Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To notice the 10% benefit rise and know I'm on the bones of my ass

241 replies

Letspovertyplayagain · 16/04/2023 14:03

I know it's tiny. But when you are properly skint after everything you notice this tiny rise will mean some strawberries for the kids or some fresh milk instead of uht. This is for the people who complain they are poor or feeling the pinch when they really have no idea. And define their poverty as not going on holidays....

OP posts:
Chattycathydoll · 17/04/2023 08:12

I also got a pay rise at work, btw. One of the measly ones being complained about, less than 3%. It’s still more than my benefits increase, because that’s how percentages work. 3% of a larger figure is still more in actual coins than 10% of the smaller figure.

Perhaps those whinging ‘I wish I had a 10% pay rise’ would change their minds when offered the actual money. Sure,
10% sounds dramatic and vast. But whinging ‘I wish I had an extra 30p a day!’ sounds pathetic (because it is). Even more so when you throw in ‘I wish I was permanently disabled so I could have an extra £9 a week!’

sashh · 17/04/2023 06:16

BigChesterDraws · 16/04/2023 17:15

10% is considerably more than the pay rise I got. How much more do you think the taxpayer should give you, bearing in mind that most of them didn’t get a 10% increase already. Every penny you get is a penny taken from someone else. It’s not free money.

I get contribution based ESA, did you get that, contribution based, it is based on how much NI I have paid in.

I also get a pension, again something I paid in to.

Half my ESA is taken away because of my pension.

So I have paid double what many people have 'paid in'.

My universal credit is reduced by both the ESA and the pension.

Geta10percentriseitsgreat · 17/04/2023 02:30

crossstitchingnana · 16/04/2023 23:48

I'd love a 10% pay rise.

Get Cancer like me it's incurable though you'll love it , I love being on benefits now 'til I die .

Badbudgeter · 16/04/2023 23:49

XenoBitch · 16/04/2023 23:05

From what I gather, the strikes are more about the working conditions than the pay. Or pay versus working conditions
I know a lot of nurses, and none are on UC. If they are on UC, and using foodbanks like media will have you believe, then everyone under their pay band will be cap in hand at food banks, and asking the Job Centre for an advance payment. That is not happening.

I'm sure it's a minority who are using foodbanks. That said how do you know who is claiming UC? I have children and some childcare costs, I own rather than rent. I'd have to take home more than £3.1k a month not to get any UC. As it is I take home £2.2K so they take £900 off of my entitlements. I wouldn't talk about it though. Generally people assume I am not on benefits, I work for the local council and often listen to people complain about scroungers etc.

I'm sure there are Nurses witrh families who have to claim too. Just because you are working full time doesn't mean you won't need top up benefits.

crossstitchingnana · 16/04/2023 23:48

I'd love a 10% pay rise.

Coxspurplepippin · 16/04/2023 23:42

DMum's attendance allowance has gone up by the exact amount her care package cost has increased.....

LakieLady · 16/04/2023 23:39

XenoBitch · 16/04/2023 23:05

From what I gather, the strikes are more about the working conditions than the pay. Or pay versus working conditions
I know a lot of nurses, and none are on UC. If they are on UC, and using foodbanks like media will have you believe, then everyone under their pay band will be cap in hand at food banks, and asking the Job Centre for an advance payment. That is not happening.

They can easily be entitled to UC if they're renting in the private sector and they live in a high rent area.

I did a benefit check for a nurse the other day, she has 3 kids and her rent is £1,500 a month. She was entitled to quite a bit of UC, despite being on almost £36k a year.

LakieLady · 16/04/2023 23:34

YetiTeri · 16/04/2023 15:34

No of course it isn't. Because benefits, and public sector wages have had below inflation rises consistently.

That's why there are more homeless, more food banks and more child poverty. It wasn't a necessity it was and is a political choice. And as someone up thread pointed out many people have absolutely no idea how the poorest have to live.

Totally agree.

Some of my ILs think that everyone on benefits is getting 100's every week and living the life of Riley. They insist that I'm wrong when I explain that a single person without children gets £77 pw/£344 a month to pay for everything, including (in many areas) 20% of their council tax, and probably a fair bit of their rent as housing benefit/UC rarely covers the full amount thanks to the freezing of local housing allowance for years.

I work in welfare rights and check people's benefits every working day, but they still maintain that I'm wrong and everyone on a low income is actually rich as Croesus.

VladimirVsVolodymyr · 16/04/2023 23:34

Letspovertyplayagain · 16/04/2023 19:05

Love the poster saying my kids shouldn't have strawberries! Why not? Yes they go quickly but they eating and enjoyed. Also ration to 3 a day and they do stretch ( I like them but pretend I don't do the kids don't realise I am missing out) When they are reduced, wonky or on offer. Some children won't eat fruit, im lucky. Working on the vegetables though. Have tried frozen ones and they didn't like the texture. Would that same poster make a smug remark that their kids only eat organic pomegranate seeds with Brussel sprouts and organic cocoa nibs yoghurt .... And we aren't all trying hard enough to give our kids a varied diet ...

