Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think smart motorways were never a good idea?

107 replies

bluebottle23 · 16/04/2023 09:42

I've just been watching a news segment about smart motorways and can't fathom how they ever got approved. Literally an accident waiting to happen and sadly many did. I hate driving on a smart motorway, especially with my daughter and just seeing aerial footage of one there is literally nowhere safe for you to get out stand and wait. I'd rather be stuck in slow moving traffic than risk my family's life on one of these motorways.

OP posts:
FatOaf · 16/04/2023 14:06

I don't feel that the design is the problem, more the way people drive and it sounds as though the tech wasn't up to it

The vast majority of people are stupid. Nothing is ever going to change that: not technology, not "education", not anything. Designing a system that requires people to behave intelligently it is 100% guaranteed to fail.

user1471434829 · 16/04/2023 13:41

My dad worked on motorway systems when they were being installed. Basically the original designs had laybys very regularly, I can't remember the distance but something like every 100m and some other features which would have made them safer. To save money they didn't install all the laybys etc and we ended up with hugely dangerous smart motorways.

Bunnichick · 16/04/2023 13:39

I agree OP!

ILikePizzas · 16/04/2023 13:25

Always obvious to everyone. But no doubt "experts" from the University of East Anglia (or god knows where) did a "study" and "the data said" etc etc blah de blah. That's how so many things feel these days.

rattymol · 16/04/2023 13:20

My only dislike for electric cars is the cost. If they be the same price as petrol cars I will buy one.

pickledandpuzzled · 16/04/2023 13:16

Cars, yes Ckelp. Electric scooters not so much, and more manoeuvrable.

The dislike for electric cars, which will undoubtedly save more lives than their quiet running takes, is mad.

And the scooter operating in the same place as a bike is more manoeuvrable and no faster.

If we got people out of cars and onto bikes and scooters we'd all be better off, but we do need to be more aware of safety, as drivers and pedestrians, when crossing and in car parks.

rattymol · 16/04/2023 13:14

Forever I notice that as well. I think it is because they are so often inaccurate

Forever42 · 16/04/2023 13:13

Also I notice many drivers pay no attention to the signs and carry on in the 'x' marked lane for as long as they can to overtake traffic,despite the fact that they don't know where the obstruction is going to be.

WitcheryDivine · 16/04/2023 13:12

It doesn't have to be things like your engine going bang either, more simple things like a broken petrol gauge meaning people run out of petrol unexpectedly, overheating gear box, brakes suddenly starting to fail.

Honestly I think the only real problem people have with smart motorways is the hard shoulder thing so they might as well rebrand the other kinds (with variable speed limits but retaining a HS) as something else and keep on doing those.

Forever42 · 16/04/2023 13:12

I regularly have to drive on a smart motorway and I dread it. Particularly worrying is the awful driving of many lorries - they come right up close behind you and leave no stopping distance.

FrostyFifi · 16/04/2023 13:10

Drpet most crashes are driver error. No system should be designed assuming drivers do not make errors

Exactly this. For instance look at the constantly developing road network in Doha. Literally designed to mitigate a truly abysmal standard of driving as far as possible.

WitcheryDivine · 16/04/2023 13:09

"I don't feel that the design is the problem, more the way people drive and it sounds as though the tech wasn't up to it."

The way people drive is in cars, and even the best drivers can't prevent machines sometimes going wrong unexpectedly. I know exactly no people who drive who haven't had to deal with a sudden breakdown at least once. No one seems to be questioning whether our cars should be better or more reliable but lots of people seem keen to blame the drivers.

rattymol · 16/04/2023 13:00

Drpet most crashes are driver error. No system should be designed assuming drivers do not make errors.

rattymol · 16/04/2023 12:59

Bikes should not be on pavements either.
Disabiled people pointing out something is dangerous for them is them being resistant to change?

breakingintopieces · 16/04/2023 12:59

I'm not a driver and had never heard of them. Just looked them up.

The thought of no hard shoulder and a constantly changing speed limit on such a long stretch of road gives me the chills. Honestly, the concept sounds terrible.

CKelp · 16/04/2023 12:55

pickledandpuzzled · 16/04/2023 11:47

I thought they were a good, efficient use of space assuming they were used correctly.

I don't feel that the design is the problem, more the way people drive and it sounds as though the tech wasn't up to it.

I see people really resistant to change because they won't change their behaviour- things like how dangerous electric cars and scooters are for people with visual impairments because they are quiet, despite them being louder than bikes which are also dangerous to pedestrians.
If we want to progress, we need to accommodate change.

Electric cars and scooters are much faster & heavier than bikes and you know, can actually kill people? No where near the same risk as a bike. Sometimes common sense had to be used when considering new tech, not solely for the sake of 'progress'.

drpet49 · 16/04/2023 12:52

A34 · 16/04/2023 09:50

IF the technology was completely foolproof (it isn't, by a long way) and IF lots of people weren't stupid (lots of people are) then they could have worked. But it isn't and lots are so there we are. I had a jolly few minutes on the M4 a few weeks ago where I happened upon a car broken down in the left hand lane of a smart motorway. No warning, nothing. Very luckily the visibility was good and the motorway not busy.

But in the majority of cases it was driver error that caused the crashes- drivers not paying attention to the warnings.

sleepyscientist · 16/04/2023 12:50

They were designed by people with new cars that don't have to really consider breakdowns. Our family car is just coming up to a year old and has run flats if we had an issue we would keep going to the next exit vs stopping.

rattymol · 16/04/2023 12:50

I like the overhead warnings. The variable speed limits are rarely up to date. About half the time it is about a breakdown that has already been removed. The lack of accuracy means less people pay attention to them.

rattymol · 16/04/2023 12:48

Yes you are supposed to get out of your car. On some smart motorways there is very little space to stand on the other side of the barrier. And the breakdown people still have to work on the inside lane. They are at more risk.

RudsyFarmer · 16/04/2023 12:46

What the hell happens when it’s dark? Sounds terrifying.

Hawkins003 · 16/04/2023 12:45

The majority of the time, it seems that due to driver inattention, ect that most accidents happen.

Aguinnessplease · 16/04/2023 12:44

They were a good idea in my opinion - much more comfortable to drive on compared to congested motorways where the middle lane is often full of overtaking lorries. Also variable speed limits are a good thing. But - they are let down by poor traffic management and cameras not switched on to catch excessively speeding drivers.

rattymol · 16/04/2023 12:44

People saying isn't it just the same as duel carriage ways. The breakdowns I have seen on duel carriage ways, the driver has always taken the car onto the grass verge. That is not possible on motorways.

LlynTegid · 16/04/2023 12:39

I agree with the OP 100%. Just a cheap way of trying to build wider roads instead of dealing with the fundamental of reducing car use. Such as better rail services and actually banning drivers who commit road crimes or have health issues.