Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

As a tall full busted woman to REALLY hate shirts?

68 replies

WeBuiltThisCity · 16/04/2023 11:29

I’m 5’11, otherwise slim but with a disproportionate chest. Being peri it’s also not a perky disproportionate chest…

I hate shirts. The bust button is always in the wrong place, far too high. If the chest fits I have a small tent on my back, to the point in bunches up when I slouch and can ride up. The only solution tends to be layers underneath in case of gaping, which is hot in summer. Or a more restrictive bra to manage the position of my boobs, or just generally looking stupid in a ill-fitting top. If I don’t get it big the buttons at the front gape as soon as I join in any movement as basic as lifting my arms.

Ive been a scout leader for some time, but I’m at the point of giving up just because of shirts. I’ve managed it by looking like a frumpy lollipop shape for ages in an over-sized shirt but it’s worn out and the new cuts are even more stupid. The womens in fairly flat chested and way to short. In my bust size I have a shark fin on my back of material, it pushes up the already too-short shirt and risks exposing my belly. The mens is long enough, but the collar is horrible and I look so stupid in it. Like a lollipop shape, I have long sticky legs. Other women are shorter and more shaper and look normal, not stunning, just normal.
I’m usually a pretty active sporty person, it’s solely button up front shirts I avoid.

I’m so fed up with layering up in warm whether, or risking exposing flesh or generally trying to take part in very active sessions in ill-fitting clothing. I’ll happily run, climb ropes etc usually but in a shirt I feel embarrassed. I also look rather stupid. It’s scouts, not a fashion show. I’m fine in joggers, and old t-shirt and no make-up… just not in comedy ill fitting clothing like a scarecrow.

I know loads of people will say ‘oh it fits me fine’, but imagine it really didn’t. You were taller than average, had the bosom of a woman twice what you’d expect for your back and it had aged too.

The gsl has dug his heels in over correct uniform, I’m tempted to leave over the new uniform cut and lack of allowance in it. He had a pretty public go about it before Easter, there’s no allowing t-shirts. I like scouts, but it’s more a giving back thing than something I enjoy. I’m not cutting off my own nose to spite my face, I have other things to do.

aibu to think many women hate shirts? I rarely see adult women wearing them through choice.

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisCity · 16/04/2023 13:58

GospelAccordingToMum · 16/04/2023 13:24

I wear pull on blouses for work. Nothing with buttons up the front. I’m tall and an E cup. Shirts just don’t work for me and make me look matronly and awkward.

Years ago for Tesco I used to sew the front of blouses and pull them on. It worked well. They were a really lightweight flexible material though, scout shirts are stiff and unforgiving

OP posts:
userxx · 16/04/2023 13:53

Bastard shirts. They are not made for a generous bust, I've not bothered with them for years.

GospelAccordingToMum · 16/04/2023 13:24

I wear pull on blouses for work. Nothing with buttons up the front. I’m tall and an E cup. Shirts just don’t work for me and make me look matronly and awkward.

DiscoDragon · 16/04/2023 13:20

I hate shirts too, I'm actually really short (5ft nothing!) but very busty. Shirts NEVER fit me, I'd have to go several sizes too big for one to fit over my bust and then the shoulders and sleeves and length of the shirt would be comically oversized.

Maple2023 · 16/04/2023 13:19

I'm with you
34K and 5ft 10
Like when people say oh a blouse. I wish Grin I don't wear anything with buttons
Not to mention anything I buy has to fit a full bra under so no strapless, halter neck, one shoulder...

FinallyHere · 16/04/2023 13:15

Get a great bra then take the oversized shirt to an alterations service. Get them to sew darts into the first, two front and back the adjust the shape. Maybe adjust shoulders too

Totally worth it.

twilightcafe · 16/04/2023 13:15

Thank you!

Socialdistancechampion · 16/04/2023 13:14

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Probably The one I described. I learned it off tiktok too and it's brilliant

twilightcafe · 16/04/2023 13:13

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Rafferty10 · 16/04/2023 13:09

I am so with you../. at 5ft 4 and a DD l can never find shirts or jackets to fit, just wish clothing manufacturers would at least put strong invisible poppers down the front.
I have had some embarrassing moments when buttons have popped open so now have to sew poppers in all new shirts.

Socialdistancechampion · 16/04/2023 13:09

Sorry, I should explain it! As a fellow busty one it's saved me so many embarrassing situations!

The two buttons that sit over the fullest part of the bust - use the lower button in the upper hole and the upper button in the lower hole. It only works if the clothing fits well otherwise but you just have a gape. If the clothing is tight size up and then try it.

