Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this the end for the NHS?

90 replies

Gigihadr · 16/04/2023 13:02

Looking at the news I don’t really see how this healthcare crisis is going to be resolved.

Should I try and take out private healthcare insurance now? Is it possible to get seen in an emergency privately?

It seems like there aren’t going to be good doctors/ nurses left in the NHS as they seem to be all leaving in droves for NZ/ Aus. Hoping that at least some of the better ones will go into private healthcare and thinking better to sign up sooner rather than get caught ill with nowhere to turn to.

OP posts:
fiftiesmum · 18/04/2023 07:57

We can't sit back and let them do it - the French wouldn't sit back
The same is happening with state schools - lack of funding and the staff will end up leaving - parents will send their children to private schools - who again cherry pick the most academic and hardworking.
Hopefully we only have eighteen months of this incompetent bunch who are only in it for their own interests. Unfortunately any incoming government will have so much shit to deal with before they can start making improvements.

Gigihadr · 17/04/2023 22:52

Offthexmaslist · 17/04/2023 20:58

... and this is what the fucking Tory cunts want .. it's taken a long time but they have achieved their aims.. they have made the NHS so awful that people are asking 'should we go private ' ???

I sat this as someone who lost BOTH parents in the last month through lack of care. Not care that people didn't want to give but were unable to give due to the diabolical management and funding ..

Starting with insufficient training places for doctors . Fucking with consultants pensions /earnings and stupid ducking BREXIT .. if ANYONE truly believed a Tory government would put £350 m a week into a SOCIALIST health system then you are imbeciles !!

So this is where we are at .. no money to pay people who have studied and sacrificed since the age of 7 to be doctors but can give their mates £mmm to invent ppe that was never delivered ??

Don't fall for it .. we should be protesting on the street to protect the NHS it is precious. Don't let these greedy self serving bastards destroy it .

Totally agree we should be protesting on the street about what is happening but the general public seem to be disinterested and are just sitting back and taking it

OP posts:
Offthexmaslist · 17/04/2023 20:58

... and this is what the fucking Tory cunts want .. it's taken a long time but they have achieved their aims.. they have made the NHS so awful that people are asking 'should we go private ' ???

I sat this as someone who lost BOTH parents in the last month through lack of care. Not care that people didn't want to give but were unable to give due to the diabolical management and funding ..

Starting with insufficient training places for doctors . Fucking with consultants pensions /earnings and stupid ducking BREXIT .. if ANYONE truly believed a Tory government would put £350 m a week into a SOCIALIST health system then you are imbeciles !!

So this is where we are at .. no money to pay people who have studied and sacrificed since the age of 7 to be doctors but can give their mates £mmm to invent ppe that was never delivered ??

Don't fall for it .. we should be protesting on the street to protect the NHS it is precious. Don't let these greedy self serving bastards destroy it .

Orangesandlemons77 · 17/04/2023 14:18

Benenden really helped me last year. It was 18 weeks wait for an ultrasound with the NHS but they got me one the following week.

It then said needed an MRI to clarify, this was done within 2 weeks and then saw a consultant to discuss a couple of weeks later.

Without it I would possibly have now had the ultrasound who knows. Thankfully nothing urgent was found anyway.

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 17/04/2023 07:21

It's not a problem you can buy your way out of - private healthcare in the UK is very limited and won't deal with anything you might need a and e, or even really minor injuries for. It's basically useful to jump the queue for planned operations and to get second opinions on things.

In general, once you have any kind of chronic condition, insurance companies in the UK will refuse to insure you.

This is the problem with people saying we can just reform the NHS - so much private infrastructure would need to be created, and the people to staff it just don't exist. Any sort of plan needs to be really long term and would involve a lot of investment. So we may as well invest in the NHS, as it's already there and pre covid was functioning.

