Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

As a tall full busted woman to REALLY hate shirts?

68 replies

WeBuiltThisCity · 16/04/2023 11:29

I’m 5’11, otherwise slim but with a disproportionate chest. Being peri it’s also not a perky disproportionate chest…

I hate shirts. The bust button is always in the wrong place, far too high. If the chest fits I have a small tent on my back, to the point in bunches up when I slouch and can ride up. The only solution tends to be layers underneath in case of gaping, which is hot in summer. Or a more restrictive bra to manage the position of my boobs, or just generally looking stupid in a ill-fitting top. If I don’t get it big the buttons at the front gape as soon as I join in any movement as basic as lifting my arms.

Ive been a scout leader for some time, but I’m at the point of giving up just because of shirts. I’ve managed it by looking like a frumpy lollipop shape for ages in an over-sized shirt but it’s worn out and the new cuts are even more stupid. The womens in fairly flat chested and way to short. In my bust size I have a shark fin on my back of material, it pushes up the already too-short shirt and risks exposing my belly. The mens is long enough, but the collar is horrible and I look so stupid in it. Like a lollipop shape, I have long sticky legs. Other women are shorter and more shaper and look normal, not stunning, just normal.
I’m usually a pretty active sporty person, it’s solely button up front shirts I avoid.

I’m so fed up with layering up in warm whether, or risking exposing flesh or generally trying to take part in very active sessions in ill-fitting clothing. I’ll happily run, climb ropes etc usually but in a shirt I feel embarrassed. I also look rather stupid. It’s scouts, not a fashion show. I’m fine in joggers, and old t-shirt and no make-up… just not in comedy ill fitting clothing like a scarecrow.

I know loads of people will say ‘oh it fits me fine’, but imagine it really didn’t. You were taller than average, had the bosom of a woman twice what you’d expect for your back and it had aged too.

The gsl has dug his heels in over correct uniform, I’m tempted to leave over the new uniform cut and lack of allowance in it. He had a pretty public go about it before Easter, there’s no allowing t-shirts. I like scouts, but it’s more a giving back thing than something I enjoy. I’m not cutting off my own nose to spite my face, I have other things to do.

aibu to think many women hate shirts? I rarely see adult women wearing them through choice.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WeBuiltThisCity · 17/04/2023 21:55

StaySpicy · 17/04/2023 14:32

I'm 5'1 and an E-cup. I haven't worn a shirt since about 2003. They never fit over my bust and they make me sweat.

I was considering volunteering with my local Scout group but will probably steer clear if the only available uniform is a shirt. I'll wait until they've brought in adult polo shirts!

To reassure you I think our group just has a belligerent guy who’s been there too long. Go find a normal lot 😆

OP posts:
budgiegirl · 17/04/2023 21:41

StaySpicy · 17/04/2023 14:32

I'm 5'1 and an E-cup. I haven't worn a shirt since about 2003. They never fit over my bust and they make me sweat.

I was considering volunteering with my local Scout group but will probably steer clear if the only available uniform is a shirt. I'll wait until they've brought in adult polo shirts!

Please don't let the uniform put you off. Most groups that I know only wear the shirts for formal activities - St Georges Day and Remembrance Sunday. And then wear polos/t-shirts the rest of the time. Adult uniform polos are very definitely available!

There are also non-uniformed roles - for section assistants, uniform is optional - or at least it is in our group.

RenegadeMrs · 17/04/2023 15:23

Yes yes yes. 6ft, 36H. I wear a fair amount of shirts but they are ususally soft jersey fabric, left open or unbuttoned fairly low with a t-shirt or cami underneath. Just wearing a shirt formally is a big 'nope' in my book. I used to have small saftey pins I'd use to close the gape on any shirts or button up dresses.

If you are uncomfortable and your gsl is being an uncompromising twat (is he drowing in volunteers? I would be surprised if he is) I would quit. I would also write to the higher ups and let them know exactly why.

Bluegingerbread · 17/04/2023 15:13

StaySpicy · 17/04/2023 14:32

I'm 5'1 and an E-cup. I haven't worn a shirt since about 2003. They never fit over my bust and they make me sweat.

I was considering volunteering with my local Scout group but will probably steer clear if the only available uniform is a shirt. I'll wait until they've brought in adult polo shirts!

