Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To notice the 10% benefit rise and know I'm on the bones of my ass

241 replies

Letspovertyplayagain · 16/04/2023 14:03

I know it's tiny. But when you are properly skint after everything you notice this tiny rise will mean some strawberries for the kids or some fresh milk instead of uht. This is for the people who complain they are poor or feeling the pinch when they really have no idea. And define their poverty as not going on holidays....

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Badbudgeter · 22/04/2023 14:49

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 22/04/2023 14:35

I suppose if you have a list of 8 benefits and they've all increased by 10%, and you're earning £30-35k PA, then that's an increase of £250-£290 per month which is VERY good.

Most people don't have 8 benefits though.

I don’t think the benefit cap applies if anyone in the family is disabled.

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 22/04/2023 14:35

brooksidebackside · 16/04/2023 17:42

@SpringHasSprungAtLast

How can that be

I just did a calculation based upon a family I know

5 kids
2 on DLA
One adult on PIP
(None enhanced rate)
Council house
No savings

£844 per week, made up from...

£536 UC
£76 carers allowance
£125 Scottish child payment
£87 child benefit
£19 council tax benefit

They are affected by the benefits cap according to the calculation but you also have to add on...

£95 DLA MRC/LRM
£128 DLA HRC/LRM
£95PIP standard for both

I suppose if you have a list of 8 benefits and they've all increased by 10%, and you're earning £30-35k PA, then that's an increase of £250-£290 per month which is VERY good.

Most people don't have 8 benefits though.

Babyroobs · 22/04/2023 13:40

UndercoverCop · 22/04/2023 08:15

I think when people are saying 30k on benefits, or relays to having to earn 30k to take home the same amount, rather than actually receiving that amount.
A family member of mine is ostensibly a single parent (father is a nightmare, sometimes looks after DC and sometimes gives her a decent amount of money, but unreliable and often losing his job, their relationship is on and off), she told me she works 16 hours a week in a min wage job earning (net) £685 a month approx, her universal credit and CB combined is £1395 a month, which includes council tax reduction, plus she gets 85% of any childcare/wrap around she uses back (around £200) so isn't really paying much at all for childcare out of that money. So to match that she'd have to earn £34,672 to take the same amount home after tax, NI etc.
She has no reason to lie to me, she feels stuck and wants to get off benefits but feels she can't, because she won't be able to get a job earning that much.

It won't last forever. As her kids get older she will have no choice to look for more hours. UC doesn't include council tax reduction, that is seperate. I agree though it's a huge amount that some people get on benefits and some people do feel trapped.

Moreorlessmentallystable · 22/04/2023 12:42

sashh · 22/04/2023 07:52

I'll swap, I'll take your job, NI, tax and you can have my benefits - but you have to take my ill health as well.

That's a very reductive point of view. Are you implying that all people on benefits are ill? Why is it one or the other? There are also people in the world that are ill and live in a country with no benefits. Would you swap them? My point is there is no magic money tree regardless of the hardships some people might be in...benefits should be only for people that can not work because of I'll was or being a full time carer for someone I'll...this is not the case!

UndercoverCop · 22/04/2023 08:15

I think when people are saying 30k on benefits, or relays to having to earn 30k to take home the same amount, rather than actually receiving that amount.
A family member of mine is ostensibly a single parent (father is a nightmare, sometimes looks after DC and sometimes gives her a decent amount of money, but unreliable and often losing his job, their relationship is on and off), she told me she works 16 hours a week in a min wage job earning (net) £685 a month approx, her universal credit and CB combined is £1395 a month, which includes council tax reduction, plus she gets 85% of any childcare/wrap around she uses back (around £200) so isn't really paying much at all for childcare out of that money. So to match that she'd have to earn £34,672 to take the same amount home after tax, NI etc.
She has no reason to lie to me, she feels stuck and wants to get off benefits but feels she can't, because she won't be able to get a job earning that much.

sashh · 22/04/2023 07:52

Moreorlessmentallystable · 19/04/2023 08:22

Well on the contrary, the higher your wage, the more gets swallowed by pension, tax and NI and btw I am only just above average UK wage, and yes, I manage by being frugal....I don't understand why you say "Clearly, if a 10% payrise would make a significant difference to you, you're earning a good wage abs managing better than a lot of other people" ? Is not that it would make a huge difference, but certainly it would make more of a difference than what I actually got ( a lot less than 10%). My point is: if most people are getting 2-6% increase in wages a 10% increase in benefits is actually quite generous. So in simpler terms: the taxpayer is giving benefit recipients a higher increase in wages than we are receiving from actual profitable companies AND we have to work for it.....

I'll swap, I'll take your job, NI, tax and you can have my benefits - but you have to take my ill health as well.

Solmum1964 · 20/04/2023 19:09

CouldIHaveThatInEnglishPlease · 17/04/2023 15:40

Tbf, my dd budgets £20 a week for her food shop. Not sure how nutritionally balanced that is mind, but it is pretty normal for a uni student to live off

That seems very low. I'm pretty certain we calculatde £30 a week when sons were at uni around ten years ago!