Of course it doesn't help our health secretary works for an investment firm with a private healthcare branch...

fiftiesmum · 17/04/2023 07:14

I had that also during lockdown - saw surgeon on Tuesday had all the tests - surgery on Friday all went well. Local NHS hospital.
People never notice when NHS treatment goes well - but will still moan (they say food was awful but then get family to bring in McDonald's or kfc😂).

Magnoliainbloom · 16/04/2023 23:21

I highly recommend going private to cover you for new conditions and GP access. I called my insurer on a Thursday for authorisation. On the following Monday, I saw a leading consultant and had all my tests. It was amazing during lockdown when I needed surgery.

Saying that, my dad has had excellent and very fast care at Salford Royal for GI issues. I called them up to see him and they did within 3 days, CT scan done and results within a week.

LunaTheCat · 16/04/2023 22:41

The Uk really needs to invest in primary care and encourage doctors to become GP’s. The evidence is that with one doc to care for you too are healthier and less likely to die.
The speed of progress in medicine is very rapid… when I trained in medicine someone with a heart attack was put in Coronary Care, given morphine and oxygen ( we now know oxygen makes the outcome worse ) and ( only if they met very strict criteria) given a clot dissolving medicine. If you have a heart attack now you are mostly taken straight away to cardiac lab, dye injected and stents put in… you do a hell of a lot better but it’s very very expensive!
I am a GP in NZ, and although things are worsening (difficulty recruiting GP’s, decreased pay) it’s a lot better ..we are funded to give IV antibiotics, tone able to send bloods in a taxi and get results in 2 hrs, to be able to order scans/Xrays/CT same day if it helps manage people in community and keep them out hospital. It makes the job more interesting and saves money.

Swiftbushome · 16/04/2023 22:29

Well dental is pretty irrelevant since most people can't get NHS dental treatment anyway

Stopsnowing · 16/04/2023 22:18

Private health insurance very unlikely to cover pre-existing conditions, chronic conditions, preventative care, maternity, emergency, gp, dental.

dryingstuff · 16/04/2023 22:15

If everyone goes private won't there be similar issues as there isn't enough staff to deal with it all?

Ithoughtsummerwascoming · 16/04/2023 22:15

It needs culture over haul, management over haul. Everything.

It's appalling.

It needs tweaking now. We have the worst cancer survival rates. We so pay for the NHS. Do we want to die?

I can't stand it being used as political football.
It needs proper interventions now and it needs random nurses chosen by the hundreds to give anonymous honest views.
The man who ran my dad's dying ward was like a fucking gangster.

Didiplanthis · 16/04/2023 22:14

I've just left medicine. I couldn't carry on as there was no way I could deliver a service that I was happy with in the current system and it was destroying me. I was dedicated, cared too much, and very experienced.... I was good at my job and loved what it could have been. I never want to do it again. I don't owe the NHS anything, I was broken by it for 25 years. I'm not emigrating, I'm doing low skill minimum wage jobs because to be honest NO amount of pay would get me back into medicine.

wiffin · 16/04/2023 22:10

We have the second lowest Dr per head of population in Europe.

You get what you pay for. We pay peanuts per capita compared to almost every other western democracy. And complain when the service can't deliver the best.

Healthcare is expensive and health inflation massively outstrips other forms of inflation.

I don't know what the solution is. But privatisation does not benefit patients. Unless you are wealthy, low risk and easy to treat.

Superstar22 · 16/04/2023 22:10

Its the best thing that’s ever happened to this country.

Its been failed by corruption & greed.

People who think you can pay as you go with healthcare are deluded. Ask America.

Im not sure where everyone thinks the Drs and nurses will come from to treat you privately; they won’t be getting the fees you’re paying, they’ll be in a shittier system with shittier T&Cs. Hedge funds will be taking the extra money, not the Drs.

Dortmunder · 16/04/2023 22:08

Gigihadr · 16/04/2023 13:02

Looking at the news I don’t really see how this healthcare crisis is going to be resolved.