@Letspovertyplayagain ❤️❤️❤️

XenoBitch · 16/04/2023 23:05

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 21:37

That it literally the point though. It makes significantly more sense to raise public sector pay for people like nurses, teachers than to keep it low and merely increase benefit top ups instead.

From what I gather, the strikes are more about the working conditions than the pay. Or pay versus working conditions
I know a lot of nurses, and none are on UC. If they are on UC, and using foodbanks like media will have you believe, then everyone under their pay band will be cap in hand at food banks, and asking the Job Centre for an advance payment. That is not happening.

NewContender · 16/04/2023 21:56

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 14:20

I dunno why everyone is taking such an issue with my comment.
10% is really not a small increase. It’s a reasonable increase roughly in line with inflation.
They are hardly going to increase benefit amounts by 20% while refusing to engage in discussions about nurses pay.

Oh, that’s easy, it’s because it came across as mean spirited, nitpicky and goady on a thread about people struggling with life’s basics.

Tumbleweed101 · 16/04/2023 21:50

The income level to get prescription help hasn't been moved either despite min wage going up last couple years. More low income families have been pushed over the threshold but not any better financially than before due to cost of living increases. I relied quite heavily on help for things like eye tests but I'm about £100 over the cut off point now 🙄.

Badbudgeter · 16/04/2023 21:49

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 21:37

That it literally the point though. It makes significantly more sense to raise public sector pay for people like nurses, teachers than to keep it low and merely increase benefit top ups instead.

I suspect from an economics point of view it makes sense to pay top up benefits when people have children rather than raise wages. Poor people will have to work longer, are more stressed and die younger. If you increase wages then you have to pay throughout peoples working lives and then again through pensions.

I don't agree with it. I'm just a bit pessimistic about the prospects of the system changing.

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 21:37

CouldIHaveThatInEnglishPlease · 16/04/2023 20:54

It’s interesting that there’s so many people comparing public sector payrises and benefit rises.

shockingly, many of these nurses who are being awarded 5%, are also heavily reliant on UC and that increase to make up the real-terms pay cut they are getting. It’s not a one verses the other. The vast majority of UC claimants are in work, and many of those in public sector roles.

That it literally the point though. It makes significantly more sense to raise public sector pay for people like nurses, teachers than to keep it low and merely increase benefit top ups instead.

Badbudgeter · 16/04/2023 21:33

I'm not in healthcare but I do work for the local council. They pay living wage or thereabouts for a lot of staff £10.90 -£12.00 some for quite specialised roles, things like bin lorry drivers where you need an HGV licence for example. By keeping wages low you preserve the budget otherwise you'd have to raise council tax. People, especially those with children or high rents, will often be subsidised by UC. Obviously the UC is paid for by general taxation but as long as it's not coming from their pot. I don't get an awful lot of UC but it's a gateway benefit for cost of living payments and the Scottish child payment so I'm much better off than I would be otherwise.

I think if I've totted everything up right I will be an extra £100 or so a month richer which is a higher than 10% increase really but the increase in the work allowance of nearly sixty quid means I get an extra £33 plus 10% if that makes sense?

Gingerkittykat · 16/04/2023 21:27

korgy · 16/04/2023 19:38

@Chattycathydoll I'd like to ditch my life for UC but I don't know how to. Do you have to lose your job before you claim or can you give it up. I think I'd be better off on UC than what I currently have after work related costs.

Most people on UC are expected to work or work search. The only exceptions are if you have a child under 3, are disabled, or are a carer.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 16/04/2023 21:23

It took me a little while to work out the OP is actually complaining about the her 10% benefits rise.

OP, how much benefits rise do you think would be reasonable for you?

Allmyghosts · 16/04/2023 21:11

Does noone remember the huge Riven thread/thing where people were outraged about her disabled child being restricted to a certain amount of continency products? That mumsnet is gone forever, its full of cruelty and snark now.

Allmyghosts · 16/04/2023 21:06

ITT people who don't understand percentages, also twatty bastards. Op you are on a hiding to nothing trying to make people understand how shitty and depressing it is to live on benefits. Contrary to the hooters that exclaim that it was always the same, no it fucking wasn't. Been here since 2003.

Capuccinopup · 16/04/2023 21:03

Not sure if it has been mentioned already upthread but the housing allowance is frozen, so the 10% benefit increase will not include any housing money. As rent has been the largest increase for many people, the 10% figure isn’t as reasonable as it seems - for families the majority percentage of their benefit is the housing benefit/housing element, so it’s a smaller portion which gets the increase.

CouldIHaveThatInEnglishPlease · 16/04/2023 20:54

It’s interesting that there’s so many people comparing public sector payrises and benefit rises.

shockingly, many of these nurses who are being awarded 5%, are also heavily reliant on UC and that increase to make up the real-terms pay cut they are getting. It’s not a one verses the other. The vast majority of UC claimants are in work, and many of those in public sector roles.

