Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Well fuck me pink and call me Rosie. AIBU?

454 replies

TooBigForMyBoots · 15/04/2023 22:44

Do you know that Belfast and NI are in the British Isles? Are you aware that some British people claim they do not know that NI is in the same timezone as the rest of the UK?

YABU = You can't expect British people to know the history and geography of their country.
YANBU = Of course British people know this stuff. Anyone who says otherwise is having you on.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Jourdain11 · 16/04/2023 15:25

DownNative · 16/04/2023 15:09

It's a point of language here. In English, the word "and" does not axiomatically mean something is separate from another and vice versa.

It depends on context.

So, in United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland the keyword is "United" which informs the context from which "and" derives its meaning. That's this - "used to connect words of the same part of speech, clauses, or sentences, that are to be taken jointly."

In simple terms, the full name of the UK means "Great Britain and Northern Ireland have been joined together to form ONE, territory and ONE people with ONE sovereign Government within ONE sovereign Parliament known as the United Kingdom".

This is the geopolitical meaning and, therefore, the two are NOT separate. Additionally, Great Britain is NOT a country so they cannot be described as "two separate countries" either as has been done in this thread.....

I never said that Great Britain and NI are separate countries. I said that NI is not part of Great Britain, which it isn't.

It's part of the UK, yes, but not part of Great Britain. I do understand the meaning of the word "and", but in order to be joined together into a union, they did originally (all of the nation states) have to be discrete entities. Otherwise there'd have been no joining to be done.

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 15:15

It wasn't started to be goady. And it certainly isn't a TAAT, or it would have been removed. I was 🤯 that any UK citizens didn't know the UK had a single time zone.

Now, at least the Mnetters on this thread know that Belfast is in the same time zone as the rest of the country.😊

OP posts:
DownNative · 16/04/2023 15:11

JaneJeffer · 16/04/2023 14:51

But it cannot be said that ALL of the Republic of Ireland is more northerly than all of Northern Ireland. Fact is, twenty-five counties of the Republic of Ireland is further south than Northern Ireland.
Well duh!

Precisely my point which shows the PP did not and cannot show my statement to be incorrect as they erroneously stated....🤷‍♂️

DownNative · 16/04/2023 15:09

Jourdain11 · 16/04/2023 13:07

Yes, exactly! Because Great Britain is an island, which comprises England, Scotland and Wales.

Northern Ireland isn't on the island, so it's not part of Great Britain, just the same as it's not part of mainland Europe or Greenland.

It's a point of language here. In English, the word "and" does not axiomatically mean something is separate from another and vice versa.

It depends on context.

So, in United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland the keyword is "United" which informs the context from which "and" derives its meaning. That's this - "used to connect words of the same part of speech, clauses, or sentences, that are to be taken jointly."

In simple terms, the full name of the UK means "Great Britain and Northern Ireland have been joined together to form ONE, territory and ONE people with ONE sovereign Government within ONE sovereign Parliament known as the United Kingdom".

This is the geopolitical meaning and, therefore, the two are NOT separate. Additionally, Great Britain is NOT a country so they cannot be described as "two separate countries" either as has been done in this thread.....

Mercurial123 · 16/04/2023 15:06

PuffinsRocks · 15/04/2023 22:58

Sadly since living in Ireland I have been stunned by the number of patent idiots people in England particularly who don't know that a) Ireland is not in the UK and doesn't have an NHS and b) that Ireland and Northern Ireland are not two names for some distant part of the UK.
Don't tell them Ireland has it's own language or that it's a republic, it might hurt their little brains.

I've yet to meet anyone who thinks this.

Abra1t · 16/04/2023 15:05

I’ve been rolling my eyes all week at people asserting that Biden didn’t visit the UK.

isitshe · 16/04/2023 15:02

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 12:39

Glad you enjoyed it @isitshe. Good manners cost nothing and I am glad that most people think IANBU.