Should I try and take out private healthcare insurance now? Is it possible to get seen in an emergency privately?

It seems like there aren’t going to be good doctors/ nurses left in the NHS as they seem to be all leaving in droves for NZ/ Aus. Hoping that at least some of the better ones will go into private healthcare and thinking better to sign up sooner rather than get caught ill with nowhere to turn to.

The doctors who don't leave the UK are also good - there's just not enough of them.

As a previous poster said, it's the same practitioners doing the private and NHS work so having not enough doctors affects both sectors.

SnackSizeRaisin · 16/04/2023 22:06

MissyB1 · 16/04/2023 20:42

Well for a start the vast majority of doctors in private are NHS. If everyone goes private they will just be on “private waiting lists” it’s already beginning, most of the surgeons at our local private hospital have waiting lists of at least six weeks for the first consultation. There are a finite amount of HCPs in the UK.

Yes exactly this

SnackSizeRaisin · 16/04/2023 22:04

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 20:19

If I could afford it I would @Gigihadr. It is great for speeding up diagnostics. I was put on a 3 month waiting list by my Trust. My insurance got me the MRI the next week.

I wouldn't have been able to afford 3 months off work and then time off for the surgery.

Not saying you are wrong to do this as anyone would if they could. But all you are doing is jumping the queue and NHS patients wait a bit longer. If everyone does it we will be back to square one.

Gigihadr · 16/04/2023 22:00

GlassBunion · 16/04/2023 21:04

After spending 21 hours in hospital with my mum , I can confidently say that the NHS is broken.
No food, no water, I had to go to the hospital shop to get food and water.
And she endured, after I left to go to bed, she endure a member of staff rifle through her handbag who got angry with her because she had no money in it. I had removed her purse.

This is exactly my worry!! It’s so broken

OP posts:
GlassBunion · 16/04/2023 21:04

After spending 21 hours in hospital with my mum , I can confidently say that the NHS is broken.
No food, no water, I had to go to the hospital shop to get food and water.
And she endured, after I left to go to bed, she endure a member of staff rifle through her handbag who got angry with her because she had no money in it. I had removed her purse.

MissyB1 · 16/04/2023 20:42

Well for a start the vast majority of doctors in private are NHS. If everyone goes private they will just be on “private waiting lists” it’s already beginning, most of the surgeons at our local private hospital have waiting lists of at least six weeks for the first consultation. There are a finite amount of HCPs in the UK.

EffortlessDesmond · 16/04/2023 20:32

We have been immensely lucky with NHS health care. DH has cardiac issues, and I have had breast cancer, and it has been a concern for both of us over the last five or ten years. Apart from that, we are in good health. But our local (superb) hospital has kept tabs on us, and checked us out regularly. Even now, with the strikes, we have been seen on schedule and every test/screen has been done.

Wisheverydaywasasaturday · 16/04/2023 20:32

If you value the NHS don't vote Tory as they are slowly privatising it. People are now looking into health insurance as the NHS is so bad and that's exactly what they want.

I say this as a long time Tory voter. I can see where the NHS is going and it's heartbreaking.

fiftiesmum · 16/04/2023 20:28

If you do what the government want and get private insurance make sure you that you read the small print as to what will be covered and what hospitals you can use and what their out of hours medical cover is.
I have seen cases of patients "running out of cover" during their treatment (including cancer), times when things have gone wrong and neither hospital or doctor taking responsibility (doctors are not employed by private hospitals) but more concerned getting paramedics to transfer patient over to the local a and e.
Not every doctor or nurse will be going to Australia.
Private medicine is synonymous with cherry picking.
This government is just so incompetent and dishonest (quite happy to give money to "lady" moan for unusable PPE but not for salaries)

wheresmymojo · 16/04/2023 20:24

Does anyone know how other countries (not the US!) do healthcare?

What other models are there?

Swipe left for the next trending thread