Babyroobs · 16/04/2023 20:49

Jabiru · 16/04/2023 20:44

It’s probably fair to say that the government cannot afford to raise benefits by 10% and also give a higher pay rise to NHS staff (it’s all staff on AfC payscales, not just ‘nurses’).

Faced with the choice, the government will raise benefits. This is why I think some people on benefits are ‘earning’ more than nurses or the difference in ‘pay’ between the ‘jobs’ (being an nurse or being on benefits) isn’t much when you work it out.

and yes, lots of people on benefits also work.

I don’t have an issue with raising benefits - I work in the nhs myself - but I do struggle when nurses and others leave university with masses of debt and transferable skills that the country needs, only to find themselves no better off financially than somebody who does unskilled work, has not amassed the debt, but earns roughly the same or slightly less through a combination of unskilled work and benefit top up.

I’m sure somebody will come along to say how the nurse has better prospects or she can get a mortgage (in fact she likely cannot afford one), but why shouldn’t she have better prospects and financial stability?

my point is, there’s very little reward or incentive to train in a shortage skill when you could earn broadly similar amounts by never passing an exam, taking unskilled work and having children.

It may be unpopular to say this, and terrible to even think it, but nurses and doctors are voting with their feet because (amongst other reasons) the difference between their pay and the ‘pay’ of people without the same skill is negligible. Why on Earth would they stay? I pay my cleaner £11 per hour cash in hand. A junior doctor gets £11.20 if you knock 20% off for tax/NI. 20p per hour more than my cleaner. And no, she doesn’t have a single GCSE to her name.

I sit next to a physio who is 18 months qualified and just accepted a job in Australia. My cousin is a nurse who has left the NHS to earn more money with an agency. The NHS needs to retain, not drive away.

I left Nursing about five years ago, totally burnt out and stressed. I do a totally different job now and even though it's charity sector and therefore the pay isn't great, it probably pays about as much as a newly qualified RN ( minus enhancements). Nothing would tempt me back to the hell that was Nursing, not even a 20% pay increase ! My SIL is also a Nurse but only does a few days a week and has started a second job as a cleaner and says her pay for cleaning/ housekeeping is almost as good as her RN pay !

Jabiru · 16/04/2023 20:44

It’s probably fair to say that the government cannot afford to raise benefits by 10% and also give a higher pay rise to NHS staff (it’s all staff on AfC payscales, not just ‘nurses’).

Faced with the choice, the government will raise benefits. This is why I think some people on benefits are ‘earning’ more than nurses or the difference in ‘pay’ between the ‘jobs’ (being an nurse or being on benefits) isn’t much when you work it out.

and yes, lots of people on benefits also work.

I don’t have an issue with raising benefits - I work in the nhs myself - but I do struggle when nurses and others leave university with masses of debt and transferable skills that the country needs, only to find themselves no better off financially than somebody who does unskilled work, has not amassed the debt, but earns roughly the same or slightly less through a combination of unskilled work and benefit top up.

I’m sure somebody will come along to say how the nurse has better prospects or she can get a mortgage (in fact she likely cannot afford one), but why shouldn’t she have better prospects and financial stability?

my point is, there’s very little reward or incentive to train in a shortage skill when you could earn broadly similar amounts by never passing an exam, taking unskilled work and having children.

It may be unpopular to say this, and terrible to even think it, but nurses and doctors are voting with their feet because (amongst other reasons) the difference between their pay and the ‘pay’ of people without the same skill is negligible. Why on Earth would they stay? I pay my cleaner £11 per hour cash in hand. A junior doctor gets £11.20 if you knock 20% off for tax/NI. 20p per hour more than my cleaner. And no, she doesn’t have a single GCSE to her name.

I sit next to a physio who is 18 months qualified and just accepted a job in Australia. My cousin is a nurse who has left the NHS to earn more money with an agency. The NHS needs to retain, not drive away.

MayThe4th · 16/04/2023 20:20

Can't those who work and earn and have a good life in comparison just stop this weird jealously, and have a think? maybe when those who are on benefits stop complaining that those who actually do work are having it tough too. Because prices are rising for everyone not just for benefit claimants.

Can’t we all just acknowledge that prices are going up for everyone and that everyone has to make sacrifices. And that even if those sacrifices are an activity for the kids which someone else couldn’t afford anyway, that activity is still important to the person who currently does it.

There is always going to be someone worse off than you are. Whoever you are. Would it be ok to say that people on benefits should be grateful because at least they’re not living in abject poverty in the third world? Because trust me that is far worse, so maybe everyone just needs to count their blessings here

firef1y · 16/04/2023 20:03

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 14:05

10% isn’t exactly a ‘tiny’ rise though.

Carers allowance is one of those that has gone up 10%. It's gone up from £69(ish) to £76. So a massive less than £7 rise.

Which when you consider that you need to care for the person for at least 35 hours a week means a total of.....drumroll please...less than 20p an hour.

If, like many on carers allowance you are actually needing to be available 24/7 it's an even more impressive inlecrease of Less than 4p/hour. So no its not a massive increase, its miniscule, and yet, yes it will still make a slight difference.

Swipe left for the next trending thread