Moreorlessmentallystable · 19/04/2023 08:22

MarvellousMonsters · 18/04/2023 16:18

I guess that depends on your wage. If my wages went up 10% I'd get less then £100 a month more Confused And that would be immediately swallowed up by the reduction in housing benefit & tax credits that would result. Clearly, if a 10% payrise would make a significant difference to you, you're earning a good wage abs managing better than a lot of other people.

Well on the contrary, the higher your wage, the more gets swallowed by pension, tax and NI and btw I am only just above average UK wage, and yes, I manage by being frugal....I don't understand why you say "Clearly, if a 10% payrise would make a significant difference to you, you're earning a good wage abs managing better than a lot of other people" ? Is not that it would make a huge difference, but certainly it would make more of a difference than what I actually got ( a lot less than 10%). My point is: if most people are getting 2-6% increase in wages a 10% increase in benefits is actually quite generous. So in simpler terms: the taxpayer is giving benefit recipients a higher increase in wages than we are receiving from actual profitable companies AND we have to work for it.....

MeinKraft · 18/04/2023 22:02

Crunchymum · 17/04/2023 19:33

I'll use my extra £20 a month to pay the extra £80 a month my energy bills have increased by.

That's maths Rishi Sunak style!

MeinKraft · 18/04/2023 21:58

LoisLane66 · 18/04/2023 21:47

I don't know how others are managing...not very well in some cases as evidenced here. I manage very well on a basic pension and have today, Tues 18th, spent £41 in Primark including a fabulous khaki/black animal print satin pleated midi-skirt, £31 on multivitamins and Straf in H&B and £25 on a fab Moroccan market basket in TKMaax. 😁 I don't run a car or have Sky, Netflix or an horrendous mobile bill. I have a £6pm SIM in a 2017 phone and use public transport.

If you had kids to feed and clothe you wouldn't be able to spend your pension in Primark Confused

violetskypurple · 18/04/2023 21:55

LoisLane66 · 18/04/2023 21:47

I don't know how others are managing...not very well in some cases as evidenced here. I manage very well on a basic pension and have today, Tues 18th, spent £41 in Primark including a fabulous khaki/black animal print satin pleated midi-skirt, £31 on multivitamins and Straf in H&B and £25 on a fab Moroccan market basket in TKMaax. 😁 I don't run a car or have Sky, Netflix or an horrendous mobile bill. I have a £6pm SIM in a 2017 phone and use public transport.

There's people here posting about being a single parent to disabled child and they can't afford their gas and electric and you're being smug about spending nearly £100 on a load of crap.

What was the point in your post?

violetskypurple · 18/04/2023 21:51

LoisLane66 · 18/04/2023 21:47

I don't know how others are managing...not very well in some cases as evidenced here. I manage very well on a basic pension and have today, Tues 18th, spent £41 in Primark including a fabulous khaki/black animal print satin pleated midi-skirt, £31 on multivitamins and Straf in H&B and £25 on a fab Moroccan market basket in TKMaax. 😁 I don't run a car or have Sky, Netflix or an horrendous mobile bill. I have a £6pm SIM in a 2017 phone and use public transport.

Have you actually come on a thread where people are talking about barely scraping by, struggling to feed their kids etc to tell us about what tat you've bought in Primark today because you're managing just fine living off your pension?

Do you have rent costs? Childcare costs? Nappies/uniform/extra mouths to feed?

LoisLane66 · 18/04/2023 21:47

I don't know how others are managing...not very well in some cases as evidenced here. I manage very well on a basic pension and have today, Tues 18th, spent £41 in Primark including a fabulous khaki/black animal print satin pleated midi-skirt, £31 on multivitamins and Straf in H&B and £25 on a fab Moroccan market basket in TKMaax. 😁 I don't run a car or have Sky, Netflix or an horrendous mobile bill. I have a £6pm SIM in a 2017 phone and use public transport.

Harmonypus · 18/04/2023 18:21

@SpringHasSprungAtLast

It's called ZipZero.

They do pay you a tiny %age of your spend value but you have to match that award with online shopping through their links, so I don't take much notice of the few pennies they pay me, I use it for the chance to keep my receipts without keeping scrappy bits of paper.

MarvellousMonsters · 18/04/2023 16:18

Moreorlessmentallystable · 17/04/2023 20:24

YABU...Wish my wage would have gone up 10% 🤣

I guess that depends on your wage. If my wages went up 10% I'd get less then £100 a month more Confused And that would be immediately swallowed up by the reduction in housing benefit & tax credits that would result. Clearly, if a 10% payrise would make a significant difference to you, you're earning a good wage abs managing better than a lot of other people.

MarvellousMonsters · 18/04/2023 12:03

Albiboba · 16/04/2023 14:05

10% isn’t exactly a ‘tiny’ rise though.

10% of pennies is still only pennies. My child benefit has increased from £87 every 4 weeks, to £95. So, £2 a week. Hardly disposable income levels Hmm

I guess if you have an income of £45k you'd think 10% was a lot, but when your household budget is under £25k it's really not going to make a huge difference.