That was directed AT you OP, it seemed like you started the thread solely for your own amusement

JenniferBarkley · 16/04/2023 14:56

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 14:15

Why @JenniferBarkley?Confused

Because it's a goady TAAT that's getting at one particular poster.

JaneJeffer · 16/04/2023 14:51

But it cannot be said that ALL of the Republic of Ireland is more northerly than all of Northern Ireland. Fact is, twenty-five counties of the Republic of Ireland is further south than Northern Ireland.
Well duh!

EveryWitchWaybutLoose · 16/04/2023 14:50

Jourdain11 · 16/04/2023 14:21

I know I'm not the one who you've directed the question to, but some wouldn't consider implicitly shaming people for a lack of knowledge to be particularly "good manners".

Well, quite.

11inch · 16/04/2023 14:43

Wow, what a circular argument! Bottom line GMT +1 applies in the whole island of Ireland but isn't called BST in part.
If NI didn't have same time zone would you not expect BBC news (yeah there is licence fee in NI) to be called News at 6 in GB, 5 in NI?
Spanish national broadcaster gives both the time on the mainland/baleraics and Canary Islands separately.

So many people know very little about NI and it's history and I have long since ceased being surprised at the batshit comments.

DownNative · 16/04/2023 14:40

Daftasabroom · 16/04/2023 13:39

Hoisted by my own petard (and dyslexia)! And I will return the favour: all of Northern Ireland is more northerly than all of the Republic of Ireland is incorrect.

Actually it's quite a serious point that so few people in the UK know much about our own history. I was really fortunate to take schools council history, which I think only ran for a few years during the transition from o levels to GCSEs.

And yet you've failed to demonstrate that my statement that "all of Northern Ireland is more northerly than all of the Republic of Ireland" is incorrect.

I've put the keywords in bold.

The reality is that a small bit of County Donegal is slightly more northerly than all of Northern Ireland.

But it cannot be said that ALL of the Republic of Ireland is more northerly than all of Northern Ireland. Fact is, twenty-five counties of the Republic of Ireland is further south than Northern Ireland.

I hope that's clearer.

DownNative · 16/04/2023 14:32

SoupDragon · 16/04/2023 12:56

You're still wrong. If NI was part of Great Britain it wouldn't need "... and northern Ireland". Great Britain does not include Northern Ireland. The United Kingdom does.

Again, the point I'm making is that Northern Ireland and Great Britain are literally the United Kingdom together. The two are not separate, but United as one sovereign country in the same way the different kingdoms of France were United into One country we today call France.

Without that, GB is simply a Kingdom of Great Britain.

You really need to refresh your English language skills because I provided the definition of "and" in the context of the UK. On top of pointing out you're blatantly ignoring the keyword "United".

Seas don't necessarily separate one bit of land from another as explained also. Madiera is not a separate country from mainland Portugal and Shetland Island is not a separate country from mainland UK. They're both examples of the sea as connectors since they both form a single sovereign country respectively.

None of this should be difficult to grasp.....

Jourdain11 · 16/04/2023 14:21

I know I'm not the one who you've directed the question to, but some wouldn't consider implicitly shaming people for a lack of knowledge to be particularly "good manners".

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 14:15

Why @JenniferBarkley?Confused

OP posts:
JenniferBarkley · 16/04/2023 13:49

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 12:39

Glad you enjoyed it @isitshe. Good manners cost nothing and I am glad that most people think IANBU.

Many of us may agree with the principle of your OP but I don't think many agree that starting this thread was a good idea.

Bluekerfuffle · 16/04/2023 13:41

No thanks.

JustDanceAddict · 16/04/2023 13:41

I thought it was the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

Daftasabroom · 16/04/2023 13:39

DownNative · 16/04/2023 12:55

Yeah....but place-names are not necessarily meant to be completely literal. But all of Northern Ireland is more northerly than all of the Republic of Ireland.