I sympathise as a HHer myself! But this has saved my skin a few times

Socialdistancechampion · 16/04/2023 13:07

Do the cross over button cheat

CoffeeCantata · 16/04/2023 13:05

I also hate shirts! They make me look busty and matronly. They look great on petite-chested women but are so frumpy on me. I'm not huge - a 12-14 - but have wide shoulders and a bust. In the old days of 'blouses', I think they were cut more flatteringly for women but now it's fashionable to wear shirt styles, not so much.

I've actually left one hobby (choir) due to the requirement to wear the same awful cheap shirt (no flexibility - brand was specified) which somehow managed to make everyone look terrible.

Hope springs eternal though, and when I see a fashion article with tall, slender models in crisp white shirts I'm always tempted to give them one more go, but it never ends well!

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 16/04/2023 12:59

I am right there with you! Similar shape, slightly shorter but with a really long. Also a scout leader!

I stood my ground on trousers, and found that Craghoppers walking trousers fit nicely, whereas SA official ones don't fit at all. My shirt is getting very tired, and is huge to get my boobs in- and still too short. I am on the look out for a beige blouse that's not polyester!

LlynTegid · 16/04/2023 12:40

Agree with you and hope you can find a way to continue volunteering with the Scouts.

crosstalk · 16/04/2023 12:38

Another big busted woman here. The only shirt that ever suited me was a dark blue denim from M&S in a soft jersey which didn't gape as tailored cotton/white shirts do. 25 years on I still have it.

The only thing I can suggest is a white sports bra if the powers that be can't listen.

WeBuiltThisCity · 16/04/2023 12:21

JudgeRudy · 16/04/2023 12:15

I worked for MFI years ago and I was issued with a new uniform that I loathed. My figure isn't as 'extreme' as yours but it didn't fit, as in too tight and too big! The armholes were tight and it was too short to stay tucked in, yet it billowed from my shoulders down. The biggest issue for me though was the fabric, a sort of hideous 'boil in the bag' nylon. I tried to negotiate an alternative to no avail so ploughed on misserably for a month. By week 4 I couldn't bear it anymore so resigned causing me some financial hardship.
I don't think my friends and family could understand how i could make such big decisions around something so 'minor' - but it wasn't minor. Every moment I had that blouse on I was miserable. I was physically uncomfortable and psychologically felt a bag of shite. As a sales person my personality was important but as soon as that blouse when on it changed. I was no longer a happy confident vibrant person but an awkward, scruffy shadow of myself.
I get it OP. Resign. I think when you do, you'll find in time that you were probably ready to move on to something new and it's 'run it's course'.
Of course, it's worth one last shot I guess. If you really enjoy it and presuming the uniform is yours you could try try sone darts...put your shirt on inside out and tack 2 darts approx mid back from bra band to just beyond waist. Even on a large bust you would likely get away with nothing at the front. Try it on the right way and once happy machine it. I did this on a shirt using my granddaughters 'hobby' sewing machine and it was fine on a bit of poly cotton. If you've got a bit more money you could get it done professionally.

But yes...I feel your pain

Yes! Sorry you went through that… but such a good description of the feeling.

Yes to armpits too. Good forbid but I am also a female with biceps. Also not allowed.

OP posts:
JudgeRudy · 16/04/2023 12:15

WeBuiltThisCity · 16/04/2023 11:29

I’m 5’11, otherwise slim but with a disproportionate chest. Being peri it’s also not a perky disproportionate chest…

I hate shirts. The bust button is always in the wrong place, far too high. If the chest fits I have a small tent on my back, to the point in bunches up when I slouch and can ride up. The only solution tends to be layers underneath in case of gaping, which is hot in summer. Or a more restrictive bra to manage the position of my boobs, or just generally looking stupid in a ill-fitting top. If I don’t get it big the buttons at the front gape as soon as I join in any movement as basic as lifting my arms.

Ive been a scout leader for some time, but I’m at the point of giving up just because of shirts. I’ve managed it by looking like a frumpy lollipop shape for ages in an over-sized shirt but it’s worn out and the new cuts are even more stupid. The womens in fairly flat chested and way to short. In my bust size I have a shark fin on my back of material, it pushes up the already too-short shirt and risks exposing my belly. The mens is long enough, but the collar is horrible and I look so stupid in it. Like a lollipop shape, I have long sticky legs. Other women are shorter and more shaper and look normal, not stunning, just normal.
I’m usually a pretty active sporty person, it’s solely button up front shirts I avoid.

I’m so fed up with layering up in warm whether, or risking exposing flesh or generally trying to take part in very active sessions in ill-fitting clothing. I’ll happily run, climb ropes etc usually but in a shirt I feel embarrassed. I also look rather stupid. It’s scouts, not a fashion show. I’m fine in joggers, and old t-shirt and no make-up… just not in comedy ill fitting clothing like a scarecrow.