StaySpicy - don't let the shirts put you off, ask your local group, many of them don't use the shirt except on parade for Remembrance Sunday and St George's Day. Our leaders live in t-shirts/polos/hoodies.

bumpytrumpy · 17/04/2023 15:08

ThinWomansBrain · 16/04/2023 11:58

They make polo shirts and t-shirts, I’d have no issue with them. It’s just shorts. But the gsl wont back down on shirts

So uniform polo shirts are available, but some jumped up little Hitler decides to insist on something that makes volunteers feel uncomfortable? Twat.
I'd be resigning, and letting the central organisation know exactly why.

Your GSL is a misogynistic twat. I also have the shirt and it's badly fitting and too short. I wear on rememberance Sunday and no other times.

Can you escalate to district?

Sugarandspicee · 17/04/2023 14:33

I have the same issue also 5,11 with bigger boobs and constantly having to wear something underneath

Ichosetheredpill · 17/04/2023 14:32

If it’s any consolation, I’m 5’4” and size 10 with an F cup bust. I’d love to be able to wear tailored shirts for work but they never sit right. I like loose fit shirts but anything else just pulls at the bust or bags out over my tummy.

StaySpicy · 17/04/2023 14:32

I'm 5'1 and an E-cup. I haven't worn a shirt since about 2003. They never fit over my bust and they make me sweat.

I was considering volunteering with my local Scout group but will probably steer clear if the only available uniform is a shirt. I'll wait until they've brought in adult polo shirts!

Bluegingerbread · 17/04/2023 14:23

Do any other countries have better uniforms for Scout leaders? I like the Australian ones for the kids but not sure what they have for adults. Our leaders often join in with activities or demonstrate them, the shirt just isn't suitable for that, even if it actually fitted them, which it doesn't.

And I agree with the PP that it's not a good choice for the Scouts and Explorers either. Beaver and Cub uniform was great. My Scout hates the shirt and my Explorer really hates the shirt. Fortunately they don't usually have to wear them.

OP, I really hope your GSL sees sense.

piratypotato · 17/04/2023 14:01

I'd just go to whoever is in charge and say lookit, I can wear a tshirt or polo or I can quit. If their obsession with uniform is more important than the people who volunteer their time, then you don't want to be there anyway.

mackthepony · 17/04/2023 13:59

I get my shirts sewn shut at the front to avoid gapage. I absolutely love shirts but hate the gape. It's only cheap to have done with a seamstress

Anyotherdude · 17/04/2023 13:56

The trick is to buy the shirt with a bust that fits, with about an inch more for ease, (measure the actual shirt’s bust line to ascertain this, as some cuts are smaller/bigger than others) then have it altered by the dry cleaners.
Once you’ve had one done professionally, you could try future alterations yourself. There’s good advice on hourglass.com
Good Luck!

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 17/04/2023 13:36

I hate shirts too. I'm 12 stone with FF breasts

twilightcafe · 17/04/2023 13:20

You'd think Scout leaders would be falling over themselves to be more accommodating to volunteers - not the other way round.
What is wrong with you wearing a bottle green sweatshirt and necker?
Bet there would be no objections if you were a man who couldn't find a shirt to fit.

nimski · 17/04/2023 13:13

I would absolutely be complaining and taking this further, it's not fair that you should have to give up something when there are other options available. I'd just wear one of the other t shorts available- what can they do?!
This is one of the rare times it would actually help if a journalist took your story to the DM!

budgiegirl · 17/04/2023 12:44

It is time HQ gave better options for leader kit

This. There was a survey a while ago, sent out by HQ, to ask what leaders and young people thought about the uniform, with a view to possibly changing it. I haven't heard anything since though, so I don't know if anything came of it.

It seems daft in this day and age to have such an uncomfortable uniform. The Squirrels, Beavers and Cubs have t-shirts and sweatshirts to wear, but scouts and leaders are stuck with stiff, uncomfortable, impractical shirts. It's about time this changed, in my opinion.

BarbaraofSeville · 17/04/2023 10:44

I think this is one of those issues that, unless it affects you directly, you go through life in blissful ignorance.

I'm known as a trouble causer at work because every time we are issued with new workwear, I complain if it's 'unisex' when we all know that means 'designed for men with no effort whatsoever to fit women'.

I don't know the answer as all the options are a bit shit. I never wear shirts/blouses but it seems that you have 'uniform' days where you have no choice. Can you get a similarly coloured shirt from elsewhere, where you have more control over the size/shape/material?

DelurkingAJ · 17/04/2023 10:43

Scout shirts are even awful for the boys…let alone the women’s. I agree, you need to back the GSL into a corner. Ours would never dream of behaving like this!

