating and enjoyed. Also ration to 3 a day and they do stretch ( I like them but pretend I don't do the kids don't realise I am missing out) When they are reduced, wonky or on offer. Some children won't eat fruit, im lucky. Working on the vegetables though. Have tried frozen ones and they didn't like the texture. Would that same poster make a smug remark that their kids only eat organic pomegranate seeds with Brussel sprouts and organic cocoa nibs yoghurt .... And we aren't all trying hard enough to give our kids a varied diet ...

OP posts:
OnlyTheBravest · 16/04/2023 19:05

What I do not understand is why do prices have to go up every year. There has to be a point were you can not increase prices anymore, if you do not want to increase the pay/benefits that people receive.
I do wonder if we are approaching the end of capitalism and are closer to a universal basic income for the majority of workers.

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 19:03

Flowersun6 · 16/04/2023 18:52

There will be plenty of nurses claiming UC too especially with a family.

Even more of a reason for nurses pay rise to be at least as high as benefits are being raised by, rather than only benefits increasing more than 10% to make up for it.

MayThe4th · 16/04/2023 18:58

Honestly all the competitive threads about who has the least are tedious.

Ultimately none of us ever feel as if we have enough money because we generally live to our means.

A 10% rise in benefits is a huge rise compared to what most of us who are on a salary will get. And plenty of people bring home far less on a salary than people get in benefits.

Everyone is feeling the pinch right now. And everyone is having to decide where to make cuts and where to spend less.

I earn just over £20k a year, am not entitled to any benefits, meanwhile my mortgage has been going up month on month, food bills are rising, and unlike people on benefits, a chunk of my salary is paid out in tax, something which doesn’t happen if you’re on benefits.

But people obviously have their own needs and spends and we all have to make the best of it.

Princessbananahamock · 16/04/2023 18:54

Any increase to benefits child or otherwise have been wiped out due to the increase of basic necessities going up quite highly. As an example willow butter (cheaper than shops own!) was £1 not so long ago now £1.50 I notice how much a basic shop has increased £20 is now £25 plus. Which I feel is quite unbelievable on a tight budget you do notice the price of things.

Jabiru · 16/04/2023 18:54

It can’t be long before benefits and nurses pay is roughly comparable anyway.

Cakeandcardio · 16/04/2023 18:53

It's hard being so skint OP. I was the child in a home where my family had very little. We only had some stuff because my gran helped out. I hope you do feel it makes some difference to you but the reality is that benefits are too low. ❤

Chattycathydoll · 16/04/2023 18:52

Mangolist · 16/04/2023 18:44

It's the posts like 'some people getting £35000 a year' which, although it has now been explained, is simply set to rile others up. I wouldn't wish the necessity for two lots of DLA and a full adult PIP award on anyone, no matter how much money they are getting.
It's the same on every benefits thread. This weird envy of people who are on benefits. Awful

And yet they never think to simply ditch their awful, cruel jobs and live the high life on UC.
Wonder why that might be…

Flowersun6 · 16/04/2023 18:52

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 18:44

Because it’s still out of line for benefits to increase by more than 10% when half that has been offered to public sector workers like nurses.
Even if someone is working and receiving UC it’s still classed as two separate incomes. For one to raise and not the other when they are all public sector just isn’t logical.

There will be plenty of nurses claiming UC too especially with a family.