But then you knew that Northern Ireland's name was originally from a time when the ROI was called Southern Ireland....didn't you?

If you're going to make a quip.....well, I'm struggling to find Northern Island on a map. Can ye help?! 🧐

Hoisted by my own petard (and dyslexia)! And I will return the favour: all of Northern Ireland is more northerly than all of the Republic of Ireland is incorrect.

Actually it's quite a serious point that so few people in the UK know much about our own history. I was really fortunate to take schools council history, which I think only ran for a few years during the transition from o levels to GCSEs.

DappledThings · 16/04/2023 13:16

I live on the Isle of Wight was asked by a visitor recently, in all seriousness, was the Isle of Wight still part of the U.K now we had left the E.U 🤔
Friend of mine was just back from a holiday on the IoW. Other friend asked her which side of the road they drive on there

EveryWitchWaybutLoose · 16/04/2023 13:14

in the so-called feminist section asking about the time of an event, whether Belfast has BST or not.

So this is a TAAT. And it’s not so much a question of time zones, but actually about whether one of the devolved nations of the UK adopting summer time.

It’s not a totally ignorant question - in Australia, for example, while Eastern Standard Time is the same for Victoria, NSW, and Queensland, Queensland has in the past refused summer time (Daylight Saving in Australian lingo).

So although the east coast of Australia is geographically the same time zone, in the summer, Queensland has a different time from the rest of the east coast.

What a nasty first post.

Jourdain11 · 16/04/2023 13:07

SoupDragon · 16/04/2023 12:56

You're still wrong. If NI was part of Great Britain it wouldn't need "... and northern Ireland". Great Britain does not include Northern Ireland. The United Kingdom does.

Yes, exactly! Because Great Britain is an island, which comprises England, Scotland and Wales.

Northern Ireland isn't on the island, so it's not part of Great Britain, just the same as it's not part of mainland Europe or Greenland.

SoupDragon · 16/04/2023 12:56

DownNative · 16/04/2023 12:37

Actually , no, you're focusing on the wrong word which you think is a key word.

The keyword is actually "United" and this tells us that Great Britain and Northern Ireland are united as one sovereign country. Hence, Northern Ireland isn't separate from Great Britain which the Belfast Agreement explicitly acknowledged. It's an INTEGRAL part of the United Kingdom until or unless we in Northern Ireland decide to leave the Union.

In the context of the full name of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, the term "and" does not itself imply separation:

"And" - "used to connect words of the same part of speech, clauses, or sentences, that are to be taken jointly."

This doesn't imply separation. It implies unity of the two into one.

You have to bear in mind that for most of human history the sea was NOT a "natural barrier" and didn't itself suggest a separation of places. This concept still survives in the 21st Century in places such as the USA, Portugal, Spain, Indonesia, etc as well as within the United Kingdom.

In contrast, the word "and" in this sentence "Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland" implies there is NOT one Ireland....but two. In that context, it spells out separation which is also the corresponding reality.

You're still wrong. If NI was part of Great Britain it wouldn't need "... and northern Ireland". Great Britain does not include Northern Ireland. The United Kingdom does.

DownNative · 16/04/2023 12:55

Daftasabroom · 16/04/2023 12:19

The most northerly point on the island or Ireland is not in Northern Island.😁

Yeah....but place-names are not necessarily meant to be completely literal. But all of Northern Ireland is more northerly than all of the Republic of Ireland.

But then you knew that Northern Ireland's name was originally from a time when the ROI was called Southern Ireland....didn't you?

If you're going to make a quip.....well, I'm struggling to find Northern Island on a map. Can ye help?! 🧐

OrangeBicycle · 16/04/2023 12:52

Being from NI I have experienced all these things when at uni in the south of England. ‘Are you jet lagged from the time difference’ ‘do you use euros?’ ‘Do you have a different passport’ many didn’t know NI existed

Swipe left for the next trending thread