SpringHasSprungAtLast · 18/04/2023 10:37

Harmonypus · 18/04/2023 00:55

I completely understand that employers aren't giving their staff 10%, but for those of us who are disabled, unable to work, and have to scrape by with the pittance we get in benefits, it's definitely welcomed.
The big things though, are that inflation climbed pretty much every month last year and we've had to wait until now to see this extra bit of cash, meaning we've had to cut back, and cut back more, every single month for the past year.
The government says that our food bills have grown by 16 or 17%, which, even if that were actually true, is still a bigger increase than we've received, and that's just groceries, never mind rents, mortgages, utilities, travel costs, etc, etc.
I scan my shopping receipts into an app, and recently compared receipts from two identical baskets of 25 grocery items from February 2022 and February 2023, and the cost increased in price by 53%, nowhere near the government's stated 16 or 17%.
I know everyone is feeling these massive price increases, but surely, it has to be easier to swallow them when you're on even £20k/yr than it is when you're scraping by on government benefits of (in many cases) less than half that amount, and some of us still have mortgages to pay too.

Oohh... what app is that? Think I need to try this

Hmm1234 · 18/04/2023 09:50

Yes I was so surprised and happy when the uplift in child benefit hit my bank. It meant I could afford bus travel a few days that week to do the nursery drop off and go into office with some left over for snacks

FFSFF · 18/04/2023 05:40

Oooh, an increase! This might mean that I can now eat something every day instead of every 2 or 3 days to ensure the DC have enough to eat. And we can have showers every 2 days instead of every 3 days to save on oil for heating the water. I'm so excited 😂😂😢

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 18/04/2023 05:20

JCHL · 17/04/2023 19:43

NC. For those Mumsnetters who do still care, I can confirm that this is still the case in Britain in 2023. My profoundly disabled, doubly incontinent, now young adult son is restricted to four nappies a day. When I explained that he needed more than that, usually eight in 24 hours, I was told to change him less.

He needs 24/7 care and I provide that. He is very much loved but it's hard. Even with the 10% increase, my Carers Allowance of £76.75 a week works out at about 45p per hour. Don't all rush at once.

And yet, the state is willing to pay £300,000 per person a year to private profitmaking care providers for individual residential care placements, and with so many reports of abuse taking place within them.
Assaults, neglect and a Taser revealed in ‘deeply shocking’ BBC care home investigation - BBC News

I'm bed bound and doubly incontinent, and have the same problem. And they won't supply any bed protection at all, so I either need to pay for that myself, or have sheets and mattress washed twice a day.

Despite my condition worsening, my councils payment towards my care has halved in the past 2 years, and with a carer for me now costing £20 per hour, it's just impossible.

With the benefit raises I'll get approximated £100 extra per month. The council will immediately take 50% of that towards "self funding" my care, and I still won't be able to pay the energy bills or eat properly.

Being on benefits is Nirvana, clearly.

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 18/04/2023 05:12

JustAnotherPoster00 · 17/04/2023 19:23

Same, i know people who get £246765775655 a week UC, for a blistered finger, she even has 7 blue badges 12 range rovers and holidays in dubai every 3 days for 2 weeks

😂

Harmonypus · 18/04/2023 00:55

I completely understand that employers aren't giving their staff 10%, but for those of us who are disabled, unable to work, and have to scrape by with the pittance we get in benefits, it's definitely welcomed.
The big things though, are that inflation climbed pretty much every month last year and we've had to wait until now to see this extra bit of cash, meaning we've had to cut back, and cut back more, every single month for the past year.
The government says that our food bills have grown by 16 or 17%, which, even if that were actually true, is still a bigger increase than we've received, and that's just groceries, never mind rents, mortgages, utilities, travel costs, etc, etc.
I scan my shopping receipts into an app, and recently compared receipts from two identical baskets of 25 grocery items from February 2022 and February 2023, and the cost increased in price by 53%, nowhere near the government's stated 16 or 17%.
I know everyone is feeling these massive price increases, but surely, it has to be easier to swallow them when you're on even £20k/yr than it is when you're scraping by on government benefits of (in many cases) less than half that amount, and some of us still have mortgages to pay too.

Fluff3 · 18/04/2023 00:23

I dont begrudge benefits going up by 10%, but there are a lot of people out there, who struggle to pay their bills and buy food, and who cant claim benefits because they are classed as earning to much. Its people like these that need to 10% raise. Its people like these who dont qualify for "free" school dinners, or help with the cost of school uniforms, because they are aeen as being able to afford them, when in reality they are ysimg food banks. Its them I feel sorry for.

Gingeroutofabottle · 18/04/2023 00:19

Considering inflating isn’t the 10% they keep faking but more 30-40%. 10% isn’t enough as it hasn’t gone up in line with inflation for years at this point. What I’m saying it should be more just to stay in line with actual costs incurred. It’s still a real terms decrease.

SchoolTripDrama · 17/04/2023 23:45

I'm a severely disabled widowed parent on disability and unable to work. My housing association have quickly increased my rent by EXACTLY the amount that my benefits have increased by