Bluegingerbread · 17/04/2023 10:31

Is the GSL supportive of women scout leaders in general? Just wondering as it seems an odd thing to be so dogmatic about for normal meetings. Our leadership has more women than men and the shirts are definitely worse on women. They only suit slim men. Ours will all wear them for St George's on Sunday, mutter darkly about the fit and then go back to the group tops and hoodies for day to day stuff as usual. It is time HQ gave better options for leader kit. I was going to buy my daughter the trousers recently and didn't because I ended up totally outraged that the official trousers have way more pockets in the male version than the female. I really didn't expect that from scouts.

FurAndFeathers · 17/04/2023 05:39

I understand the suggestions of seamstress alterations and meetings with the district commissioner are helpful but honestly the OP is a volunteer donating her time and energy to an organisation who doesn’t care about her comfort and dignity.

why should she make extra work or spend extra money simply because her misogynistic gsl would rather lose her that be flexible. This is a hobby for her, it’s supposed to be fun.

she’s clearly been told how much she’s valued in the organisation by that behaviour.

I’d be withdrawing and telling all the parents and the GSL exactly why they’d lost a valuable volunteer.

ElTingo · 16/04/2023 23:12

I have to agree and Tbh I might have considered being a leader at beavers but the uniform really does put me off!

I think most uniforms for women are unflattering. There is such variance in body size with height/ bust. I'm tallish (5"9) but with a long torso and big bust (H) and every top feels cropped. I hate it! Men's sizes are longer, but cut for men and highly unflattering too as it gives no shape.

Bluegingerbread · 16/04/2023 22:30

Scouts shirts are sized really badly, even for the kids. And they're no longer a practical garment for activities. Our GSL is female and all our leaders wear group t-shirts and hoodies. Shirts only for Remembrance Sunday and St George's. I've been told you can send measurements to the supplier and supposedly get one made to your size but no idea if they're any good either as shirts are just rubbish for big boobs. Is there a different local scout group you could move to? It's a shame to give up something you enjoy and that is such a good thing.

budgiegirl · 16/04/2023 22:16

Parisj · 16/04/2023 14:52

I know this is easy to say in the virtual world and hard to do in the real world. But I would keep it factual, reasonable and open and very very direct. I would request a meeting or write a letter and patiently describe the reasons the shirt is not comfortable or practical for your female body in minute detail. I would state 'I enjoy contributing as a volunteer but I am unwilling to do so in uncomfortable impractical clothing choice when there is a simple solution available (T shirt or polo shirt). If he refuses to back down I would say 'can I be clear that you are refusing to accommodate my reasonable need for comfort and dignity?' Then I would take it to the top of the organisation. Ideally I would speak to him face to face with a witness and as a prearranged meeting to show you are serious. I would be completely warm and polite and friendly, I would not apologise for being me or having needs. I would make it his problem to solve.

This sounds like a good way to approach it. It's crazy that your GSL won't allow an alternative to the shirts, when polo shirts etc are available.

I agree that the womens shirts are horrendous, so badly cut, horrible thick material, and way too short.

I'm a cub leader, and we are pretty relaxed about uniform, leaders can wear the shirt if they want, but almost all wear scout t-shirts or polos and jeans for meetings, along with the necker.

We do ask for shirts/smart trousers to be worn twice a year for Remembrance and St Georges Day parades, but if a leader was very unhappy about this, they wouldn't have to. We have one leader who is a very large gentleman, who can't get a shirt to fit, so he just wears a smart suit for parades instead.

If your GSL won't listen to reason, take it higher - to your District Commissioner, or higher than that if you need to.

Parisj · 16/04/2023 14:52

I know this is easy to say in the virtual world and hard to do in the real world. But I would keep it factual, reasonable and open and very very direct. I would request a meeting or write a letter and patiently describe the reasons the shirt is not comfortable or practical for your female body in minute detail. I would state 'I enjoy contributing as a volunteer but I am unwilling to do so in uncomfortable impractical clothing choice when there is a simple solution available (T shirt or polo shirt). If he refuses to back down I would say 'can I be clear that you are refusing to accommodate my reasonable need for comfort and dignity?' Then I would take it to the top of the organisation. Ideally I would speak to him face to face with a witness and as a prearranged meeting to show you are serious. I would be completely warm and polite and friendly, I would not apologise for being me or having needs. I would make it his problem to solve.

Maray1967 · 16/04/2023 14:16

JaceLancs · 16/04/2023 11:42

I’m not as big as some of you but I sew invisible press studs between the buttons in the bust area and size up if needed

I do this.
And I remember my seamstress gran saying that when she trained (1930s) the cleavage button was positioned first in the right place and then the other buttons spaced up and down from it. She was always annoyed that readymade clothes just spaced them down from the neck.