I know loads of people will say ‘oh it fits me fine’, but imagine it really didn’t. You were taller than average, had the bosom of a woman twice what you’d expect for your back and it had aged too.

The gsl has dug his heels in over correct uniform, I’m tempted to leave over the new uniform cut and lack of allowance in it. He had a pretty public go about it before Easter, there’s no allowing t-shirts. I like scouts, but it’s more a giving back thing than something I enjoy. I’m not cutting off my own nose to spite my face, I have other things to do.

aibu to think many women hate shirts? I rarely see adult women wearing them through choice.

I worked for MFI years ago and I was issued with a new uniform that I loathed. My figure isn't as 'extreme' as yours but it didn't fit, as in too tight and too big! The armholes were tight and it was too short to stay tucked in, yet it billowed from my shoulders down. The biggest issue for me though was the fabric, a sort of hideous 'boil in the bag' nylon. I tried to negotiate an alternative to no avail so ploughed on misserably for a month. By week 4 I couldn't bear it anymore so resigned causing me some financial hardship.
I don't think my friends and family could understand how i could make such big decisions around something so 'minor' - but it wasn't minor. Every moment I had that blouse on I was miserable. I was physically uncomfortable and psychologically felt a bag of shite. As a sales person my personality was important but as soon as that blouse when on it changed. I was no longer a happy confident vibrant person but an awkward, scruffy shadow of myself.
I get it OP. Resign. I think when you do, you'll find in time that you were probably ready to move on to something new and it's 'run it's course'.
Of course, it's worth one last shot I guess. If you really enjoy it and presuming the uniform is yours you could try try sone darts...put your shirt on inside out and tack 2 darts approx mid back from bra band to just beyond waist. Even on a large bust you would likely get away with nothing at the front. Try it on the right way and once happy machine it. I did this on a shirt using my granddaughters 'hobby' sewing machine and it was fine on a bit of poly cotton. If you've got a bit more money you could get it done professionally.

But yes...I feel your pain

BatshitCrazyWoman · 16/04/2023 12:10

I'm not a fan of shirts in general (can never get why they are so lauded as classic must-haves in women's wardrobes), I hate collars!! But I also have a similar issue with gaping/not fitting/riding up over boobs and needing to be pulled down. I'm a 32E.

So I feel your pain, but I just don't wear anything that buttons down the front.

Phoebo · 16/04/2023 12:03

Yep I'm with you. I'm a shirt big busted women and I hate them too. I've only found one that was good with had "hooks and eyes" instead of buttons. For it to fit, it needs to have a very specific tailored shape

Baldieheid · 16/04/2023 12:02

If the mens shirt is long enough, it might be possible to alter it by adding darts etc, and redoing the collar but it's a heck of a lot of work and therefore cost.
You could argue that they're discriminating against you as a female by refusing to provide a uniform that's fit for purpose, or allow you to wear something else in the same colour. It's a total lack of thought - is that indirect discrimination? Newsflash - women have breasts. If they won't supply you a garment that fits, you should at the very least be allowed to wear something else. You can't risk flashing the kids you're volunteering with.

jay55 · 16/04/2023 11:58

You would not be unreasonable to quit.
I was a guide when the uniform changed from shirts to T-shirts and polos and it was such a relief.
Left venture scouts over the unforgiving uniform and that was over 25 years ago, can't believe they're still trying to make women fit into men's army style from ww2.

ThinWomansBrain · 16/04/2023 11:58

They make polo shirts and t-shirts, I’d have no issue with them. It’s just shorts. But the gsl wont back down on shirts

So uniform polo shirts are available, but some jumped up little Hitler decides to insist on something that makes volunteers feel uncomfortable? Twat.
I'd be resigning, and letting the central organisation know exactly why.

Luredbyapomegranate · 16/04/2023 11:53

Sounds absolutely infuriating and really unfair.

Please don’t quit. I would try and find a local dressmaker who can advise you on what shirts to buy so she can alter. Failing that, I’d find a tailor who can make you a shirt.

Also I would start a formal and loud process with the scouts because it is sexist and sizest (it impacts on women with bigger breasts) - and is discouraging women and girls from being active.

I love a fitted shirt, because I am a c cup, but I am also plus size with swimmers shoulders so I am infuriated at the outsized and puff sleeved bonanza that is currently all you can get.

StraightHairDonCare · 16/04/2023 11:53

I see. What an idiotic rule that doesn't make allowance for anatomical variations.

Swipe left for the next trending thread