Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Well fuck me pink and call me Rosie. AIBU?

454 replies

TooBigForMyBoots · 15/04/2023 22:44

Do you know that Belfast and NI are in the British Isles? Are you aware that some British people claim they do not know that NI is in the same timezone as the rest of the UK?

YABU = You can't expect British people to know the history and geography of their country.
YANBU = Of course British people know this stuff. Anyone who says otherwise is having you on.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
16
Dishwasherdisaster · 18/04/2023 01:27

Ourladycheesusedatum · 17/04/2023 20:57

I dont remember it ever coming up, in school or elsewhere.
I dont know very much at all about Ireland/northern Ireland. And from the stuff I've read so far on this thread, I'm no wiser. Lots of posts state a thing, a few posts later someone denies that thing.

If people who live there cant be factual, I'm not sure Google will help.

And OP heres a 🍪

Are you happy with yourself for being so condescending.

What are you finding confusing exactly @Ourladycheesusedatum? (Apart from this thread that is, and I don't blame you 😅)
But maybe we can clear it up?

NameChangeFoot · 17/04/2023 21:37

DownNative · 16/04/2023 21:03

Wow, you seriously need to take English refresher classes!

My statement is correct because the ONLY way ALL of the* Republic of Ireland could be more northerly than ALL of Northern Ireland is for TWENTY-FIVE counties *to somehow be moved above Northern Ireland!

Impossible! 🤦‍♂️

A very small part of the Republic is more northerly than Northern Ireland, yes. But this does not mean the Republic itself as a whole is more northerly! 🤦‍♂️

Apart from County Donegal, the entirety of the ROI is to the south of Northern Ireland.

So, the statement "all of Northern Ireland is more northerly that all of the Republic of Ireland" still stands as correct.

The keyword in the statement is "ALL".....twice.

Oh ffs, as numerous people have told you YOUR statement is incorrect. Obviously it's not true that ALL of the ROI is more northerly than ALL OF NI. NOBODY SAID THAT.

"ALL OF NORTHERN IRELAND IS MORE NORTHERLY THAN ALL OF THE REPUBLIC OF IRELAND" is completely incorrect. Think it's you who should take some classes. All of NI is NOT more northerly than ALL of the ROI. You're literally contradicting yourself. Donegal IS in the ROI and as part of it IS more northerly than ALL of NI (no matter how small) your statement is WRONG. You are correct that the keyword is ALL🙄.

Ourladycheesusedatum · 17/04/2023 20:57

Rosula · 16/04/2023 00:13

We've all had the benefit of being entitled to free education, and I refuse to believe that any school teaches that Northern Ireland is so far away that it is in a different time zone.

I dont remember it ever coming up, in school or elsewhere.
I dont know very much at all about Ireland/northern Ireland. And from the stuff I've read so far on this thread, I'm no wiser. Lots of posts state a thing, a few posts later someone denies that thing.

If people who live there cant be factual, I'm not sure Google will help.

And OP heres a 🍪

Are you happy with yourself for being so condescending.

DemiColon · 17/04/2023 18:53

isitshe · 17/04/2023 00:47

Of course you can. My response ‘It's astounding to think that people in mainland Britain may think NI is in a different time zone’ was to one PP. I wasn’t ridiculing people, I thought that PP’s post was ridiculous. I didn’t even touch what he/she haughtily said here: ‘You would be better off going 'Low Contact' to use the MN phrase, and either becoming and independent state or re-joining the rest of the Island of Ireland.’
Why ever didn’t we think of those options?!

I do still think it’s astounding that people in mainland Britain may think NI is in a different time zone.
The USA is huge, of course you could walk across a border and be in a different state or time zone, and the divides, even in a clustered area like Western Europe have to be demarcated according to some logic, i.e. borders, but look at this image of Britain and Ireland. It must be such a familiar image to so many people, seen in homes on a daily basis. It’s such a tight cluster, and even if you know nothing about NI/ROI you must get the concept that we’re somehow physically ‘separate’ to the rest of Europe, and have some geographical commonality. I’ve met Americans who didn’t have a blind notion of where Ireland was, never mind in relation to Britain, it seemed really abstract to them, but I don’t know how any one from any of these islands could think the geographical divide is that significant.

It doesn't really matter how huge it is. It depends where the lines for the time zones are. They are largely based on lines of latitude, it's entirely possible for even a tiny country to have a line that happens to go right down the middle. There are cities in some places that are technically divided by time zone.

Usually in a case like that, the tint country will choose one zone or the other. But where there is a national border, especially where there is a sea in between, or a historical political division, you would be more likely to find they were in different zones. If it happened to be the case that the time zone line was between the two islands, I would not be at all surprise to find the ROI wanted to be different from the UK, and I could easily imagine NI might go either way.

As it happens, if you look at the time zones, the east coast of England and the west coast of Ireland do pretty much cover a whole time zone and in fact cross into another one. So, it's not really so small compared to the width of a time zone.

DemiColon · 17/04/2023 18:42

YABVVU

Why:

  1. You worded the OP to be misleading - when you were talking about time zones, you made it unclear enough that more than half the people in the thread think you are talking about what countries and divisions are part of the UK or Ireland.

  2. I am pretty sure you don't actually understand how time zones work, or at least you didn't when you started the thread.

  3. When people learn geography at school, learning what time zones the each country has isn't usually something that's emphasized or often even touched on.

DappledThings · 17/04/2023 17:33

queenmeadhbh · 17/04/2023 15:46

that’s not what “all” means.

all of Northern Ireland is more northerly than MOST of ROI, yes. But for ALL of NI to be more northerly than ALL of ROI, then NO PART of ROI can be more northerly than ANY of NI - which is not the case.

All (pun intended) of this!

queenmeadhbh · 17/04/2023 15:46

that’s not what “all” means.

all of Northern Ireland is more northerly than MOST of ROI, yes. But for ALL of NI to be more northerly than ALL of ROI, then NO PART of ROI can be more northerly than ANY of NI - which is not the case.

DownNative · 17/04/2023 12:39

DownNative · 17/04/2023 12:29

It actually isn't valid to lump three different viewpoints in as one by any reasonable and logical basis. For example, Don't Know does axiomatically imply disinterest or don't care.

If your assertion were true, Ashcroft would have stated precisely what you assert. But he did AND does not. The fact remains you offer no evidence to support your argument and, where some is offered, you simply misrepresent the data to suit yourself.

Very curious how you don't even apply the same flawed argument in relation to Scotland. The percentages and, thus, the viewpoints of the English population is highly similar to that in relation to Northern Ireland.

It helps highlight your flawed logic.

Final word to Ashcroft AGAIN:

"....only a handful say that if either voted to leave the UK they would be happy to see them go. Of those who say it is for Scotland and Northern Ireland to decide, a large minority nevertheless say they would be sorry to see them leave if they chose do so. This means that, overall, most English voters would rather keep the union together if it were up to them – though they recognise it isn’t up to them."

Ashcroft is an experienced pollster who knows how to correctly draw conclusions from his own poll.

You, on the other hand, simply aren't experienced nor know how to correctly draw conclusions from polls.

Correction: For example, Don't Know does NOT axiomatically imply disinterest or don't care.

DownNative · 17/04/2023 12:38

queenmeadhbh · 16/04/2023 22:03

This is bonkers logic.

is every single square mile of ROI south of every single square mile of NI?

No. Every single square mile = all.

On the contrary, it shows you've misunderstood the statement itself.

You would be entirely correct if I'd stated "all of Northern Ireland is more northerly than the Republic of Ireland".

The word "all" is there just once and that statement would obviously be incorrect since there's no qualification in it. In this statement, you'd need just ONE part of the ROI to be more northerly.

Hence why I structured it as "all of Northern Ireland is more northerly than ALL of the Republic of Ireland".

The two statements look similar, but they do not have the same meaning whatsoever.

DownNative · 17/04/2023 12:29

Stillcountingbeans · 16/04/2023 21:48

It's illogical to lump this 13% in with the 10% who said they didn't know and with the 43% who said they had no view, but that its up to the people of Northern Ireland. These are THREE different sets of views, so it makes no sense to treat them as though they mean the same thing!

You are over-stating your case.

It is statistically valid to add the 10% who said didn't know and 43% who said they had no view, making 53% who could broadly be called 'indifferent'. Which is what I originally said - most English people just don't care about NI.

I am surprised that the 13% in favour of NI leaving the UK was as high as that - as it is a clear viewpoint and shows some interest/engagement with the matter.

It actually isn't valid to lump three different viewpoints in as one by any reasonable and logical basis. For example, Don't Know does axiomatically imply disinterest or don't care.

If your assertion were true, Ashcroft would have stated precisely what you assert. But he did AND does not. The fact remains you offer no evidence to support your argument and, where some is offered, you simply misrepresent the data to suit yourself.

Very curious how you don't even apply the same flawed argument in relation to Scotland. The percentages and, thus, the viewpoints of the English population is highly similar to that in relation to Northern Ireland.

It helps highlight your flawed logic.

Final word to Ashcroft AGAIN:

"....only a handful say that if either voted to leave the UK they would be happy to see them go. Of those who say it is for Scotland and Northern Ireland to decide, a large minority nevertheless say they would be sorry to see them leave if they chose do so. This means that, overall, most English voters would rather keep the union together if it were up to them – though they recognise it isn’t up to them."

Ashcroft is an experienced pollster who knows how to correctly draw conclusions from his own poll.

You, on the other hand, simply aren't experienced nor know how to correctly draw conclusions from polls.

isitshe · 17/04/2023 01:00

Kanaloa · 16/04/2023 23:24

I was replying to a pp who insisted that because the two countries are close by each other then anyone who doesn’t know they share a time zone must be stupid. I was explaining that two places being close to each other does not guarantee they will share a time zone. That poster had in fact mentioned other countries.

I notice you still haven’t explained why you think sneering at those who don’t know things is helpful or useful?

If that PP was me, I didn't insist that those people must be stupid. Ignorant perhaps. But of course we all know stupidity and ignorance aren't the same thing. I think it's bad craic to sneer at people, stupid or not, I think it's perfectly reasonable to sometimes be astounded by ignorance.

isitshe · 17/04/2023 00:47

Kanaloa · 16/04/2023 22:58

You can stand on the border of Michigan and look into Illinois. They share a border but not the same time. You can literally take five steps and lose an hour. Ridiculing people for not knowing there is no time difference because two places look close on a map hardly positions you as so much cleverer than them. Two places being close by each other doesn’t guarantee there will be no time difference.

Of course you can. My response ‘It's astounding to think that people in mainland Britain may think NI is in a different time zone’ was to one PP. I wasn’t ridiculing people, I thought that PP’s post was ridiculous. I didn’t even touch what he/she haughtily said here: ‘You would be better off going 'Low Contact' to use the MN phrase, and either becoming and independent state or re-joining the rest of the Island of Ireland.’
Why ever didn’t we think of those options?!

I do still think it’s astounding that people in mainland Britain may think NI is in a different time zone.
The USA is huge, of course you could walk across a border and be in a different state or time zone, and the divides, even in a clustered area like Western Europe have to be demarcated according to some logic, i.e. borders, but look at this image of Britain and Ireland. It must be such a familiar image to so many people, seen in homes on a daily basis. It’s such a tight cluster, and even if you know nothing about NI/ROI you must get the concept that we’re somehow physically ‘separate’ to the rest of Europe, and have some geographical commonality. I’ve met Americans who didn’t have a blind notion of where Ireland was, never mind in relation to Britain, it seemed really abstract to them, but I don’t know how any one from any of these islands could think the geographical divide is that significant.

Well fuck me pink and call me Rosie.  AIBU?
Well fuck me pink and call me Rosie.  AIBU?
TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 23:57

I might start a thread saying...

You're welcome to start any thread you like @TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl. Even one inspired by this one I won't take it personally. I will read it and move on to another or I will comment.

OP posts:
TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 16/04/2023 23:50

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 22:15

I worded the OP in my way. I make no apology for that.

Of course this isn't a TAAT. This thread is not about what Kier said to Rishi (as linked upthread). It is not a thread about party politics. It is a stand alone thread. And I am grateful to all who took the time to reply. Even those who NC'd to have a go at me.Thanks

Well “your way” is being a sick to someone who YOU misunderstood. And it IS a TAAT. It doesn’t have to be about the other thread title, just the content and conversation.

The fact you refuse to answer so you mean, and then even pretend you don’t mean anyone at all - is that wording it your way too?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 16/04/2023 23:42

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 23:36

Exactly @Jourdain11. They are not random places to those who live there. The people who live there know about the time difference. Just as I expect the people of the UK to know if there are any time differences in their locality/country.🤷‍♀️

But despite your faux shock, nonone has actually said that the UK has 2 different time Zones.

I really don’t know why you’re lying about this not being a TAAT when we’ve all seen your posts on another thread 😂 that and the fact you won’t answer who you mean really does show you’re talking utter bollocks

Either that or you have genuinely started a thread and picked a totally random thing to ponder about British people.

I might start a thread saying “Oh my god, kick my face and call me Susie, some people think dogs can’t look up” even though literally no one has suggested this (little nod to the SOTD there Wink)

Kanaloa · 16/04/2023 23:38

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 23:36

Exactly @Jourdain11. They are not random places to those who live there. The people who live there know about the time difference. Just as I expect the people of the UK to know if there are any time differences in their locality/country.🤷‍♀️

Oh, so you’ve conducted a poll of all the residents of Midwest America now, as well as every British citizen? Christ, you must be busy.

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 23:36

Jourdain11 · 16/04/2023 23:24

Michigan and Illinois (and I'm sure their residents don't think they're random places 🤔) is just one example of that point.

Exactly @Jourdain11. They are not random places to those who live there. The people who live there know about the time difference. Just as I expect the people of the UK to know if there are any time differences in their locality/country.🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 16/04/2023 23:36

Kanaloa · 16/04/2023 23:24

I was replying to a pp who insisted that because the two countries are close by each other then anyone who doesn’t know they share a time zone must be stupid. I was explaining that two places being close to each other does not guarantee they will share a time zone. That poster had in fact mentioned other countries.

I notice you still haven’t explained why you think sneering at those who don’t know things is helpful or useful?

The two states, even. Just because they’re close to each other doesn’t mean that Michigan and Illinois must share a time zone. Just because you can look from parts of Ireland into parts of England doesn’t automatically mean people should understand that automatically they share a time zone. And realistically what harm can possibly come of it? If those people (the ones you know who don’t know they share a time zone) go for a holiday to Belfast for whatever reason, I’m sure they will manage to get along without a time difference. Unless you live in Belfast and have relatives living in England who continually call you at odd hours because they think there’s a time difference, it will literally never ever have any impact on your life if somebody on another thread thought there might be a time difference.

Dishwasherdisaster · 16/04/2023 23:29

Apart from County Donegal, the entirety of the ROI is to the south of Northern Ireland.

@DownNative
As a matter of fact, as well as Donegal, some parts of counties Mayo, Sligo, Leitrim, Cavan, Monaghan, Louth and possibly Roscommon have more northerly latitudes than the southern parts of NI. If you're in Monaghan town in ROI, for example, NI is to your east and west as well as north.

Jourdain11 · 16/04/2023 23:24

Michigan and Illinois (and I'm sure their residents don't think they're random places 🤔) is just one example of that point.

Kanaloa · 16/04/2023 23:24

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 23:18

We are not talking about 2 random places on a map. We are talking about the UK citizens, in the UK, a country with only 1 time zone.

I was replying to a pp who insisted that because the two countries are close by each other then anyone who doesn’t know they share a time zone must be stupid. I was explaining that two places being close to each other does not guarantee they will share a time zone. That poster had in fact mentioned other countries.

I notice you still haven’t explained why you think sneering at those who don’t know things is helpful or useful?

Jourdain11 · 16/04/2023 23:23

The point is, saying "you can see from one to the other, they must be the same time zone" doesn't necessarily make sense. You can see France from England on a clear day, but they're not in the same time zone.

TooBigForMyBoots · 16/04/2023 23:18

Kanaloa · 16/04/2023 22:58

You can stand on the border of Michigan and look into Illinois. They share a border but not the same time. You can literally take five steps and lose an hour. Ridiculing people for not knowing there is no time difference because two places look close on a map hardly positions you as so much cleverer than them. Two places being close by each other doesn’t guarantee there will be no time difference.

We are not talking about 2 random places on a map. We are talking about the UK citizens, in the UK, a country with only 1 time zone.

OP posts:
Everydayshouldbe · 16/04/2023 23:11

Oops, attachments don't show when you quote

Well fuck me pink and call me Rosie.  AIBU?
Well fuck me pink and call me Rosie.  AIBU?
Everydayshouldbe · 16/04/2023 23:08

inyoureyes · 16/04/2023 01:04

It a was a single poster and other other posters comment was misinterpreted.

I didn't have to go looking for other threads OP - your comments are here for anyone to see in the screenshots attached to the post I've quoted above.
I've reported your OP, let's leave it at that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread