Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go against DDs wishes with this

286 replies

BlueIndigoViolet · 16/04/2023 11:40

DD (16) had a bf for almost a year. They were all loved up as teenagers are. A month ago he cheated on her at a party and, after lots of begging on his part and tears from them both, DD ended things.

DD has worked so hard to get herself back to "normal" again but he just won't let it go. He sent her flowers the week after it happened (DD binned them). He kept turning up on the doorstep begging to see her (turned away by us at DDs request). She blocked him on all social media but he keeps making new accounts and sending her Instagram messages saying how much he misses her and tagging her in stories. He turned up here again last night and left a bagful of her favourite drink, chocs and a teddy on the doorstep when we told him she didn't want to see him.

I told DD enough is enough and said I was going to message his mum and tell her if he doesn't stop them I'll be contacting the police. However DD is adamant she doesn't want that because it will just make it embarrassing at school. They're about to do their GCSEs and she will be going to college after the summer so they won't need to see each other after June. But I really can't see him stopping any time soon. DD had a panic attack when she realised it was him at the door last night.

DH thinks I shouldn't go against what DD wants but it's starting to border on stalking and I think he needs at least a warning to stop (we have told him ourselves to stop but clearly that's not working).

So AIBU to want to text his mum and follow through with the police if he does anything else?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Invadersmustdie · 16/04/2023 15:46

@mainsfed I don't think that poster cares. They seem to have a bit of a thing for encouraging women to stay in abusive situations.

mainsfed · 16/04/2023 15:43

Viviennemary · 16/04/2023 15:23

It is annoying but doesnt sound like he has overstepped the mark. Phone his mum but don't threaten the police, just say you want it to stop.

Do yourself a favour and click on the links upthread and watch and read happened to Alice Ruggles, Claire Bernal, Molly McLaren and others.

I can only deduce that you are speaking from a place of complete ignorance or stalking and these links will educate you.

knittingaddict · 16/04/2023 15:41

My daughter had a boyfriend like this. Numerous opportunities to end it, shich she did. Turned up in our city and waited for her after work, threatened to kill himself. She took him back. A few years later they married. A few more after that and she had to leave this abusive man and go to a refuge.

5 years after that we are still having to deal with him. I look back on that opportunity to end it all those years ago and it's enough to make me weep.

My advice - do everything you can to get shot of him. Being kind, being reasonable gets you nowhere.

FrosteeFlake · 16/04/2023 15:31

Hi OP, we went through this senerio as well when DD was 16. She also did not want the police or parents contacted (though in our case his parents were furious that she had broken up with him). I finally said enough was enough when the messages bordered on threats and texted him with her permission. I was very polite but firm that he was to desist from contacting her in any way or I would be reporting his behaviour to the authorities as it was stalking and harassment.
He was shocked as I think he hadn't really thought she was telling us exactly what was going on. So the realization that her parents knew everything, and we were prepared to report him, made him finally bugger off. It's been over four years now. He has contacted her once two years ago, to say hi and I hope you're well and can forgive me, but she deleted it without opening it, and there has been nothing since thankfully.
I wish you and your DD the best and hope the situation is resolved soonFlowers

Zwicky · 16/04/2023 15:29

7 weeks is ages and given that stalking tends to escalate rather than peter out and given that your dd is likely to be home alone during exams/study leave etc then I would be involving the police and beefing up your home security.

I might give a message to the mum out of courtesy as you have a relationship with her but the priority is protecting a 16yo girl from someone who has tipped over from normal upset at a breakup to harmful, psychologically disturbed, criminal stalking. It’s not normal to harass someone who doesn’t want to see you for 7 weeks. It’s not cute. It needs to be stopped.

ProtestantsHateAbba · 16/04/2023 15:29

Viviennemary · 16/04/2023 15:23

It is annoying but doesnt sound like he has overstepped the mark. Phone his mum but don't threaten the police, just say you want it to stop.

How is he not overstepping the mark?! He’s been told to stop coming to the girl’s house and keep showing up, he’s been told no more “gifts” and hasn’t stopped, the girl has blocked him several times and he gets round this by setting up new accounts.

He’s definitely overstepping the fucking mark.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/04/2023 15:27

I have a year 10 dd. If this were happening to her, I would contact the police. Your husband has no idea as he’s never been afraid of a partner. Women and girls put their lives in their hands of men and boys, expecting them to treat us with care and decently when they have the strength to kill us. Your dd is just learning how vulnerable she is as a female. I hope she’s feeling ok after the chat.

BringtheJury · 16/04/2023 15:26

Viviennemary · 16/04/2023 15:23

It is annoying but doesnt sound like he has overstepped the mark. Phone his mum but don't threaten the police, just say you want it to stop.

Doesn't sound like he's overstepped the mark ? Wtf is overstepping the mark then ?

I despair at this sort of attitude.

Viviennemary · 16/04/2023 15:23

It is annoying but doesnt sound like he has overstepped the mark. Phone his mum but don't threaten the police, just say you want it to stop.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 16/04/2023 15:22

Z

ProtestantsHateAbba · 16/04/2023 15:19

AgrathaChristie · 16/04/2023 15:05

He calls again invite him in. Sit him down while you put the kettle on. Then reach for your phone and say while the kettle’s boiling I’ll call the police. This is harassment, I’ll insist you’re prosecuted. Hand him over to police officer.
The men who harass and stalk exes were not given this severe warning at the beginning of their stalking careers.

Dear god, don’t invite him in, why would you do that!? And then telling him you’re going to call the police right there in front of him? What’s he going to do then? Sit there meekly with his cuppa, and wait patiently for the police to arrive, possibly hours later when you hand him over to them?

FYI, you can’t “insist someone is prosecuted”. That’s not how it works. You report a crime and the police and CPS decide what happens from there. You can withdraw a statement but doesn’t mean the case goes away.

Honestly, this “advice” would be laughable if it didn’t carry a risk of being dangerous.

Maria1982 · 16/04/2023 15:17

I would also echo what others said - maybe she felt she has to be strong and deal with this herself - but the fact she has now shown you new messages she had previously not shown you, to me suggests she will be relieved if you step in to help and protect her.

Good luck with it.

Maria1982 · 16/04/2023 15:15

BlueIndigoViolet · 16/04/2023 12:12

Oh believe me I've told her all of this. But, like I said before, her dad just keeps telling her he'll soon get bored. Even after DD had a panic attack when she realised it was him in the doorstep again last night, DH still doesn't think it's that "deep"

I'm taking DD out in a while so will talk to her again without her dad around and try to get her to see how bad this actually is

Your DH is minimising this!! I would be very unimpressed. She had a panic attack and he still won’t take it seriously? Honestly, read him the riot act.

TheShellBeach · 16/04/2023 15:06

ginlovingqueen · 16/04/2023 14:35

Oh gosh! Just message her and and say you're concerned for her son as he is clearly struggling with the situation

He's struggling?
WTF have I just read?
He'll be "struggling" even more if he gets convicted of serious assault or murder!
I wish people would stop minimizing what's happening here.
The girl is in danger.

LegallyFit · 16/04/2023 15:06

AgrathaChristie · 16/04/2023 15:05

He calls again invite him in. Sit him down while you put the kettle on. Then reach for your phone and say while the kettle’s boiling I’ll call the police. This is harassment, I’ll insist you’re prosecuted. Hand him over to police officer.
The men who harass and stalk exes were not given this severe warning at the beginning of their stalking careers.

OP please do not do this. Inviting him into your home is so dangerous. These types of people are not reasonable and will resort to violence when they feel desperate enough.

AgrathaChristie · 16/04/2023 15:05

He calls again invite him in. Sit him down while you put the kettle on. Then reach for your phone and say while the kettle’s boiling I’ll call the police. This is harassment, I’ll insist you’re prosecuted. Hand him over to police officer.
The men who harass and stalk exes were not given this severe warning at the beginning of their stalking careers.

bigbabycooker · 16/04/2023 14:58

Yes, I would say police here.

They won't give him a record for this. And you can tell them this is not what you are asking for and what you want is a warning about how serious this behaviour is and how much of an impact it is having on his victim.

Then school.

If other parents contact you, to apologise or ask why police first, I would tell them that you asked the police to have a word to bring home how serious this behaviour is and the impact on your daughter, as he wasn't heeding firm warnings from you, but say that you do understand that kids make mistakes and that you hope he is getting help with his own mental health.

I'd tell your daughter that she has been brilliant up to now, but it is time for someone else to take over on her behalf, as these things can escalate and you have witnessed her having a panic attack. (She will probably feel very relieved). This is not healthy and your daughter needs to see that you will always take her safety seriously.

custardbear · 16/04/2023 14:58

Good that she's not just allowing him back after betrayal- I hope she's ok and the boy stops harassing her

WilsonMilson · 16/04/2023 14:49

Your DH is being an utter wet lettuce about this. He needs to tell the boy to gtf and stop harassing your daughter.

Don’t go to the parents as you’ll only get drama and defensiveness.

If it continues, I actually would go to the police as it’s just not bloody on.

neverbeenskiing · 16/04/2023 14:48

School Safeguarding Lead here. Taking the emotion out of it and focusing on the facts, these are the pertinent points if I've understood correctly: Your DD was in a relationship with this boy and she ended it. Over the past 7 weeks he has turned up at your house uninvited on numerous occasions. On each occasion he has been told she does not want to see or speak to him, but this has not deterred him. He has sent your DD numerous messages professing his love and asking her to take him back. She has tried to block him on social media, sending a clear message that this contact is unwanted, but he continues to message her by creating new accounts. She has tried ignoring the messages, and when this didn't work she replied asking him to stop contacting her but this has not deterred him. He continues to turn up at your home uninvited, and has left unwanted gifts for DD on the doorstep. You have warned him that further approaches could lead to police involvement, but this has not deterred him and he continues to try to contact her. The last time he turned up at your home your DD became distressed and experienced a panic attack.

If you were a parent at my school I would strongly advise you to contact the Police and report this boy for harassment. If you didn't, frankly I'd be concerned. Although at 16 she may have the capacity to make choices for herself, your DD is still a child and sometimes the adults have to step in and take charge.

I would advise you against contacting his parents directly. IME this rarely ends well. However "lovely" they are, they are incapable of being objective and at 16 they have limited influence over his choices anyway.

As DSL I would also speak to your DD myself to ensure she understood why this boys behaviour is unacceptable, and to identify a member of staff she felt comfortable talking to in school so she could report any concerns or worries. It's likely his friends will come up to her asking why she has reported him, so I would emphasise that if this happens she needs to let me or another trusted adult know immediately and they will be told to mind their own business and leave her alone. If they don't, there would be consequences.

If she has classes with the boy we would look at moving him, or if this was not possible rearranging seating plans so she doesn't have to sit anywhere near him. I would find out where both their friendship groups tend to hang out at lunch and break and ask the members of staff on duty in those areas to keep an eye out for anything untoward.

I would speak to the boys Head of Year and we would be keeping a very close eye on him and his interactions with other students. He may also need some targeted support and a keyworker to go to, depending on his individual circumstances. We would also look at some whole year group tutor time activities or assemblies around boundaries, consent and healthy relationships, but that should be happening anyway.

IME the Police will most likely not be interested in criminalising a 16 year old for this kind of thing in the first instance. But they will explain to him in no uncertain terms that his behaviour is unacceptable and needs to stop, and what will happen if it doesn't.

Deathraystare · 16/04/2023 14:44

I would say if he turns up again at your house, then you threaten him with the police and tell him what he is doing is stalking and also tell the school.

TomatoSandwiches · 16/04/2023 14:42

The OP has a responsibility to protect her DD and her DD alone.
She has no duty to help protect her ex from the consequences if his criminal and abusive behaviour.

This 16yr old has been told, repeatedly to leave her alone and has been stalking and harassing her going on 7 weeks now.

OP has no responsibility to engage with the parents of her daughters stalker just because he is 16, previously had a relationship and his mother was nice.

Just because posters as parents would want to know if their child was acting like this doesn't mean you are owed a talk or warning first before police are contacted.

RedToothBrush · 16/04/2023 14:41

McSlowburn · 16/04/2023 14:36

Yes what's he's doing is stalking. No two ways about it.

However, your poor DD is correct in that approaching his parents about it would just make it blow up at school and potentially ruin her chances of doing well in her GCSEs.

My advice would be to try to wait until after her GCSEs are over and then take action. In the meantime explain to her that what he's doing is very serious but that you are there for her in every sense.

She hopefully won't have too much more contact with him as there's only a few weeks left of actual school before it's just exams and study leave.

Current situation could blow her GCSEs too. Doing nothing isn't a neutral response.

RedToothBrush · 16/04/2023 14:40

BlueIndigoViolet · 16/04/2023 11:49

DD replied to his last Instagram message saying this. She'd been ignoring all his messages until then. And I told him last night that he needs to stay away or I'd be contacting his parents, but he then sent her another Instagram reel about being in love etc.

Has she told him in not uncertain terms to not contact her?

You have, and if she hasn't she needs to.

At that point he has clearly overstepping and isn't respecting boundaries.

You need to speak to your daughter about this and what it means.

At that point you will have the evidence to present to parents / school that this is now into harassment and any further transgressions will mean you have no other choice but to go legal.

Make it clear to your daughter that her ex is responsible and old enough to understand and make decisions. If he is disregarding women's boundaries this isn't a small matter - it becomes about power over women.

The fact she is now having panic attacks about this is a clear sign it's problematic and about control over her and this is unhealthy.

You need to spell it out to her in steps so she understands and can see how it is escalating and can't just be ignored.

saraclara · 16/04/2023 14:39

And as an aside, where the hell are both the fathers in all this?

In the case of my daughter's school mates, the boy's dad who I knew well through my daughter's hobby, was as good a person as they come. The siblings also lovely. The boy had problems that were entirely of his own, as far as I can tell.
His parents were destroyed. It really doesn't help for people to point the finger at them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread